Lee Carroll discusses The Benefits of Medicinal Mushrooms with Dr. Ben Weitz.

In this episode of the Rational Wellness Podcast, Dr. Ben Weitz welcomes Lee Carroll, the Chief Medical Herbalist of Real Mushrooms, for an in-depth discussion on the health benefits of medicinal mushrooms. They delve into the properties of various mushrooms, including Reishi, Shiitake, Turkey Tail, Lion’s Mane, Cordyceps, and Chaga, and their roles in supporting immune health, fighting cancer, cardiovascular health, and cognitive function. Lee Carroll also explains the science behind the synergy of mushroom compounds, the importance of consuming mushrooms regularly, and the specifics of mushroom supplements. Don’t miss this informative conversation on the power of medicinal mushrooms and their potential impact on your health.

[If you enjoy this podcast, please give us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts, so more people will find The Rational Wellness Podcast. Also check out the video version on my WeitzChiro YouTube page.]

 

Podcast Highlights

3:00  The Science of Medicinal Mushrooms. Fungi have unique, signature molecules on their exterior cell wall, which are beta glucans. Beta glucans engage our immune systems and tell it to be more vigilant, to be more accurate in your responses and to have populations cell types that are more appropriate for the place where they hang out.  So for example, if its cordyceps, it might be the population of surface immune cells in the lungs. 

7:17  Cancer and Mushrooms.  Consuming mushrooms or taking a quality mushroom supplement like from Real Mushrooms you can reduce the risk of getting cancer.  Once a patient has cancer, mushrooms can help the health of the patient and enhance the effectiveness of the conventional therapies.  For example, a patient with cancer who taking Taxol and was suffering from the side effects of the Taxol, so he gave her Turkey Tail and a bioavailable curcumin and this reduced the complications of the chemo and her health improved.

10:00  Mushrooms and Cardiovascular Health.  Reishi has the best record for supporting the cardiovascular system, though we don’t have enough studies to demonstrate this.  Reishi contains triterpenes that are bitter herbs that support endothelial function and can mitigate against stress.

14:59  Cholesterol.  Shiitake and oyster mushrooms in particular can have some influence in lowering levels of LDL and oxidized LDL and raising HDL.

15:39 Cooked mushrooms. It is better to cook mushrooms to break them down so you can extract the beta glucans and the other active constituents.  The button, crimini, and the protobello mushrooms grow on manure, so it’s not a good idea to eat them raw. 

18:00  Ergothioneine.  Ergothioneine is found in mushrooms and this is an amino acid derivative that can help with cardiovascular and brain health as well as healthy aging.  It is also where LSD came from, as well as the migraine medication ergotamine and other alkaloids.  Ergothioneine is an intracellular antioxidant and we have discovered specific transporters to take ergothioneine into cells.  Ergothioneine is similar to glutathione, but unlike glutathione, it is not made by the body, but must be retrieved from our food.  Ergothioneine is like a backup antioxidant to glutathione and it has a unique biology that can modulate to when cells become more acidic or alkaline and it engages when there’s excessive stress.  The average American only gets 1 mg of ergothioneine in their diet.

28:40  The Stoned Ape Theory.  Terence McKenna was a famous psychonaut and proponent of psychedelic exploration and therapies and he came up with idea that psilocybin mushrooms facilitated the rapid increase in the size of the brains of humans a few hundred thousand years ago.  The theory is that psilocybin allowed for enhanced communication and the development of language and complex problem solving skills, which makes some sense when you consider that ergothioneine plays a role in neurogenesis.

 

 



Lee Carroll is the chief medical herbalist of Real Mushrooms.  The website is RealMushrooms.com.

Dr. Ben Weitz is available for Functional Nutrition consultations specializing in Functional Gastrointestinal Disorders like IBS/SIBO and Reflux and also Cardiometabolic Risk Factors like elevated lipids, high blood sugar, and high blood pressure.  Dr. Weitz has also successfully helped many patients with managing their weight and improving their athletic performance, as well as sports chiropractic work by calling his Santa Monica office 310-395-3111.

 



Podcast Transcript

Dr. Weitz:  Hey, this is Dr. Ben Weitz, host of the Rational Wellness Podcast. I talk to the leading health and nutrition experts and researchers in the field to bring you the latest in cutting edge health information. Subscribe to the Rational Wellness Podcast for weekly updates. And to learn more, check out my website, drweitz.com.  Thanks for joining me and let’s jump into the podcast. Hello, Rational Wellness Podcasters.

Today, I’m excited to be having a discussion about medicinal mushrooms with Lee Carroll, the chief medical herbalist of Real Mushrooms. Medicinal mushrooms include mushrooms like Reishi, Shiitake, Turkey Tail, and Lion’s Mane.  These are mushrooms that have powerful health promoting properties, including strength in the immune system, and even the National Cancer [00:01:00] Institute has a whole detailed section on medicinal mushrooms for fighting cancer. Turkey tail. Reishi, Shiitake, and Maitake are four of the mushrooms most known for strengthening the immune system to fight cancer and infections.  Lion’s Mane is a popular mushroom used for cognitive health and you see it in a lot of brain formulas. Cordyceps is another medicinal mushroom that’s known to support the kidneys and the lungs. It’s often included in adrenal formulas and also has benefits for sports performance. Chaga helps with digestion and skin as well as with immune function.  So those are a few of the medicinal mushrooms that we’ll probably include in our discussion today. So Lee, thank you so much for joining us today.

Lee Carroll: My pleasure, Ben. It’s lovely to be here.

Dr. Weitz: So, how did you end up becoming the Chief Medical Herbalist for Real Mushrooms?

Lee Carroll: That’s a good place to start.

Dr. Weitz: How did you end up knee deep in fungus?

Lee Carroll: I have had a long career in herbal medicine. And when COVID happened in early 2020, I was working for a small company in Northern California, and I got the opportunity to develop a range of, of functional mushroom products using Namex extracts. And that was kind of like the segue I realized, you know, in 30 plus years, I hadn’t really focused on mushrooms much.  And then I fell in love with them and started developing educational materials for healthcare professionals around that. And I just haven’t stopped since. It’s just, there’s so much to learn. And, and, uh, there’s so much to discuss with mushrooms. They’re really underrated in the, in the modern clinic.

Dr. Weitz: Right. So let’s get into the science of medicinal mushrooms and how they can help us promote greater health. So why don’t we start with one of the properties that mushrooms are known for, which is immune health. Perhaps you can explain why mushrooms are beneficial for that.

Lee Carroll: Sure. So mushrooms as a group fall into a different kingdom of life to plants.  So when we’re thinking about the way that fungi interact with human biology, there’s a whole different set of chemistry that interacts with the human body. And if you go back a thousand million years, fungi and, and animals, humans have a common ancestor. So we split off from a common ancestor.  So we’ve got shared biological features. So [00:04:00] cholesterol in our cell walls is similar to ergosterol and fungal So there’s a lot of intracellular machinery. And then, as those two lineages interacted with each other originally, like in the primordial kind of ocean, fungi were needing to survive and eat food, so they would attack animals.  This is kind of like the highlight. So fungi and animals have been kind of going at it, you know, for millions and millions of years. And fungi have got these unique, signature molecules on their exterior cell wall, which are beta glucans to a lesser extent, alpha glucans, a few other unique molecules. So animal biology has evolved to recognize those patterns.

And when those patterns are recognized, it engages the immune system. So, if it’s a pathogenic fungus, it can cause disease. And humans are so resistant to fungal infections that it’s not a very common thing. So most of us are familiar with tinea and athlete’s foot, jock itch, dandruff, for example.  So when a human encounters a non pathogenic fungus as a mushroom, say shiitake or lion’s mane, those beta glucan signatures are still there.  They don’t represent any pathogenic threat because they don’t have that capacity, but they talk to the immune system in a very similar way to the pathogenic fungus.  And the message that the beta glucans send is to tell the immune system to be more vigilant, to be more accurate in your responses, to have populations of cell types that are more appropriate for the place where they hang out. So it might be, if it’s cordyceps, it might be the population of surface immune cells in the lungs, for example.

So this is driven by very highly specific receptors. that are, some of them are broadly tuned to receive all sorts of different messages from different sources, but some of them are very highly specific, and they’re tuned just to receive the messages from fungi, and mushrooms. So when we engage in the behavior of eating mushrooms, And we should dissect mushrooms out into their own kingdom of life.  And they should be a separate food group when we eat mushrooms on a regular basis, we’re educating our immune system to be healthier, to be calmer, to be more responsive, and to be more accurate at removing the neuro plastic cells that otherwise shouldn’t be there like neo plastic cells, for example.  It’s a bit more complicated than that. There’s a bit of fermentation that goes on in the gut. So short chain fatty acids play a bit of a role, but that kind of story is like the underpinning of the main reason why we should be eating mushrooms more frequently.

Dr. Weitz: You mentioned neoplastic, so that refers to cancer.  And which mushrooms are best for helping us fight cancer? I’ve heard a lot about turkey tail. I’ve talked to integrative cancer experts who recommend using various forms of mushrooms and mushroom extracts for fighting cancer.  Some have recommended Turkey Tail, some have recommended Reishi, a mixture, rotating them.  There’s extracts, like there’s one popular one known as AHCC, and I remember for a while there was one called Maitake D Fraction that was really big. What’s your take on which mushrooms are best for fighting cancer? Is it better to use or to rotate them or use a number of them?

Lee Carroll: It’s a tricky question that one.  Um, the first, the first thing I’d say is that if a person consumes mushrooms regularly as part of their diet or takes a supplement every day, a good quality supplement, you know, like a, like what Real Mushrooms offers, then the risk of developing cancer can be reduced. Uh, and there’s, there’s really good epidemiology data that backs that up.  Cancers of all types, uh, prostate cancer in men, breast cancer in women, colon cancer. So, um, in terms of our health, you know, modern humans aren’t that smart really because, you know, we don’t engage in the behaviors that are [00:09:00] preventative. So prevention is kind of optimal. So we’ve got to get more into having them as part of our regular diet.

If you have cancer and you’re looking to, you know, use natural supplements to kind of, you know, support the fight against that cancer. Mushrooms on their own don’t have great evidence to fight the cancer. What they do have is great evidence as part of conventional therapies. So when, when patients are undergoing treatments, mushrooms, across the board [mushrooms] make the patient more vital and they’re more able to cope with the rigor of the drug that they’re receiving because many of the drugs are really toxic. I’ve got a breast cancer patient at the moment. She’s taking a turkey tail extract and she was suffering badly as a result of the Taxol that she was having weekly.  And I just gave her turkey tail and a bioavailable curcumin. And over the course of four months, the oncologist said, well, I’ve never seen this drug work so well.  And her health improved significantly. She was, the complications and the side effects of that drug weren’t as great.  So it’s a little bit complicated and it’s beyond the time that we’ve got here, but when you have, when you have a particular cancer, you’ve got to go with the evidence.

Dr. Weitz: Oh, yeah. Look, I’m not suggesting that people should not get chemo or radiation or you know, targeted therapies.  I’m just suggesting from a integrative perspective, we want to help them support that person’s fight and help their immune system, which it needs to be a big participant. A lot of times these drugs, unfortunately, at the same time as they fight cancer, they end up suppressing the immune system.

Lee Carroll: Yeah, they do. So, and there’s, In China, many of the beta glucans have been purified and turned into drugs, and there’s about 30 of them. And they do, they’re ideally suited for all particular different types of cancers, so, broad brush, you can’t go wrong using Turkey Tail as an adjunct. You can’t go wrong using Reishi as an adjunct.  Uh, they’re very safe places to go. In terms of helping the patient and some of the drugs have their efficacy improved when they, when the treatment includes a mushroom. So the, some of the more specific drugs work a whole lot better under those conditions.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. Let’s talk about some of the other benefits of mushrooms.  I understand some mushrooms are beneficial for the cardiovascular system.

Lee Carroll: Yep. So Reishi probably gets the best, um, kind of track record there, although the evidence doesn’t really support it, but the, the tradition does. We just, the clinical trials that have been done with Reishi just haven’t been done very well, haven’t been done long enough, haven’t been done with quality materials. So, you know, if you’re an evident, if you’re on the evidence based end of the spectrum, it can be a bit challenging. But if we, but beta glucans play a role in cardiovascular health as well, but Reishi Hass got molecules called triterpenes that are very bitter.

And these triterpenes have got a structure that can interact with human physiology. The structure of those terpenes is similar to the triterpenes in a herb like Korean ginseng or bitter melon or astragalus for example. So those, those triterpenes, when you consume them, the first place they go is your vascular system.  And then they get, some of them get consumed by your liver, but then they end up in circulation. And the triterpenes get taken up by the endothelial cells in the vascular system. And much of the cardiovascular disease has its origins in dysfunctional, um, endothelial cell function. And the inner layers the intima, for example, they get stressed as well.  So in animal studies, the triterpenes can mitigate against the stress and the dysfunction in those cells and allow them to be more functional and healthy. So you get less cardiovascular disease. A curious thing that has not been studied is that those molecules are really very bitter and bitter receptors aren’t just in the mouth.  There’s bitter receptors expressed everywhere in the body and humans have 29 different bitter receptors and they perform very, very highly specific roles. And the heart and the vasculature express 21 of those 25 receptors and there isn’t one piece of research investigating how bitter molecules influence the functioning of the heart or the vascular system.  So it’s my theory that really good quality extracts that are very bitter are going to be more effective at supporting the cardiovascular system via the endothelial cells and the other, the original stuff that I mentioned, but also this unexplored area of bitterness and how it plays a role in cardiovascular health.

Dr. Weitz: Interesting. I was also reading an article about oyster mushrooms that have certain compounds that actually help to lower cholesterol.

Lee Carroll: Yeah. So that’s, that’s the other side of the equation and many mushrooms. Shiitake and oyster mushrooms kind of stand up as the dominant ones, they have minor influences over the levels of LDL, HDL, the amount of oxidized LDL.  And, cause that’s the real problem is how much oxidative stress there is in the bloodstream. So mushrooms help to mitigate against that as well.

Dr. Weitz: To get the most benefit out of eating mushrooms, is it better to cook them or eat them raw? 

Lee Carroll: It’s better to cook them. The button mushroom and crimini and portobello, they grow in cow manure, so it’s not a good idea to eat them raw because you might be getting a little bit of, you know, manure in your salad.  But mush, because mushrooms are 

Dr. Weitz: Oh, I thought they all grew on manure.

Lee Carroll: No, no, some, some will grow on wood. Okay. Some will grow on, you know, other types of substrates. Okay. But I think the real reason, the most important thing is that mushrooms have got a unique biology and if we want to extract the beta glucans and the other active constituents from the really robust cell walls that exist in these, in these organisms, then they need to be cooked, boiled is optimal.  So, you know, good quality extracts, processed using heat for a couple of hours and that gives the best extraction of all of the different phytochemistry and these things are very stable in heat. So, my rule at home is, and it’s a bit harder when you’re cooking because you’re on a time frame, you don’t want to spend all day in the kitchen.

Dr. Weitz: Yeah, who’s going to cook them for a couple of hours?

Lee Carroll: So, I tell people when you’re frying them or cooking them at home, 10 or 15 minutes at least to do some work at breaking them down. And the smaller the particle size, the more benefit you’re going to get. If you just, if you don’t chew your food well, and many people don’t, then if you’re swallowing large pieces of mushroom, they don’t get digested in the gut.  So they, they get a little bit of fermentation by bacteria, but we don’t have any enzymes or acid doesn’t break it down. So the smaller you chop them up the healthier it’s going to be, particularly for your large intestine.

Dr. Weitz: That’s, that’s what I do. I often have mushrooms with my eggs in the morning and I chop them up and  my favorites are shiitake and lion’s mane.

Lee Carroll: Yeah. Oh, that’s a beautiful breakfast. Yeah. I’d be all over that one as well.

Dr. Weitz: Um, [00:18:00] tell us about this compound ergothioneine. I’m sure I’m probably not pronouncing it correctly. That’s good. Yeah. And how it helps with, uh, cardiovascular health, with healthy aging, with brain health, with

Lee Carroll: Yeah, that’s, that’s a really fascinating topic that ergothioneine gets its name from the ergot fungus.  Uh, it was discovered back in 1909. So it was given the name ergothioneine because it’s a derivative of an amino acid.

Dr. Weitz: Is it now where like LSD came from?

Lee Carroll: And that’s where LSD came from. Yeah, and it’s also where ergotamine and other, other alkaloids came from that get used as vasoconstrictors and used in childbirth, et cetera.  The Chinese were using it for thousands of years. I think

Dr. Weitz: migraines.

Lee Carroll: Yeah, so ergothioneine is a derivative of an amino acid, and it’s technically a thiol, which makes it in the [00:19:00] same category as glutathione. So the role that it plays in the human body is the role of an intracellular, antioxidant. But it’s a very unique molecule and there isn’t any other metabolite in the body like it.  It’s totally unique. And just like vitamin C has got vitamin C transporters to bring vitamin C into the body. Vitamin C relies on glucose transporters to get into the cells. Uh, the kidney has got transporters to moderate the loss of vitamin C. So if you, if you’ve starved of it, then you’ll get better reabsorption.  So ergothienine has the same aspects to it. There’s, there’s very highly specific transporter proteins that bring that ergothienine from the diet into the bloodstream. And then many of the cells in the body have got transporters that are pretty much exclusive to [00:20:00] ergothioneine into the cells. And then the kidney doesn’t ever let any go.  It avidly retains any loss that might, you know, make it through to the kidney. So, um, that, that imparts upon it like a really high level of biological value, but Modern science has only worked out how important ergothioneine is just in the last 10 or 15 years since those transporters have been discovered.  One of the problems with managing human health is that the modern world creates It’s more oxidative stress than our kind of evolutionary capacity can handle where you’re exposed to all of the chemicals that are in our environment, you know, all of the psychosocial stress, heavy metals, all that sort of stuff.  So ergothioneine’s role really fits into supporting the modern person in a very highly specific way, because it sits at the boundary between intracellular oxidative stress and intracellular inflammation.

Dr. Weitz: So But yet, unlike glutathione, we don’t produce ergothioneine,

Lee Carroll: right? We have to get it from the diet.  Yeah. So it, it’s like a vitamin. It doesn’t quite meet the definition of a vitamin because a, a vitamin has, there has to be a deficiency disease associated with it. And in humans, it’s almost impossible to Um, create a deficiency because ergothioneine only comes from fungi and some soil bacteria and plants take it up from the, from the fungi and the soil bacteria.  So when you eat plants, you get 10 to 100 times less of the ergothioneine that you get if you consume a fungus. So, ergothioneines, this is Once you dive into the biology of it, um, it’s really quite fascinating. So when a, [00:22:00] when a cell experiences stress, so let’s just use the most simple example of someone exercising.

So the mitochondria are making more energy, there’s a bit of leakage from the, the, um, the, the electron chain of energy production. And so the, the amount of, of, um, free radicals increases in the cell, um, as a result of that. And the cell has got natural mechanisms to cope with that. So some of those, um, reactive oxygen species will interact with, um, NRF2, which is pretty, you know, popular and, and understood now.

And then that will engage, you know, more antioxidant defenses to cope with that stress. But you reach a point at which the glutathione in the cell, which is, you know, reacting with those. entities, it starts to get depleted and it takes a little bit of time to [00:23:00] regenerate glutathione. So when oxidative stress is ebbing and flowing in the cell, when glutathione is low, Um, ergothioneine steps in and plays a, plays the defensive backup role of being the antioxidant that allows the glutathione time to regenerate.

And then ergo has got this unique biology. So as the cell webbed, um, waxes and wanes in terms of its stress, the, the pH goes up and down. as a result of the, you know, the, the free radicals. When the free radicals are high, the, the, the cells are a bit more acidic. So ergothioneine, when the cell is acidic, it goes into its active form.

When the cell’s at its healthy normal pH, it’s in its inactive form. So as an antioxidant, um, it’s a very intelligent, adaptive mechanism that supports the cells. When things get tough, but it can’t auto [00:24:00] oxidize or cause mischief because when cells are healthy, it doesn’t, it doesn’t play a role. So it only engages in sites where there’s excessive stress.

And there are some places in the body that experience more stress and ergothioneine plays a more dominant role like in the eyes, for example, or in the liver, in the endothelial cells, ergothioneine plays a bit more of a dominant role, but it plays a role in all of the cells in the body and when we’re deficient in it, we get all sorts of age related diseases.

Dr. Weitz: And are mushrooms the only way to get ergothioneine?

Lee Carroll: They’re the only way to get, um, healthy levels of it. And humans need, uh, you know, three or four or five milligrams a day of this stuff. And the, the epidemiology that’s been done is, it’s not fully complete, but it suggests that the American diet, uh, on average [00:25:00] only has about one milligram a day.

Dr. Weitz: And I saw a paper where patients with Dementia or diminishing cognitive faculties seem to have lower ergothionine levels.

Lee Carroll: Yeah, and we don’t have a commercial test for it at the moment, so it’s still like a laboratory research tool, but I think we’re only a year or two away from having a diagnostic test that people can take that will say, if your ergothionine is below this level, and that number hasn’t been quite been set yet, um, you’re at a significantly increased risk of um, neurodegenerative disease, so mild cognitive impairment, Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, a bunch of other ones, um, and macular degeneration has got kind of like the highest association, but cardiovascular disease is in there.

Dr. Weitz: Macular degeneration, interesting, and that’s related to, [00:26:00] there’s some relationship between that and Alzheimer’s as well.

Lee Carroll: Yeah. And it’s, uh, there’s a vascular component to it and it’s, it’s to do with, you know, cells that can’t cope with the, with the stress that they’re under. So, you know, a neuron that has got too much inflammation, um, the, the, the enzymes that cleave the, the amyloid proteins go a little bit crazy.  And instead of making a healthy protein, they make an amyloid beta protein that can build up. So it’s all, it’s not a bad. Reducing, it’s not about targeting the, the, the amyloid protein in this case, it’s about reducing the inflammation to stop it being produced. You’ve got to go to the source, which is where all of our natural health, kind of philosophies take us.  And ergothioneine is the missing link in that bridge between how cells control their, their stress. and how they engage [00:27:00] their inflammatory responses. And Ergothenia has got this really interesting relationship with inflammation. So as, as the inflammatory environment increases, that engages Nucleofactor Kappa B, which, you know, many of us will be familiar with.

So as Nucleofactor Kappa B starts to get engaged, the ergotransporter proteins get increased in the cell to bring more ergothioneine in. And then as the inflammation starts to ebb, the ergothioneine transporters get removed. So ergothioneine sort of sits in the middle of, of managing stress and managing inflammation.  And then it’s, it’s uncontrolled inflammation that then leads to all of these downstream consequences, including cancer.

Dr. Weitz: And from what I read, the mushrooms that are highest in ergothioneine are Oyster, Porcini, and I think Shiitake.

Lee Carroll: Yeah. Yeah. You’ve done your homework well, Ben. You could put lion’s mane in there as well.  Okay. The yellow oyster represents the most easily accessible highest source.

Dr. Weitz: The yellow

Lee Carroll: oyster.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. Is it, does it have a yellow color? Is it easy to identify? Yeah. That’s,

Lee Carroll: that’s where it gets its name from. It’s this beautiful bright yellow color. Okay. Real Mushrooms has a, has a supplement called Ergo Plus, which is made using the yellow oyster.  So each capsule gives you a five milligram dose.

Dr. Weitz: Cool. Tell us about the stoned ape theory.

Lee Carroll: Well, that’s good timing with that question because it, I came up with that theory, um, as a result of my research into ergothionine. So Terence McKenna, who [00:29:00] was, you know, famous psychonaut and proponent of, you know, psychedelic, exploration and therapies, came up with this idea that,  it psilocybin mushrooms, um, by early humans that facilitated the rapid increase in the size of our brains a couple of hundred thousand years ago that psilocybin allowed for enhanced communication and the development of language and complex kind of problem solving skills. So when you look at the arc of ergothionine, it, it plays a role in neurogenesis and There’s many, many ape species, uh, you know, and, and primate species consume mushrooms as, as do many animals.

So, the essence of the, of the, the gourmet ape theory is that Um, there’s archaeological [00:30:00] evidence, the archaeologists scrape the teeth of archaeological specimens, and then they look at them under microscopes, and they, in some cases, they can get DNA out of them. So, 16, 000 years ago, The specimens from Spain were consuming vast quantities of boletes, so porcini, um, and vast quantities of agaricus mushroom.

For example, other species, other specimens have been, uh, looked at that are 48, 000 years old and they were consuming, um, Schizophyllum commune, which is a medicinal edible mushroom from China that’s still used today. Um, and Copranopsis, the Shaggy End Cap. So, there’s very scant evidence because mushrooms don’t survive.

Um, but the, the, the fact is that it’s very likely that modern, early humans Um, eight vast [00:31:00] quantities of mushrooms and the ergothionine content in the mushrooms will have played a role, um, throughout the evolutionary process and guided the way that, um, brains have developed. And when you look at Um, Ergotheanine’s role in cognitive function, that the TRACB receptor gets a lot of attention, and that’s a neurotrophin receptor that receives the BDNF signals.

It’s also a receptor that psilocybin binds into. Some of the molecules of lion’s mane might bind into that receptor as well. And when, when that receptor receives its signal, then the downstream intracellular messages, kind of housekeeping messages and house maintenance messages. So it might be Hey, you don’t have enough synapses, you’ve got to have more synapses, or your cytoskeletal arrangement internally is not quite optimal, or you’ve, you know, the [00:32:00] biological functioning of the cell might not be optional, optimal.  So ergothionine plays a role in making that, um, TRACB receptor, um, more able to deliver the messages via enhancing the intracellular domain of that receptor. So I think that, um, the human development, um, has in part been shaped by our consumption of mushrooms.

Dr. Weitz: It’s interesting. Other theories have explained that growth of the brain based on the fact that we started consuming meat and got concentrated  calories. Other people have talked about the consumption of fish and the omega 3 fats as being important for that, but 

Lee Carroll: And all of that is true but because ergothionine’s such a recent thing, um, it hasn’t been factored into [00:33:00] Those types of theories and mushrooms in general haven’t been factored into a, paleolithic diet.  So when, when researchers come up with what they think early humans ate, A, it’s very variable when you look at the data, depends on where you lived, where the fossils come from, but researchers look at collagen. And they look at the carbon and nitrogen isotopes, and that gives them an assessment of how much amino acid and therefore protein was consumed in those diets.  None of those researchers have ever considered that early humans ate mushrooms. And the little bit of work that’s been done shows that the, the isotope signatures, the carbon and nitrogen signatures that get reflected. in the collagen, um, can’t be distinguished between protein from animal sources or mushroom sources.

So the fact that we’ve got this archaeological evidence showing [00:34:00] that early humans ate vast quantities of mushrooms when they’re available probably, um, means that our Ideas around modern diets, um, haven’t included mushrooms because it hasn’t been factored in. And the more mushrooms we can include in our diet, the healthier we’ll be.

And there’s, there’s some really good evidence to show that if you can just swap two meat meals a week out of your diet and replace them with mushrooms. It has significant impact on your risk of diabetes and obesity and metabolic syndrome, for example. Interesting. So the gourmet ag theories are kind of broad Iraq.

And I think that, um, you know, the consumption of mushrooms going back, you know, probably millions of years, Um, not just the last couple of hundred thousand has really kind of shaped, um, you know, the way that, that human evolution, particularly from a nervous system point of view has transpired.

Dr. Weitz: Of course, some mushrooms [00:35:00] are poisonous and I wouldn’t want to be the guy in a primitive tribe who gets to test out the new mushroom.

Lee Carroll: Yeah, it’d be an awful, awful way to go.

Dr. Weitz: If I was considering taking, oh, let’s just follow up a little bit on the brain health, um, what is it about, um, what is it about, um, Lion’s Mane that makes it such a powerful factor for brain health?

Lee Carroll: Okay, that’s a great question. Can, can I start by saying that the consumption of all culinary mushrooms, when they’re done over the course of years, so, you know, two years, five years, 10 years, 20 years, um, the epidemiology of that tells us that just one serve of mushroom a week can improve cognitive function in healthy people as they age.  [00:36:00] And higher serving sizes, so when you get up to 7, 8, 9 serves of mushrooms a week. So a serve is about half an ounce of fresh mushroom. So not crazy amounts. Um, when you get up to those higher servings in a week, the risk of, um, developing neurocognitive challenges, you know, like Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s, mild cognitive impairment, the risk decreases by about 75 to 80 percent.

So there’s something about mushrooms in general that is really quite significant, uh, in terms of how this plays out, but at the moment all of the attention is on lion’s mane and lion’s mane special for a couple of reasons. So, um, lion’s mane’s got beta glucans, they play a role, um, it’s got ergothionine, And at reasonably high levels, it’s kind of in the high category.

So that plays a role. And it’s got secondary [00:37:00] metabolites. And the metabolites are different between the fruiting body and the mycelium. And the fruiting body is where the tradition comes from. So the, the tradition around Lion’s Mane having these effects. was to do with people consuming the mushroom. So there’s the intersection of those three different aspects of the chemistry, which I believe have a synergistic effect, uh, which promote, um, you know, the optimization of how the brain works.

And in the modern world, It’s pretty hard to avoid people being reductionist. They want to hone in on just what is the one thing that’s the most important. You can’t do that in biology, and you definitely can’t do it when you’re talking about, you know, functional mushrooms and, and, um, natural medicines.

So Lion’s Mane, the beta glucans, um, get fermented in the gut [00:38:00] and beta glucans get converted into short chain fatty acids. And there’s really good evidence to show that. Um, any, any short chain fatty acids, uh, when they’re produced in the gut are going to have in, in, uh, improvements in brain health. So synaptogenesis improves BDNF as you know, is the driver of that, for example, certain areas of the brain can be increased in size.

Ergotheanine plays a role as I was just describing earlier. Um, it helps manage the oxidative stress in the brain and it allows the TRACB receptor, at least, but possibly many other receptors that we haven’t been explored yet to be more functional, to deliver better messages. And then you’ve got the secondary metabolites.

So in the fruiting body, the mushroom, um, it’s harrisonones, um, which, uh, interact with various receptors in the body to modulate the behavior of neuronal tissue and maybe increase nerve growth factor. What was

Dr. Weitz: that? What was [00:39:00] that term? Harrison mounds.

Lee Carroll: Hericinones. It’s a type of diterpene. So it’s a, it’s a class of molecule that’s quite unique to lion’s mane.  

Dr. Weitz: How do you spell that?

Lee Carroll: H E R I C E N O N E S, I think.

Dr. Weitz: Okay, cool.

Lee Carroll: So when you, when you get that cocktail of, uh, chemistry, um, at the right dose. And the clinical trials tell us that you need, um, three to five grams of the mushroom a day to move the dial on people that have got cognitive impairment. Okay. If you do it, if you do lion’s mane regularly, um, and you don’t have cognitive decline, one gram a day over the course of your life will, um, you know, prevent cognitive decline from happening and keep your cognition.

Dr. Weitz: Now, approximately how much [00:40:00] lion’s mane mushroom is in a gram? Like, like if you had a, um, a fist? Amount would, would that be a gram more? Yeah, if you’re eating fresh.

Lee Carroll: If you’re eating fresh lines mane. Right. Um, uh, it’s about 90% water. So if you had 10 ounces of lions mane, you’d have one ounce of dried mushroom.  Oh wow. You’d have 28 grams, so you’d have a whole month’s worth. So you could eat just a little bit every day. Okay. But the sort of capsules that, that people have access to, so the. The Real Mushroom Lion’s Mane Capsules, um, they’re 500 milligrams each, so two of them gives you a gram, that’s the equivalent of 10 grams.  I see. Fresh.

Dr. Weitz: So, but for, so, one gram would be, of a quality product would be sufficient for prevention. What was the amount for a patient who [00:41:00] already has, say, mild cognitive impairment? 

Lee Carroll: The research tells us about three grams.

Dr. Weitz: Three grams. Okay.

Lee Carroll: And clearly, you know, the, the more you throw at it, the better it will be.  There’s a long list of things that, you know, a patient will do well with.

Dr. Weitz: Now, you mentioned that a lot of these ingredients are in the flowering part of the mushroom rather than the mycelium. Can you explain what the mycelium is and the difference between, specifically as it relates to mushroom supplements, the importance of the flowering body versus the mycelium?

Lee Carroll: Sure. Yeah, that’s a, that’s a really vexing question at the moment. And in every industry disruptive ideas and practices get introduced, uh, which create a lot of confusion [00:42:00] and that’s happening at the moment and has been for the last 10 years in the mushroom industry. So, Let me see if I can kind of dissect it up to make it clear for people because there’s lots of opinions and a lot of emotion around this topic when you get into public debates.

So from a traditional point of view, uh, it was only ever the mushroom or the fruiting body, um, which was used as a medicine and These, these, uh, mushrooms were mostly boiled or decocted, uh, and taken as a, as a beverage, so as a tea or as a medicine. So if we want to, um, understand the traditional use and reflect that traditional use in a modern setting, then we need to kind of stick with the tradition.

So there’s a lot of, there’s a lot of value around the mushrooms. And then there’s a huge amount of modern research to back up the traditional use of it. And there’s a huge volume of research around beta glucans. [00:43:00] And then there’s a, there’s a developing body of research around all of the other constituents that support that.

So back in the sixties, scientists realized that mushrooms are quite special. And there was a lot of focus on cancer and mushrooms are hard to grow. So they thought let’s grow the mycelium in a tank of liquid, and then we might be able to extract the, the highly specific beta glucans from that mycelium, do it more cheaply and create like a drug out of it. So when we’re talking about mycelium, that’s the like, legitimate way to make a product from mycelium. So PSK and PSP from Turkey Tail, which are kind of famous names as, as very highly specific. beta glucans with, with proteins attached. Um, that’s, that’s a legitimate way to do it.

And there’s a large volume of science to back that up. So it’s a new discovery. Um, and for a new discovery to [00:44:00] have value in a modern setting, you’ve got to have the research to back it up. So the research has been done and it’s really overwhelming and conclusive. So if you want to embrace the use of mushrooms, They’re the two aspects of mushrooms you need to use.

Dr. Weitz: Now, by the way, if you look at a mushroom, you’ll see this, uh, let’s say you look at a traditional, um, you know, white mushroom, black mushroom, uh, you’ll see this bulbous thing and then you’ll see a little stem. Is that stem, is that the mycelium?

Lee Carroll: The mycelium is inside the the substrate that is being used as the food.  So it might be in the soil. It might be in the log.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. But, but it’s not in either the stem or the bulb.

Lee Carroll: Well, we’re getting into technical territory. So let me take that out for you. So the main organism of a fungus. Um, [00:45:00] is, is made up of mycelium and that mycelium inhabits the environment that, uh, that fungi is suited to.  So it might be a decomposing log. So the purpose of that mycelium, that’s kind of like the body of the fungus. So it’s rationale for life is to survive, to eat food, and then when conditions are right, reproduce. So when the conditions are right, that, that fungus produces the fruiting body or the mushroom, and then that’s the reproductive structure.  So you’ve, and then you’ve got spores, which are kind of like, in essence, the seeds. So you’ve got those three parts. as an analogy is much more complex. So the thing that’s really confusing the supplement industry at the moment is that people grow the mycelium on brown rice or sorghum or [00:46:00] oats, and then that gets that gets dried.

No fruiting bodies may be present or there may be primordial fruiting bodies or there may be a scant number of fruiting bodies. Um, those products get dried and they get sold as if they’re a mushroom and they’re not technically a mushroom. They’re a, they’re a digested or a technical, it’s not fermented really, but it’s a processed food and the science is not conclusive yet on any of the active constituents in those products and what they do.  There’s a small amount of science to suggest that they might have some immunological benefits, which puts it into the category of the shiitake that you mentioned earlier that’s grown on brown rice. So many people are being confused at the moment and they’re buying myceliated grains or mycelium on grain thinking that they’re getting a mushroom.

And you’ve got really slick [00:47:00] marketing campaigns that are behind these products. And if you want to be scientific about it, you know, there’s no consensus yet on what’s in those products that makes them work. They don’t contain beta glucans in any therapeutic level. Their ergotheanine is not detectable.

If you’re looking at Reishi, Reishi only produces its bitter molecules that I mentioned earlier, if it grows on wood. So if you grow it on brown rice, you don’t get any triterpene. So my myceliated Reishi, brown rice isn’t bitter. So you can’t get any of the, the pharmacological benefits of those bitter molecules.

So I do think that there will be some benefit to these products, but we can’t call them a mushroom and the benefits are likely to be very different and derived from a different set of chemistry to that from which, you know, the mycelium, the pure mycelium or the fruiting body is delivering. [00:48:00]

Dr. Weitz: So you’re saying to No, we’re going to get the benefits of mushroom supplements.  We’ve got to make sure that the product contains only from the fruiting body and not the mycelium.

Lee Carroll: No, the, it can be the fruiting body that can be the pure mycelium as a beta glucan. Oh, standardized extract. Or it’s the myceliated grain products, which are an outlier and they, they shouldn’t be considered a mushroom.  And the companies that promote those products, piggyback off all of the traditional claims. So let’s just use Reishi as the example. When you grow Reishi on brown rice, you get, you get very low levels of beta glucans and you get no triterpenes and none of the other molecules are there in any significant level.  So it’s unethical and fraudulent in a way to use the traditional claims that have been developed around the consumption of the mushroom or the fruiting body, which has got high levels of beta glucans, it’s got high levels of triterpenes. It’s not, it’s not. 

Dr. Weitz: So you’re saying there’s, there’s two problems.  The first problem is if the mushrooms used, in the supplement or even the mushrooms you buy at the store. If they’re not grown on the right medium, then you’re not going to get the right product. How do we know the mushrooms we even buy at the store are being grown the right way?

Lee Carroll: Well, the ones that you buy at the store you’re pretty safe.

Dr. Weitz: Oh, we know they’re going to be grown the right way, not on brown rice or

Lee Carroll: no, it’s the, it’s the supplements that, okay.

Dr. Weitz: Okay, so, so then when we’re talking about supplements, number one, [00:50:00] the mushroom in the, uh, supplement needs to be grown on the right medium to have the right raw ingredients, and then if the mycelium is grown on grains, how, how do we know if it says mycelium, that the mycelium is grown on grains, does it have to say that?

Lee Carroll: It has to say that on the label.

Dr. Weitz: Okay.

Lee Carroll: But the trickery is that the labels are replete with images of all of the mushrooms. So you get the consumer gets tricked into thinking, uh, and the average consumer doesn’t, you know, isn’t an avid reader of the labels. So it’s, it’s easy to be misled. So it’s incumbent upon the mycelium on grain manufacturers and producers and sellers to do the research to demonstrate that there is efficacy.  And there’s only a very small amount of that efficacy. [00:51:00] And the people that are prominent in that area create confusion by saying, you know, beta glucans, you know, aren’t all that everybody makes them out to be. There’s other things there.  

Dr. Weitz: So what should the label of a good quality mushroom supplement say in terms of where it’s from?

Lee Carroll: So it should say the, the exact, um, path that’s being used. So, um, the mushroom or the pure mycelium. So, you know, some products, as we talked about, you know, you, When you’ve got pure mycelium that’s grown in a submerged culture, you can get a pure beta glucan from that. And then there’s good evidence around, you know, how they work.

But for the most, they’re not as freely available. So the label should say that it’s, that it’s made from mushroom. It should have the levels of beta glucan. Um, in there for to, to ensure that [00:52:00] there’s, you know, going to be efficacy and where, where, uh, mushrooms have got easily measurable actives. Like Lion’s Mane, there aren’t standard tests yet, so you can’t put it on the label, um, if, if a label says it’s standardized for, for, um, the secondary metabolites, the haricinones that we talked about, that’s not possible because labs can’t do that test yet, so Reishi should have triterpenes on the label, and then a mushroom should be organic, Um, there’s, there’s good access to, you know, organic mushrooms these days and that guarantees, you know, an enhanced level of safety because mushrooms, um, you know, can fall foul of pesticides and chemicals just like plants can.  And China grows like 85, 90 percent of the mushrooms in the world. And they’re a very high quality source for mushrooms. So [00:53:00] the fact that China is the country of origin, um, you know, for many things, it might be a negative, but it’s not a negative for, for mushrooms.

Dr. Weitz: Yeah. As soon as I hear China, I’m like, ah,

Lee Carroll: Yeah, and rightly so. However mushrooms that the growers that, that Real Mushrooms and, and the parent company Namex work with are in the, in the woods of China. They’re being grown in, in pristine places in an organic way. Uh, and very often by people that are the embodiment of the tradition of those mushrooms.  So, there’s a huge amount of ancestral knowledge in China around the use of mushrooms. There’s, there’s numerous mushroom research institutes, you know, I think there’s only one in the US. Um, so. If you, if you’re growing mushrooms in the middle of Beijing, you know, [00:54:00] like, yeah, that might be a problem, but, you know, China is a massive country and there’s plenty of opportunities to, um, grow mushrooms where they’re, where they’re most ideally suited to grow.

Dr. Weitz:  So in terms of supplements, like the real mushroom supplements, is it, is it, better that the supplements are a capsule with powder, or that it’s in a liquid tincture, or some people make a coffee out of mushrooms, make a beverage out of it. Does that affect its efficacy?

Lee Carroll: It, unfortunately it does. Um, it is possible to make a good quality liquid mushroom extract, but I just don’t see any on the market. When you remove the moisture, you can get more concentration. So it’s much more cost effective to, and much more therapeutic in my opinion, to take a dried extract as a capsule compared to a liquid.  All of them. You can see behind me, I use a lot of liquids in my clinic. I see that. You got tinctures. Yeah. Even the, even the high quality professional lines that I use don’t do a good job of liquid mushroom extract. So it is possible. I just don’t see any. So. For the, for the consumer, I think it’s much safer to stick with a, with a dried extract.  There’s lots of reasons to back that up, but they get a bit kind of technical.

Dr. Weitz: So give us an idea of what, what sorts of supplements, let’s say somebody’s on a longevity program and they want to have maximal Brain Health, Neurological Health, Cardiovascular Health. What might be a regimen of, uh, mushroom supplements that they might want to include?

Lee Carroll: Good question.  I’ve been doing mushrooms every day [00:56:00] now since 2020 when I kind of discovered them. Um, so it takes time for the effects to build up. With me, one of the curious effects, there’s two curious effects. Been a herbalist 35 years and my frequency of of infections has been less in the last four years than it was in the previous 15.  So the only difference is mushrooms and my white hair is going black again. So there’s something about the Reishi that I take daily that’s rejuvenating the, the, the pigment cells in my hair. So to get the, to get the benefit out of mushrooms, it can’t be a fad. You have to buy into it. 

Dr. Weitz:  I’ll be totally honest with you, looking at your hair, I’m not sure I’m going to buy the idea that it makes your hair darker, but.

Lee Carroll: Oh, my hair was pure white. Oh, okay. And there’s about 15 percent black hairs there now. You can’t see it on the camera. Right, okay. So it’s just ever so slowly [00:57:00] going back to its original color. Okay. So for people to get the best out of mushrooms, you need to do a range of mushrooms. So, you know, a number of them over the course of years, you can’t just do it for a few months and say, Oh, I tried mushrooms and I didn’t get any benefit.

Dr. Weitz:  Right, I get that. It’s a long term deal.

Lee Carroll: So Real Mushrooms has got a product called 5 Defenders. So it’s got 5 mushrooms. Uh, there’s Lion’s Mane, sorry, there’s, there’s, um, Reishi, there’s, there’s Chaga, there’s Turkey Tail, there’s Maitake and Shitake. So that’s a fantastic blend if you’re, it’s available as a powder or a capsule.  So if you like it as a hot beverage or a cold beverage, it’s a very kind of strong, um, um, Robust, uh, coffee kind of like flavor. So, I would, that’s, I do, I do that daily. Um, so 

Dr. Weitz:  You have the powder or the capsules?

Lee Carroll: I like the powder. So, I do [00:58:00] a gram of that a day. 

Dr. Weitz: Could you add that to your, let’s say I, I made some coffee.  Could I pour that in there?

Lee Carroll: You could, yeah. I like mine neat, but a lot of people like it with the addition of a coffee flavor. So it’s entirely up to the individual how they want to, you know, kind of use that. So one or two grams of that a day, uh, long term is kind of like a, a, a basis for good health.  Um, and then if there’s concerns about cognitive function, I’d take lion, I’d take lion’s mane, you know, one, two, three grams a day. Um, if, if there’s lung and kidney issues, uh, in the patient, I’d recommend cordyceps. If there was, uh, an interest in improving athletic function, then, you know, cordyceps. And then to ensure that there’s enough Ergotheanine, because many of the benefits of mushrooms aren’t just, um, beta glucans, they’re ergotheanine.

I’d re I recommend, [00:59:00] um, taking an Ergo Plus capsule, which delivers a minimum of five milligrams of ergotheanine a day. So, um, you know, those, those three things, so the five defenders as a base, Pick a mushroom that suits, you know, your individual and specific needs, and then add a bit of ergothionine in.  And wherever I get the chance with a patient, that’s what I do.

Dr. Weitz: Right. Cool. So, I think, um, I’m ready to wrap. Um, final thoughts for listeners and viewers, and then, uh, tell us how we can get a hold of the real mushrooms. Are these just sold professionally through practitioners? Or are they sold direct to patients?

Lee Carroll: So it’s through both. So some practitioners have got, uh, accounts and it’s, direct to consumer, so you won’t find it in a shop per se. Okay? So if you go to real mushrooms.com, um, you’ll see all of the products [01:00:00] there. If you use my name, uh, just LEE, it’s very hard for me to say e with an American accent,  So you’ll get, you’ll get, uh, 20% off your order and, okay. My final comment, uh, I think in this whole topic is that mushrooms aren’t a fad. Uh, we need to accept that, um, you know, they’re a natural part of our human history and we need to start taking them as foods and as supplements and never stop. Um, you know, they need to become an integral part of our, of our daily lifestyle routine, just like exercise.  You can’t do. All of your exercise in one year of your life and have the rest of your life off. You know, you’ve got to do it regularly. 

Dr. Weitz: So the website is what? Realmushrooms.com?

Lee Carroll: Yeah, realmushrooms. com.

Dr. Weitz: Cool. Well, thank you so much,

Lee Carroll: Lee. My pleasure, Ben. It’s been wonderful. I’ve enjoyed chatting with you.

 


 

Dr. Weitz: Thank you for making it all the way through this episode of the Rational Wellness Podcast. For those of you who enjoy Listening to the Rational Wellness Podcast, I would appreciate it if you could go to Apple Podcasts or Spotify and give us a 5 star ratings and review. If you would like to work with me personally to help you improve your health, I do accept a limited number of new patients per month for a functional medicine consultation.  Some of the areas I specialize in include helping patients with specific health issues, like gut problems. neurodegenerative conditions, autoimmune diseases, cardiometabolic conditions, or for an executive health screen and to help you promote longevity and take a deeper dive into some of those factors that can lead to chronic diseases along the way.  Please call my Santa Monica White Sports Chiropractic and Nutrition Office at [01:02:00] 310 395 3111. And we’ll set you up for a new consultation for functional medicine. And I look forward to speaking to everybody next week.

Alan Barrier discusses The Hypothalamus, Pituitary, Adrenal, Thyroid Axis with Dr. Ben Weitz.

[If you enjoy this podcast, please give us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts, so more people will find The Rational Wellness Podcast. Also check out the video version on my WeitzChiro YouTube page.]

 

Podcast Highlights

5:01  Some people think of Standard Process as this antiquated brand, but it has existed for 95 plus years because patients who take the products get results. Their products all come from their certified organic farms, which they manage in the US.  We should be more connected to the plants that nurture us.  How well our cells function is related to the quality of the nutrients that we take into our bodies through our diets.  The Minnesota Starvation Study by Ancel Keys involved a number of men reducing their calories to 1000 calories per day and their psychological behavior got very bad. They started diving into dumpsters, fighting one another, stealing food from the kitchen. So we understood that that psychological expression of starvation caused us to become ravenous and demand nutrients.  To get them back to health they tried giving them a drink with high dosages of synthetic vitamins and there was no physiological change.  But once they gave them nutrient dense food, the epigenetic changes of their cells turned back on, and their cells regrew into an activation factor and they gained their weight back.  What we actually need to change is our philosophy to help. We need to return to the soil. We need to return to the nutrient density of nature.  

9:55 Thyroid Health.  The thyroid exerts hormone effects across nearly all organ systems by increasing their function and metabolism.  You have thyroid receptors on every cell of your body.  Every 13 minutes, all of the blood that’s in your body travels through your thyroid.  It starts with the hypothalamus releasing thyroid releasing hormone, resulting in the pituitary gland releasing thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH).  TSH travels to the thyroid and activates the thyroid to produce T4, thyroxin, which then gets converted into T3.  

 

 



Alan Barrier is is the National Product Sales Training Manager for Standard Process supplement company. The website is StandardProcess.com.

Dr. Ben Weitz is available for Functional Nutrition consultations specializing in Functional Gastrointestinal Disorders like IBS/SIBO and Reflux and also Cardiometabolic Risk Factors like elevated lipids, high blood sugar, and high blood pressure.  Dr. Weitz has also successfully helped many patients with managing their weight and improving their athletic performance, as well as sports chiropractic work by calling his Santa Monica office 310-395-3111.

 



Podcast Transcript

Dr. Weitz: [00:00:00] Hey, this is Dr. Ben Weitz, host of the Rational Wellness Podcast. I talk to the leading health and nutrition experts and researchers in the field to bring you the latest in cutting edge health information. Subscribe to the Rational Wellness Podcast for weekly updates. And to learn more, check out my website, drweitz.com. Thanks for joining me. And let’s jump into the podcast. Welcome, everybody. Thanks for coming to the Functional Medicine Discussion Group. And please tell your colleagues I’ve been working to try to get everybody to come back to in person and everybody’s so used to Zoom. So tell all your colleagues in the functional medicine world that these are great educational events.  I hope you’ll consider attending some of our future events. Next month August 22nd, Dr. Howard Elkin will be speaking about Integrative Cardiology, and September, this meeting’s going to be on a Tuesday, so it’s going to be Tuesday, September 24th. Also, by the way, I welcome feedback if listeners prefer Tuesdays instead of Thursdays. We usually meet on the 4th Thursday of the month, but September 24th, Dr. Tom O’Brien is going to be speaking to us. He’s got a great new presentation on mystifying lipopolysaccharides and I encourage everybody to participate and ask questions. And if you’re not aware, we have a closed Facebook group for practitioners, the Functional Medicine Discussion Group of Santa Monica, so please join that.  Also, this event is going to be recorded. And included in my weekly rational wellness podcast, so please check that out you can find it wherever you see podcasts, as well as there’s a video version on YouTube, and if you do listen to it, enjoy it, please give me a ratings and review on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.  And now I’d like to thank our sponsors for this evening. We have Integrative Therapeutics and Standard Process. 


Dr. Weitz: So I really appreciate Integrative Therapeutics for being our monthly sponsor. And since the topic is hypothalamus adrenal pituitary axis they make the Cortisol Manager which is one of the best selling products on the market for managing adrenal function and includes adaptogens for adrenals and now we’d like Standard Process to come up and tell us about their company.


Hi, I’m Kaylee. I’m the Standard Process rep for West Los Angeles. I have a bachelor’s degree in nutrition. I’m a nutritional therapy practitioner, and I just graduated with my master’s in herbal medicine, so.

Love Mediherb. It’s kind of my wheelhouse, but [00:03:00] yeah, we have a 500 acre organic farm up in Wisconsin, and 80 percent of the Ingredients in our products are from our organic farm. But yeah, I would love to talk to you guys after and set up a meeting to discuss standard process further. We did just launch a new product called Biofilm ProBalance.  It’s kind of a three pronged approach. We have organic kale from the farm, organic garlic. An enzyme alpha amylase as well as three screens of probiotic help support the gut microbiome. So we published a white paper on it and would love to give you that information after this presentation. So thank you.


Dr. Weitz:  So now I want to introduce our speaker for this evening, which is Alan Barrier, and he’s going to talk to us about the hypothalamus/pituitary/adrenal axis. And I’ll let Alan introduce himself further. 

Alan:  Thank you. Thank you, sir. I appreciate it. This is coming through. Everybody can hear pretty well.  Wonderful. If you need, can you hear me now? Is that okay? Yep. Is it okay? I just, [00:04:00] yes, sir. Without the microphone. Okay.  So can I use that one? It sounded like that was a little bit more booming. Oh, that’s that one. That one’s a little bit more booming, baby. Okay. My name’s Alan Barrier. I’m with Standard Process.  I’ve been with the company for 15 years. And so during my time with the company, I ran an independent on, on Uh, business model down in Northern Florida. So I was responsible for managing the brand, marketing it clinical insight, and now transitioned into the new company structure. And I’ve now gone to training the sales force on the product line.

So I have a deep appreciation for the history of Whole Food Nutrition, Dr. Royal Lee, as well as many of the philosophies that have built this company. So when we think about Standard Process, we have to understand there’s always this attitude that this is an antiquated brand, but that’s just not the case.  For 95 plus years, we’ve existed, we’ve existed based on results. If we were, if our products would have, we would have known seven decades ago that these products didn’t work. So we know to this day that our philosophy has an impact on human health. Can I just show you a picture here before we even get into the conversation on thyroid?  Plants. You see this plant here in the ground, this is actually our Organic Farms Standard Process. As Kaylee was discussing, our Certified Organic Farms. If one of these plants were to start to show disruption, they weren’t flourishing. Kaylee. What would you do as a gardener? You would put a stick in the ground, you would tie the plant to the stick, and then what?  You would feed the soil. One of the things that we’ve gotten to in society is this disconnection between our relationship with the nutrients that we take into our bodies through our diets and the quality of how our cells function. Now, one of the studies I like to reference in regards to that concept is the Minnesota Starvation Study.

This was done by Ancel Keys. And Ancel Keys is very famous for a seven country study on saturated fat and cholesterol, which there are a lot of, let’s say, inaccuracies in the reporting of that study and our understanding of saturated fat and health. But one of the studies on the Minnesota study that was so interesting was post World War II he took a number of men and began taking their diets down 1,000 calories a day. And what he was really monitoring was the psychological expression of the individuals. And they showed individuals diving into dumpsters, fighting one another, stealing food from the kitchen. So we understood that that psychological expression of starvation caused us to become ravenous and demand nutrients.

But once they had them on that low calorie diet, when they wanted to bring them back to health. The synthetic vitamin model was just entering into the lexicon of society because we were discovering vitamins in food and in the laboratory we were able to mimic that compound. So we were making high dosage vitamin C and high dosage vitamin E supplements.  And so what they did was they actually added those into a drink for those patients and gave that to them to see how they responded. And there was no physiological change.  But once they gave them food, and it was nutrient dense food, not high calorie food, because you can’t just, again, refeeding somebody a lot of calories.

Just by giving them nutrient dense foods, the epigenetic changes of their cells turn back on, and their cells re grew into an activation factor and weight poured back onto the body. So we have this relationship that there is a magic substance out there that if we put into our bodies, our physiology will change. What we actually need to change is our philosophy to help. We need to return to the soil. We need to return to the nutrient density of nature. Whether or not you see this world as a 6,000 year old world, or what would be considered the long version, billions of years. You have to take into [00:08:00] consideration all of the physical processes that brings that soil into existence.

The earthworms churning it. The importance of understanding volcanic, eruptions, our distance from the sun, the moon, the atmosphere, the water cycle, all of these physical processes have to take place for the nutrients even to come into existence. It’s once we believe that our human consciousness could mimic that we could play God with nutrition is when we got offset.  And this is what happened to our food supply. He began denaturing our foods and adding these synthetic vitamins back to it and mimicking a marketing approach on the importance of these vitamins for health. And all we did was sustain life. Remember the difference between a vitamin from nature and a vitamin that we make in a laboratory.  Laboratory vitamins are essential vitamins. What does that mean? You die without them. But that’s completely different than full growth and development. When you introduce nutrition from nature in a concentrated form, your cells from a genetic perspective see that nutrition and activate a biological process that you can only activate from nutrient density.

So that’s what we do here at Standard Process. So we discuss tonight about the importance of thyroid health and adrenal health. Understand that at the backbone of what we are is to then feed the system and let the system respond to those genetic changes. So with that being said, I’m going to have a discussion tonight on thyroid.  Um, so, please feel free to stop me with any questions as we go through some of the information. Um, but just wanted to give you really an overview of thyroid health and the importance of interacting with it. 

So, first thing is to understand that the thyroid gland exerts hormone effects across nearly all organ systems by increasing their function and metabolism.  You actually have Thyroid receptors on every cell of your body. So you have vitamin A receptors that trigger cell mitosis, and you have thyroid receptors that trigger metabolic activity. So the [00:10:00] importance of having a healthy thyroid means a healthy metabolism.  Every 13 minutes, all of the blood that’s in your body travels through your thyroid.  So it’s important that as we’re thinking about our metabolism in the circulatory system, we want to make sure that this thing is doing its job properly. Now it begins in the hypothalamus, so this is the area of the brain that regulates your entire hormonal cascade.  What happens is, is your hypothalamus releases thyroid releasing hormone this is an activation factor for the pituitary gland.

From there, the pituitary gland releases thyroid stimulating hormone. This is what travels into your thyroid and activates thyroid act production. So this is the opportunity for your body to begin making T4 thyroxin. Now, a portion of T3 is also made in the thyroid. Yet, from there, the T4 actually has to be converted into T3.

Jowitt does this by removing an iodine molecule. [00:11:00] T4 means? It is a tyrosine amino acid bound to four iodine atoms. So for that conversion to T3, which is the tyrosine with three iodine atoms, you actually have to have a selenium based enzyme that converts that, and it does that in multiple areas of the body.

As T3 is approximately eight times more biologically active than T4, activating factor of thyroid And that T cell is 90 percent circulating T3 is being produced. So 90 percent of the circulating T3 is converted with these enzymes in the brain, the liver, and the bloodstream. So your body actually has to function on multiple levels for you to have good thyroid function.

So it’s not just the thyroid, it is the hypothalamus and pituitary. One of the things that we do at Standard Process is we address the body from the tip of the head down to the toes. So when you think about Inflammation [00:12:00] in the hypothalamus. Well, how would you address that? You’ve got to get inflammation under control in the body.

Same issue when it comes to the pituitary gland. What happens when your pituitary gland is chronically stressed? How do you address the pituitary health? These are some of the things that we’re able to offer answers through at Standard Process is support for these tissues. And then from there, your body’s ability to make these conversion factors.

It’s important to make sure you get adequate trace minerals into your diet, which includes selenium. When you understand how we farm in this country, we use what’s called NPK. Nitrogen, Phosphorus, and Potassium. The problem with that is it removes all of the other trace minerals like Magnesium, Selenium, and Zinc, Copper.  All of these trace minerals that are so beneficial to the body, we lack in our diet because of our fertilizing practices in this country.

So from here, the free thyroid hormone binds within the nucleus of a cell and acts to increase [00:13:00] the basal metabolic rate and thermogenesis, causing increased oxygen and energy consumption. It is the gasoline to the body. When we think about hormones, we think about how much hormones we’re producing. To be honest with you, a lifetime of hormone is about a teaspoon.

So these are not very much to the body. It’s the accordance of the quality, how the body manufactures them. that you have the building blocks to do so. From there, other effects of thyroid hormone include the weight, rhythm, and force effects of cardiac functions. So your thyroid regulates your heart. So individuals who have an overactive thyroid, they can have a pounding heart.

So this would be an indication where you might want to look at the thyroid. They can feel their heart beating, but they have a racing heart. Another area that you may look at is the stimulation of the nervous system resulting in increased alertness. Some of the issues when we see an underactive thyroid is brain fog because the mind cannot activate [00:14:00] properly.

Another issue that we actually don’t even discuss in society is anyone aware that an iodine deficiency in childhood leads to a 10 point drop in iq? So the importance of getting iodine into our systems increases the speed of thought. One of the things that happened to me in my past, yes, sir.

Fair, and you know one of the things I will tell you is that I’m not here to promote high dosage iodine. that’s not the idea. It’s the importance of getting iodine into the diet. The reality is that Japanese women living on the coast of Japan are Consume anywhere between 12 and 15 milligrams of iodine daily.

In this country, we [00:15:00] recognize 140 micrograms as the daily RDA. That’s a lot lower, but yet Japanese women living on the coast have some of the lowest levels of ovarian, stomach, and breast cancer in the world. The challenge that we face in society is that we are inundated with chemicals that displace or replace iodine in our systems, and we’ll talk a little bit more about that as we go.

Yes, please. It actually doesn’t, it doesn’t, it’s not a worry about the trace minerals. So there’s no measurement. The NPK actually is steroids for the plant. So you can have trace minerals in the soil, but you have to care about the soil. Our farming practices in this country, they don’t test the soil that way.

In the great dust bowl of the 1940s and 50s was because of monoculture where they didn’t have trace minerals to turn the actual top soil into dust. And that’s what blew across the Midwest. Yeah, I think the point you’re making is that the soil is [00:16:00] depleted and we’re only repleting it with a very small percentage of the minerals that are needed.

Absolutely. Did a lot. Yeah, that microphone was a little low. Okay. So I think what he’s saying is it’s that the soil is depleted. It’s been overutilized and without replenishing, dropping things, like putting all the minerals that we’re just putting in. Yeah, I mean, look, I will tell you this right now. The number one mineral deficiency in the American diet is magnesium.

It’s 50 percent on average lower in your body than you would actually need. When you trace how magnesium functions in the body, it actually regulates your potassium levels. So if you have low magnesium, your body begins to dump potassium. The other thing is, is that when you have Low Magnesium, you actually lower your Parathyroid Hormone, Parathyroid Hormone is [00:17:00] important to stimulate your kidneys to convert Vitamin D2 into the active form of Vitamin D3, I’m sorry, Calcidiol to Calcitriol, which is the active form of Vitamin D.

So, for your kidneys to actually function well, to convert vitamin D, you actually have to have adequate magnesium. So, it really comes down to, do you want to chase a mineral, or do you want to get all of those minerals in your fluid at once? I mean, one of the things that’s great about magnesium, plant based magnesium, comes from Swiss chard and buckwheat.

These are just plants, yet they come in these multiple forms of magnesium, 40 different salt bases. Now, your body does not look at one form of magnesium and say, that’s the one I want. What it wants is complexity. You’re a complex biological system. All of your cells interact with complexity. When we dummy our nutrition down to a molecule, We’re introducing the same concept of NPK into our bodies versus a full [00:18:00] broad spectrum trace mineral soil.

So the importance is to introduce that complexity back into the system, so you can get adequate trace minerals along with magnesium just by eating these nutrient dense plants. As far as some of the other things that thyroid is important for, which is development of fast switch muscle fibers, so when individuals have a hard time exercising and filling satie, Dreading proteins, as we talked about vitamin A receptors, that stimulatory factor is from your thyroid, your thyroid hormones.

It helps to regulate the ovulatory cycle and spermatogenesis. So, again, it both regulates female cycles as well as men’s production of sperm. Now, some of the common causes of acquired thyroid disorders include nutritional deficiencies. Things like iodine, things like tyrosine, things like trace minerals.

One of the things that people don’t realize that before night AIM 40, All essential fatty acids had an iodine number because it was known that when you took fat [00:19:00] in the diet, there was a certain portion of iodine that helped the body to absorb. Some of the best fats for iodine absorption were flaxseed oil.

That’s why we have such a deep relationship with that type of fat. It’s also important in the body to support the metabolism of calcium as well. But when you see the synergy of health, you understand that iodine helps to feed the thyroid, but it also makes calcitonin. Calcitonin is what drives calcium into bones, so our thyroid and fats go hand in hand, so we’re getting good quality fats back into the diet.

I will say this too, whenever you look at all of the studies on the importance of diet, it always reaches back to the Mediterranean diet. Why the Mediterranean diet? Omega 3 fatty acids, healthy fat, soil dense vegetables, fruits, green meats, fish, fish Things that we were meant to have from a nutritional perspective.

Then you can have autoimmune activity against thyroid tissue. [00:20:00] This is the importance of understanding the immune system directly. One of the things that we’re worrying about the gut microbiome is its ability to regulate T regulatory cell production. Now how we do that is we have to interact with compounds that down regulate inflammation through the immune system.

Some of this can come from direct tissue support, such as organotherapy approaches, where you actually take in tissues that are thyroid based. Or looking at other types of themes that support a better microbiome profile, which could include the production of Bacteroidetes. This is where we’re seeing a lot of research on how herbs function and normalize the profile of our gut microbiome.

The other one is Firmicutes. Interestingly enough, when we exercise, Firmicutes is the actual dominant profile that, that shows up. But always remember this. If you want to be firm, we use Firmicutes. It doesn’t mean that you don’t want the Firmicutes, but [00:21:00] Firmicutes upregulates calorie absorption into the body, so children should have elevated Firmicutes as do Boeing, and the elderly need to have elevated Firmicutes to keep eating muscle mass on the body.

But during our midlife, Bacteroidepines is the profile that we’re looking for. This is what helps to regulate inflammation in our immune system to help to down regulate some of these issues. If you have environmental toxins, which we have a slide on that one. And some of the last ones are radiation, surgery, and medication.

So, our current medical practices in this country are leading to damaging effects on the thyroid directives.

So what are some of the supportive lifestyle practices? So let’s talk a little bit more about the stress cycle and the importance of how it affects our thyroid. So promote stress reduction activities, stimulate parasympathetic nervous system. I know many of you in this room are familiar with Andrew Huberman.

Andrew Huberman. But if you ever want to know how to [00:22:00] activate your parasympathetic nervous system, you can just stare as far off to the right as you possibly can until your body sighs, and then back to the left as far as you can until your body naturally sighs again. This is actually an activation factor for your parasympathetic response.

So calming down the stimulatory effects of your sympathetic nervous system. Now what happens in regards to an overstimulated sympathetic nervous system is elevated cortisol This can lead to decreased levels of free T3 and increase the risk of autoimmune activity against the thyroid. So just to give you kind of an indication of what that looks like here, this is your hypothalamus in the brain and your pituitary as well as your thyroid.

Now what happens in the hypothalamus is that you have your thyroid releasing hormone. which triggers the anterior pituitary to release thyroid stimulating hormone, and then your thyroid releases T4, which is either converted into [00:23:00] reverse T3, or T3 based on the quality of selenium in your body. Now from here, these back lines here in the middle, show that cortisol inhibit TSH, and then also inhibit the conversion of T4 to T3.

So, it’s more important to keep your stress under control when it comes to the importance of the quality of your thyroid outcomes. Now, some of the other things that you can do to regulate your cortisol levels is to encourage regular exercise, utilizing a combination of both moderate aerobic intensity.

So, this is the idea of getting your cardiovascular exercise in, making sure your heart is functioning better. as well as weight bearing activities, which can increase more of your growth hormone and give you a better hormonal response as well, making your tissues more sensitive to T4 8. So again, exercise improves thyroid function by increasing tissue sensitivity to the hormone, promoting healthy weight management, And [00:24:00] improving perfusion of the th to the thyroid gland itself.

So helping the thyroid to both uptake nutrients as well as to excretions. So in understanding the cortisol, we actually need to have a relationship with the importance of the cortisol cycle. So the way our bodies work in a circadian rhythm is that we release melatonin throughout the night. Now, Melatonin itself is made from Vitamin D, Tryptophan, and Magnesium in the brain.

So it’s, this is one of the more important reasons why brain Magnesium crossing the blood brain barrier is so important, so that you can keep sleep pressure on the brain. But what happens in the morning is that Cortisol rises, and this is your awaking hormone. So people who have challenges with Cortisol.

We’ll have issues where they may wake in the middle of the night, or they’re tired in the morning and cheat up at the end of the day, or they may have low cortisol and are fatigued all the way throughout the day. So they wake up tired and go to bed tired.[00:25:00]

So what does hypercortisemia look like? So high levels of cortisol. So in an acute stress response, the body’s fight or flight response leads to temporary physiological changes, such as increased heart rate and adrenaline release. I know you’ve heard this before. But if you’re in the wild and a tiger is chasing you, the most important thing for you to do is run as fast as you can and avoid being harmed.

So your body is going to then pick up your heart rate. We know adrenaline does that because that’s what coffee does. When you drink caffeinated coffee, it makes your heart rate go up. This is why we give people EpiPens. If you have an anaphylactic shock when it comes to having a food allergy, you immediately give them epinephrine to make our heart beat faster.

So what we want to do in an acute stress response is have an elevation of that. Now we do release cortisol as an anti inflammatory. From an evolutionary perspective, if a tiger gets you, you’re bitten. You [00:26:00] need to immediately trigger an anti inflammatory response in those tissues. So the body is naturally going to bring out cortisol for that purpose, and its secondary benefit is as a glucocorticoid to raise your blood sugar levels.

Because now your muscles can be fed with the sugar and keep your energy levels up. But it also inhibits over activation of the immune system. And the reason for that is, is that if you’re running from a tiger in the moment, you don’t want to be in a rest and digest relaxation response. You want your immune system to be suppressed while you’re getting away.

Now the problem is when chronic stress takes place. This occurs when the stressor persists over an extended period of time. This is an issue where you have continued elevation of cortisol. So your body is constantly pressing the body on the stress response. This leads to continuous elevation of blood sugar.

This is why nurses who work night times have some of the highest rates of type 2 diabetes in the world. Because of their inability to have a [00:27:00] normal cortisol cycle, they’re tired all the time and they’re stressed all the time. So this is what leads to their physiological outcomes. Immunosuppression or susceptibility to infections.

One of the things about increasing blood sugar is that it’s been shown in research studies to suppress your immune system by about an hour and a half. And that’s a challenge when you think about it. So Just for fun, who here knows the first day of flu season?

November 1st. Why would it be November 1st? It’s the day after Halloween. All of those kids consume all that sugar, suppresses their immune system, they walk into class the next day, the first kid that sneezes on them, I’ve got the flu. Guess what we have for you? The answer, right? And so, at the end of the day, it’s all about regulating blood sugar so that you can have a better immune response.

So individuals who are under [00:28:00] chronic stress, it’s actually end up suppressing their immune system, and this is also going to lead to a dysbiotic gut. So just to kind of came back to again, as we’ve been discussing the importance of the pituitary effects, it releases ACTA that cortisol. This will cause faster breathing, this converts that glycogen storage site of sugar into glucose, it’ll increase your blood pressure, You’ll get tunnel vision.

This is a nice way of actually looking at someone’s adrenal insufficiency. You can actually shine a light into their eye. The retina inside their eye should constrict. The muscle should change. If you have proper adrenal function, once you start seeing adrenal fatigue, it’ll flutter. And then from there, if they have adrenal exhaustion, it’ll just dilate because they don’t have enough of an adrenal response to contract the eye.

So it’s a nice window into adrenal function. Very simple test to look at. You can have accelerated [00:29:00] acceleration of heart rate. And digestion slows down as well as sweating. Now, one of the reasons why I want to discuss acceleration of heart rate for adrenaline is the importance of understanding Laglan’s test.

So, this is an old test done by medical doctors looking at adrenal insufficiency. So, what they essentially did was they would take the blood pressure of the patient lying down and immediately have them stand up. Your systolic blood pressure should rise by 10 points. Why is that? Because when you go from lying down to standing up, Your heart can’t beat fast enough to get oxygen into your brain.

So your adrenal glands have to release adrenaline to stimulate your heart to beat fast. So if you take their blood pressure lying down and then standing up, and you don’t get a systolic raise, there’s no adrenaline being released by the adrenal glands. So Radlin’s test is a wonderful insight into adrenal insufficiency, and a great thing to address nutrition with, and see if your nutrition is actually working.[00:30:00]

So again, when we think about the General Adaptation Syndrome, or GAS, this was brought to us by Hans Selye. and understanding the different phases of the adrenal response. We go into an alarm phase, a resistance phase, and then to an exhaustion phase. In the alarm phase, we have the initial stressor and adrenaline response, fight or flight, increased blood pressure blood sugar, and heart rate.

Now, if you’re interested in continuing to understand your studies on this concept, a great book to read is Robert Sapolsky’s Why Zebras Don’t Get Ulcers. Think about a zebra in the wild, just chewing on grass. The lion chases it, it runs, and then stops and chews on grass again. So that’s how your adrenal glands should work.

You should stress, and then calm down. But if you’re always stressed, you can see how our adrenal glands aren’t functioning properly. Now what happens is, we can get into a resistance phase, This is where the stress continues and the body compensates the signs of anxiety, insomnia, [00:31:00] appear as cortisol is chronically released.

So this would be the individual who tries to go to sleep at night, but they have so much stress hormone they can’t fall asleep. Their mind is just racing, racing, and race. Now what happens is you get into an exhaustion phase. This is the inability to manage chronic stress. So you get a depletion of hormones and fatigue and inflammation worse.

This is the individual who wakes up in the middle of the night and can’t go back to sleep. So, on average, Americans at the breakfast table will eat anywhere between 200 and 400 grams of carbohydrate. What this does is it spikes their blood sugar, and in response, they spike their insulin. The insulin will drive the blood sugar down, but there’s still too much insulin.

Here, a body does not make insulin in response to the blood sugar. So, what ends up happening is you have to make stress hormones, glucocorticoids, to release stored sugar into circulation. The problem with that is, is all day long, your body is yo yoing that response. So you wait [00:32:00] for candy, coffee, or something to stimulate you throughout the day.

The problem is you lie down to sleep at night. You can fall asleep because your cortisol levels are low. Yet your blood sugar dips even lower while you’re asleep, and your body says you’re going to die. So I’m going to dump cortisol into circulation, and all of a sudden at one o’clock in the morning, I’m awake again.

And I can’t go back to sleep. So when you think about cortisol and its regulation of our waking up response, also think about the effects of blood sugar, as well as your adrenal function.

So some supportive lifestyle practices. If you’re not doing a purification detoxification type program in your practice, now’s the time to get started. One of the things that we know is we need to minimize our exposure to these endocrine disrupting chemicals. And they actually disrupt the thyroid directly.

So this is what thyroxin looks like on a chemical level. You can see two benzene rings. You have your iodine molecules. [00:33:00] Now, what we do know is that when you look at dioxins, two benzene rings, it looks like thyroxin. You have VPA, bisphenol A, it looks like thyroxin. So if you’re loaded in toxic compounds in your body and you’re not supporting Phase 1 and Phase 2 detoxification with your sulfur containing plants like kale and russet sprouts or Spanish black radish, you’re not supporting your Phase 2 mechanisms.

You can push the body with chemicals, but you need to feed it as well.

To some whole food nutritional recommendations, ensure adequate but not excessive amounts of iodine. I’m not a fan of iodine. Brownstein, Guy Abraham, Overload the Thyroid with Iodine. Remember that your body is going to displace iodine with halogen molecules like bromide and fluoride as well as picolinate, which is a jet fuel.  And so [00:34:00] whenever you take too much iodine into the system, your body tries to dump all of those halogen molecules at one time. It will put stress on your kidneys and your liver. So you want to make sure that you nourish the kidneys and liver to be able to handle the detoxification before you ever start ramping up iodine.

So it’s not so much that you don’t want to not use iodine, you just want to use adequate amounts. So the American Thyroid Association says that 600 micrograms a day is safe. But at the same time, the upper limit is 1. 6 mg of iodine. So you can take a little bit more iodine in certain cases. But at the end of the day, you can also get iodine containing foods.  Iodized salt, fish, seaweed, and dairy products. Now iodine deficiency can lead to hypothyroidism. That excess iodine has been shown to precipitate thyroid issues and exacerbate pre existing thyroid conditions. Now, the Weft Checkoff effect prevents the thyroid from synthesizing large [00:35:00] amounts of thyroid hormone by rejecting excessive iodine quantities.  So you’re not going to just take a bunch of iodine and make the thyroid worth better. It’s more about getting adequate amounts of iodine on a regular basis.

Some other whole food nutritional recommendations is to promote proper thyroid hormone conversion by supplying that adequate amounts of selenium. Zinc is important for thyroid receptors, so all the receptors of your body require adequate zinc. Now what I will remind everyone about zinc is that we have what are called metalloproteins in our bodies.

A metalloprotein is something like hemoglobin, which is important for binding iron. Now, these metalloproteins have a cascading effect of which mineral they actually want to attach to. And much of your metalloproteins need copper. Once you have inadequate amounts of copper in your diet, the next mineral that these metalloproteins go after is zinc.

So when you’re giving [00:36:00] zinc to your patients and they’re not responding to the therapy, it’s because they have a copper deficiency. So you have to address the importance of copper. Now copper is not one of those scenarios where you just want to get copper directly. Copper is naturally occurring in things like mushrooms and potatoes in the form of chirosomase.

This is organic copper, biologically active copper. So getting these feeds back into your diet allows you to get adequate copper, which also feeds your adrenal system as well. So when we think about the importance of zinc, you also have to address other minerals, but zinc is important for those receptor sites.

It is necessary for the production and activation, again, of T4 to T3. So selenium is a trace mineral found in things like Brazil nuts and organ meats. But one of the things about organ meats, Organ meats are the most nutrient dense foods you can possibly eat. We just don’t have a relationship with it. In 1952, the average American ate liver twice a week.

When’s the last time any other person [00:37:00] in this room has had liver for dinner? He just don’t consume it as much as we used. And so, the idea of things like blood sausage, or sweet bread, or kidney pie, you just don’t consume these foods on average any longer. But we do know that historically, we did have a relationship with them.

You can actually go back to ancient Egyptian papyruses, where you can see them actually consuming liver for night blindness. So we do have a relationship throughout human history with organ meats. And if you look at animals in the wild, when a lion kills a zebra, it eats its adrenal glands and heart, and its intestines, and its kidneys, and leaves the muscle meat for the jackals.

So, you can see a lion is a beautiful specimen of strength and power in nature. And what is it eating to get that outcome? Is the organ it eats. Zinc is found in oysters, beef, fish, and seafood. I [00:38:00] commend that those with underactive thyroid avoid consuming large amounts of raw goitrogenic foods such as Brussels sprouts, kale, and broth.

It’s not that you shouldn’t eat these foods, it’s just that goitrogens are sensitive to food processing, including heat, which can denature them, and steaming has been shown to reduce their effect. So have steamed kale. Have steamed Brussels sprouts. Have steamed broth. Because of what these compounds actually do is they ramp up phase 2 liver detoxification.

That actually helps the body to clear thyrox. So you don’t want to clear thyroxine when you have an underactive thyroid. So the importance then is to make sure you slightly prepare those instead of eating them in their raw state. Now, raw food is very healthy for you. I don’t want to tell you not to eat raw.

There was a study done in 1951 in Switzerland by the name, a doctor by the name of Dr. And what he did was he was actually monitoring white blood cell activity and whether [00:39:00] or not you ate cooked food or raw. And what he found was that people were eating cooked food and it would stimulate an immune response.

But when they ate raw, there was no immune response. But the nice thing was when they ate half cooked and half raw, there was no immune response. So it doesn’t mean that you have to eat 100 percent raw, but you need to have some raw food in your diet that will keep your immune system from over responding.

And so if you’re not consuming raw foods. Consider raw supplements and a few concentrates that can help to supply that outcome for you as well.

So this is what a few looks like. This is what most people don’t consume. I know we live in challenging times. You know, we live in food deserts at times, getting access to organic foods, nutrient dense foods, knowing that the farmer or the individual who are pulling the fish or making the dairy products is taking care of the supplying substance, the soil, the anima, their farming practices.

But at the end of the day, this is what we need to have a [00:40:00] relationship with, is healthy foods, because there are healing factors within foods that you can only get by eating these. The problem that we face in this country is this is what the average American diet looks like. These foods are made in a laboratory, just like synthetic vitamins, where they’re there to try to stimulate a response.

Push a pathway, but when it comes to foods, they actually use what is called functional MRI, where they’ll attach your brain to a system, feed you a food, and watch areas in your reward centers of your brain fire off like fireworks. Thanks. And then they’ll say, we got it. And then they’ll add chemicals that make it taste like food.

And then they’ll add coloring that’ll make it look like we can gas vegetables in this country. You pull them raw. And then we gas them to make the colors come back out. Because when you use NPK, you can’t wait long enough for it to go to its full ripening. It results. [00:41:00] maintain its structure. So we have to gas it so that you’re condensed.

If I’m eating tomatoes at the grocery store, I’m needing help. Now I’ll give you a little bit of insight on how bad industrialized food products are. Rats in laboratories, they’ll stay up against the whale of the king because it’s a survival mechanism. They’re scared of the environment. And what they did was they took those rats that they were feeding pellets to.

They started changing their diet and they gave them foodie pebbles. And those same rats. That would stay against the wall for safety purposes and come out into the open to eat the foodie pups. So it bypassed their evolutionary instinct to survive. That’s what these foods are doing. They’re making us addicted to them to the way that we can’t break our relationship.

So I’m not trying to shame for this. This is an actual travesty in this country where we produce foods that no longer provide health. [00:42:00] The idea that we’re even having a conversation on healthy thyroid is nonsense to me. Not because it’s not important to eat, because if you were eating whole foods all along, having a relationship with them, you wouldn’t have to have these conversations.

It is pottinger’s cats or epigenetics. It’s the sins of the father on the second and third generation. We’re now in a food testing system where we’ve changed the food supply so it can have better shelf life from the small eater so that we can keep it in a grocery store that we can buy and consume. You know, what’s happening is, is we’re now giving birth to children and we’re changing the way, my wife had three miscarriages.

It was the most difficult thing for us to get pregnant, and we’re passing these same types of genetic expressions down generation after generation. And it’s because of those facts of the epigenetic changes, there was a famous doctor named Francis Pottinger in the 1940s, did what was called the Pottinger’s Cat Study, where he was actually trying to renew their adrenal glands.

He wanted to [00:43:00] make a drug, a specific adrenal drug from these adrenal glands. The problem was is people found out he had cats, and so they started giving him cats. So at first, he was just giving him the food that they had access to, which is raw meat and dairy. Now, the problem was, is in the next cats that came in, they didn’t have enough food for them.

So they started giving them food leftovers and powders, that what he ended up finding out was the ones that were getting the second dosage of foods started ningsing their hair. They started having bone density issues and they are, they had issues with co creation by the second and third generation.

They no longer could make hats anymore. And the challenges. When they began feeding the cats properly again, it took them six to seven generations before we normalize again. So the importance of getting whole foods back into your diet is the best thing not only can you do for yourself now, but for the generations to come.

You need to feed people and that’s exactly what we want to do is [00:44:00] provide the missing components in the food supply that they’ve taken out. So this is what conventional pest and weed management looks like. This is putting glycophosphate on to The the plants themselves, if you’re interested in understanding that research and how devastating that concept is, the book is called Whitewash, where they talk about the importance of understanding that pesticide and the diseases that it causes.

And this is what people are consuming that are disrupting their thyroid function. We at Standard Process hand weed our plants. We use no inputs on the soil. We make sure that these nutrient dense soils are full of trace minerals. The mycorrhizae, the bacteria and fungal profiles of the soil and plant have a symbiotic relationship with the nutrient uptake from the soil.

And we make sure that we remove all invading factors that could disrupt that plant’s growth. So this is all hand weeding that we do at Standard Process. www. StandardProcess. com In [00:45:00] there have the healthy plants start with healthy seeds. We actually understand the genetic profile of our seeds to make robust plants.

We have over 800 plus acres of certified organic farm where we choose seeds for nutrient density. These are rows and rows of of plants coming from the standard process farms. On our farm, majority of our ingredients are grown locally from organic farm. Things like alfalfa. Alfalfa has a deep root system.

It goes Coombed to six feet into the soil, pulling minerals from the earth’s crust into the plant. So when you think about the importance of trace minerals, you need alfalfa in your diet. Wiley grass, a wonderful source of chlorophyll. Chlorophyll is plant blood. Plant blood has unique benefits in the human system.

It actually neutralizes the taint poison called guanidine. Elevations in guanidine disrupt thyroid function. So getting more chlorophyll back into your diet. The importance of beedleaf and [00:46:00] roots. One of the things that we know that when your thyroid is not functioning well, dimethylation factors are decreased as well.

One of the things that’s nice about beets, this red coloring in the beet itself, which is very concentrated in the root. Why the root? Because as the nutrients come into the root, it makes the bulb, and from the bulb, there is an explosion of the plant top. So once the bed was made, the concentration of nutrients come out into the stem and the leaf.

are also in the root. So that red coloring is called Vatagln. Vatagln is tri methylglycine. Gly methyl donors on the vagfone of glycine. Interestingly enough, butathione is made from the amino acid glycine. So getting methyl donors, as well as glycine into your diet, is getting beets back into your diet.

Then you add the importance again of brussel sprouts for that phase 2 sulfur. Bonilla. Buckwheat is rich in thioflavonoids. Thanks. This is the plaque, the [00:47:00] structure of our cells. Vitamin C doesn’t work without the bioflavonoids. Nature of bioflavonoids is Mutin. Mutin is an interesting compound. It’s been shown in studies that if you have adequate Mutin in your diet, that it disrupts hemolysis, the breakdown, premature breakdown of your red blood cells.

So when you think about the quality of your circulatory system, it’s important to get those bioflavonoids. Kale, similar to Brussels sprouts, Kidney beans. Kidney beans have an interesting concept eating, they’re shaped like the kidney and they’ve actually found a compound in kidney beans that helps your kidneys to make more urine.

So the importance of getting things like kidney beans, which are also rich in the natural vitamin A precursors so that your body can get more of those on support or vitamin A receptors of the body. Oats are interesting because not only do they have vitamin E and vitamin B, but it’s a rich source of silica.

Silica is what makes your skin integrity more capable. So when you think about [00:48:00] gut lining or your skin, if it’s getting thin or easily cutting, it’s a lack of silica in your diet by getting oats, you can return to that. Pea vine, that’s that vitamin E from nature. One of the things that’s interesting about vitamin E is it’s rich in phytoestrogens as well.

Before the 1950s, if you had stomach ulcers, They would actually inject estrogen into your body to heal the ulcer. So what we actually know now is that it’s an estrogen deficiency. So who gets stomach ulcers? Postmenopausal women and thin men. Because they lack estrogen in the body. Now one of the things that’s nice about plants, by providing those phytoestrogens, you can provide that healing factor, some nature.

Cutting through things like key bind. And then Spanish Black Radish. is wonderful for clearing phase two detoxification factors. So this is our manufacturing facility at Standard Process. These are large drums of the vegetables coming directly from the soil [00:49:00] that we’re going to produce into our tablets.

So the key to the highest quality is the manufacturing process from Dr. Royalee, the founder of Standard Process. So what we do is we harvest crops at their peak nutritional state on the farm. We press them, freshly harvested crops, immediately to extract the juice. www. StandardProcess. com We then dry that juice in low temperature, high vacuum dryers, which we have some new technology that has actually increased the yield of our harvest.

And then we process by milling, mixing, capsuling, and then tabling and bottling products. So this is actually kale coming from our farms. That robust vein system in a beautifully grown organic plant. So robust. We’re able to then juice that out and pull the nutrient density from the tail. So we remove all the fiber and bring the nutrition out of that.

Just as the same concept with Spanish Black Radish and beets, how we chop them and begin the juicing process. This is the RDW dryer system. This is where we take that [00:50:00] juiced fluid and allow it to dehydrate into just the nutrient density from the flour. So what Standard Process is able to do is to give you feed based therapy, so what you’re not able to consume that.

So when you think about the importance of eating beets, if I give you a product called Beta Flute from our line, It is a concentrated beet manure. For me to give you 9 tablets of beta food would be upwards of 15 to 20 beets. Who’s going to sit down and have 15 to 20 beets? Get 9 tablets and give you the nutrient density of those beets.

So it’s gene based there. From there we take the dried powder and begin the tableting process. And from that tableting process, you can see here, we’re able to then bottle it and this is what is delivered to you. So it comes right from the farm. Right from the soil, right from the nutrient density of organic farming, right to your office.

So this is what Standard Process is. It’s Whole Seed Nutrition Therapy. We’re not an antiquated product line. [00:51:00] We are THE product line. You’ve always been right, and you continue to be right. Our job is to feed America, and that’s what we do. So with that being said, a little summary on Whole Foods Supplements.  They’re complex formulas retaining the synergy of nature. They start with the best quality seeds bred for nutrition, grow them to the richest, highest quality soils, harvest our crops at the peak nutritional content, process them quickly and gently to retain the inherent bioactive compounds, and fuel spectrum extracts to obtain whole vitamin and mineral complexes.

So thank you so much for giving me the opportunity to share this message with you tonight.  Please. So do you sell it for me? Yes. Yes. Yes. I’ve seen people eat kong, cow tongue. Now, let me tell you something about this. You know, I used to be [00:52:00] 275 pounds and I had a real challenge in life with my health. I had high cholesterol, high blood pressure. I was doped. And I used to, I’m a, I’m a business graduate from the university of Florida.

And I went during the real estate crash, I was in real estate to start out my career. And I’m, I was looking for a job in pharmaceutical industry. I thought, My dad told me when I was young, if you start taking the drugs, you’ll have to live on the drugs for the rest of your life. So I said, maybe I’ll go work in pharma.

They’ll give me a company car and they’ll give me the secret on how to take better care of myself. And I stumbled into the standup process experience that word. So I, in fact, doored it into this. For six months, I told myself, this is all nonsense. These food tablets? If there was something intuitive about it, carrots and beets.

I didn’t eat those things. Yet what happened was when I started taking the supplements, I started I had physiological changes in my body. And from there I started doing the purification program, which is a behavior modification. Not only is it clinically supportive of your body, which it ramps up [00:53:00] phase one and phase two detoxification, but you also began eating safe foods.

And I felt better eating that diet. So when I went back to those process feeds, I didn’t want to eat them. They made me sick. So the weight just started shedding off my body at that point. And from there I introduced iodine as a concept. and my brain sped up. Now all of a sudden I can retain knowledge and then it just became an issue where I just wanted more and more and more and more.

So then I went on a journey. 1, 500 books later, 30, 000 seminar hours later, running a business model for standard process, sharing this message, seeing people’s lives change. I didn’t even really fully articulate the concepts here. And you understand complexity theory? AI is actually chasing that concept.

What does that mean? They believe that as they make a computer more complex, out of that complexity, there will be emergent properties which will mean that the AI will become sentient. I don’t believe that, but I do believe in complexity theory. Look at a [00:54:00] snowflake. Each snowflake is like a fingerprint beneath the disc.

It’s the complexity of nature. That’s what these plants are, is a highly complex structure in nature that we have evolved over billions of years for 100, 000 years on this planet to have a relationship with. We thrive in the presence of, it’s only since we’ve removed ourselves from nature that we see sickness rising like we do now.

I actually believe a lot of our individual, Emotional challenges in society where we’re all disconnecting from one another is because we’ve lost that connection to soil. It’s once we return to nutrition that we return to each other again. We’re all a part of this together. But at the end of the day, we’re all starving.

And by that starvation response, we’re actually challenging one another because of it. You can find common groundies, find who are helped. And that’s really why I’m passionate about sharing is the importance of shedding fat to eating whole foods. And if you can’t, think about taking a concentrated key [00:55:00] tablet while you change the behaviors towards the end of those states, Ben.

Dr. Weitz: Yeah, there was just a recent report that there has been a significant increase in scurvy in the United States. Shock, we’re eating so many ultra processed foods that We’re actually getting vitamin deficiencies, which you only have to have 10 milligrams of vitamin C a day to not get scurvy.

Alan:  Albert Stengorgy was the discoverer of bioflavonoids.  So he did research on ascorbic acid and he was very famous in his book discussing scurvy. He actually gave pure ascorbic acid to a patient in Scurvy and they did not respond. That way he gave them paprika, which is rich in ascorbic acid. They healed from scurvy. So remember, vitamin C is not ascorbic acid.  Ascorbic acid is a part of the vitamin C complex. Bioflavonoids, tyrosinase, vitamin K precursors, all of these are found in nature around vitamins. Remember that the [00:56:00] Pirates and sailors of the British Army, they didn’t heal scurvy by ascorbic acid, they did by limes, and lemons, and citrus burts. All nutritional deficiencies, every one that we ever discovered in nature, was cured by food.

It wasn’t a chemical. So I’m not saying that ascorbic acid can’t change your P8, or stimulate and affect your body. But at the end of the day, it won’t be the full picture that your body needs from a vitamin C, but you should see that same concept radiates through all the vitamins. Peace. Very good. That’s good to hear.  Let’s take a break.

So what I think that would be, is that person eating from an organic farm? Are they getting all organic vegetables in their diet? Or are they just eating conventionally grown vegetables? Again, if someone’s living a good lifestyle, supplementation [00:57:00] is not necessary. What is supplementation? It supplements your diet that you’re not getting.

So if you’re eating conventionally grown tomatoes, I mean, I don’t even show it in this presentation, but there was a study done at Rutgers in 1991 where they put together conventional vegetables versus organic vegetables. And what they found is that in tomatoes alone, there is 2,000 times more iron in organic vegetables than there is in non organic vegetables.

The amount of B12 that people are so concerned about getting only shows up in organically grown vegetables. It’s very rare that all showing up in conventional gourmet vegetables. So again, it depends on the quality of the foods that you’re eating. Now, the way I live my lifestyle, I remove three main fats.

Trans fats, enriched flour products, and high fructose corn syrup. And then I supplement the rest. So I live in today’s world just like me. I’m not a purist. Again, I have a [00:58:00] problem. I was born premature. And my mom during her pregnancy could only consume saltine crackers and ginger ale. So think about the baby that developed in that environment.

I came out of the womb starving. So I don’t have an off switch in my brain. When I eat, I just keep eating and keep eating and keep eating. So if you have that issue, it’s called the volumetrics diet. There are actually receptors in your stomach that when activated tell your brain to stop eating. Well, what’s the best way to do that?

Boiled potatoes. Vegetables, fill your stomach and activate that sensational fullness with low calories. If not, I’ll replace that with potato chips and french fries and things that are very small and dense, and I’ll over consume them. Our society is actually over consuming food. On average in this country, we’re consuming 3000 calories in this country to 3200 calories.  People are consuming skin much. And now we’re having issues associated to that [00:59:00] same calories. Yeah, so we just, we have, we’re in abundant kinds, callas, what we’re missing are the nutrients from those callas. So it’s exactly.

So.  I have a lot to say on that, but I do represent Standard Process. I wouldn’t mind addressing that in a different way.

Dr. Lee’s original formula was called catalyn. And so catalyn is our, what we would consider a multivitamin, but we don’t look at it as a multivitamin. It has desiccated adrenal, who’s eating that, desiccated spleen, desiccated liver, and desiccated kidney. Now, why we want to take those things into our diet is that think about your kidneys for a moment.

How many different nutrients would you have to consume [01:00:00] to recreate nutrients that seeds your kid? You go right to the kidney and all the nutrients the kid he needs are in the kidney tissue directly. Then we also add things like carrots, and buckwheat, and all these other factors to figure out a fuller way of nature’s trace minerals, as well as vitamins as nature makes.

Catalyn, C. Think about it as an idea of a catalyst. Dr. Roy Elise said that vitamins and nature come in complexes. They’re bound to minerals and proteins. They act as enzymes in your body. So by getting them in the whole food storm, they enzymatically catalyze activity in your body. So again, it’s just the importance of getting those nutrients into your diet.  And again, you don’t have the supplement, but if you’re not eating that way, this is the reason why we want some.

Yes. Any.[01:01:00]  That’s.  Totally.  Thank you for that. One of the things that’s unique about Wisconsin is that a large glacier cut topsoil at Wisconsin. and basically pulled all the trace minerals out of the soil. That’s why it’s a cattle state, because of the dairy. Cheese is more robust. Attle is more robust. That’s why we organically farm in Wisconsin, because of all that nutrient density in the soil.

Dr. Weitz: Please.

I can tell you right now that fluoride has been shown in the early 1900s,[01:02:00]  To depress about 50 percent of your fatty acid metabolism. And it makes you just docile enough to not air. And that’s because of the iodine displacement, your thyroid shuts down because of all the fluoride in our drinking water and it’s everywhere. Just fluoride, not the, to consider all the other chemicals that we’re exposed to in our environment.

Think about what we’re breeding in today. And the amount of compounds that you can actually smell something and change your physiology. The same concept happens as the poisons in the air. You’re smelling it and it’s changing your stress cycle. So our bodies have to detoxify all of that. Are you taking sulfur based compounds into your diet to support that?

If not, you’ll end up being toxic. I have a presentation on the purification program where I show a picture of a polluted lake and a running whip. And the question is which one would you rather be or what would you [01:03:00] rather drink? The polluted lake of the running up. So our bodies need to be constant, functionally clearing its oxides.

And that’s what our diet does to support those pathways as the bodies.

Please,  Kaylee right here in the back will be wonderful to connect with and and connect about that. But I actually don’t have a detox video as much as I’ve been teaching the purification program for years. Yeah, but we definitely need to have people that we can point me in that direction in as far as video summit.

Just think about the purification program, not always as a clinical approach, although it has dramatic clinical outcomes. We actually have a study at Stand Up Process, where we took a number of patients, we put them through the 21 day, and we normalized their triglyceride levels and their blood sugar levels within three weeks, showing that things like triglycerides are a dietary issue more than anything else.

But at the same time, We change people’s behaviors. People become standard process users and stay in this work. Because we change [01:04:00] the way they have a relationship with chewing. It’s a behavioral modification. So when you’re thinking about helping the patients to be better ASD patients, think about something that will help them to change their relationship with their diet.

Because most people eat from a multitude of reasons. Sometimes it’s emotional. At the end of a tough day, a bowl of ice cream makes a person feel better. People who have lack eat and fast to consume a lot to get that sensation of bloat. It actually gives them a hugging feeling in their body. So there’s a lot of psychological reasons why people have bad relationship with bloat.

So by introducing them to also a food approach, they can get many of those same benefits. You can eat many of these benefits, love your foods, and have your brain say, thank you. Or you can eat high volume, effort foods and make your belly go pimp, but it won’t cause you to gain weight, but you’ll still get that sensation of falling full.

It’s just you have to put the white beans in. Yes,

to [01:05:00] me.

I would say that remember that your brain looks for magnesium and potassium. Your nervous system uses potassium to regulate its activity along with sodium. Your nervous system also uses calcium for exocytosis. So when you release neurotransmitters, you have to have adequate calcium in your nervous system.

So when you’re exercising, you have to replenish those minerals for your nervous system to respond again. So your brain says, go get them. The problem is we reach for a sports drink or just a protein bar, and we don’t feel full from that. Because we didn’t get the nutrients that our bodies would chase. So we go back again, and again, and again.

And so most people don’t realize they’re overfed, but they’re getting nutrients to support their health. And so, yes, absolutely, whenever your body goes through a time of [01:06:00] stress, nourishing it is the best thing you can do to recover from that stress. Robert McPherson in 1923. So the British Medical association was looking at European deficiencies in glandular functioning.

And what he found was, as your th a squa, your immune system and your adrenals are the first to go offline in deficiency. So by nourishing yourself, your immune system becomes more robust and your adrenal system becomes more robust. Thyroid is in the weeds down the road.  Is it, yeah. Well they found DDT and algae in Antarctica.  So yes, we’re [01:07:00] swimming in it. So the best thing that you can do is to support your body’s ability to clear it. That’s all that we can do is to help us support our bodies to be more robust in the presence of it. And that’s exactly what things like kale and bluster sprouts and Spanish black radish are.

That’s the importance of things like volcanic ash, Zeolites, You They are adsorbents, they adsorb toxins. The ability of our bodies to turn over our gyphoidal bacteria. The bacteria in your gut lining are heavy metal chelators, toxin chelators. So 60 percent of the dry weight stool is the bacteria. So individuals who have bowel movement issues, diarrhea, these are individuals who are not turning over the bacteria, meaning that they’re toxic loaded.  And they’re reabsorbing those toxins repeatedly, so you have to support the whole body to be able to help cure the toxic load.

 


 

Dr. Weitz: Thank you for making it all the way through this episode of the Rational Wellness Podcast. For those of you who enjoy, Listening to the Rational Wellness Podcast, I would appreciate it if you could go to Apple Podcasts or Spotify and give us a five star ratings and review.  If you would like to work with me personally to help you improve your health, I do accept a limited number of new patients per month for a functional medicine consultation. Some of the areas I specialize in include helping patients with specific health issues like gut problems, neurodegenerative conditions, autoimmune diseases, cardiometabolic conditions, or for an executive health screen, and to help you promote longevity and take a deeper dive into some of those factors that can lead to chronic diseases along the way.  Please call my Santa Monica Weitz Sports Chiropractic and Nutrition Office at 310-395-3111 And we’ll set you up for a new consultation for functional medicine. And I look forward to speaking to everybody next week.

Dr. Jill Crista discusses PANDAS and PANS with Dr. Ben Weitz.

[If you enjoy this podcast, please give us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts, so more people will find The Rational Wellness Podcast. Also check out the video version on my WeitzChiro YouTube page.]

 

Podcast Highlights

1:39  Dr. Crista became interested in studying and treating PANS and PANDAS because she had two twin kids with PANS and this was before it had a diagnostic name.  Her kids were pretty normal and went to school and played sports and all those sorts of things.  So many of the other parents brought her their kids with various neurological things going on. The tie between mold and PANS and PANDAS is that mold can become the trigger. 

3:38  The most common signs and symptoms of PANS and PANDAS include emotional symptoms like anxiety, separation anxiety, OCD, tics, and also urinary frequency, generalized abdominal pain, not wanting to leave their room, aggression, irritiability, and the inability to write well.  Exposure to mold, weed killers, herbicides, heavy metals, as well as Lyme and various other types of infections.  

 

Dr. Weitz: I mean, cause we know most of these infections are low grade chronic things. And a lot of times we see even in mold, it seems to be a slow developing chronic thing.

Dr. Crista: [00:08:00] Yeah. So by the clinical criteria, yes, it needs to be acute. Where it gets a little wiggly is if it was acute and mild, then we can miss it. Usually, the classic story, the classic case is, the kid gets strapped, three weeks later, they change overnight, and they have tics, OCD, they can’t leave their parent, they have the anxiety, they have, all of a sudden this is a different kid.  And that can be anywhere from right after the infection, during the infection, usually not during because usually it’s like a secondary response, but it can be up to three to maybe even six months after that infection to fit the clinical criteria that you have a kid that just overnight changes, the parents will say, I feel like our kid was just like a body snatchers, they came and they took it and they put a monster inside of my kit instead.

And it’s very scary. And these kids can get extremely scary, sick, they can start to feel like maybe their parent [00:09:00] is an imposter. So they get afraid of their parent, one parent and clingy to the other, so there’s a lot of, the brain just doesn’t work right when it’s so that’s the classic picture.

However, and I talk about this in my book on the definition of PANS, the reason that we even created a second thing from PANDAS is they found out that, wow, not all of these cases that are classic had strep. Some of them got the flu. A lot of them. Flu is a big triggering infection for kids. Also Mycoplasma Pneumonia, Chlamydia Pneumonia.

 

 



Dr. Jill Crista is a Naturopathic Doctor and the author of Break the Mold: 5 Tools to Conquer Mold and Take Back Your Health and now of this new book, A Light in the Dark for PANDAS and PANS. Dr. Crista offers several popular physician training programs on both Mold and also on PANDAS and PANS, as well as a course for patients on mold. Her website is DrCrista.com.

Dr. Ben Weitz is available for Functional Nutrition consultations specializing in Functional Gastrointestinal Disorders like IBS/SIBO and Reflux and also Cardiometabolic Risk Factors like elevated lipids, high blood sugar, and high blood pressure.  Dr. Weitz has also successfully helped many patients with managing their weight and improving their athletic performance, as well as sports chiropractic work by calling his Santa Monica office 310-395-3111.

 



Podcast Transcript

Dr. Weitz: Hey, this is Dr. Ben Weitz, host of the Rational Wellness Podcast. I talk to the leading health and nutrition experts and researchers in the field to bring you the latest in cutting edge health information. Subscribe to the Rational Wellness Podcast for weekly updates and to learn more, check out my website, drweitz.com. Thanks for joining me and let’s jump into the podcast. Hello, Rational Wellness Podcasters today.

We’ll be speaking about Neuropsychiatric illnesses in children, referred to as PANS and PANDAS, with Dr. Jill Crista, who has a new book on this topic called A Light in the Dark for PANDAS and PANS. PANDAS stands for Pediatric Acute Onset Neuropsychiatric Disorders Associated with Streptococcus.  And PANS stands for Pediatric Acute Onset Neuropsychiatric Syndrome. Dr. Jill Crista is a naturopathic doctor and the author of the best selling book, Break the Mold. She offers several popular physician training programs on both Mold and also on PANS and PANDAS, as well as a course for patients on mold. Dr. Crista is now focused on research, teaching and writing, specializing in mold sickness, brain injury, and PANS and PANDAS. Thank you so much for joining us, Dr. Crista.

Dr. Crista: Thank you for having me. It’s great to be back.

Dr. Weitz: Thanks. So how did you become interested in studying PANS and PANDAS?

Dr. Crista: I’m a mom of twins with PANS.

Dr. Weitz: Oh, okay.

Dr. Crista: Yeah. In the trenches, that was before it even had a diagnostic name. My kids are 24 now, so this is, 20 years ago. Oh goodness, what’s going on and how do I help them? So I’ve been in the trenches and then thankfully my kids seemed pretty normal, with all that they had going on.  They still went to school, played sports, all those things.  And and you get known as the person who helped them. Her own kids do that. Then it’s oh let’s have you, every special kid, then come see Dr. Jill. I got a chance to see a lot of kids with different neurological things going on and autoimmune diseases and things like that.  That’s how I got into it. And the tie between mold and PANDAS and PANS is that in many of the cases that I was seeing, mold was the trigger for the development of PANS.

Dr. Weitz: And it’s there’s certainly just seems to be a plethora of kids with psychiatric conditions these days. Anxiety seems to be everywhere.  ADHD, difficulty concentrating, learning, there’s so many kids with psychiatric conditions. And it’s fascinating to consider that these psychiatric conditions may actually be caused by physical things happening in their bodies, rather than just this being a mood or emotional disorder.

Dr. Crista: PANDAS and PANS have really, and COVID actually helped us with that as well, this paradigm change in mental health, that it’s not just wrong thinking, there’s actually something physically going on in the body affecting behavior.

Dr. Weitz: Some of the most common signs and symptoms of PANS and PANDAS are all these emotional things.  And how do we how do we wrap our heads around figuring out, how do we decide, how do we figure out what are some of the underlying causes? And I understand from your book that some of the underlying causes are mold, as you just mentioned, streptococcus, these other underlying infections, possibly toxins.  How do we go through trying to figure this out?

Dr. Crista: There’s the art of medicine, right?

Dr. Weitz: Exactly.

Dr. Crista: If you have a child who develops anxiety, separation anxiety, OCD, tics we often see urinary sensitivity. So urinary frequency, generalized abdominal pain. There’s a confluence of symptoms. There are different clinical criteria for each condition, but anxiety is the one that is in pretty much 100 percent of the kids.  There’s some level of anxiety. And what’s interesting is I see that with mold as well. Mold exposure there’s I don’t know that I’ve seen a mold sick patient that didn’t have some level of anxiousness that’s been ramped up. So if there’s that acute onset, and now acute could be a mild case coming on suddenly.  So it may not be picked up the first time at the onset, but then with recurrences and flares, you get this, exaggeration of the behaviors that were happening before with, not wanting to leave a parent, not wanting to leave their room. Maybe we see some aggression or irritability.  We might see some inability to write the way that they could. So they’ll start to drift across the page. So there’s all these little signs and symptoms. If we can catch the moment when it happened, and a lot of times that’s going back in time, family’s going back and saying, before it was really, really bad, it was bad, four months before that, remember when he couldn’t stop washing his hands all the time.

And we thought he was finally getting it and being clean. And instead that was actually the first onset. It was acute overnight, but it might’ve been mild. When we go back and we find, where was the time when the child’s behavior really changed? What was the fun? There was a fundamental difference or a behavior change, or maybe again, clinginess to one parent.  They didn’t want to leave the parent or they’d cry.  Or they might act out with anger ’cause they’re, that’s a real need for them. What was going on before that?  So in that three month period of time, before that happened, did you move to a new house?  Did they start at a new school?  Did they go to summer camp?  All those could be mold exposures. Did you get a new lawn ’cause you just moved into a new house or something like that and sprayed it with a bunch of chemicals?  And make sure it was, looking like carpet and not like regular lawns.  So the weed killers and the herbicides are the number one bad guy environmental toxin in these conditions.  And I can talk about why that is, but look back about three to four months before that moment. And that really tells us a lot about what was going on. And the people that are doing more functional medicine, like you and I that are treating these kids. We are expanding the triggers beyond just infection.

So if you look in kind of the, in the conventional model, the focus on what’s the bug? What’s the bug? What’s the bug? Let’s make sure we take care of the bug. And that’s important because if the child has environmental toxin exposure, that has wrecked their gut microbiome, which is where our immune system lives, Then, 70 percent of our immune system is from our gut health.[00:07:00]  If we are, they’ve just been chemicalized, talking chemicals or mold other things like EMS and mercury, if they’ve just had a dental appointment and they got a bunch of fillings or even one filling, if they’re a sensitive kid to mercury, that toxin exposure now has set the stage for the infection to just trip the last trigger.  So the infection is important to, manage it and keep the load down on the kid, but that’s not the whole story. The whole story is how did that kid get a regular old infection that other kids get and have an autoimmune disease start? So there’s the question. Yeah. So I think looking at time helps.

Dr. Weitz: Now, does it have to be acute onset? What’s the importance of acute onset?

Dr. Crista: Yeah. This is a debated subject. 

Dr. Weitz: I mean, cause we know most of these infections are low grade chronic things. And a lot of times we see even in mold, it seems to be a slow developing chronic thing.

Dr. Crista: [00:08:00] Yeah. So by the clinical criteria, yes, it needs to be acute. Where it gets a little wiggly is if it was acute and mild, then we can miss it. Usually, the classic story, the classic case is, the kid gets Strep, three weeks later, they change overnight, and they have tics, OCD, they can’t leave their parent, they have the anxiety, they have, all of a sudden this is a different kid.  And that can be anywhere from right after the infection, during the infection, usually not during because usually it’s like a secondary response, but it can be up to three to maybe even six months after that infection to fit the clinical criteria that you have a kid that just overnight changes, the parents will say, I feel like our kid was just like a body snatchers, they came and they took it and they put a monster inside of my kit instead.

And it’s very scary. And these kids can get extremely scary, sick, they can start to feel like maybe their parent [00:09:00] is an imposter. So they get afraid of their parent, one parent and clingy to the other, so there’s a lot of, the brain just doesn’t work right when it’s so that’s the classic picture.

However, and I talk about this in my book on the definition of PANS, the reason that we even created a second thing from PANDAS is they found out that, wow, not all of these cases that are classic had strep. Some of them got the flu. A lot of them. Flu is a big triggering infection for kids. Also Mycoplasma Pneumonia, Chlamydia Pneumonia.

Mycoplasma is a lot like strep that it can go, it can evade the immune system and can be persistent for a long time. So that’s a, that’s like a, and it loves the brain. So it’s a classic other bacteria that can happen. And then we can see things like so then they were like, okay not everybody has strep, so we’ll create this other condition called PANS.

So it still has the acute onset. It can be an older [00:10:00] kid. It doesn’t have this like tighter age requirement as long as it’s a pediatric, before they become an adult at 18. If it was onset during that, it might be onset in a teenager for mono. So they had to open it up and I’m hoping we’ll open it up one more time for the congenital infection because that’s where it gets a little squishy.

These are kids who never really developed a totally healthy immune system. And that’s where my kids fit. I gave, I gave ’em a great sense of humor, but I also gave them Lyme and Bartonella . So I had that low ly and didn’t know it. I was diagnosed with quote fibromyalgia. It was chronic Lyme disease, and I gave that to my kids, which reactivated when I was pregnant.

Dr. Weitz: Now, how can you give Lyme disease to your kids? Is it that the ticks actually spread or is that somehow their immune system changes?

Dr. Crista: Because I had it in my bloodstream when I was pregnant and it crosses the placenta.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. Okay. 

Dr. Crista: So they literally get Lyme disease. Okay. 

Dr. Weitz: And Babesia

Dr. Crista: and Bartonella do the same.  [00:11:00] So it’s a vertical transfer, it’s what we call it in medicine. But basically it’s like mom had it, it could cross placenta, it could infect baby. And we know this as, we know Lyme’s, some of the things that Lyme does is it reduces immunity, and it’s a neurotoxin, so it changes the neurology. So it’s a perfect setup for Pandas and Pans, which is an autoimmune disease attacking the nervous system.

Dr. Weitz: So those of us who like data, is there data to show that Lyme can be spread to children?

Dr. Crista: We have animal studies. We have a dog study that Dr. Charles Ray Jones, who I trained with in my Lyme training when we give a mom dog infected tick bite most, but not all the pups develop Lyme disease when they’re born or test positive for it when they’re born.  And the cord blood is also positive. So that’s a way that we, those of us that treat. People with Lyme who want to get pregnant, cause they’re, they had Lyme, they feel [00:12:00] healed, but pregnancy can be such a stress on the body that you can have a reactivation just like what I did. I had it under control, and then, a twin pregnancy was enough to stress it out.  So there is data in animals that show that there’s this vertical transfer is very possible and probable, we could say, because most not, but not all the pups got it.

Dr. Weitz: And then when it comes to infections, a lot of these, especially the viruses, tend to sit in your body and are already there, and then you get another infection that a lot of times will reactivate one of these latent infections.  Things like strep, a certain amount of strep is present in our system all the time, but then can be activated or grow to a point where it creates symptoms.

Dr. Crista: And that’s the mold connection. So mold mycotoxins deplete our immune system of all of our respiratory passages. So our sinuses, our lungs, our gut too.  But what can happen then [00:13:00] is we, if we don’t have enough immunity on those respiratory passages. The boss of the airways, which is strep, can then colonize, and that can become a fungal colonization if you’re exposed to mold spores in a moldy environment, and it can colonize with your own respiratory flora, so we get, basically, I think about our sinuses, our gut our mouth, everything has its own unique microbiome, and that is a healthy, sharing commensal community.

Everybody’s working together, working for the good of the whole kind of thing. But when you get exposed to mycotoxins, that starts to shift. So those commensal species, so all of these good flora that’s supposed to be there to protect us, which is primarily strep, by the way, they’re not all pathogenic types of strep.

Most of the strep in our respiratory passages are protecting us. But there are pathogenic strep that as you’re exposed to mycotoxins and you start to get that flora shift to having to act [00:14:00] defensively instead of communally and then over time that defensive activity is harming themselves and their neighbors and that allows more non commensal or what we’d say pathogenic species to be hosted in those passages.

And then you are dealing with antimicrobials, antibiotics, antifungals, to try to get that system back and, back in balance and have the commensal species take over again.

Dr. Weitz: Interesting. I want to go down a side rabbit hole just for a minute here and not get too off track. But How I’ve always tried to figure out, I don’t understand, but somehow I know they’re related.  They mold ends up increasing Candida. And I know that they’re both fungi, but mold is a different thing than Candida, but somehow you’re treating a patient with mold and they end up having this increased Candida that you have to deal with also.

Dr. Crista: a lot of times. So not [00:15:00] everyone with Candida has mold illness or mold exposure because you can get it from, a course of antibiotics or junky diet or those kinds of things.  But a lot of people with mold exposure have Candida overgrow. And so what the mycotoxins are, let’s talk about what they are. So when mold is in an environment, it’s making mycotoxins to compete for territory. And what mycotoxins are poisons that are meant to harm other living things. And they are meant to allow the mold to creep its territory.

So really the mycotoxin message is, I’m trying to move in, mold’s trying to move in. And so when we have mycotoxins in our gut lining, what mold’s moving in means is it is laying a red carpet for the fungal species to survive. And so it’s doing things like immune depletion, it’s reducing gut motility, it’s changing the kinds of nutrients that your microbiome [00:16:00] craves to become a carb craver versus a protein craver.

And so it’s just like laying the red carpet and saying, here we go. And then all the other fungi are like, yes, we’re going to take over this, and that’s how they, that’s how they work together. They compete, but they also work together in that way.

Dr. Weitz: Just for a second. I have to go down another slight rabbit hole.  I can’t help it, but what’s becoming really popular in, in the United States right now are medications to deal with obesity that work by slowing gut motility. And you were just talking about the problems with gut motility. And I treat a lot of patients with gut problems and motility is a huge problem.  And now millions of people, and this is even being recommended for kids, are taking these GLP 1 agonists. And I know some people have had wonderful benefits in weight loss, but it works by [00:17:00] slowing gut motility. And what plethora of problems are we asking for by doing this?

Dr. Crista: Probably in someone who is healthy, not much.  And I’m a huge fan of those for the right purposes used at a naturopathic dose. Not the big old doses that we would do for diabetes, but and actually my friend, Dr. Tina Moore, she’s taught me a ton about this and is a great resource for that. But in a normal person, that’s probably not doing much because it’s changing the motility globally.  So from the top down, so we’re not picking and choosing areas of motility changes like we see with certain kinds of neurotoxins like Lyme. like mold EMFs can change the calcium potential in a tissue and can change the motility. It can change neural function, all those kinds of things. 

Dr. Weitz: SIBO is often caused by motility problems.

Dr. Crista: Yep. SIBO is a motility disease, not an infection disease. If it’s motility first, infection [00:18:00] is the result.

Dr. Weitz: And that’s the first thing I think about when I think about patients who are, affecting their motility.

Dr. Crista: Yeah, I know I do wonder, I think slowing is different than reversing, SIBO, one of the main causes of that is someone having food poisoning and vomiting, so things, come up in a very violent way and then because we have the wrong species, the right species in the wrong place, That can affect the neurological system of that area.

And then you get focal or targeted neurological problems. And then in mold, in the cases of mold with mycotoxins. We can get these little focal areas as well, wherever there’s a concentrated lymphatic pack pocket. So you can get these kinds of spotty gastroparesis things that can have, or motility issues, gastro is technically stomach, but you can see these focal areas, of course, global, you can get top down.

But I think that, yeah, if you have had mold exposure, if you’re dealing with any kind of neurotoxin illness, if you have chronic constipation and you [00:19:00] can also have diarrhea, SIBOs, Diarrhea is the, reaction to that to try to clear them out. That’s a healthy reaction, but if it’s gone on long enough, then you get this like alternating constipation, diarrhea.  I, I think you’re being really wise to say, Hey, maybe this isn’t the right thing for you because we could be making the problem worse.

Dr. Weitz: So let’s go into testing for PANS and PANDAS.

Dr. Crista: First message is these are clinical diagnoses, which means they can be diagnosed and treated without having to have a positive lab test.  That’s a really important thing for parents to know and practitioners, because I will see practitioners be worried about using some of the medications we need to use. Some of these kids that get real sick, We need to put them on long term prophylactic antibiotics, because strep becomes their kryptonite, it’s just 

Dr. Weitz: And it can be hard to justify that without having data.

Dr. Crista: Without [00:20:00] having the data, I know, yeah. But right now, because it is such a new burgeoning condition, and newly recognized, it’s been around a while, but it’s newly recognized. And also on the rise, because we have things like covid, we have so much more environmental toxicity. So these are on the rise that when I first started and 20 years ago I think it was estimated that maybe one in 500 kids, one, one in 500 to a thousand, and now the estimate is anywhere up to one in 200 kids are gonna develop these conditions.  So that’s a ton of kids and that means it has been on the rise in a exponential way over the last 20 years. And now I completely lost your question.

Dr. Weitz: Oh, about testing. Oh, testing.

Dr. Crista: Okay. Thank you. So we don’t have the data yet to know exactly what’s the mechanism and is the mechanism different between the two conditions.  And like I was talking about with the congenital, we need a third category, so we have Pandas, [00:21:00] PANS, and we need plans, like pediatric long name associated, something like that. We need one, a third one. So we’re lumping these congenital ones into the PANS people so that we can administer treatment that’s effective for them.

But yeah it’s tricky because what tests do you do if we don’t know exactly what’s the target? So we know some targets. We know that the dopamine receptors in the brain, which is in the basal ganglia, get destroyed. We are assuming that’s an autoimmune. So the body attacking itself, that’s their, that’s why pediatric autoimmune neuropsych syndrome disorder associated with strep.

Dr. Weitz: Is there a way that clinicians can determine that?

Dr. Crista: By clinical symptoms. So yeah, once, that’s the thing is we’ve gone, we haven’t gotten from research to clinical completely. There is something called the Cunningham Panel that catches PANS pretty well. And that looks at some of those autoimmune targets against basal [00:22:00] ganglia and gangliosides and some of the things that are in the brain.

You

Dr. Weitz: can Which lab offers the Cunningham Panel?

Dr. Crista: That’s Molecular Labs.

Dr. Weitz: Okay.

Dr. Crista: Yeah, but just know that if you have a PANS or a uncategorized congenital, you may have a kind of normal looking Cunningham panel and they still have a condition.

Dr. Weitz: Okay.

Dr. Crista: That’s a nice test for when you have a PANDAS case where strep was the infection, then you have an acute overnight change in the kid.  I’m finding that the Cunningham panel is really nice for that. And it’s a nice piece of paper. It’s yes, there’s, this is an actual physical thing happening in your kid’s brain. It’s not just bad behavior. You’re not a bad parent, just Just, it’s okay, this is physical however, just know that can miss some of them, and so that’s the problem is that the newer research is showing that there’s also destruction of the cholinergic interneurons, meaning things that use acetylcholine, which is runs our autonomic nervous [00:23:00] system.  Those neurons, those inter neurons that are going to be telling one, one nerve to talk to the other using acetylcholine, those are having destruction as well. Yeah. And that’s why I like to use the herbs that I use because they address all of it.

Dr. Weitz: So what kinds of panels do you recommend for us to do, or should we just go right into treatment?

Dr. Crista: Again,

Dr. Weitz: the

Dr. Crista: clinical diagnosis is key. So you can feel like, okay, if there are, the child is meeting these major criteria there are certain criteria that need to be met. Some are major, some are minor, and then you can diagnose them and you can feel very comfortable treating them based on that.

That is that’s the standard of care is that we’re using clinical diagnoses. And those clinical criteria, just be really that, then you do need the acute part of it, the acute onset part of it. So yes, Cunningham panel can help to answer the question. Point more arrows. There’s also some of the things like Vibrant has a neural zoomer [00:24:00] that you can look to see, is there a blood brain barrier breakdown?

That gives me a little more hint that we’ve got to really focus on the gut, because if the gut’s leaky, the brain’s going to be leaky. And then Cyrex Labs has some really nice arrays. Their Array 7 is great Array 20, so we can look at some of the correlations of Again, blood brain barrier breakdown.

What are there any auto antibodies being made, meaning antibodies to the brain? So that can give you a picture if you are dealing with families that need paper proof, and that’s very helpful. And that’s only telling you like, yeah, this is probably pandas or pan, but it’s not telling you why did we get there?

And then if they’re a kid who needs psychotropic medication, I highly recommend. the gene site test where we pre test their genetics for processing those medications. Because most of these kids have blood brain barrier leakage and because psychotropic medications are designed with chemicals [00:25:00] to open up the brain so that you can get the medication up there.

So when you administer psychotropic medications, you’re causing blood brain barrier leakage on purpose. We know that’s what these drugs do. So if you have someone who already has an open brain and you’re giving them psychotropic medication that opens it farther, they’re going to be acutely sensitive to a regular dose.

So if they need psychotropic medication, what I will do to start is test their gene site to make sure they’re not a speedy or a slow metabolizer of that drug and know that I’m going to open up their brain like a sieve when I give these medication. So I started an eighth, sometimes even a 16th of the normal dose, and you’ll need compounding for that.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. So. Let’s what about if you’re suspecting Lyme? Do you do a Lyme panel?

Dr. Crista: That’s also a clinical diagnosis.

Dr. Weitz: Okay.

Dr. Crista: Yeah, and congenital Lyme won’t necessarily look the same as a classic Lyme. They’re not going to have, the blown up joints, but they have joints that are, that tend to injure very easily and they [00:26:00] take a long time to heal.

So a kid that’s just their ankle is out, now their knee is out, now their shoulder feels popping, those kinds of things. Like it, it doesn’t look like a classic Lyme case if it’s congenital. He found some core things in kids who were born with Lyme and had, had Lyme through congenital exposure.

And atonia was one of those. What does that mean? That means low or no autonomic tone. And these will be the kids that they’re the natural tone. If you’re out, if your autonomic system is toned, normally you will have your shoulders higher. Like I have You can probably even see them and people who are listening are like, what is she talking about?

Like my shoulders go down because I have dysautonomia. So if you have a normal autonomic system, you’re going to have a higher tone. You can hold your posture up better. So you’ll see that atonia, there’s just that little bit of drop in the shoulders. A lot of times you can look at like how far do their hands go down their [00:27:00] legs.

If it’s longer than, I think there’s measurements that we can do, but that’s because their body is not holding those shoulders up. And so the arms can drop down. So as a chiropractor, that’s an easy thing that you can test and see, okay, did they look like they have longer arms than they should?

That’s because they’re not holding the tone. They don’t hold chiropractic adjustments well. So these are kids that you adjust them and then the body doesn’t adjust to the adjustment, so to speak. There was one other thing. Oh, and then you can tell if they also have vagus nerve involvement, if you have them open their mouth, stick out their tongue and go ah, and try and go, Oh, like that a little higher, their uvula will go off to the side and that they have some vagal nerve.

So something’s going on in the autonomic system that we can take a look. If they have, those are little teeny, tiny signs. It’s this might’ve been a congenital. And then you look at mom, you check out her history, if there’s any, history of Lyme, history of fibromyalgia, those kinds of things, then we have a kid that may need to be treated for [00:28:00] Lyme.

Dr. Weitz: Okay, so let’s go into treatment.

Dr. Crista: Oh, I had one more thing.

Dr. Weitz: Oh, yeah.

Dr. Crista: If there’s Lyme Borrelia, which is the way that they move through the body, they corkscrew through tissues, and kids will have tics that have a twisty or corkscrew nature to them when they have that. When they have sinus colonization, they will have a lot of eye blinking as part of their tics because their body is, or they might even hum their tonsils have turned into just mush.  And they’re hosting a lot of things. They will have a hum because they’re trying to increase the nitric oxide on the surface and kill the bug. So by the, we can watch what the ticks are doing to tell us where the kid needs support.

Dr. Weitz: Do you swab the nose and test for strep?

Dr. Crista: Yeah, I test for everything.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. Most people don’t realize that the nasal cavity is this direct route into the brain.

Dr. Crista: Yes. I show, I [00:29:00] created a couple of images in my book for that very reason to show that strep throat also becomes strep nose. So what happens is when you get strep throat, the body will send messengers down to the lymph nodes in your neck, and then it’ll make antibodies.  And then those antibodies get sent to the throat, but also up to the nose. Cause the body’s duh, it’s our breathing zone. Of course our nose is going to have problems if the throat has problems, But when those antibodies get up there, we know from mouse studies, when they put strep on the nose of mice, those antibodies will migrate back to the basal ganglia, to the brainstem.  And that’s what’s running our whole background autonomic system. And then they see that they will start to make antibodies to that own tissue just by getting repeat exposure to their nose. The great study out of Columbia. Yeah.

Dr. Weitz: Oh, wow. Fascinating. It’s

Dr. Crista: not, it’s not the strep getting in the nose.

Dr. Weitz: It’s the

Dr. Crista: antibodies, which means every time you have strep throat, you could be getting destruction of the central part of the brain. [00:30:00]

Dr. Weitz: You wonder what role this can play in development of dementia when they get older? Because you were talking about deteriorating of handwriting, and that’s one of the characteristic things with patients with Alzheimer’s.

Dr. Crista: I think there’s a high correlate, high possibility of correlation with Parkinson’s. And Early Onset Panda’s Pans, because of the basal ganglia distraction. And then we

Dr. Weitz: also know about the research that’s been done about how amyloid plaque builds up to protect the brain from infection. So you’re getting these antibodies into the brain and then, it’s probably setting up an increased risk of this amyloid plaque building up to protect the brain.

Dr. Crista: And then, and yeah, I think Dr. Dale Bredesen was the first one that said, amyloid plaques are really good mycotoxin sponges.

Dr. Weitz: It’s interesting. There’s almost this symmetry between childhood and old age. And you start out in diapers and you end up in diapers. So [00:31:00] let’s go into treatment.  You have this really organized system of understanding how to set up a treatment protocol. It’s fairly complex, but it’s very well organized.

Dr. Crista: Thank you. Yeah. These are families in chaos. So I tried to be as. Organized as possible. So it’s there’s a step one, there’s a step two, here are the tools and here’s how you match it to the kid, yeah. So I came up with I put in the book core four, I wanted to put core 10, but I didn’t want to overwhelm anybody. So I made five, six, seven, eight, nine, 10 is all part three in the book of this is how you actually do recovery. And the core four is how you do rescue. So that’s the, let’s get out of crisis mode.

And then when you’re out of crisis mode, please go to part three. That’s how you get out of this finally, and keep your kid not so flareable. We see flares happen about every three months and that’s the tricky part with treatment is then. You start [00:32:00] administering treatment, the child might be really getting better with that and you can be high fiving yourself and it’s only because that was the course of the disease it was going to calm down anyway.

Y’all, you also might give some treatment and they flare a little bit and you think, did we do that? Did we push the body too hard? And it was just going to be that they were going to take a, you A turn, an increase in symptoms anyway, so you, this is a long game, I guess is what I’m trying to say.

Dr. Weitz: Patients and clinicians need to understand that this is going to be treated over a period of potentially years, right?

Dr. Crista: Years, usually yeah. Okay. And that’s how I wrote the book. I wanted parents to have tools in hand. And so they can be working with their practitioner and they know what to do in the, in between they know what to do between appointments and maybe even to, save appointments in general.

So I have the core for the first core is tame the flame. The second is beat the bugs. The third is regulate immunity. And the fourth is guard the gate. And that’s the rescue plan, so tame the flame has to do with all neuroinflammation. So neuroinflammation means inflammation in the nervous system.[00:33:00]

In these cases, primarily it’s in the central nervous system, like we were talking about deep in the brain. So we’re trying to take things that are going to calm down the neuroinflammation and paying attention to the trigger. So if we’re only focused on a bug, we might just deal with the inflammation you could handle with Advil.

But it isn’t only that inflammation, because they have environmental exposures that set the stage. So we know that there’s going to be mast cell involvement. We know there’s going to be specific types of inflammation we can adjust. And we know where it’s going to be. It’s going to be primarily in the central nervous system.

So that’s why I like to use things like Resolvins. These are the most anti inflammatory aspect of fish oil, so they’re extracted out from fish oil.

Dr. Weitz: Also known as like SPMs.

Dr. Crista: Yes, yeah, SPMs, Special Pro Resolving Mediators. They are, they can go into the brain tissue, and they can reduce inflammation. So they’re fat soluble, and that’s one of the reasons I put that as the first thing, because We know the type of [00:34:00] inflammation those are going to deal with.  We know if we extract that out of the fish oil, even people who have histamine responses to whole fish oil can tolerate the, these extracted aspects. They don’t get a histamine flush from them.

Dr. Weitz: What do you think about patients who have fish allergies?

Dr. Crista: Yeah, they can’t take it, unfortunately.

Dr. Weitz: Okay.

Dr. Crista: Yeah, I know. That’s the bummer. And that’s why I put other tools because it’s that’s not the only one, we can get at it a different way. Another nice fat soluble thing that tames the flame is PEA, which is not the food pee, but palmitoylethanolamide. And it’s basically this thing that we make in our brain naturally to reduce inflammation.

But if you have an attack on the brain. You will plow through that. So that’s a way to get that that nutrient, we could say anti inflammatory nutrient back in the brain where it belongs. And that’s another fat soluble one. So if I have somebody who’s fish allergic, then we’ll go heavy on the PEA [00:35:00] instead.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. And then fever few, which I usually think of something for headaches.

Dr. Crista: Yes. The parthenolides in fever few are amazing. They are hitting the type of inflammation that we get with these autoimmune attacks. And I cannot tell you, I have emails that I get that I’m just in tears reading that a family will say, our kid’s been sick for four years, won’t come out of the bedroom, has stopped reading, can’t go to school, obviously, this is a kid who’s losing their childhood.

They started the child on fever cue only. And then they like, they’re like, okay they didn’t react too bad. So we’ll add resolvents. So it was fever cue and resolvents. And the resolvence wasn’t even till the tail end. And in two weeks, the child was out of the room reading chapter books to the parents and it completely transformed the child.

So brains are inflamed and we have so many tools to help them with that.

Dr. Weitz: And then under flame the teams, you have these other categories. So you [00:36:00] have the

Dr. Crista: The mast cell managers, right? Yeah, because there’s different kinds of flame. So again, if it was just Advil, and sometimes kids are sick, we will go for the ibuprofen.

Absolutely. A two week trial of ibuprofen as a clinician. That is a wonderful test because if that changes the child’s behavior, you probably have a panda’s pants get on your hand. So just a two week trial of ibuprofen, a nice high dose like 10 mg per kg kind of thing. So it’s more of a pharmaceutical dose and you got to warn families, if you do that, there’s a risk of GI bleeds.

There’s a risk of bleeding in general, there’s Kidney things that can show for

Dr. Weitz: a hundred pound kid. You’re talking about 2000 milligrams is it

Dr. Crista: throughout the day?

Dr. Weitz: Yeah. Okay.

Dr. Crista: Yeah. And then I always do that with BPC one 57 so we can protect the gut lining. Okay. Tolerate it. You do it.

Functionally, right? It’s a very helpful drug. And there’s these other things that we want to make sure and [00:37:00] protect the tummy lining, but just to, you don’t do that forever, but that’s a wonderful drug trial to see if there’s a profound change. And you can see a kid who’s ticking, who can’t sleep.

Maybe they haven’t slept for two days. This, these are all the things that we can see from the autoimmune destruction of the basal ganglia. Why is that? That’s because. Those receptors receive dopamine and dopamine can transfer into glutamate really easily. And those are excitatory brain chemicals.

So is acetylcholine. So those cholinergic interneurons, when they get destroyed, acetylcholine doesn’t have anywhere to go. So the kids are, their brains are swimming, drowning in these excitatory brain chemicals. And that’s why the tics and that’s why the OCD, it’s like There’s all this energy with nowhere to go, and that’ll cause, in a lot of cases, it can cause insomnia, too.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. You have Perilla, which is an interesting one. We’ve used that [00:38:00] for allergies.

Dr. Crista: Yes. Yeah, and allergies are mass, so meaty,

Dr. Weitz: you

Dr. Crista: know?

Dr. Weitz: Have you tried that product with the quail eggs from Integrative?

Dr. Crista: Yeah, I haven’t seen huge differences. I know some people say it’s a game changer, but I think for my patient base, we’re also talking about dietary things typically.

Dr. Weitz: Okay.

Dr. Crista: However, with pandas and pans, one of the symptoms can be restricted eating. And so we want to be really careful not to add to that problem. My only. 100 percent like diet advice is organic and everything else is on the table, because if you have a kid who’s restricting food, we don’t need to take away anything.

Now, are there perfect things we could add? Yes, we could do a histamine free diet. A lot of kids with mold exposure have high oxalates. We can, reduce their oxalate load. But histamine is usually the one that does it. makes the big difference in the kid because of the mast cells going into the brain, [00:39:00] spill, spilling histamine.

A lot of times we can make a big dent there.

Dr. Weitz: That’s why I said a glyphosate. Do you take away gluten?

Dr. Crista: I don’t, because again, the restricted eating thing, just say, take the pressure off yourself. These are parents who, a kid isn’t sleeping for two days. Okay. They can’t, the parent can’t even take a shower without the kid.  Cause the kid has. Separation Anxiety they might be aggressive, so they have to protect the other people in the family, so things can get really off the rails.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. And,

Dr. Crista: With Glyphosate, and not just Glyphosate, but Atrazine causes a change in the dopamine receptors in the brain any kind of herbicides, pesticides.  If you’re doing organic, those are out and then you’ve reduced the, that exposure for the kid and we can try to recoup some of the gut microbiome so we can get their immunity back again.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. And then you have to beat the bugs.

Dr. Crista: Beat the bugs. So the bugs are a problem. What got the kid here, like I said, was this pre [00:40:00] state, this antecedent state that they had immune depletion.

That’s where the environmental toxins really come in, but then there’s a bug, so there is, there’s been a few cases where we, a kid had an acute glyphosate toxicity, like played on a soccer field. I have one case where played a soccer day, a whole tournament day, and they had just sprayed that morning and they didn’t tell anybody.

So they had just sprayed everything and the kid developed PANS. We couldn’t track any other infection. So in a few cases, it’s environmental only. But in the majority of cases, then there’s an infection that challenges the child’s immune system and the immune system just wasn’t up for it. So we do need to beat back those bugs and get things back in balance.

Dr. Weitz: And so the first category you have is these botanical avatars and you have Chinese skullcap as one of your favorites.

Dr. Crista: Yes. Botanical avatars, I name them that because an avatar means an ideal. And so when we look at all of the mechanisms that go into this condition, the immune [00:41:00] depleted state. The brain chemistry changes, what happens with the receptors themselves if they’re food restricting, low blood sugar, we’re looking at all of the things, gut microbiome, and when we look at the whole picture, these avatars in this section were perfectly made for these conditions.

You could use that one plant and that one plant only and make a big dent. So for me, once we get the kid out of flame, then the avatar becomes the foundation at the base of everything that we do. So an avatar stays with them their whole treatment period, and then we plunk the other things on top of that.

So Chinese skullcap is wonderful because it’s great for mycoplasma pneumonia, which is a really hard bug to get at. Also for strep and it has all the other things, the brain chemistry balancing, the gut microbiome. And we see that things like that, Oregon grape root, they have antibiotic activity, but people are like, okay, [00:42:00] so does that mean it’s going to wreck the gut?

It turns out that those two plants actually increase the butyrate, which is the favorite food of our commensal, of our favored microbiome in our gut. So the plants don’t act the same way. in their antimicrobial property as a drug does.

Dr. Weitz: Oregon grape is basically berberine. Is that the main ingredient?

Dr. Crista: Yeah. But the whole plant is what changed the butyrate, not just the berberine. The berberine.

Dr. Weitz: Interesting.

Dr. Crista: If you’re just going for the berberine, you’re going to miss the activity that we’re looking for pandas and Pam.

Dr. Weitz: You also have got a cola, which I always think of as a blood sugar thing.

Dr. Crista: Yeah interestingly enough, gotu kola, we can give this it crosses the blood brain barrier within 5 to 15 minutes of taking it.  And it’s a really nice tea. It doesn’t, it’s one of those things that kids will actually drink. You can add a little honey and you can get it down because it doesn’t taste like much. It just is like a musky green [00:43:00] flavor. But it crosses the blood brain barrier in 5 to 15 minutes and it will protect the microglia, which are the naughty little monkeys in the mind that do all this destruction.  It will calm them down so that when a child eats, if they get any increase in gut endotoxins. it won’t agitate the brain and induce attack. So part of the food restricting is that when kids eat, they will get this increase in endotoxin and it starts to increase the attack on their own tissue. So the body wisely says, stop eating.  We can’t do this. And, but unfortunately then kids can get very underweight. That go to Cola can be done ahead of time. You can give ahead of time before meals. And it’ll protect the microglia monkeys and keep them calm. Interesting. Yeah.

Dr. Weitz: Cool.

Dr. Crista: Amazing. Like we have so many tools. So cool.

Dr. Weitz: And then antimicrobials. So things like oregano, thyme. [00:44:00]

Dr. Crista: Just depends on what critter you’re trying to whack back. And that’s the clinical discernment. You as a doctor, are you dealing with a kid with Lyme? Probably need to get some cryptolepis and Japanese knotweed. You’re dealing with a kid with parasites.  These kids can get really wormy because they don’t have the gut immunity like most of us. There’s a lot of hypogammaglobulinemia in these kids. That was why they got Panda’s Pans. So they can tend to take on parasites. So I use a lot of black walnut with them and a lot, you just treat them like, treat them aggressively and they need the help,

Dr. Weitz: or

Dr. Crista: fungi, we need that omega 9 time.

Dr. Weitz: And you also talk about making a steam out of some of these herbs and getting it into the nose that way.

Dr. Crista: Yeah, that’s in the Guard the Gates because we do need to, their defenses are down. These are kids whose defenses are down. And just a simple steam inhalation can be both calming to the child and it’ll also, it calms them from a few things because those [00:45:00] volatile oils are also acting as an aromatherapy.  When we steam some of these plants that we know, we all know and love and we’re familiar with, like kitchen herbs. Sage in particular, and thyme, you can steam them. Those volatile oils have more antimicrobial property than eating the plant itself. So once we steam it, something magical happens.  and steam can reach every part of the sinus cavity. So a nose spray only goes so far, but a steam you can get everywhere and you can get into the lung tissue as well. There’s some research showing that a change in the lung microbiome can affect the brain as well. It’ll agitate the microglia monkeys in the brain.  So a steam is getting all of that taken care of. So we have the effect of the volatile oils on the bugs themselves. but also on the brain chemistry aromatherapy effect.

Dr. Weitz: And then we have to regulate immunity.

Dr. Crista: Regulating immunity is [00:46:00] primarily the gut. We are more microbe than man, as they say, so if we did a cell to cell count of your bacteria in your gut and your cells of your muscles, bones, all that thing, we’d have more cells in our gut that belong to the other guys than our own tissue.

And if you did a DNA count, it would be the same. So there’s more DNA that belongs to the critters in our gut than our own DNA tissue. So they determine a lot. And when autoimmune disease. It’s the body attacking itself. Why would it do that? Why it’s supposed to attack us

Dr. Weitz: reactivity, right?

Dr. Crista: Because it’s lost discernment of what is self. And so if our definition of self is basically our gut microbiota, because there’s more of them than there are of us and we have anything that is destroying our gut microbiota. Now the immune system is let’s see what’s self. What’s not self. It loses that discernment.

So when we regulate immunity, focusing on the [00:47:00] gut, what we’re trying to do is build back the microbes, not just the bugs themselves, but by giving them the food that they like, like butyrate. It’s wonderful. It’s known as a nootropic, which means it helps with the brain healing itself. It also helps with the panda’s pan’s brain as well by calming down the gut microbes and not having them feel so at risk.

Dr. Weitz: But you might also feed the bad bugs too, right? With butyrate?

Dr. Crista: Not as much as you would think. So that’s why we have beat the bugs first. So sometimes you can add, if gliotoxin is a mycotoxin that’s high in a kid because they have fungal burden veering toward fungal infection, they can have high gliotoxin and things with sulfur like butyrate can help the mold if you do too much, if you don’t have the Antistep on board first.

Dr. Weitz: So that’s

Dr. Crista: step two. And then we can add the butyrate kind of free form.

Dr. Weitz: And then [00:48:00] probiotics is part of the mix as well?

Dr. Crista: Yeah, probiotics, peptides. Yep. Those are all things. And then regulated immunity. We didn’t really talk about what drugs fit in each of those, but that’s where IVIG would come in because some kids do need that.

We give IVIG at a very high dose and I want to tell everybody, I have a typo in my book. It’s very important. It’s 1. 5 to 2 grams per kilogram of IVIG, which is a suppressive dose. So we flood the body with IVIG. with immunoglobulins and we do it over and over again because we want the bone marrow to take a vacation and forget that it was upset about, that it wanted to make antibodies to its own tissue.

If you do the supportive dose of immunoglobulins, which is below one, up to one milligram or grams. See, I did it again. gram per kilogram of body weight. You can actually make it worse because you can fuel the autoimmune attack.

Dr. Weitz: Interesting. So this is intravenous immunoglobulins. [00:49:00]

Dr. Crista: Yeah, and usually my, depending on the severity of the kid, we might do that every four weeks, every six weeks, every eight weeks.  The goal is to get them out of crisis, and then we stretch it out to see how long can we go before their immunoglobulins hit a trough again. We don’t want them to hit that trough because that, then can allow the autoimmune attack to happen.

Dr. Weitz: So that’s a strategy for acute flares.

Dr. Crista: To, for healing.

Dr. Weitz: Right.

Dr. Crista: For recovery.

Dr. Weitz: All right. And LDN, you use that as well sometimes?

Dr. Crista: Yep. I use it a lot.

Dr. Weitz: Oh, okay. Yeah. And you like certain peptides?

Dr. Crista: Yep. The BPC 157 the TB4 FRAG is, it’s basically thymicin. It’s from our thymus gland. And again, both of those go back to the pre immune depleted state situation.

So how do we get kids out of this? We nourish their immune system so that they can get [00:50:00] out of it.

Dr. Weitz: And both of these are oral peptides.

Dr. Crista: Yeah, they don’t have to be IV, peptides are very stable, so the capsules can be opened up, they go right through, they’re not broken down by the stomach acid, actually that’s, they’re the result of breaking down proteins in the stomach acid, so they’re like, yeah, they get the path.

Dr. Weitz: That’s cool.

Dr. Crista: Yeah.

Dr. Weitz: All right, good. Final thoughts about how to overcome pans and pandas?

Dr. Crista: Just know it’s the long game. And you’re not a bad parent. This is not behavior problems. This is a body problem. So if you’re not getting the support that you need with the doctor you’re working on, or if they’re not panned or pandas or pans literate, go find someone that is because you can do real damage.  The longer this brain attack can happen in your kid, the more damage that’s happening in their brain. So because it’s not immune, get to it.

Dr. Weitz: And how does somebody find a practitioner who’s skilled in pants and pandas?

Dr. Crista: Right [00:51:00] now in the footer of my website, I have Mold Literate, Lime Literate, and PandasPans, so you can go there and get links.

There are a couple of organizations. There’s the Pandas Network and then there’s the Neuroimmune Foundation. And those are some areas that you can go find. I do any continuing ed than any of those have given all through time. And there are tons of amazing doctors that also attend those that can help.

Dr. Weitz: Cool. And how can listeners get ahold of you and find out about your programs?

Dr. Crista: They can come to drcrista. com. That’s D R C R I S T A. com. And I’m also on Instagram and, Facebook and all those things. YouTube.

Dr. Weitz: That’s great. Thank you so much, Dr. Crista.

Dr. Crista: Thank you.

 


Dr. Weitz: Thank you for making it all the way through this episode of the Rational Wellness Podcast.  For those of you who enjoy listening to the Rational Wellness Podcast, I would appreciate it if you could go to Apple Podcasts or Spotify and give us a five star ratings [00:52:00] and review. If you would like to work with me personally to help you improve your health, I do accept a limited number of new patients per month for a functional medicine consultation.  Some of the areas I specialize in include helping patients with specific health issues like gut problems. neurodegenerative conditions, autoimmune diseases, cardiometabolic conditions, or for an executive health screen and to help you promote longevity. and take a deeper dive into some of those factors that can lead to chronic diseases along the way.  Please call my Santa Monica Weitz Sports Chiropractic and Nutrition office at 310 395 3111 and we’ll set you up for a new consultation for functional medicine. And I look forward to speaking to everybody next week.

Brian Keane discusses How to Get into Your Best Shape with Dr. Ben Weitz.

[If you enjoy this podcast, please give us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts, so more people will find The Rational Wellness Podcast. Also check out the video version on my WeitzChiro YouTube page.]

 

Podcast Highlights

 

 

 



Brian Keane is a personal trainer, nutritionist, best-selling author, and the host of the Brian Keane Podcast, the #1 health and fitness podcast in the United Kingdom.  His website is BrianKeaneFitness.com. His books are The Fitness Mindset, Rewire Your Mindset, and The Keane Edge. He also hosts a very popular podcast, the BKF podcast.  

Dr. Ben Weitz is available for Functional Nutrition consultations specializing in Functional Gastrointestinal Disorders like IBS/SIBO and Reflux and also Cardiometabolic Risk Factors like elevated lipids, high blood sugar, and high blood pressure.  Dr. Weitz has also successfully helped many patients with managing their weight and improving their athletic performance, as well as sports chiropractic work by calling his Santa Monica office 310-395-3111.

 



Podcast Transcript

Dr. Weitz: Hey, this is Dr. Ben Weitz, host of the Rational Wellness Podcast. I talk to the leading health and nutrition experts and researchers in the field to bring you the latest in cutting edge health information. Subscribe to the Rational Wellness Podcast for weekly updates. And to learn more, check out my website, drweitz.com. Thanks for joining me. And let’s jump into the podcast. Hello, Rational Wellness Podcasters.

Today, we’ll be having a conversation with Brian Keene about how to get into the best shape of your life and how to be your healthiest. Brian Keene is a entrepreneur, personal trainer, nutritionist, best selling author, and host of the Brian Keene podcast, the number one health and fitness podcast in Ireland and England.  Brian, thank you so much for joining us today.

Brian:  Ben, thank you so much for having me on. I’m really looking forward to chatting.

Dr. Weitz:  Good, good, So what do you think would be a good way to start? I was thinking maybe you could tell us about, what if you’re working with a client who’s basically sedentary and overweight?  How would you approach their, let’s start with exercise recommendations? When it comes to or do you tell him to just take Ozempic and forget about everything?

Brian: I don’t go down that route and it’s funny, I did a podcast on my show with Johan Hari, who’s a three times New York Times bestselling author.  He wrote Lost Connections, a great book around anxiety and depression, but his new book is talking about Ozempic and we had a very black, white and gray conversation on there because he takes it based on his history and as a fitness professional and as a nutritionist.  I’m not completely anti drugs when it comes to there are certain cases where all risk mortality goes up if somebody’s weight is and they might need something to get them over the start line or to the start line. But I think there are very much a [00:02:00] last case results. There’s so much you can do with either your exercise options or your nutrition or a combination of both, and then your sleep and your stress that you can control and should always look at that. Prevention first, you know this from functional medicine, everything.

Dr. Weitz: 100 percent and be honest with you, even if you were going to use Ozembic as a tool, if you don’t have those other building blocks in place, the diet, the exercise, the stress control, sleep, all those things, then first of all, even if you do lose weight with Ozembic, you’re just going to gain it right back, unless you plan to take it for the rest of your life.  And there’s too many side effects for that, in my opinion.

Brian: 100%. And it’s really important when you think about someone who’s starting, who’s overweight, potentially incidentary to start with that. One of the mistakes I see most often, and I’m sure you see this as well, Ben, is people making too many changes too soon.  And exercise is a really good example of this. [00:03:00] If you are not working out or moving a lot, you don’t actually have to do an awful lot of exercise to elicit some physical positive benefits. I. e. if you stay eating the exact same and you start going for a half an hour walk at lunchtime, all other things equal, you’ll potentially be burning more calories, which could kickstart that weight loss journey.

And then if you’re feeling good, it might improve your sleep, which could help with balancing the hormones. It can help with things like your ghrelin, your leptin, things you’ve talked about on the podcast when it comes to hunger and satiety, making sure that you’re noshed. You’re feeling full after meals, which obviously comes down to your food choices, in which we can get into as well, but your feeling of just overall wellness.

And what happens with a lot of people that I’ve worked with in the past who are in that bracket is they don’t know where to start, or they’ve done several diets or several exercise programs, made too many changes too soon. couldn’t sustain it because they felt terrible or they were hungry all the [00:04:00] time, or they felt sore and then fell back off track and then went back to their normal routine.

And in some cases they ended up in a worse position than when they started. So I would say with your exercise choice, doing more than what you’re doing now is better and is the best way to approach things. You don’t have to join a gym and go six days a week. You definitely don’t need to do that, but go for a walk for half an hour at lunchtime, and then maybe increase that to 45 minutes over the next couple of weeks.

And the same with nutrition. Something I will do with my overweight, and I’ve worked with clinically obese people in the past in my one to one programs, and You can’t change someone’s nutrition and overhaul it at once and for them to stick with it because generally there’s bad food behaviors. There’s been poor habit formation around food and the way that they potentially might emotionally eat or use food to soothe in a lot of cases.

It can happen with people that go, not everyone, there’s genetic components and lifestyle components and just the food system, et cetera. But in a lot of cases with the people I’ve worked with, there’s an emotional underlying issue as well. When it comes to, I feel bad. I go to [00:05:00] food, I feel stressed, I turn to food.

And you need to look at that and break it down into smaller component parts. So one thing I would say here, if you’re in that starting point, is look at one meal, pick a meal, normally breakfast, it’s the low hanging fruit, you normally feel your best when you wake up in the morning, or you should at least, and you go, right, I’m going to make a healthier breakfast.

Breakfast food choice, whether that’s a bowl of oatmeal in the morning, or some scrambled eggs, or a smoothie that has loads of greens and potentially some fruits if you want to keep your sugars in and then some fats to balance it out so your blood sugars don’t spike, and then eat everything else as normal.  Your normal lunch should be your normal dinner, your normal snacks. Just change that one meal and you’ll start to see a positive change over time. And then look at your lunch and then over the next six, several weeks, keep everything else the same, put your breakfast and lunch are going to be considerably higher nutrient quality and better food quality than you’d been making prior.

And then look at your dinner and then look at your snacks. And over the space of three, four or five, six months, you might’ve overhauled your entire nutritional plan and potentially your exercise regimen. And that’s something you’re going to be able to stick to because you didn’t make all the changes too soon.[00:06:00]

Dr. Weitz: You mentioned snacks. I guess we’ll go back and forth between nutrition and exercise. I was thinking we would cover exercise first and then nutrition, but snacks is an interesting, one because I’ve been involved in health and fitness and giving people nutritional advice for, 35 plus years and competed as a bodybuilder way back in the 80s.  And I remember when I first got into, this, we would tell everybody, you absolutely have to eat breakfast. You’ve got to start your day off with some healthy food. And then you’ve got to eat every 3 or 4 hours during the day. You’ve got to have a meal or a snack to keep a steady blood sugar. And over the last 10, 15 years, it’s become much more popular not to snack, to skip meals, to do what we call intermittent fasting, and a lot of people do that by skipping breakfast, and it’s a, it’s kind of going [00:07:00] back and forth right now, but I think it’s kind of interesting how we’ve gone from people skipping breakfast, eating a big dinner, to going to sleep, gaining weight, and then getting people to eat breakfast.  And now it’s become very popular to skip breakfast. So where do you stand on intermittent fasting and, also, having snacks?

Brian: It’s such a great question, Ben, because when you think about nutrition, something that I try and educate my audience on is it’s impossible to take black and white in a topic that’s gray.  And what I mean by that is different nutritional protocols work for different people and a better way to look at nutrition and a better question isn’t, should I intermittent fast? Because that’s what everyone should be doing. Or should I be eating vegan or carnivore or paleo or insert, ketogenic diet here.

It’s thinking about nutrition, like square pegs into square holes. And there’s a [00:08:00] nutritional protocol out there that will work really well for you, but you might have to experiment with it. And I get it because I wish as a nutritionist, and I’m sure it’s the same with you, Ben, that you could just say to everybody, eat this way, train this way, and you’ll get amazing results because that’s not the truth.

The truth is you have to experiment with exercise. I’m a firm believer in, unless you’re working to an extreme goal, a marathon, a triathlon, a bodybuilding show, you have to find an exercise regimen that you enjoy, like something I’ve, recommended to clients in the past is try and find exercise that feels like play to You if you like playing five a side basketball, or you like to go to run for running sessions to de stress, or you like to cycle or hike, that’s what you should base your foundation of your exercise regimen around because that won’t feel like exercise to you. It’s going to feel like play to you.

It’s going to be something that you enjoy. Food can be very similar to that. You have to first ask, well, what can I stick to over the longterm? Now I do intermittent fasting. I’m a big fan of it. It suits my schedule for me. I get up in the [00:09:00] morning. I like to train fasted. I like to kind of keep my brain clear so I can do my creative work in the morning.

And then I’ll have my first meal, after a cup of coffee, several hours after I’ve gotten up, I used to bodybuild and I competed in bodybuilding for years as well. And I did the six meals a day, six small meals a day. And that worked really well for me at the time as because that was my schedule and my lifetime at the time.

It was all about building muscle, losing body fat, getting ready for stage and getting ready for shoots and things along those lines. So at different stages of your life, different nutrition protocols may or may not work for you. I’m a little bit of a guinea pig when it comes to, I’ve tried all of them.

I’ve done carnivore, I’ve done vegan, I’ve done keto, I’ve done fasting, I’ve done multi day fast, I’ve done the bodybuilding plan. Because I like to see when I’m working with clients, look, this is probably how you’re going to feel. Now, everyone has different starting points and there’s terms like metabolic, flexibility that are important to know that if you’re burning carbohydrates or burning fat as your primary fuel source, your starting point is going to matter a great deal.

So somebody like me [00:10:00] who was relatively lean starting intermittent fasting didn’t really find it that difficult where someone who’s been eating sugary cereals all their life for breakfast and is riding a sugar rollercoaster all day is really going to struggle with intermittent fasting in the beginning because you’re, burning glucose, you’re burning glycogen, you’re burning carbohydrates as your only fuel source.

Your body doesn’t know how to burn dietary fat or the fat stored in your body in some cases, whereas someone relatively lean whose body does know how to do that isn’t going to struggle. So there’s pros and cons to every diet. It’s ultimately about finding, okay, I like the sound of that. That sounds good.

I’m going to experiment with it for a few weeks. You might need professional help, somebody that can help coach you through it. And that’s okay too. We all need coaches in different areas of our life. And then you decide, actually I like this. I can stick to this. I’m getting the results I want. I’m going to continue with it because sustainability and longevity at the end of the day is what it’s all about when it comes to nutrition and exercise.

Dr. Weitz: So let’s go back to the exercise portion. Is weight training or cardio more important?

Brian: I, when people ask me about weight training and cardio, about being more important, I always say, what’s more important to live, your brain or your heart? And the answer is, both because they serve different purposes.  And weight training, I’m biased towards weight training and strength training because of all the benefits that you get. One, it increases your metabolic rate, which is probably the most important thing. Something that people don’t understand is they’ll do cardio when they’re trying to lose weight or lose body fat.  And on paper it makes sense. Cardio doesn’t burn body fat. Cardio burns calories and burning calories can support a caloric deficit, which can support your body’s ability to tap into fat stores and use them for fuel. So people will think, Oh, I’ll go do 40 minutes on a cross trainer, or I’ll go walk for half an hour on a treadmill.

That’s going to work great for my fat loss. And in some cases it can. What strength training does and what lifting weights does is it increases your metabolic rates so that you burn more [00:12:00] calories while you’re resting. It’s the calorie burning fat loss, equivalent of making money while you sleep. So I’m very biased towards that when somebody is looking to improve their body composition, but weight training and strength training.

Also, if you think about yourself in 20 years, 30 years, 40 years, I’m in my mid thirties. Now I want to be able to walk up and down stairs when I’m 70, 80, I want to be able to move around and not break a hip. Strength training improves that. and increases your body’s ability to be stronger and adapt with that force as you get older and that bone density.

So I love that. Cardiovascular activity then is great for endorphin release. You’ll hear a lot of people saying runners high or cyclers high or swimmers high. Cardio is really good for that so you could feel better doing it. You can also burn more calories if you have a weight loss goal. It can also reduce potentially in some cases your risk of certain, diseases and illnesses.  Again, mostly down to improvement of blood flow and reduction in body fat, et cetera. So I like [00:13:00] both. It’s very much a case of if you ask me what’s the best, I would say do a combination. I would say do some cardio, do a little bit of weight training and mix and match.

Dr. Weitz: And as far as cardio, we have long term steady state. What, I guess technically is term zone two training. And then we have higher intensity cardio where you really get your heart rate up and you get out of breath. do you recommend both of these? Do you?

Brian: It depends on the starting point of the individual because they serve kind and slightly different purposes.  So I do a lot of my, and my profession is based around body composition, people, weight loss. fat loss, toning up, building muscle. So getting people into physical shape. When you put that lens and put it through that lens, your high intensity interval training is going to be better for those looking to preserve muscle because it’s shorter, it’s higher intensity, it’s not going to take as long.

So it means you can prioritize other things like your weight training. but it’s also been shown in the research and the evidence that it’s preserves muscle better than low [00:14:00] intensity, steady state cardio, all other things equal. Whereas low intensity, steady state, like your 20 minutes, 30 minutes, 40 minutes on a cross trainer is your zone two.

It can be really good if your calories are quite low and your energy levels are quite low. The downside of HIIT training is if you’re in a calorie deficit or your calories are quite low, you might not have the fuel. to be able to keep that intensity high during the session, especially if your carbohydrates are low, because you tend to find that high intensity interval training is a lot more glycotic.

It’s going to be a lot more carbohydrate based, whereas your low intensity steady state, your zone two, it’s a little bit more and potentially can, be in that fat burning zone if your calories are controlled and they’re in that deficit. So that’s where people mix and match it for body composition. I think it’s very much a case of what do you prefer and what can you stick to.

I personally do long distance running and I’ve done ultra marathons and things along those lines. I don’t enjoy it. I’m built for speed and I’m built for short bursts and I love HIIT workouts. I love being able to just, I’m in a hotel room, I’ve got 20 minutes and I’m just going to do [00:15:00] 10 exercises, one minute on each one, two rounds and just go straight through, work up a sweat and I’m done in 20 minutes. I don’t want to go walking on a treadmill for an hour in the morning if I’m busy and have to speak at a conference or whatever it is. So there’s an element of what you enjoy, what fits into your lifestyle. But knowing that there’s pros and cons to both, depending on your nutrition, depending on your starting point, and if you have any preexisting injuries.  Obviously, if you have a knee injury, you’re going to be very limited with certain movements for high intensity where you might be fine on a cross trainer. So you have to take all of these things into consideration.

Dr. Weitz: Sure. Absolutely. If you’ve got a knee injury, you’re likely not going to be able to do squats or burpees or lunges or things like that some people combine their cardio with their weight training, as you were just mentioning, either doing body weight or relatively lightweight going from set exercise to exercise, keeping the heart rate up. what do you think are the benefits of doing, let’s say you have an hour. Would you be better off doing an hour of [00:16:00] higher intensity weight training where you do a set of something, do something else, maybe a burpee, a set of burpees, or maybe just go from one weight training exercise to the other, or is it better to do like a half an hour of concentrated weight training trying to lift as much weight as possible and then doing 30 minutes of cardio?

Brian: Again, it would be goal dependent. So if you’re talking someone who just wants to get stronger or someone who just wants to build muscle, your hypertrophy or strength ranges, you’re going to be better doing something that’s very specifically optimized to that. You’re 30 minutes spent on concentrated training.  If you just want to feel better, you want to get your heart rate up. You just want to look better. You want to be fitter, a little bit stronger, and just move better. Then your circuit training can be. Amazing there. We are going and picking maybe five, six moves, doing 10, 12 reps on each one and doing it in a circuit that can be a very effective way to training based on a specific goal of the individual.

Dr. Weitz: should it cardio, is it better to do [00:17:00] cardio when you’re fasted? Is it better if you’re doing cardio and weight training, do you want to do the cardio before after the weight training, before, maybe it’s going to warm you up, but afterwards, maybe you’ve depleted the glycogen from the weight training.

Brian: Great. Another great question because there’s a few angles I could come at this from Ben. I had a video go quite viral recently about. And it was in that order about do your cardio vascular activity after you’ve weight trained. And when you’re looking at things like fasted cardio, and I’m an evidence backed coach, so I use the evidence to research because it’s very difficult.

Otherwise I’m just offering opinions, which isn’t really helpful for anyone unless I say this is my opinion. This is what’s worked for me. When you look at the research, things like fasted cardio and overall cardio time is what’s the most important. So whether you do it fasted, 20 minutes in the morning or 20 minutes.  5 times spaced over the day or 20 minutes at the end of a workout. All other things equal, the results will be very, very similar, but they’re [00:18:00] not always similar because context matters. For example, when I used to compete in bodybuilding shows, I loved fasted cardio and not because it sped up fat loss. It was because I was a bit of a zombie in the morning, so I could walk on a treadmill.

I could keep that routine. It was getting me out of bed early. I could do it and it never got missed because it was anchored as a habit at the start of my day, which meant the consistency was really high. So fasted cardio can be really good for people because you can habit stack it with other things.

You wake up in the morning, grab a cup of coffee, go and do your cardio. And you’re very unlikely to skip it then because it’s part of your routine. Morning routines can be really useful for people. But ultimately, if it’s better for you to do it at the end of your workout or to do it at lunchtime, then That’s going to be fine as well.

All other things equal, particularly for body composition and weight loss. When it comes to doing it at the end of sessions, I like to take the approach that your energy levels, if you think of a gym session and you have 45 minutes in the gym. which is generally an [00:19:00] average workout for most people. If you’re any longer in the gym, you probably need to bring a stopwatch, which in time your rest periods, because you probably don’t need to be in the gym any longer than 45, 50 minutes, unless you’re training for a marathon or an Ironman or something that’s more endurance based.

But for body composition, muscle building, toning up, weight loss, fat loss, 45, 50 minutes max is all you’re going to need three, four or five times a week if you’re an advanced trainer. And if you go in, your energy levels at the start of workouts tend to be higher. Regardless. of your nutritional protocol.

Most people just tend to have more energy at the start of a workout, whether you’re carb based, fat based, whether you’re using really high quality foods, which is obviously what I recommend, or if you’re using low, low quality foods, people’s energy tends to be higher at the beginning of a workout and you get tired as it goes on.

Weight training, Unresistance training and strength training gives you a better bang for your buck, as I mentioned, because it will increase your metabolic rate. You want to do those more difficult movement and exercises and parameters of training when you’re fresher. So if you’re going in, it’s the same reason you don’t [00:20:00] go in.

And you know this from your bodybuilding days, you don’t start your workout with a bicep curl and, midway through your workout, when you’re feeling the best. You start doing bicep curls, you do your squats, or you do your deadlifts, or you do your bench press, or you do your military press when you’re fresh.

Those compound multi joint exercises that are going to recruit a lot of muscle, a lot of your body, and are going to give you a better bang for your buck when it comes to the exercise choice you’re choosing. I think of cardio and weight training is very similar. Weight training. All other things equal gives you a better return on your investment.  So do it when you’re fresher and then do your cardio at the end when you’re a little bit tired, especially if you’re doing low intensity steady state.

Dr. Weitz: And I think the other thing is, you want to burn off your glycogen with the weight training. Cause then you’re going to burn a higher amount of fat because your body’s going to use the glycogen, the storage form of carbohydrates before it starts burning fat.

Brian: Yeah, a hundred percent. And again, your nutritional protocol would be dependent there because people that are on higher fat diets. And again, this is the reason I want to preface it because [00:21:00] intermittent fasters or people who go higher dietary fat, their glycogen stores can be largely depleted by the time they start training.  So that’s why if you are doing a strength program and you’re on a ketogenic diet, sometimes you can find that your weakness or goes down, ie your strength goes down because you don’t have the best fuel source for the activity that you’re trying to do. It’s just one of the trade offs. Ketogenic diet is great for brain function, can be great for hunger, satiety, mental clarity, all these other things.

It can isn’t always the best for strength and weight training. It doesn’t happen to everybody. There is a point at which your ketosis and ketones go to a certain level where improvement and strength can go up, but in the initial phases, it can go down. So the starting point matters greatly, but for the average person consuming an Irish diet, English diet, American diet, that, a kind of healthier version of it.  They’re going to find a better bang for their buck trying to work through that glycogen depletion and then better utilize their body’s ability to burn fat for fuel as the workout goes on.

Dr. Weitz: By the way, what is an Irish diet?

Brian: [00:22:00] Potato, potatoes and meat, potatoes and meat with a little bit of vegetables thrown in.

Dr. Weitz: Okay, that sounds like the American diet.

Brian: Yeah. It’s very similar. I lived in California for years. Exactly. You have better, you’ve got better desserts. I must say your desserts are considerably better in the States than we have over here.

Dr. Weitz: So when you’re working with a client who wants to lose weight, how do you decide what type of a nutritional approach to use with them?

Brian: What I do with my clients, and it’s not necessarily a recommendation for any other coaches or personal trainers, but I find this works really well for me. I normally get them to do a food diary for three days. And if they eat Oreos for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, I say, put down the Oreos for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.  Like, tell me what you’re actually eating. And the first thing I’ll try and do is, right, what are they doing well? And in most diets, I’ll say 95 percent of people have good habits somewhere in [00:23:00] the nutrition. They’re making good lunch choices, but maybe their breakfast isn’t that good. Or they’ve got a really nutritionally dense dinner, but they’re snacking on cookies and Oreos through the day.

I will look to see, all right, these are the things that aren’t going to support them with the goal. These are the things that are, and I try and layer the nutritional plan that I create for them on top of that so that they’re just building off the good habits they already have, and they’re minimizing the bad habits that they’re doing. I had one of my clients before and I put this in the last book and it was a story that it went viral when I released it at the time because my client was speaking about it. 

Dr. Weitz: Either way, what was, what’s the name of that book?

Brian: The last book was The Keen Edge, Mastering the Mindset for Real Lasting Fat Loss.  And I talk about him in there. I’ve got three, Fitness Mindset, Rewire Your Mindset, and The Keen Edge are my three books. The two, first two are, First one and last one are fitness books. Second book is all around mindset and personal development. But I had a client who came to me, Ben, who ate 10 Mars bars every day, literally 10 Mars bars every day.

He would get two of the family packs and you can get five bars in the family packs in [00:24:00] Ireland. And when I was working one to one, I’m all online now, but I was working Did you measure his blood glucose? Oh, I didn’t. He was very overweight to come in with. And we kept it very simple because he’s like, I’ve been to coaches.

I’ve been to trainers. I’ve been to slimming clubs and nothing is working. And I’ll never forget the look he gave me the first day when he came in, because our entire workout session was just going up and down the stairs of the gym. Cause that’s all he was able to do. And he didn’t want to go in. He was a bit nervous and had gym anxiety around it.

He was telling me about his Mars bears. And I said, okay, I’m All I want you to do for this next week with your nutritional plan is I want you to eat nine Mars bars. That’s all I want you to do. I was like, eat, your normal diet, but I don’t want you eating 10. So I want you to eat.

Dr. Weitz: Brian King recommended eating nine Mars bars.  

Brian:  Nine bars, the fat loss plan, nine, nine, nine, nine bars. He came back and he was very skeptical and he came back in the next week and his weight was down and he goes, I don’t know how my weight is down. He goes, maybe I walked a bit more. I was like, okay. No changes this week, except instead of nine, I want you to eat eight this week.

So you can [00:25:00] have them anytime you want to eat them when you want, but we’re going to bring it down to eight. You’re way too nice. But the thing was, and I wouldn’t do this with everybody because sometimes I make more changes depending on the starting point, but this, When I’m chatting to somebody on a consultation call and they’ve been to 10 trainers before me and they’re still overweight and they’re still having problems.

I’m like, well, all the traditional methods don’t work. So I just rule that out initially. So we went from eight and you can tell where the story is going. It went from seven to six and it actually got down to the point where he was eating two every day, but it controlled his calories and brought his calories down.

And he ended up losing a hundred pounds over the space of several months. And all we did now, Confidence was huge for him when he actually started to see the weight going down without making any extreme changes. He bought so much into the idea of what we were doing. If I told him to run through a brick wall, Ben, he’d run through a brick wall by the end because he just had so much faith in what we were doing because he saw the results.

But it was about building sustainable habits for him. And I was trying to illustrate that. The importance of somebody like that. And I know you talk a [00:26:00] lot about gut health and, the functional medicine side and overall hormonal balance, et cetera, which is extremely important, but for someone like him who just needed to control his calories for the most part, it was to illustrate you’re eating too many calories every day.

That, that’s it. You’re eating 10 Mars bars. That’s a lot of calories. And just bringing that down. And then we ended up looking at his nutrition overall, his breakfast, lunch and dinner. And over the space of, it was about nine months total, he had completely changed the way that he ate, but that’s how it started.  So sometimes the non traditional approach, depending on the circumstance of the individual is just as important as the method that you use

Dr. Weitz: with them. Well, let’s say somebody comes to you and they say, look, I want to be in the best shape. I want to be healthy. I want to lose, 50 pounds. I’m willing to eat any way you tell me to eat.  Should I eat paleo? Should I eat Mediterranean? Should I eat keto? What, what would you tell them?

Brian: If somebody was [00:27:00] working with me, the advice I’d offer, if it was a general question versus someone working with me would be different. So I’ll unpack. both and talk through the difference between both. If it’s someone that’s working with me, where I’m monitoring their food and keeping an eye on their food, I don’t really mind how quickly or how slowly we make the changes because I’m assuming they bought in for 3, months, especially if they have 50 pounds to lose and they want to lose and they want to keep it off.

So when I’m working with somebody, I’ll do that food diary approach and I will make small changes over time. is going to support them. As I said, someone that’s 50 pounds overweight in most cases didn’t get there by accident. They’re not a professional athlete. They’re not a fitness person by nature. If I’m working with somebody in that space, I can make more changes with them because they’ve got just a different mindset and they have a different starting point coming in.

So when I’m working with that individual, I’ll make those small changes based on a food diary and try and build off the habits that they’ve already formed that might be good and then make changes around it. [00:28:00] If somebody asks me outside of that, I would generally say you can’t go too wrong. Nutrition is such a funny topic, as Ben.

And the piece of advice that I historically have always been able to give without any push back. And now in 2024, it gets pushed back is eat more fruits and vegetables. Like you generally, eat more vegetables in particular, green leafy veg, and now you have communities of people online who be like, don’t eat green leafy veg, they’re poisonous.

So that, one piece of advice that was a truism for so long now gets pushed back because of the way things are online in particular. But I think if you want to just go with a good healthy food approach, I think complete protein sources. So that’s going to be your meat and fish for the most part, grass fed if you’re in the States, particularly.  Making sure you’re getting good sourced fish, high levels of Omega 3.

Dr. Weitz: Can you guys not get grass fed or is all the meat grass fed? All of ours

Brian: EU regulations here. I remember when I was in the States and when I’m working with people in [00:29:00] the States, I’m like, I have to give different specific guidelines.  Whereas that’s not an issue here. I’m working with someone in Ireland or England or in Europe. We don’t have that problem. We don’t get the same level of hormones and peptides put into our food. There’s just, it’s, a hard no from the EU regulation. So our quality of meat tends to be higher. compared to the states where it’s way less strict. so that’s what I would look at your complex carbohydrates for most people, your oatmeal, your sweet potato, your yams, your brown rice, all good options, healthy fats, avocado, nut butters to a degree, olive oil, and then your fruits and your vegetables, especially fruits, which get demonized by some. If you have a sweet tooth, you can’t go too wrong.

And again, the quality of food matters, where you’re getting it from matters, but I’m just talking general best practices for people, which is kind of Mediterranean mixed with kind of a paleolithic style diet, which is kind of adjusted depending on the complex carbohydrates. You’re not going to go too far wrong with that.

And I like that approach. because the fiber is high, the nutrients are high. Your cravings [00:30:00] can go down. You’ll, this from talking about episodes of the gut microbiome, you’re giving your body what it needs in terms of good nutrient dense foods. You’re going to have a higher satiety effect. You’re going to feel fuller for longer between meals.

You’re going to have less cravings and that makes dietary adherence considerably easier. And ultimately with 50 pounds to lose, it’s dietary adherence. You’re better off to stick in the gut. 80 percent to a diet that isn’t amazing, then fall 100 percent off one you can’t stick to.

Dr. Weitz: What about your mindset about food?

Brian: It’s so interesting, and I’m glad you’ve given me such an unintentional segue, Ben, because my first book, The Fitness Mindset, and it’s not a plug for the book, people can pick it up if they want. I’m a believer that some people should read the book, some people shouldn’t. all books, every book you’ve ever read in the planet, the people that need it should read.

Dr. Weitz: I think all people need to read more books. Yeah.

Brian: Yeah. it’s a good piece of advice in general, but mindset, I wrote that first book and that first book changed my whole career. It came out in 2017. [00:31:00] It’s been 16 weeks on the Amazon and national bestseller list and opened up more doors for me than I knew what to do with at the time.  I’m very, very grateful for it. And Part of the reason the book took off was I broke it into two sections. The first section was called the fitness mindset. The first section is called fitness, which is all about sleep, nutrition, training, stress, supplementation, everything you need to know how to get in shape.

The whole second section is around mindset, your anxiety, managing that stress levels, your behavior around food, making sure that you’re being around good people and supportive people. All these things that people don’t always necessarily think of when they think about mindset around fitness. And I think the reason the book did so well was because that’s what my clients at the time were struggling with.

Most of the ones who came to me knew they should move more. They knew they should make better food choices, and they had a good idea of that yes, broccoli is going to be more beneficial than having a cookie at lunchtime. They knew all these [00:32:00] basic things, but they still couldn’t stay on top of their nutrition and the training program.

There was self sabotage. They were around people who weren’t supporting them. They were anxious and stressed and they couldn’t control that. And that led to either skipping exercises or skipping workouts or making poor food choices. So I merged those two things together. So my entire philosophy as a coach is around that mindset.

And it’s funny, I could be working two, three, four weeks with somebody, I’ll design a nutritional plan, I’ll design a training program, which to be fair, let’s call it a spade a spade, any good coach can do. And then they’ll say something on week three or week four about their relationship or about their job, or about their stress levels.

And I go, okay, now we’re onto something. This is why you haven’t got the results with other coaches or why you haven’t got results yourself in the past. I would start to unpack that and see, well, what’s going on with your mindset? Why are you self sabotaging around food? Why do you need to numb out or why, What, are the emotional triggers that are going on within you that are setting you off and making you fall off track with your nutrition?

And they’re the things that ultimately come down to the [00:33:00] mindset side. So I think it’s really important because fitness isn’t complicated. Yes, we can argue back and forth between weight training and cardio and high intensity and low intensity, but movement is something we can all agree is good. Move more.

Most people need to move more and the same with food. Less processed food, more whole food, in whatever capacity that looks like, is generally going to be better. Most professionals will agree on that. We’ll have nuances in between, but we’ll agree on that. But it’s the mindset that makes people fall off track, and it’s why they can’t stick to it.  So I think it’s extremely important.

Dr. Weitz: Let’s go into a little bit about maximizing performance. Protein. We know we need a certain amount of protein to maximize muscle gains. How much protein should the average person have? And, when should that protein be eaten? What about the timing?

Brian: With protein, there’s different recommendations depending on What it is that you’re training for.  So someone that’s doing a [00:34:00] strength program or an athlete that plays a sport, basketball, football, rugby, et cetera, the requirements are gonna be slightly different. General best practice is gonna be one to two grams per kilogram of body weight. So that’s per two pounds of body weight if I’m doing the correct.

Dr. Weitz: yeah, I think one kilo is like 2.2 pounds.

Brian: Yeah. So in, in terms of kilos, if you are 80 kilograms, you’re going to want to get about 80 to 160. g of protein per day and it’s very easy to calculate your calories around that for every gram of protein you eat there’s four kilocalories in it, so you can get and do the maths from that.

But what sometimes people fail to recognize is fats and carbohydrates serve as proteins, bigger in macronutrients, meaning that. If you are consuming a decent level of carbohydrate or fat or a combination of both, your body will prioritize that for energy and for fuel, and then it’ll utilize the protein and the amino acids that are the makeup of that protein for repair.

And [00:35:00] sometimes you’ll see, and you probably did this in the bodybuilding days, Ben, I don’t know, I definitely did. So a lot of bodybuilders did where they just ramp up protein to like 300 grams a day. Sure. And you get all the negative side effects, constipation, dry mouth, stomach discomfort and GI distress.

Thinking more is better when in reality you’re would have been way more and optimize your performance in a better way. If you just adjusted your carbohydrates or fat upwards and down and actually took your protein down and you’d feel better. through the day and your inflammatory, your body gets so, like your gut gets so inflamed and your protein is way too high, hence the constipation in a lot of cases.

So I’d say one to two grams per kilogram of body weight, doing the pounds equivalent of that, and then basing the rest of your nutrition around it. So your caloric intake is important. I’m a believer that it’s the bottom of the pyramid of prioritization. IE, you need to know what your calories are. If you have a body composition or performance goal, your macros come on top of that.

Your food choices come on top [00:36:00] of that. Like I, I like the whole food approach. I think the more whole foods you eat, the better you’re going to be. You’re going to do in terms of performance, whether you’re looking to lose weight or whether you’re an athlete, you’re going to get more micronutrients, you’re going to feel better, your fiber will be higher.

And I think when you look at protein, it’s the most important of the macronutrients for an athlete for repair, for performance, because those building blocks, those amino acids that make a protein are the building blocks of all things in life. And you need them to repair from sessions in terms of timing.

Best practice, I like spacing it out through the day, but your workout window is important. So they’ll generally say, depending on your starting weight, 25 grams to 50 grams of protein in your pre and post workout meal, normally in the easily digestible source. So, you know, if you’re eating meat, that might be a chicken breast before training with some sweet potato.

After it might be some oats and a whey protein shake or a dextrose. If you’re really trying to replenish glycogen levels fast, if you’re a high level athlete and you’ve got a game the next day or a training session the next day or a gym session the next day, you [00:37:00] might want to go with something that’s a bit more higher GI, your dextrose, your glucose, et cetera, so that you replenish glycogen stores faster.

And then you have a complex carbohydrate meal, 30 to 60 grams. of carbohydrate and 25 to 50 grams of protein in that meal, half an hour, 45 minutes after you’ve trained when that lactic acid is cleared down. That’s generally how you’d approach it. And then you build the rest of your nutrition around that pre and post workout window.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. What about nutritional supplements? Do you recommend them specifically related to training, pre workout, post workout things?

Brian: I have a food first, but not food only approach. And somebody that has 50 pounds of weight to lose, supplements tend to be pretty low down on the list. They can help.  And I will recommend ones. I’m a big fan of caffeine and green tea extract like harness and things along those lines that won’t have a negative impact in terms of a rebound effect or a decrease in appetite or an increase in appetite suppression, and then a rebound where [00:38:00] your appetite ramps up. I like those types of supplements.

Win performance is the goal. You can’t go too wrong with a good quality protein powder, whether that’s a high quality whey protein, if you’ve no issue with dairy for ethical reasons or no issue with dairy for digestive reasons, or, a vegan based blend, if you prefer to go with that, and then creatine, you cannot go wrong.

with creating the most scientifically backed sports supplement of all time in terms of increasing performance for strength for sprint based athletes. And then I maybe throw beta alanine on top of that. Beta alanine helps to buffer lactic acid. So if you play competitive sport or you play high level sport and you get that buildup of lactic acid, which inhibits your performance, your beta alanine can help to buffer that and it can increase the longevity in which until that happens.

So I would look at a good quality protein powder. maybe some creatine, maybe some beta alanine, and then obviously caffeine. If you want to use caffeine in some form, assuming that you’re a caffeine responder, you’ll get great performance benefits from [00:39:00] those.

Dr. Weitz: What type and how much creatine?

Brian: It depends on your starting weight.  General, depending on the type, monohydrate is the most scientifically researched, which normally needs to be loaded. But creatine is kind of a funny supplement in the sense that sometimes people are like, what’s the difference? Well, I’ll take it before my workout and it’s going to help me with my strength training.

That’s not how creatine works. Creatine works. And the analogy I give is if you picture a two liter water bottle, when you have a two liter water bottle that’s empty, you’re able to bend and crack it. When you fill it with water, you’re, you can put a lot more strain on that two liter water bottle. That’s effectively what happens with your muscles with creatine.

Creatine pulls water underneath the muscle so that you’re able in the setting of a gym, for example, to move more weight than you normally would, or you’re able to do the same weight for more repetitions because you have more water and you’re able to put more strain on that muscle. So when it comes to creatine loading, All you’re looking to do is saturate the cell.

So saturating the cell in some cases is going to be loading it for say 20 grams. You normally have five gram [00:40:00] dose four times a day over a three to five day window. And then you do a maintenance dose, which is five to 10 grams, depending on your starting weight, but you don’t have to do that. You’ll saturate a cell over a longer period of time, but just five grams a day, it just takes longer.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. how about beta alanine? How much do you recommend?

Brian: That one I would time around your workout, similar to caffeine. So caffeine and beta alanine are one side of the coin and then creatine on the other side. With creatine, the most important thing is about the consistency, meaning that you’re taking the right dosage.

The timing, I take it around workouts just so I don’t forget to take it. Literally the only reason I take it before I go to the gym, so that I’ve Don’t forget to take it. Beta alanine you’ll take in that 30 to 60 minute window before you train and it’s worth noting you’ll get sometimes what are called beta alanine tingles where you’ll get this weird tingly feeling in your face or in your hands.

I remember the first time I took it in college Ben I thought it was my fabric softener that I was using and I remember I changed and I was like I’m allergic to this fabric softener and the thing I’m washing my clothes with I [00:41:00] didn’t realize it was the beta alanine tingles and I was training for about two months before I realized this is like pre forum days, pre Instagram, pre Google, which is showing my age as well. and I didn’t know it was beta alanine, but taking it before training, normally around, 1. 5 to 3 grams, depending on your starting weight is going to be very effective. And a lot of people will pair that with caffeine, which will be, between a hundred MCGs and 300 MCGs, depending on how caffeine sensitive the person is and that stack with your pre training of beta aldehyde and caffeine and maybe some creatine in there and then post workout of something like a high quality whey protein or a protein powder is going to give you very good benefits as an athlete.

Dr. Weitz: So the caffeine is that like in a pre workout formula or are you talking about coffee or tea?

Brian: It doesn’t really matter. Like caffeine itself is the thing you’re looking to do. It’s the stimulant that’s going to give you your central nervous system response, which is going to increase your, rate of perceived exertion in terms of your, you won’t feel as tired. You’ll be more alert. You’ll feel like you’re able to [00:42:00] push harder in this workouts.

So the vehicle and distribution of it matters less, whether that’s a can of monster, a cup of coffee, a caffeine tablet, a pre workout, they all have pros and cons depending on, I use a caffeine tablet, Partly because I love black coffee, but I can’t take it in the morning or else my stomach and my guts feel like someone’s like attacked me with a knife for the rest of the day.

So I have to have food in my stomach before I have my cup of coffee generally. And so I use a caffeine tablet. I use pre workouts for years. Again, there’s a lot of additives, a lot of extra stuff in those that are great, same as cans of Monster. But if you’re talking just purely the caffeine element of the performance enhancer, it doesn’t matter as much in terms of how you consume it.  But if you’re talking other things, what’s the cleanest way, probably a black coffee or a caffeine tablet compared to a pre workout or a can of

Dr. Weitz: Monster or Red Bull. Yeah, speaking of that beta alanine sensation with the skin, you ever take niacin before you work out? Yeah, just very similar. It’s a bit more flushy, but it’s [00:43:00] very similar.  I know you did a podcast on that recently. I’m a big fan of niacin, but that flushing can be uncomfortable. It’s not harmful, but. Yeah, it feels weird. It just feels weird. Yeah, I used to do that before workouts or before sauna.

Brian: Yeah, it’s really, good. And again, I know a lot of people do it before sauna it’s a big thing over here too. yeah, I, again, similar to belalanine, when you know what it is, it’s fine. But when you don’t, it’s a bit worrying. You actually think something’s gone wrong with your body. Like there’s like a mini alarm system going off, but once you know what’s the niacin or the belalanine, you’re normally fine.

Dr. Weitz: Have you experimented with the nitric oxide, supplement?

Brian: Yeah, I’m a fan. So I make up my own pre workout before I train. And I have AAKG in there, which is a form of arginine. And I use citrulline malate, which is a supplement that’s in most pre workouts for blood flow. So my pre workout is 200 mcg’s of caffeine, 5 grams of creatine, 3 grams of beta alanine, three grams of citrulline malate, and three grams [00:44:00] of AAKG.

And I just make that up myself. And then I throw some acetylalcarnitine for cognitive function in top. And I use that before I train. Oh, interesting. You get powders of all those? Yeah. And it ends up working out way cheaper, but just, I have a little bit of a sensitive stomach. So I literally just put them into a shake, little bit of a drop of cordial or sweetener that goes with them.

and then I just down that before the gym. And it works great. It ends up working out way cheaper because like pre workouts are actually very expensive when you think about what you’re getting dosage wise. So when I’m working with clients, I’ll normally create these stacks with them as well. So they’ll end up paying whatever, 50, 60 dollars for all these individuals.  And then it lasts for like three, four or five months and they’re getting the correct dosage for each thing.

Dr. Weitz: Yeah, one of the downsides of bodybuilding supplements in particular is they tend to add artificial colors, artificial sweeteners, all this junk. So

Brian: much. And that’s actually what put me off originally, because I was taking those when I was competing in bodybuilding shows.  And [00:45:00] I would hate to see what was going on in my gut microbiome during that time, because it was definitely screaming at me from the inside. So I’ve been a lot better with that over the last decade.

Dr. Weitz: That’s great. so I think we’re ready to wrap. What kind of final thoughts or, concepts do you want to leave our viewers and listeners with?

Brian: No, I really appreciate that, Ben. It was a great chat. As I said, I’m going to double down on what I said about finding what works best for you, whether it’s exercise, whether it’s nutrition. I know you’ve got some great guests on the podcast. You’ve got episodes and covering content yourself on your Instagram.

Ultimately for people listening, find what’s going to work best for you with your nutrition, with your training. And if you need a coach or a trainer that can help get you there, Find somebody that will serve you. As I said, square pegs into square holes. You might listen to me and go, it’s not Brian. It’s going to be someone else.

But again, I have a Muay Thai coach. I have a yoga coach. I have a Spanish coach. Three things in my life that I’m weak at, that I need to improve on. I’m a big believer that coaches need coaches and that people need help in areas that they’re struggling with. And again, look for [00:46:00] those. use the old Buddha quote, when the student is ready, the teacher will appear, find the coach that will support you, whoever that is, and know that square pegs fit into square holes.  And it’s ultimately about finding what’s going to work best for you.

Dr. Weitz: Now, what if they want to get ahold of you? Do you still work with clients? Do you have programs? And how would they get ahold of you? I

Brian: do. Yeah. I’m briankeenfitness. com is where I have all the details on my programs. I’m from my one to one.  My one to one is application only. so you have to apply to work.

Dr. Weitz: Can you spell out your name?

Brian:  Brian Ke, B-R-I-A-N-K-E-A-N-E, fitness, F-I-T-N-E s.com. so brian ke fitness.com. I’m on social. Instagram is the one I’m on the most often, but I’m on all of them. And the Brian Ke podcast and then Brian Keane, the books are on Amazon and available everywhere books are found.  So I’m all over the place. It’s just very much a case of finding. What way do you like to consume information? Do you like to listen? Do you like to watch? Do you like short form videos? Do you like writing? Whatever way you want to consume information. Hopefully I can help anyone that reaches out. and for anyone that wants to work with me directly, I have programs on [00:47:00] that website and then applications to work one to one as well as I mentioned, just, it tends to be a bit more at the extreme cases that I take, because I have programs that serve for just general body composition that tend to work better at a lower price point for people. So we try and serve people all along the way of their journey.

Dr. Weitz: That’s great.  Thank you so much, Brian.

Brian: Thank you so much, Ben.


Dr. Weitz:  Thank you for making it all the way through this episode of the Rational Wellness Podcast. For those of you who enjoy. Listening to the Rational Wellness Podcast, I would appreciate it if you could go to Apple Podcasts or Spotify and give us a five star ratings and review. If you would like to work with me personally to help you improve your health, I do accept a limited number of new patients per month for a functional medicine consultation.  Some of the areas I specialize in include helping patients with specific health issues, like gut problems, neurodegenerative conditions, autoimmune diseases, cardiometabolic conditions, or for an executive health screen and to help you promote longevity and take a deeper dive into some of those factors that can lead to chronic diseases along the way.  Please call my Santa Monica White Sports Chiropractic and Nutrition Office at 310 395 3111 and we’ll set you up for a new consultation for functional medicine and I look forward to speaking to everybody next week.

Dr. Darin Ingels discusses Lyme Disease at the Functional Medicine Discussion Group meeting on June 27, 2024 with moderator Dr. Ben Weitz.  

[If you enjoy this podcast, please give us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts, so more people will find The Rational Wellness Podcast. Also check out the video version on my WeitzChiro YouTube page.] 

 

Podcast Highlights

2:57  Dr. Ingels got bit by a tick in 2002 while living about 30 minutes from Lyme, Connecticut and he got Lyme Disease.  It took him about three years of cyling through a cascade of different Lyme treatments, that are often targeted at killing the organism, though effective treatment for Lyme Disease involves much more than just killing the bacteria.

4:02  Lyme disease is a bacterial infection caused by the Borrelia species of spirochete bacteria and transmitted by the bite of a deer tick.  Back in the 1970s there were a rash of kids suffering with arthritic conditions, so they started to send blood samples in the NIH, where a researcher, Willie Bergdorfer discovered the Borrelia bacteria that was causing these symptoms, so they named this species Borrelia Bergdorferi. There are at least five subspecies of Borrelia Bergdorferi, over 100 strains of Borrelia in the US and more than 300 strains worldwide.  Unfortunately, testing usually just looks at one strain. While the largest concentration of cases are from New England and the Midwest, but the East and West coasts are not both endemic for Lyme disease.  The CDC says that California is the fifth fastest growing state for Lyme disease. The ticks are carried not just by deer, but also by mice, rats, squirrels, and raccoons can carry these ticks.  We get about 476,000 new cases of Lyme every year in the United States.

 

 

 



Dr. Darin Ingels is a Naturopathic Doctor with a license both in California and Connecticut, and his office is in Irvine, Califonia. His practice focuses on treating patients with Lyme disease,  Dr. Ingels has published three books, the most recent is The Lyme Solution: A 5-part Plan to Fight the Inflammatory Autoimmune Response and Beat Lyme Disease. His website is DarinIngelsND.com.  His office is in Laguna Hills and his phone is 949.551.8751.

Dr. Ben Weitz is available for Functional Nutrition consultations specializing in Functional Gastrointestinal Disorders like IBS/SIBO and Reflux and also Cardiometabolic Risk Factors like elevated lipids, high blood sugar, and high blood pressure.  Dr. Weitz has also successfully helped many patients with managing their weight and improving their athletic performance, as well as sports chiropractic work by calling his Santa Monica office 310-395-3111.

 



 

Podcast Transcript

Dr. Weitz:  Hey, this is Dr. Ben Weitz, host of the Rational Wellness Podcast. I talk to the leading health and nutrition experts and researchers in the field to bring you the latest in cutting edge health information. Subscribe to the Rational Wellness Podcast for weekly updates. And to learn more, check out my website, drweitz.com. Thanks for joining me. And let’s jump into the podcast.

Hello, everybody. Thank you for joining our functional medicine discussion group meeting. I’m Dr. Ben Weitz. So we hope you’ll join some of our future meetings as well. We usually meet on the fourth Thursday of the month.

July 25th, Alan Barrier is going to speak about the hypothalamus pituitary adrenal axis.

August 22nd, it will be about Integrative Cardiology with Dr. Cynthia Fink. 

September 26th, Dr. Mark Pimentel will be talking about SIBO as the cause of IBS and all his exciting new research.

I encourage everybody to participate and ask questions. If you’re not aware, we have a closed Facebook page, the Functional Medicine Discussion Group of Santa Monica.  So please join that and we continue the discussion. We post a lot of articles and, uh, this is going to be recorded and included in my weekly Rational Wellness podcast. So please check that out. And if you enjoy listening to it, please give me a Ratings and Review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

So we’re so grateful that Dr. Darin Ingels has made the trek all the way from Irvine to speak to us about Lyme disease. Darin is one of the leading experts in the country on Lyme disease. He wrote a spectacular book called The Lyme Solution and his practice is focused on treating Lyme disease and I’ll let Darin introduce himself.

Dr. Ingels:  So, my own story, if you don’t know, is I was a Lyme patient. So nothing like getting an education on Lyme disease than getting the disease yourself.  I got bit by a tick in 2002, living about 30 minutes from Lyme, Connecticut.  I got bit two weeks before my own practice, so, uh, the timing of it couldn’t have been worse. And it really was the perfect storm. And I think, you know, as we kind of dig into Lyme, we’ll realize that it’s a common infection. I think there’s a lot of people that have that exposure, uh, but it is an opportunistic infection.  And it’s not just about killing the bug, it’s about all the other things we do to help heal the body, helping the terrain, the most inhospitable place for the organism. So, it took me about three years to go through my cascade of all the different Lyme treatments, and we’ll see this is a very common scenario with people dealing with Lyme disease, as often they cycle through treatment after treatment, often it’s targeted towards killing the organism, but we’ll see as we go through this that, there’s a lot more to it.

So, let’s dive in. So just a little background on Lyme disease, if you don’t know, it’s a bacterial infection primarily caused by the Borrelia species. Borrelia burgdorferi is the most common strain in North America. It’s transmitted primarily through the bite of a deer tick, the Ixodes tick in particular.  And this all started back in the late 1970s in Lyme, Connecticut. There was a group of children that started having this mysterious arthritic stuff. And juvenile rheumatoid arthritis is actually a very rare condition. But there were a lot of kids and there were a handful of adults that had all these arthritic things.  They didn’t really know what was going on. Nobody recalled getting, a rash or any kind of tick bite. And, uh, they started sending, uh, samples to a guy named Willie Bergdorfer. He was a researcher for the NIH. And his expertise actually is Rickettsial Illness, Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever. So they thought this was some weird Rickettsial Illness, and it took them several years, but they finally found this little critter under a microscope.  So the rule is, if you discover the bug, you get to name it after yourself. That’s why it’s Borrelia burgdorferi. It’s named after Dr. Willie Bergdorfer. And Dr. Bergdorfer just passed away not too long ago.

So there are at least five subspecies of Borrelia burgdorferi, over 100 strains in the U. S. and more than 300 strains worldwide.  This is important because when we talk about testing, testing looks at one strain. So often we’re missing the boat of all the potential Borrelia species that are out there that can cause infection, but there are a lot of them. We don’t even know how many strains are clinically relevant. Our best guess is it’s probably somewhere around 8, 8 to 10, uh, but nonetheless there are a lot out there.  Most of the cases in the United States come mostly from New England, the Central, Midwest. We’ll see in a little bit though that the East and West coasts of the United States are endemic for Lyme. And yes, even here in California, there is a ton of Lyme disease. The CDC says California is the fifth fastest growing state for Lyme disease.  I’ve had doctors in California tell patients there’s no Lyme disease. I had one doctor in San Diego tell my patient there’s no deer in California, I’m like, dude you need to get outside.  There’s deer everywhere. But deer, by the way, aren’t even the primary vector for carrying ticks. I mean, every furry little creature, mice, rats, squirrels, raccoons, all of them can carry these ticks.  So we get about 476,000 new cases of Lyme every year in the United States, more than 90,000 cases in Europe, and again, that’s new cases. We don’t really know how many new cases there are because of the reporting criteria.

Most people who have Lyme do not meet the CDC criteria for a positive Lyme test.  We’ll talk more about testing, but we’ll find that the testing was never designed to be diagnostic. The testing was designed as a surveillance tool for people who had known Lyme disease. So we know that whatever number’s out there, it’s probably much bigger than we think it is.  So, you can do the math, that’s almost half a million new cases a year.  We literally have millions and millions of people in North America living with Lyme disease. So, I mentioned transmissions primarily through the deer tick bite. There is very weak evidence that other biting insects might transmit Lyme. There’s a few small studies out of Europe with baby mosquitoes.  We actually have a colleague who is a medical doctor. His son is an entomologist in Florida. They actually were looking for Lyme in mosquitoes in Florida, and they found no evidence of Lyme in mosquitoes. So, I think that’s very low. However, other biting insects can transmit other diseases. They can transmit Bartonella and Babesia and Rickettsia.  We know Bartonella can be transmitted through fleas, it can be transmitted through lice. So, even though these biting insects may not carry Lyme per se, they can carry other tick borne illness and the symptoms look very, very similar.

We’ve now got ample evidence there is vertical transmission from mom to baby.  So if mom is pregnant, she can transmit it to her baby. And vertical transmission usually results in stillbirth, birth defects or these children start up with severe developmental delays. They miss all the early milestones and so forth. So, I’ve had parents come in where they got a nine year old child who’s having issues and mom found out she had Lyme.  She’s like, oh, I gave my baby Lyme. I’m like, well, if it started happening at seven years old, probably not. You know, if you live in the same area, child could have had their own ticks, but it’d be unlikely that was related to mom passing. With sexual transmission of the Lyme, we don’t really know, to be honest.  As far as I can tell, there’s only one study. Ray Stricker, who’s a researcher up in San Francisco, he did a study where he looked at the semen of men, looked at the vaginal secretions of women, he found it was like below 20 percent had evidence of Borrelia, but we don’t know if it actually gets transmitted.  Vaginal pH is very acidic, most organisms don’t thrive very well. So, Richard Horowitz, who’s really the Lyme guru of the country.  He’ll stand on stage and say his wife’s had Lyme forever, he’s like, we have unprotected sex, I’m not worried. So it’s possible, probably not probable, but we always err on the side of caution.  If one partner has Lyme, we do recommend barrier protection, just in case, because we don’t really know the truth. There’s other strains in the United States, Burrelia Burgdoferi, most of the East Coast, but we see it here on the West Coast. Borrelia miyamotoi has been an emerging strain that we see a lot more, about half the cases out in California are Borrelia miyamotoi.  There’s Borrelia mayonii, Borrelia lonestarii, Borrelia hermcii, which is causing what we call relapsing fever. In Europe, Borrelia afzalii and gorinii are the primary strains. So, it’s good to understand for a patient, where have they been in the world? Because, they may not have acquired Lyme here, they could have. We’ve been backpacking through Switzerland, and they got a bug while they were there, so it’s good to ask about foreign travel.  Uh, interestingly, Australia says there’s no Lyme in Australia, I guess ticks can’t swim that far. But, we’ve had a few Australian patients we’ve worked with that actually test CDC positive, so again, I don’t know what to tell you. I think they’re looking for the wrong thing, because they’re testing for Borrelia burgdorferi.

You’re looking for the North American strain in Australia, and you’re just, like, you’re probably looking for the wrong thing, would be my guess. This is just a map of how Lyme has changed over the years. Uh, the one on the left there is 2001, just kind of showing where we get, this is CDC positive Lyme. You can see, fast forward to 2022, that green is getting bigger and spreading.  Again, this is grossly unreported, but this is the CDC statistic and you can see that it’s getting worse. And again, if we start looking at where ticks and other infections are found, I’m sorry, no, this one’s on ticks. And you can see that the spread of ticks is starting to get worse and worse. They’re finding that the migration of birds has changed with climate change, and birds basically become the carrier of the tick hops on the birds.

Bird flies from Vermont to North Dakota, lands, and now there’s a new tick population in North Dakota. Uh, there’s been at least almost a 48 percent increase since 1996 of Lyme.  59 percent of U.S. counties have established populations, almost half of the country has established populations of these ticks.  And again, we’re seeing a merging of these regions where there used to be gaps, they’re now getting closer and closer together. So again, people who live in Texas and Colorado places, they say, well, there’s really not a lot of Lyme. Again, it’s been reported in all 50 states. In addition to that, we’re seeing all these other illnesses, Lyme disease, Rocky Mountain spotted fever, Anaplasmosis, Ehrlichiosis, Babesiosis Tularemia, Bartonella, again, all these are getting worse and worse.

Now this is just a map of Europe just to show again that they’re, pretty much almost all of Western Europe is endemic for Lyme disease, so, uh, they get it there too. If you’ve never seen a picture of a blacklegged tick, this is it. This is, there’s Ixodes scapularis, which is primarily on the east coast.  There’s Ixodes pacificus. I can’t tell the difference between the two, they look the same to me, but apparently there is a difference. These are the different species of the ticks, and these ticks are tiny. So a fully engorged tick is a large poppy seed. A non engorged tick is a very [00:12:00] small poppy seed.  So a lot of people, even if they had a tick on them, they would very easily think it was a fleck of dirt, uh, something else. And, uh, I can remember, after I had Lyme disease, I remember standing on my porch in Connecticut, and I saw a little fleck of dirt on my arm, and I went to flick it, and it started moving.  Dirt doesn’t move. Uh, and I realized, oh shoot, it’s another deer tick. I was already on treatment, so I’m kind of like, ha ha, screw you, you’re already dead. Uh, yeah, these things are very hard to find, and they like the warm, moist areas of your body. They like the back of your knees, armpit, behind your ears, hairline.  So again, a lot of people who get bit, even if they had a bullseye rash, they might not even see it. Because it does go to those areas we don’t usually check for. It is the number one spreading vector borne epidemic in the world. It can affect any organ, any tissue, and as a result of that, we see a very large variety of symptoms.

There’s over a hundred different symptoms of Lyme disease. Borrelia is also a true shape shifter. It has the ability to change its shape and it is one of the, as far as I know, I think it is the slowest replicating bacteria out there. So if you consider most bacteria in your body replicate every 10 to 20 minutes, Lyme replicates every 1 to 16 days.  And if you get tuberculosis, Mycobacterium tuberculosis, your doctor will put you on 3 hardcore antibiotics for 9 to 12 months. Why? TB is a very slow growing organism. It replicates every 15 to 20 hours. So why are we willing to give people hardcore antibiotics for a year for TB and we’re willing to give people two weeks of doxycycline for Lyme disease?  It makes zero biological sense. But this is, this is what they do. Uh, the nature that Borrelia can change its shape also makes it a true evader of the immune system. So the immune system’s effort to get rid of the bug, and I’ll show you a picture in a second how that looks, but this ability to get into different tissues, change its shape, it really is able to hide the immune system, which just makes it more difficult to kill.

So if you look at the picture here, you can see over there on the left, you know, that’s a spirochete. It’s a [00:14:00] sort of corkscrew shaped organism. Of course, this is a 2D image. We’re not appreciating it. It does look like a corkscrew. And that’s in its uncoiled, normal form. That’s the best time our immune system has to recognize it and kill it.

You can see in B there, some of them are starting to ball up. It goes in what they call a round body form or cyst form. That little gunky stuff around it is basically biofilm. It’s protecting the organism. And when it goes into that form, our immune system and most antibiotics will not kill it in that form.

Uh, they’ve done lots of studies on doxycycline, rifampin. They do not work when it goes into that round body form. Or what they call stationary bugs. And then you can see, uh, there’s like a couple of organisms, they’re all bound up in that biofilm together. Very hard to kill, and, uh, very hard for the immune system to recognize.

They’ve done studies with other organisms that when biofilm is present, you have to give 250 times the amount of antibiotic to kill the bug when biofilm is not present. So, part of our treatment we’ll talk about is breaking down the biofilm to expose the [00:15:00] organism to whatever treatment we’re instituting.

So I kind of break Lyme down into acute and chronic Lyme. In reality, it’s a gradation, it’s a continuation. But most people with acute Lyme disease are sick. They are acutely sick. I’ve treated over 8,000 Lyme patients at this point. Maybe I’ve treated 40 acute Lyme patients. You know, more often if people have these symptoms, they probably go to the ER, they go to their primary doctor.  I’m not either one of those, so more than likely they’re going somewhere else to get that initial help. But, headaches, stiff neck, high fever. When I had Lyme, I had 105 fever. It looks a lot like meningitis, and you can’t get any type of Lyme meningitis. Arthritis, swollen joints, back pain, spine pain, muscle aches.

That erythema migrans, that classic bullseye rash. I’ll show you a picture in a minute. That’s sort of the telltale path, mnemonic sign of Lyme disease. Uh, the CDC says 60-80% of people with Lyme get the erythema migrans rash. The research suggests it’s about 40%. Those of us in clinical practice will argue it’s less than probably 20%.  So if you’ve got the rash, you know, do not pass go. Do not collect $200. You know you have Lyme, but the absence of the rash doesn’t mean anything about whether you’ve been exposed to Lyme or not. Fatigue, Chills, Lymphadenopathy, Heart palpitations, there is a rare form of Lyme Carditis, which will cause an AV heart block.  You’ll see that on EKG. Shortness of Breath, Memory Loss, Brain Fog, and Bell’s Palsy, One Sided Facial Paralysis are all very common acute Lyme disease. This is kind of what the bullseye rash looks like, the target logo.  There are a lot of variations of this rash. I’ve seen patients that don’t have that necessarily, the red with the central clearing and then the red again.  When you see a flat, red, spreading rash, be suspicious. This gets confused with histamine reactions all the time from someone that got bit by a mosquito. Histamine reactions usually go away in 24 to 48 hours. These rashes will usually last days to weeks. Mine lasted almost eight weeks before it went away.  Mine started off about the size of, I’ll say, a baseball, and by the time it was done, it was almost 18 inches. It covered the entire back of my leg. And that’s very common for a Lyme rash. But it also doesn’t tend to itch. Most mosquito bites, horse flies, other bite instances, because of the histamine reaction, tend to get very itchy and raised.

This is flat and generally not itchy, at least not for several days, until after the bite. Acute symptoms can happen within 3 30 days following a tick bite. As I mentioned, CDC says a bunch of people get the rash, most people don’t. So again, the absence of the rash doesn’t really mean very much. And because Lyme causes so many different symptoms.

Misdiagnosis is really common. People go to their PCP, they go to the ER, they get all these standard tests. Frustratingly, most standard blood tests look normal in Lyme patients. You know, their white count is elevated, their CRP is normal, they’re not showing all the typical things of like autoimmune disease.

And so often though, they get all these blood tests, they might get a CT scan or an MRI, [00:18:00] everything looks normal. They get sent out the door with, you know, it takes Vibuprofen and good luck. But that’s a very, very common scenario. And chronic Lyme disease, we’ll see a lot of the same kind of symptoms, more debilitating fatigue, we might start getting abdominal change, bowel changes, more memory loss, cognitive impairment, more neuropathy, numbness, tingling, different kinds of sensory distortions, burning sensation in the skin, a type of neuropathy is very common with Lyme and Martinella.

A blundering joint pain, we call migratory joint pain, that’s another classic sign of Lyme. There’s a lot of things that cause joint pain, there are very few things that cause migratory joint pain. One day it’s my right shoulder, then it’s my left knee, then it’s my right ankle, then it’s my right wrist.

That is very classic for Lyme. You know, my big red flags, when you hear about arthritic symptoms and neurologic symptoms, think about Lyme, because again, there’s very few things that cause Lyme. Light and Sound Sensitivity, Dizziness, Vertigo, Sleep Disturbances, Rheumatism, I mentioned Heart Block, Coordination Problems, People all of a sudden will complain they’re clumsy, I’m dropping things, [00:19:00] I’m tripping, I call it Newly Acquired Dyslexia, it happened to me.  People start transposing letters and numbers, whether they’re writing it or typing it, I think it’s just part of the neurologic disruption that happens, and then you can start to see secondary endocrine disruption. Hypothyroidism following live is very common, but when we start having reproductive hormone issues, adrenal issues, all that could be affected after.

Lyme in children, uh, if you treat children in your practice, what’s a little bit different, again, these kids can be acutely sick. Uh, it looks sometimes like strep throat, a complaint of a sore throat, swelling glands, fever, uh, fatigue. You might see gait alterations. But mood changes, you know, it looks like PANS, Pediatric Acute Onset Neuropsychiatric Syndrome, where all of a sudden it’s anxiety, OCD, tics, Lyme is a major, major trigger for PANS.  We used to call it PANDAS because we said it was associated with strep. Strep can be a cause of it too, but in our practice, I would say Lyme is probably a bigger culprit than strep. So if you get these kids that all of a [00:20:00] sudden overnight turn into little demon seeds, I would be very suspicious of something like that.

The great imitator, the great imitator, Lyme looks like a lot of different things, any chronic neurologic illness can potentially be due to Lyme. You know, I think it’s kind of interesting, you know, you talk to a neurologist, talk to a rheumatologist, but any disease, MS, lupus, rheumatoid arthritis, they say, okay, well, here’s your label grade.  Why? I don’t know, you know, bad luck, bad genes. Well, is it possible that there’s an infectious cause that’s triggering this autoimmune inflammatory condition? And more often than not, they’ll say no, but when you go into the research, all you have to do if you’re really interested, go into PubMed, and type in any condition, and in capital letters and, this is what they call Boolean search, Molecular Mimicry.

Molecular Mimicry is the immune mechanism by which most organisms trigger this autoimmune response, and it’s amazing. Go type in Aromatoid Arthritis and Molecular Mimicry. Klebsiella, Proteus, all these different viruses have all been [00:21:00] associated as causes of rheumatoid arthritis. So, are we just going to give immune suppressive drugs, or are we just going to treat the underlying cause?

And you’ll be amazed at how much information is out there, on, you know, post infectious and post adventure. Uh, autoimmune issues. You know, for better or for worse, I think COVID kind of brought this to light. You know, all these people have long COVID, so you can get a virus and have all this sequelae afterwards, long after the viral infection is cleared.

Well, duh, I mean, you know, we’ve known this forever and ever. It’s just different organisms causing a different set of problems, but Lyme is a, I mean, we’ve been dealing with this for years with Lyme. There’s a lot of co infections. We know from the research, there’s Certainly the ticks up in New England, like 33 percent of the ticks that carry Lyme, also carry something else.

So if you suspect Lyme when we’re testing, we’re almost never testing just for Borrelia, we’re testing for other organisms that might have been transmitted during that tick bite. So Babesia, Bartonella, Hannaplasma, Ehrlichia, Mycoplasma. That’s why every time I go to another Lyme conference, we’ve learned there’s now 10 [00:22:00] other things that ticks carry that we need to test for.

But understand what’s in your area. I mean, here in California, I mean, we test for, I mean, it also depends on the symptoms too, but I routinely test for Lyme, Bartonella, Babesia, Mycoplasma, Anaplasma. Rickettsia, I hardly ever see, unless I have a patient that has symptoms that make me think Rickettsia. But the other ones, a lot of these viruses are pretty rare, uh, Powassan virus, I don’t know that we’ve even seen in California, Tularemia, Harlan virus, these kind of things are pretty unusual.

So, from my standpoint, there’s the first tier testing, and then as we get stuck, maybe the second tier would be some of these more obscure pathogens. So the diagnosis of Lyme disease, again, the CDC criteria was for surveillance purpose, it was never designed to be diagnostic, at the end of the day, Lyme is a clinical diagnosis, It’s based on your sign and symptoms.

This is even according to the CDC. Incredibly, infectious disease doctors don’t even follow the CDC guidelines. You know, if your test is negative by CDC, they say, well, you don’t have Lyme [00:23:00] disease, they will fight you tooth and nail on this. But that’s not even the CDC guidelines. Go figure. As again, I mentioned with all these different strains, we’re testing for one.

Maybe we’re just testing for the wrong stuff. So this is straight from the CDC’s website. Lyme is diagnosed based on signs and symptoms and a history of possible exposure to infected blacklegged tists. Laboratory tests are helpful if used correctly and performed with validated methods, blah, blah, blah.

But basically, it’s a clinical diagnosis. As I’ve mentioned, you know, this test was never designed to be diagnostic, it was designed to monitor people with no Lyme disease. So if you have somebody who has these symptoms and their tests come back negative, that doesn’t mean they don’t have Lyme. But, depending on what lab you use, and I’ll talk about that in a second, some labs do better testing than others, and, uh, again, I was a microbiologist before I was a doctor, I used to do Lyme testing for a living, so I know what I’m looking at.

If we even see Lyme specific antibodies, even though it doesn’t meet the CDC criteria, and you have clinical symptoms, just document that. It’s like, hey, we did this test, they’ve got Lyme specific [00:24:00] antibodies, their clinical symptoms fit Lyme, and, you know, they probably ruled out other things. So, at least it gives you justification of why you’re implementing some element of treatment.

So this is the CDC criteria. They do a Lyme screen. If that test comes back positive, it flexes over to what they call a Western blot. It’s a more specific antibody test for IgG and IgM antibodies against different parts of the Lyme organism. And so these, these antibodies are called BANs. They separate it out through electrophoresis, so they’re separating out the antibodies by weight.  And each weight antibody represents a different antigen on the Borrelia surface. Now again, we know some of these are specific. Some of them are not.  The CDC criteria says you have to have 2 out of 3 IgM or 5 out of 10 IgG to cause either one positive. Well, if you’ve got one Lyme specific IgM band, and you have clinical symptoms, why is it that relevant? I mean, it’s like being a little pregnant, right? I mean, you [00:25:00] are, you are. So if you’ve got Lyme specific antibodies, I think that’s relevant.

And for me, that’s important. In 40 years, this criteria has never changed. Uh, you know, we’ve learned about which antibodies are specific to Lyme, which ones are not. Why we’ve never even changed the criteria really just to focus on the Lyme specific antibodies, I don’t know. There’s a whole political thing behind this that I can’t even begin to speculate.

But, uh, nonetheless, this is where the criteria is and it hasn’t changed in 40 years. So yeah, just looking at these bands, so IgM, so 23, 39, these are Lyme specific antibodies. 41 is a very non specific antibody, it’s a flagellar protein. A lot of bacteria have the little tails, flagella, that’s how they swim through the body.

So flagellar protein antibodies by itself aren’t specific to Lyme. Uh, but yeah, 23, basically everything under 41 or less. 31 does cross react with Epstein Barr virus, so that’s a semi specific antibody, 23, 34, 39 and 93. All those antibodies [00:26:00] are very specific to Lyme. The other ones are not specific. So when something comes back to Western blot, it’s 45 and 58 and 66.

Without the Lyme specific antibodies, maybe it’s Lyme and maybe there’s something else going on, so we don’t have as much teeth behind our justification, but again, at the end of the day, we treat people, we don’t treat pieces of paper. This is the alternative criteria that was developed by ILADS. This is the International Lyme and Associated Disease Society, basically a group of doctors that kind of said, you know, the CDC is kind of off on this, and so again, if there’s even one positive band that’s Lyme specific, that’s relevant, and so again, it’s just a different interpretation of the same data.

So, really the pitfalls of testing is that a lot of people are seronegative, they don’t make antibodies. The further you get from year to year, the less likely you are to pick it up on a test. We know that immunity wanes with time, so, again, if you’re testing someone six months, six years, ten years, twenty years after their exposure, the likelihood of picking it up on an antibody test goes way [00:27:00] down.

Uh, again, because the, for a band to be considered positive, they are comparing you to a control, and you have to meet a certain percentage of the control. So they are measuring quantity of antibodies. So the CDC assumes if you have one, you have a very robust antibody response. There are a gazillion reasons people don’t have a robust antibody response.

And the lab that I use, they change it a little bit, but they used to give us a percentage. The cutoff was 60%. You had to be 60 percent of the control. Well, I get the test back, it was 59%. I’m like, that’s how much water you had to drink that day. That’s the difference between you do or don’t have Lyme? I mean, this is kind of the silliness of it.

So they only have one threshold where most tests kind of have a low, medium, high control. With this, it’s just a high control and that’s, so again, a lot of people unfortunately get missed even doing these kind of tests. Um, again, these labs aren’t testing for the breadth of antibodies, all the different strains of Borrelia, so it’s easy to miss.

And again, it can even take up to six weeks to make antibodies. So if you test someone right after their exposure, you might be too early in the window, or they haven’t made [00:28:00] antibodies yet. And you do the test and go, well, your test is negative. I’m like, well, you know, test them again in another three or four weeks and see if they’ve made antibodies then.

So I mentioned iLabs again, they came up with different criteria. At the end of the day, most iLabs doctors do the same thing I do. You know, they treat based on symptoms. And again, if there’s any evidence of Lyme specific antibodies, that’s relevant. Uh, again, it’s important to rule out other possibilities because Lyme does look like a lot of things.

So it’s good to run other tests, make sure they don’t have some other autoimmune disease or other explanation. And I also think sort of legally having that justification. You know, California, I’ll say, is a semi decent state. There are other states where they are very aggressive in going after practitioners for treating Lyme if the patient doesn’t meet the CDC criteria.

I’m sorry. So the labs that I use, uh, Igenex, they’re based out of Palo Alto, they do great testing. My only complaint about Igenex is that unless you have Medicare, they don’t take insurance and they’re expensive. So it’s not uncommon if you do a [00:29:00] full tick borne panel, 1, 500 to 3, 000 out of pocket. That’s a lot of money for people.

Uh, but their testing is great and reliable. Uh, we use a lab mostly called MDL, Medical Diagnostic Labs in New Jersey. They do very comprehensive testing. There are some tests that Igenex do, that MDL doesn’t do, but they build insurance. And for people who don’t have insurance, their cash pricing, if I run all the Lyme testing, Bartonella, Babesia, Mycoplasma, Anaplasma, their cash price is like 250 bucks, where Igenex is like 2, 500.

So, it’s a big savings, but again, they’ll bill those people’s insurance. So, they’re kind of our go to for testing, and they’re the only lab to actually send you a copy of the Western blot, the actuals, they take a, like a picture of the strip, so you can look at those percentages, you can see the different antibodies, and make a decision for yourself, you know, what you think Uh, Dr.

Richard Horowitz, he came up with this MS IDS questionnaire. He actually validated this research. It’s a free download. Uh, I recommend if [00:30:00] you’re treating Lyme, you know, have your patients fill this out periodically. It’s a good objective assessment on how they’re doing because it’s based purely on symptoms.

And there’s a score, and he actually did a study that found that if you score in the range that he says, there’s a high probability you have Lyme, even if your tests are negative. And the fact that he actually studied this is pretty cool. It’s a free download. Anybody can download it and fill it out for you.

Uh, I came up with my own little questionnaire. Dr. Hurwicz’s is a longer three page. This is my little one page cheat sheet. Same concept and uh, it’s in my book. Uh, I apologize. I had all these books sitting there. I was going to bring them and I completely forgot. So if anybody would like a copy of my book, uh, just grab me afterwards and I’m happy to send it to you.

So other labs to run. Again, it’s good to look at all the co infections. Look at endocrine function, thyroid, adrenal, run the CBC, iron panel, you know, sometimes you will see little changes metabolically after someone has Lyme. So just to be thorough, I like to look at immune markers, inflammatory markers, often [00:31:00] we’re looking at nutritional markers, and a lot of my patients have a lot of GI issues, so running a stool test in our practice is pretty common.

So conventional treatment, uh, if there is a known deer tick bite, this is the CDC recommendation. If it’s a known tick bite, they say give a single dose of 200mg of doxycycline for adults or children over 8. There’s actually zero recommendations if the child’s under 8, good luck. So uh, there’s no recommendations for other confections and this, the studies out there have never shown that this adequately treats Lyme disease.

What it does do is it suppresses the Lyme rash. And that sucks because that’s our marker that someone’s been exposed to Lyme. So not only does it not treat Lyme, now you potentially suppress the rash that would tell us you had Lyme, and it’s a completely worthless, ineffective approach. So for those who test positive for Lyme, it’s typically for adults, you know, doxycycline or [00:32:00] amoxicillin.

If people have neural Lyme, they’ll do IV rocephin, ceftrioxime. They’ve changed the guidelines recently. I think the latest recommendations from the IDSA, the Infectious Disease Society, I think they’ve shortened it from 21 to 14 days of treatment. They’re getting even shorter. For children, same thing, amoxicillin, doxy if they’re over eight, cefiroxime, and it’s just weight based dosing.

But again, it’s, you know, anywhere from 10 to 21 days, which we think is far inadequate. If the organism replicates every 16 days, And think about doxycycline. Doxycycline is not a bacteriostatic antibiotic. It’s not bactericidal. It actually doesn’t kill the bug. All it does is it stops the bug from replicating.

So you may have stopped the bug from replicating for one cycle. That’s it. Why would we expect this to be effective? You know, at least amoxicillin and bactericidal might actually kill the bug. So, a lot of the ILIS doctors who prefer the antibiotic approach, using two or three antibiotics in combination is kind of the norm now, [00:33:00] because you’re trying to stop it from replicating, you’re trying to break down the cell wall, and you’re often trying to get it from multiple approaches.

But, as you can imagine, the more antibiotics you add to the load, the greater the risk of side effects. So, the good news with antibiotics, I mean, some people do really well on it. They get better, and sometimes that’s the end of that. If you do get lucky enough to catch them early in their illness, there’s a good chance that, you know, you’ll treat them before they get into the chronic stage.

And, great. Uh, it can be really effective in the early stages of Lyme, and sometimes, you know, for people who have had exposure a while ago, some people do respond quite well to different antibiotic regimens. And of course there are some people where we’re not really sure and doing a therapeutic trial of antimicrobials I think is an accepted way and they do it in medicine all the time just to see if you get a clinical response.

If you improve on antibiotics, then there’s a good chance you’ve got this underlying infection and you’ll hear this in some of your patients where, you know, I was on antibiotics for sinus infection or had bronchitis and my joint pain [00:34:00] got better. You know, they weren’t even thinking about these other things in the background until they got treated for something completely unrelated.

Certainly the Lyme, but that’s kind of a clue that, oh, you got better on antibiotics, your other systemic symptoms got better. Maybe there is some other underlying infection that just never got addressed. The bad, of course, is that some people get really bad die off reaction. We call this a Gerrush Herxheimer reaction, a.

  1. a. Herxheimer reaction, a. k. a. Herxing. And it’s really a combination of the organism, like, literally popping and releasing all the toxic material, plus it’s a combination of the immune system responding. And most people get these flu like symptoms. More tired, more foggy, more achy, just that general blah feeling.

A true die off only lasts for a handful of days, maybe up to 10 days tops. If it’s lasting longer than that, that’s not a die off. That’s them having a problem with whatever treatment they’re getting and they need to shift gears and do something different. Of course, the more combination of antimicrobials you use, nausea, loss of appetite, you know, disrupt the gut [00:35:00] microbiome.

So diarrhea, loose stool, abdominal pain, headaches, all that can happen. Of course. Some people were on antibiotics for weeks, months, even years, and, uh, I’ve seen people, I had one patient, uh, who was seen by a very well known Lyme doctor in the area where I was at the time. She had been hospitalized three times because of her antibiotics.

They made her so sick. And they kept giving her more toxic antibiotics, and I’m like, at what point do you draw a line in the sand and go, maybe this isn’t the right approach? But it is an approach. And of course, the ugly is, again, you can just completely wipe out your gut flora, C. diff infections, yeast infections, secondary infections.

Immune suppression, organ damage. All that can happen is for some people if they’re on antibiotics too. So, let’s dig into my world, natural treatments for Lyme. Um, I think starting with gut and diet is important. You know, the gut’s really the cornerstone of health, right? You know, 80 percent of your immune function stems from the gut.

So if your gut’s not functioning well, it’s very hard for your immune system to function well. And in terms of diet, you know, [00:36:00] there’s a lot of different diets that are promoted for various health reasons. I’ve always been an advocate, really, of an alkaline diet. I didn’t develop this. There’s books written about this going back to the 50s and 60s.

But the concept behind it makes a lot of sense. Now, if you look at cell physiology, your cells function best in an alkaline state. Your skin, your stomach, the bladder area, for women, the vaginal area, they’re very acidic to protect against outside invaders. The rest of your body is more or less alkaline.

Even your blood pH is slightly alkaline. And the argument I get all the time with, uh, alkaline diet is like, No, it doesn’t change blood pH. I’m like, I know it doesn’t change blood pH. That’s not what we’re trying to do. We’re trying to change cell pH. And it does do that. And you can actually check this very easily.

Have your patients just get some pH paper at the pharmacy. It’s very cheap. 30 to 60 minutes after eating, go pee on the strip. We want your urine pH between 7. 2 If you can get in that range, we know metabolically you’re kind of doing what your body wants to do, and we’re giving your cells the opportunity to function the way they should.

So all those enzymes work the way they should, [00:37:00] all the repair mechanisms work the way they should, and it seems pretty straightforward. So the way I’ve kind of divided it is in three categories. Category 1, these are foods you can eat as much as you want. Uh, and by the way, if you guys want these slides, just let me know and I’m happy to send them to you.

Um. So, most of these are vegetables, vegetables as a whole tend to be very alkaline forming, so it’s not about the pH of the food, it’s about how it breaks down the body, so like lemons and limes are very acidic, if I squeeze lemon juice on pH paper, it’s very acidic, when I drink lemon juice, as it breaks down the body, it makes me very alkaline.

So again, forget the pH of the food, it’s about what it does to you metabolically. So all the food, the foods you can eat a bunch of, you’ll see it’s a lot of vegetables, there’s a few fruits, a few nuts and seeds, grains and so forth. Category 2 are foods that are either kind of neutral when you break down, slightly acidic, maybe slightly alkaline.

So it’s not that you can’t have it, but you don’t want it to really be the bulk of your diet. I tell people to try to keep it about 25 percent of their dietary intake. The [00:38:00] best way to think about Category 2 is to take your plate, divide it in quarters. It shouldn’t take up more than a quarter of your plate.

So it’s all animal protein, eggs, fish, meat. It’s a lot of fruit. Again, it’s not that you can’t have it, it’s just not the bulk of your diet. So people are really eating a mostly plant based diet with some lean proteins, uh, eggs, and things of that nature. And then Category 3, these are foods that are just highly acid forming, that’s a lot of junk food, processed food, garbage food, which I’m sure your patients don’t eat anyway, uh, dairy products, coffee, they’re all very acid forming.

But again, people are like, well, I love my coffee, and I’m tired all the time, I need my coffee. I’m like, well, If you have one cup of coffee, and they do make low acid coffee, uh, check your pH. If you’re able to keep the rest of your diet very alkaline, that one cup of coffee may not make a difference, and you know, you’re okay.

So, you know, you can just check yourself and see how you’re doing. Uh, when we started getting into active treatment, I am a big proponent of herbs. Now, I’m an atropathic doctor by training. Herbs, you know, we spent years in [00:39:00] medical school learning about herbs, so, uh, you know, I’ve said I’ve treated over 8, 000 blind patients.

I have probably written 10 prescriptions for antibiotics. Herbs work really, really well. And I think the beauty of herbs, too, is that they are chemically complex. So when you look at the constituents, there are components that target Lyme and the co infection. There are components that are anti inflammatory.

There are components that help support the immune system. There are components that soothe the mucous membrane. So you can really mix and match herbs for your patient to really tailor to what their body needs to get them through their collection of symptoms. So often we’ll find there’s like a few core herbs that we’ll use because they work really well against Lyme and co infection.

Oh, but this is really great for joint pain. And this is really good for the reflux and the GI issues you’re having. So again, I like the ability of being able to have all these different possibilities. And then when I sit down with my patients, I’m like, we need a place to start, but we’ve got plan A, B, C, D, E, F, and G if we need it.

We just need to give whatever we start with an [00:40:00] opportunity to do what we want. So my, my rule for treatment is two months. Whatever you’re doing. Antibiotics, herbs, I don’t care. You get two months. If they’re not better in two months, you’re barking up the wrong tree, and you need to switch and do something different.

I have seen patients be on the same protocol for six months, a year, and they and the practitioner are waiting for the magic to happen. It hasn’t happened. Like if it hasn’t happened in two months, it’s not gonna happen. You need to switch gears and do something. So the beauty of plants is that Relative to antibiotics, I think they’re safer.

Side effects are really uncommon. If they do happen, they tend to be very mild, go away quickly. It’s a much more comprehensive approach because of the broad activity of the herbs. Definitely less negative impact because they’re plants. Plants tend to get absorbed in the first part of the small intestine.

Very little of it actually gets down to the large intestine where most of your bacteria live. So we don’t see the same die off like you do with antibiotics. A lot of these herbs cover Lyme and the common infections, so there is a lot of overlap. Uh, Dr. Lee Cowden, I think Dr. Cowden, [00:41:00] he’s a big name in the Lyme world.

Uh, we were at a lecture he gave a few years ago, and he kept talking about this herb. I go, well, this is, yeah, he’s from Texas. And he goes, this is the key herb. And I go, yeah, I’m hearing this herb, this is the key herb. I’m like, I don’t know what you’re talking about. He goes, well, it kills everything except people.

So, you know, a lot of these herbs, because they’re antibacterial, they’re antiviral, they’re antifungal, Again, if there is overgrowth of other microbes in the body without knowing what it is, there’s a good probability with plants you will cover that base. So I like that perspective. Again, it can be very much tailored to the individual needs, help and support the immune function.

There are very few herbs that truly have immune suppressive activity, uh, maybe more cost effective if people are paying for some of these antibiotics out of pocket, because insurance will put a cap on how much antibiotics somebody gets, um, and when it gets out of pocket, some of these are very expensive.

Herbs by and large tend to be pretty inexpensive. Clinically, they’re very effective. Again, I’ve had great success over the years using herbs, and you’ll have people come in who tried the antibiotic route, just didn’t work. You know, they’ve been on three, four, five, [00:42:00] six, eight, ten different antibiotic regimens, didn’t work, or they got worse, and they’re looking for the next option.

So, uh, there’s a Dr. Zhang out of Johns Hopkins, and he and our colleague, uh, Dr. Jacob Leonian and naturopathic doctors, they’ve been looking at different plant extracts on how they affect Lyme and Bartonella and Babesia, and so this is all published research out of Hopkins. And looking at different herbs that are effective against Borrelia, uh, crypto sangu, polygonum ano, that’s called Japanese knotweed jus nigra.

That’s black walnut Artesia annua, that’s sweet. Warm wood Osa is ka claw sti, and canes is sti and ensis is Chinese. And you’ll see as we look across, so this is for Borrelia, this is against Bartonella, we see a lot of the same players, and same thing with Dobesia, so when I talk about getting this overlap of how these herbs treat these other different infections, you know, we know that we can use these herbs and they’re going to cover a [00:43:00] broad base.

So just kind of going through some of the plants that I use, uh, Allicin, this is garlic, Allium Sativum, this is a very well known antimicrobial, uh, soldiers in Russia in World War I used to carry it on their pack, they called it Russian Penicillin, if they were out in the field and got wounded, they would rub the garlic in their wounds to prevent infection or they would eat it to keep their immune system healthy.

It contains a component called Allitrity, that characteristic odor of garlic is Allitrity getting converted to Allicin. Uh, again, very well established antimicrobial, but also helps improve blood flow, and it has mild anti inflammatory. Uh, it’s best as a time release capsule, so it releases that allicin over time.

Uh, people will definitely excrete this through their skin, so for one, drink it in garlic, two, be prepared that you’re gonna smell like a pizzeria. Uh, when I first had lime, uh, I was treated by a different Dr. Zhong in New York City, and he gave me a lot of his allicin, which is a great product. And I was still seeing patients.

Like, you know, people would walk in my room and they’re like, you know, like, what does that smell? So I had to [00:44:00] stop doing it because it was just becoming offensive to me and everyone around me. So, forewarned people, uh, it’s gonna get excreted through their breath and their skin. People can take chlorophyll to help offset some of the odor.

If they want to stay on garlic and they’re worried about the odor, chlorophyll will help bind up. Andrographis, Andrographis paniculata. This is a great herb. It has very broad antimicrobial activity, including parasites. This is also a very effective antiviral herb. Uh, Andrographis actually was approved in Thailand as a treatment for COVID 19.

Uh, it works great for a lot of different viral illnesses, but it’s also a hepatoprotective, an immune modulator, antidiarrheal, anti inflammatory, helps improve cardiac output. And, uh, they typically sell it as a standardized extract. Uh, the one we use has a 50 percent andrograph lye content. Uh, I, I like this plant a lot and, uh, we use that quite often.

Uh, Artemisia, Artemisia annua, there are different species of Artemisia. So, if you’re looking at using Artemisia, make sure you got the right one. There’s Artemisia annua, which is what we want to use. [00:45:00] There’s Artemisia vulgaris, there’s Artemisia absinthium. They have different purposes, they have different constituents.

So, The artemisinin we’re using contains a compound called artemisinin. There are some supplement companies that will sell pure artemisinin. Be careful with pure artemisinin. There’s at least 14 cases of it causing idiosyncratic liver toxicity. Uh, I believe these are people that already have, uh, underlying liver disease that made it worse.

But nonetheless, if you use pure artemisinin, you do need to test your patient’s liver enzymes periodically. probably every few months just to make sure it’s not causing a problem. I’ve never seen it with whole plant Artemisia, so that’s my preference is to use whole plant Artemisia. Uh, it’s got a sesquiterpene lactone with a peroxide bridge.

Basically think it’s the peroxide bridge that’s causing oxidative stress in the organism and that’s what’s killing it. Artemisia has been used forever as a treatment for malaria, so anything that treats malaria is probably going to treat Babesia, since they’re both blood parasites and kind of cousins of each other.

Um, it helps with autoimmune [00:46:00] reactions, has anti inflammatory effects. There are studies on artemisia for rheumatoid arthritis and other autoimmune diseases as an immune modulator. And, um, again, just make sure that, uh, artemisia, then, uh, check liver enzyme. But I would just recommend, there’s a lot of great companies that make whole plant artemisia.

Uh, Campciandra goes by the trade name of Bandarol. Uh, Nutramedic is the company that makes this particular one. This herb is somewhat unique to the Amazon jungle. It comes out of Peru. Nutramedics, uh, because they have a relationship with the Peruvian government, it’s one of the few companies that’s allowed to export it.

Uh, but it’s a very effective plant against Lyme and other co infections. They use it locally to treat malaria. Also, again, very potent anti inflammatory, treats arthritis. You can get some decent herds reactions with it, but it’s, it’s not too bad. Uh, Cemento, Cat’s Claw, Mouncaria Tomatosa, uh, has, uh, what they call alkaloids.

These are the active ingredients that help fight the infection. Also anti viral, it inhibits a lot of these pro inflammatory [00:47:00] cytokines, protects against oxidative stress, also useful treating co infections, and almost little to no side effects. There’s a woman out of the University of New Haven, Dr. Eva Shapi, SAPI, and she studied the combination of Cemento, Vanderol, and one I’ve talked about called Kumanda, and the combination of those three were more effective than doxycycline or rifampin in vitro, and it treated Lyme, whether it was replicating or not.

So there’s an argument that herbs actually may be more effective than antibiotics in some cases. These cases, uh, kafu is a nerve that’s used mostly in traditional Chinese medicine. Kafi, ensis. This is the root. It’s very rich in a compound called Burberry. You might know Burberry because it’s found in Golden Seal.

It’s found in Barberry, it’s found in, um, um, forgetting the third nerve. There’s, there’s three of ’em that are, are very rich in Burberry, but Copti is one of em. So, you know, burberine is a very well known antimicrobial, um, compound that again treats bacteria, viruses, fungi, parasites. Um. In vitro studies, [00:48:00] it’s found it’s as effective as a lot of antibiotics and ricketting for eradicating other infections, like staph infections and strep infections and so forth.

So I’ll use Coptis even for people who get bronchitis and sinus infections and things of that nature. Also very potent in anti inflammatory, and Coptis has this unusual effect that’s really effective at getting gallbladder sludge out. So if you’re someone who’s got gallbladder sludge and they don’t want to have their gallbladder taken out, it’s got like an 88 percent efficacy in getting gallbladder sludge out.

Go figure. Cordyceps is a medicinal mushroom that has been used in traditional Chinese medicine for 2, 000 years. Very potent immune booster, so a lot of these medicinal mushrooms, they don’t kill the organism, they just help support the immune system to fight the infection. They contain beta glucans. Beta glucans, you’ll find in a lot of supplements now, has an immune stimulating.

Particularly, they help increase T helper cells, activate NK cells, and macrophages. They also help improve circulation, and they’re great for fatigue and inflammation. They do have mild blood sugar lowering effects, so if you’re going to use Cordyceps, if you’ve got a diabetic, [00:49:00] particularly if they’re on insulin, just be careful.

Make sure they monitor their blood sugar a little bit more. Decimodium or Berber, this is a plant that also grows down in Peru in the Amazon jungle. This is really just to help support detox pathways. We can get a lot of people out of their HERX reaction if they start taking more Berber and then companies like Nutramix, they also make one that’s a combination of Berber and Pinela.

Uh, the two of those together work really well at just clearing out the toxins faster. So, we don’t want people to stop their treatment. If they start Hurtsing, sometimes they feel so bad, they just say, you know what, I, this treatment is making me feel worse, I’m going to stop. And then you never get past that point of feeling better.

So if we can get people through their treatment, get through those handful of days of Hurtsing, then usually when they come out the back end, they feel a lot better. And this is a plan you can use as a rescue medicine to get people through that time. So they can take this every 10, 15 minutes. 30 minutes until they feel like that hertz reaction goes away.

Uh, Hetunia, Hetunia cordata, uh, this is another plant that’s used a lot in Chinese medicine. It has a [00:50:00] historical use of treating it for leptospira. Leptospira like, uh, Lyme. Uh, syphilis is the other spirochete that we all know about. We don’t see a lot of leptospira here in the U. S., but it’s pretty common in China.

Uh, leptospira we see here mostly with dogs in the U. S. They can be a cause of meningitis for dogs. But nonetheless, anything that treats, uh, spirochete probably works for Lyme as well. And in vitro studies found it’s antibacterial, antifungal, enhances the immune system, gets rid of swelling and inflammation, and it’s also one of the plants that helps break down biofilms.

So again, if we’re trying to expose the organism, breaking down biofilms is a good thing. Uh, it does have a relatively short half life, so this is one you probably need to dose three times a day just to keep enough of the herb in your system. Japanese Knotweed, Polygonum Cuspidatum, again very broad spetum and microbial, and again we found in Dr.

Zhang’s research that this is one of the top herbs to deal with Lyme and a lot of the co infections. Lion’s Mane is another great medicinal mushroom, again it doesn’t kill [00:51:00] anything, but it helps stimulate oligodendrocytes, helps make myelin based protein. I think a lot of Lyme patients that are dealing with these cognitive issues, neuropathy issues, To a certain degree, there probably is some impairment of myelin function, and that’s why they have this.

So, anything you do to help repair a damaged neuron is a good thing. Otava, this is commando. This comes from a bark of a tree, again, that grows in South America. Probably one of the best broad spectrum, uh, herbs against Lyme and co infections. Also very potent anti inflammatory, and again, this is one of the three I mentioned with Dr.

Schappe. It was found to eliminate all the different forms of Lyme. Uh, Porreria, this is a nerve that gets used mostly in Chinese medicine, but treats high fever, muscle spasms, headaches. So, this is a good adjunct for your pad if people are having a lot of the acute symptoms of Lyme disease. Helps improve blood flow.

Uh, also anti inflammatory. It can cause blood pressure to drop a little bit, so if anyone has POTS, they’re already prone to low blood pressure, just be a little bit careful. [00:52:00] Wireweed, this is called Ceta Acuta, broad spectrum antimicrobial activity, reduces fever, protects the liver, immune modulator. I don’t use this one as much, uh, Stephen Buehner, who’s an herbalist, he wrote two books on, one on Lyme, one treating on co infection, he used a lot of Ceta Acuta, uh, I like to mention it, but, uh, I don’t use this one as much, uh, it blends well with my practice.

Uh, Yellow Dairu, Cryptolepis, I use a lot of this, Cryptolepis Sanguinale, I like to mention it. This is the one, again, that Dr. John also found with Japanese not wanting to be at the top of treating Lyme and all the co infections, and you’re probably getting the idea here that they’re anti microbial, anti inflammatory, and reduce fever.

They all have very similar mechanisms. So again, this gives us the ability to swap out. If you start someone on Cemento and Banderol, they don’t seem to be doing well with one. This is where I actually like using the individual herbs versus combinations, because if someone has a problem with one, very easy to switch out, where if you give them a combination, they have a problem.

I don’t know what herb is the culprit. And it’s hard to figure out. Uh, other herbs just to [00:53:00] mention, uh, there’s one called Oncaria Orynchophylla, which is a cushion of Cat’s Claw. Uh, Stephen Buehner really liked it for Neuroborreliosis. Chinese Skullcap, very well studied. Astragalus, Hawthornberry, Alcornia.

Uh, again, I don’t use these as much. I’ve been using more and more Chinese Skullcap since Dr. John published his research. Uh, and also very good anti inflammatory. I’m going to skip through some of this just because, you know. So, Dr. Cowden has a whole protocol where every month there’s a whole protocol that, you know, they change all the herbs.

The idea is to kind of never let the organism get used to what you’re doing. He used to be very involved. The company has recently revamped it. It’s a much simpler protocol now. I do what’s called a modified version of Cowden. And I really just narrow it down to like three or four herbs. I use the Cemento, I use the Vanderol, I use the Camonda, I use the Berber Pinella as a base.

And then I’ll add in these other herbs really just as adjunct therapies. Uh, so these [00:54:00] combinations again help target the microbes, support detox pathways, clear heavy metals. It’s a nine month protocol where every month it changes. Uh, I know Dr. Tran uses it a lot more than I do. Again, it still works for people, but the old version was just more, took more compliance, because every like two hours you had something to do.

The new version is much more simple for people. So again, I do a modified version of it, and here’s kind of the doses. Uh, for acute Lyme disease, it’s better to go in with higher doses. You know, at 15 to 30 drops twice a day, you put all the tinctures together in a little bit of water. So it’s nice for people who already take a lot of capsules.

These are liquids. They can just put it in water in one glass, pour it up and drink it, a dose in the morning, a dose in the evening, it’s pretty simple for people. And again, we can add in Berber, Penelope, if they’re getting heart sick, and they can all add in others really as supportive for whatever they’re experiencing.

For chronic, uh, I found if you try the same approach, a lot of people will get pretty significant hurt. So I like to start really with just one or two drops twice a [00:55:00] day, and then every two days titrate up slowly by one drop. So if they start with one drop twice a day, two days later they don’t feel any different, they go to two drops twice a day.

Two days later they don’t feel any different, they go to three drops. And what you’ll find is some people, even at very low doses, get clinical benefit. I have some people do one drop of Simvastatin and they start Hurksin. So I find a lot of people with Lyme tend to be very sensitive and a little goes a long way.

So don’t feel like you have to go in with high doses. Low doses often will really be clinically effective for people. And for children, again, we just drop the dose down based on body temperature. So the advantage is it’s pretty easy to administer their liquids. The herbs actually don’t taste bad at all.

Nothing’s uberly bitter and nasty tasting like some herbs are. Uh, clinically very effective, reasonably very cost effective. You know, if people are only using two or three drops twice a day, that tincture might last them six, eight weeks or longer. So it, it ends up being very cost effective. The disadvantage is, is that you can’t get irksing, but you can get that with any Lyme treatment.

I’d say all, most Lyme treatment does tend to be [00:56:00] long term. I tell my patients 6 18 months of treatment is normal. Because of the slow growing nature of Lyme, and the up and down cycles of it, that’s pretty normal. Sometimes people recover faster, sometimes it’s longer, but 6 18 months is very reasonable.

Dr. Zhang, different Dr. Zhang from the Dr. Zhang at Johns Hopkins. Uh, this Dr. Zhang is a Chinese medical doctor in New York City. He’s who I saw after I was on nine months of anaphylaxis getting worse, and he turned me around in a month. And so, he uses a series of verbs. He’s got an Artemisia, Hetunia, and he’s got a couple of combination products.

Again, I won’t go through all of them, but a lot of them I’ve already talked about. Uh, Again, I like his approach because I think it encompasses a very broad scope of what Lyme does to your body. So there’s herbs to target infection, herbs to reduce inflammation, herbs to support the immune system, herbs to break down little crystals and micro clots, and I think it’s very comprehensive.

And again, it turned me around in four weeks. So [00:57:00] some of the formulas, he’s got one called R 5081M, Uh, seven traditional Chinese herbs, including Smilax and Chinese Skullcap. Uh, these are effective in treating leptospira, trypanema. They also help remove detoxification, reduce inflammation. So I like this formula because part of it’s killing the bugs, and part of it’s helping support detox.

He’s got one called Circulation P. This is a combination of two traditional Chinese medicine formulas. There’s 10 herbs in it, and it’s really to help prevent platelet aggregation in the microplots. And you can tell Lyme patients, if you draw blood in your office, you can almost tell when you draw blood, instead of the blood coming out like water, it comes out like oil, you can see the viscosity even when you draw blood, and that’s just a sign of inflammation.

It’s very common with Lyme patients. AIM, this is a nerve called Sardentodoxae. Again, we don’t use this in Western medicine, this is a Chinese herb, uh, but it has, uh, pretty significant anti inflammatory and analgesic effects, so this is a great one in to help control pain in patients. inflammation. So [00:58:00] John’s Protocol, again, combinations of petunia, coptis, cordyceps.

You might add in the AIM if there’s a lot of inflammation or peraria if they have high fever and muscle aches. Artemisia is great for Babesia. Persistent Lyme Disease, same kind of herbs. The dosing actually doesn’t change as much between acute and chronic like it does with the liquids. But again, I just wanted to give you an idea of some other ways of using these herbs.

The advantages is clinically very beneficial. I’ve probably used his herbs more than anyone else’s over the years. Herbs reactions are not common actually. Very few side effects. I find they’re very well tolerated. The biggest downside is that his herbs are expensive and people usually spend 500 to 600 dollars a month on his formulas relative to others which are much less expensive.

Byron White is an herbalist. He’s got different combination formulas that he kind of puts together for individual infections. So there’s not really a protocol with his stuff, like AL [00:59:00] complex is for Lyme, ABAB is for Martinella, and so forth. So here you’re kind of picking the formula based on whatever the patient’s dealing with.

I’ve used them, he has one called A Myco for Mycoplasma, that I’ve used a lot, it works very well for Mycoplasma, and I’ve used ABAB and ABARD, and again, they work, it’s just again, they’re combination products, so if people have a problem with it, you just won’t know. What the problem is. People like these because again, it’s like one tincture or two tinctures.

It’s not multiple tinctures. They are really concentrated herbs. So the amount you use is usually anywhere from like two to six drops twice a day. It’s a lot less than even the other tinctures out there. So for people who don’t like to do a lot of stuff, this might be an option because it doesn’t require a lot of stuff.

Disadvantages, uh, it’s just that herxing is actually quite common because they are so concentrated. Each bottle is about a hundred bucks, so the bottle itself is expensive. Now again, they’re not using a lot of it, so often it still lasts a while, but [01:00:00] when you talk to people like, hey, I want you to buy this little tincture, it’s a hundred bucks.

Uh, I have some formulas I developed myself with allergy research. I have a product called PhytoTik Defense. So, I took a lot of the herbs that I had used when I was being treated by Dr. Chong. Uh, so it’s got Nezunia, Artemisia, Cat’s Claw, Coptis, Cordyceps, Lion’s Mane, and Beta Glucans. I wanted something to get the encompass line and all the other co infections.

I’ve got a product called Biofilm Neutralizer to break down biofilm. I’ve got a product called Herxipher Support to reduce inflammation and to get Herx reactions. And Mitochondrial cofactors to help support the mitochondria. So these four were designed to kind of work together. Uh, the nice thing for patients with this is that they’re pretty easy to take, pretty well tolerated, and all four of the formulas are about a hundred bucks a month.

So it’s fairly reasonable for people. Uh, so here’s just the dosing schedule on those. Uh, the advantages, uh, really is it’s clinically beneficial, easy to administer, it’s pretty inexpensive. I really haven’t come across any major disadvantages. [01:01:00] I mean, I don’t get complaints of people not tolerating it, upset stomach, bad diet offset.

So far, they’ve been out for about a year and a half, and, again, I really haven’t had any major complaints. Other botanical therapies, again, Stephen Buehner has two books if you’re interested. It talks about some of these other herbs. There’s also a company called Beyond Balance. Uh, they make a series of combination herbal formulas.

Susan McCamish founded the company. She’s an herbalist. They make some good products. They’re all in glycerin. So for people who don’t tolerate alcohol and so on liquids, this is a great option because they’re not alcohol based, they’re glycerin based. So it’s great for kids and I don’t see any people anymore, but people are using disulfiram as a treatment for Lyme for a while.

Which, you know, you get disulfiram, you can’t take alcohol. It’s a contraindication, so people can still use Beyond Balance while they’re on disulfiram, but I think disulfiram’s kind of fallen out of favor. I don’t see anybody really on it anymore. Managing HERX reactions. Anything that’s anti inflammatory is probably going to help.

You know, tons and tons of [01:02:00] research on curcumin and boswellia reduces all the pro inflammatory cytokines, help prove vascular endothelial function, reduces oxidative stress. Uh, so, my product has a combination of curcumin and boswellia together, and then if you alkalize the body, this is an old school environmental medicine trick that people are having die off reactions or having allergic reactions.

When you take an alkalizing agent, you start shifting your cell pH, a lot of these reactions get better. So the Herx reaction gets better. I’ve had people stop their asthma attack by taking Alka Seltzer Gold every hour. Uh, kind of the worst thing that happens if you get too much bicarbonate formula is it gives you a little bit of diarrhea.

Um, but often we’ll stop that. So sodium potassium bicarbonate, I think potassium bicarbonate is a more effective agent. So regular Alka Seltzer is sodium bicarbonate, and baking soda in your fridge is sodium bicarbonate. In a pinch people can use good old Arm Hammer baking soda, but it’s kind of gross and um, I don’t think it works nearly well as potassium bicarbonate.

[01:03:00] But the whole idea behind it is that bicarbonate is shifting your cell pH and we know that potassium bicarbonate locks increase your glutathione levels. Breaking down biofilm, this is the slime that surrounds the bug. Uh, there’s a lot of different ways to approach it, but again, that protective slime is, you know, keeping the immune system and the herbs or antibiotics from targeting the organism.

So anything we can do to break it down. Proteolytic enzymes like serrapeptase, like trypsin, natokinase, is very effective, alpha lipoic acid. So again, the product I developed, he biofilm neutralizer, it has all four of these in it, just as a way to break down biofilm. So it’s important with any kind of biofilm disruptor, you take it away from food.

If you take it with food, it’s going to digest your food, and it won’t do much to break down biofilm. Environmental lifestyle factors, of course, anything we can do to lower the body burden. I will argue that most of my chronic Lyme patients are toxic, for various reasons, and anything we can do to [01:04:00] improve their detox pathways, reduce their body burden.

Help. So, it’s just bringing awareness that, you know, get all the crap out of your house. The Windex, the 409, Uh, the Glade plug ins, all that stuff. I mean, my sister and I have this running thing now. She’s better about it. We go visit the Glade plug ins in the bathroom, and I unplug it, and she plugs it back in, I unplug it, she plugs it back in.

I think one time we took it in the trash.

Dr. Weitz: Anyway,

Dr. Ingels: yeah, so anything you do to people can reduce that stuff. So be aware of what you use around your home, what you use on your skin. Personal care products, makeup, shampoo, detergents, laundry stuff, all that roundup, all that adds to your body where it has to load, makes it harder to get well.

And this is stuff people have control of. They can control what they use in and around their body and around their home. Lifestyle maintenance, sleep is critically important. Most of my patients don’t sleep well for various reasons. Uh, this is just some of the things I use with my patients to help them get to sleep, stay asleep.

Uh, melatonin is great for some people, helping them fall asleep. GABA, PharmaGABA is better at staying asleep, getting deeper sleep. Magnesium, particularly Mag threonate has evidence that it penetrates the brain better than other Mag chelates. Get them into a deeper state of sleep. 5 HTP, 5 Hydroxytryptophan is a precursor to serotonin.  You could use straight L tryptophan as well. Um, 100 to 400 milligrams of bedtime. Uh, just be careful if someone’s already on an SSRI, you don’t want to get serotonin syndrome. And there’s a lot of herbs. I mean, Passionflower, we use a lot of. Ashwagandha, Valerian Root, Lemon Balm. I’m becoming a bigger fan of California Poppy.  California Poppy works really well. You just have to warn people, if they ever get drug tested, you know, we’ll test positive on a drug test. I had a patient in New York City that, uh, he didn’t have one. I can’t remember. He called me one day, and he was a big financier. And he was just pissed at me, yelling at me, he goes, I don’t know what you gave me, I flunked my drug test, da, da, da, da, da, it’s something in your supplements.

And he calls me back two days later, very apologetic, he goes, every morning I have a poppy bagel, poppy seed bagel. [01:06:00] The poppy seed bagel was causing a drug test to go positive, so anything that comes from the poppy plant will test positive for heroin on the drug test. So, you just have to warn people if they have a job where they get drug tested, but it doesn’t cause any of the effects that heroin does, it’s just a cross reaction.

But yeah, California poppy can be very effective too. Getting exercise, movement, you know, I think it’s good for obviously moving blood flow, moving lymph, especially the lymph. It’s good for enhancing mood. So trying to get some element of movement every day. And it’s hard. I mean, for when I had Lyme, I mean, it was all my strength just to sit in front of the television.

And so, you know, I would start stretching and then, you know, a couple of laps around the house. So gentle exercise usually works best. If someone does any kind of activity and it wipes them out for three days, it was too much. So they have to scale it back. So it started with, you know, yoga, walking, swimming, tai chi, qigong, you know, whatever they feel like they can do.

But a little bit of movement every day is Stress management, this is always the, I [01:07:00] think, the hardest thing for people. Having any chronic disease sucks. You know, you’re, you’re trying to figure out how to manage your stress. A lot of people we see, they’re, you know, financially in trouble because they’re ill.

Many of them aren’t working as much as they should, or they’re having trouble in the work they do. So there’s a lot of stress on how it affects them, how it affects their loved ones, their family, their kids. There’s a tremendous amount of guilt about having a chronic illness. For So helping people navigate that, whether it’s with a guidance, with a counselor, a therapist, a support group.  But try and help and encourage people to find ways to deal with stress because you’ll hear it from every Lyme patient. Every time they go through a stressful time, their symptoms get worse. Nothing else changes in their treatment, but it’s just the stress that’s kind of undermining everything else. So as much as we can help support them.

Other treatment approaches, I just want to mention, Low Dose Naltrexone. This is a medication that was designed to get people off drug and alcohol abuse. We know at low doses it has a very different effect. It binds to opioid [01:08:00] receptors in the brain for about 4 6 hours, and then it causes a natural release of your own opioids for about 20 hours.  So it can be great for pain modulation, it’s great for modulating the immune system. There’s actually quite a few studies on Low Dose Naltrexone. It’s very safe, it’s very inexpensive, and I find it’s kind of the 50 50. 50 percent of people feel like it helps, 50 percent of people feel like it did absolutely nothing, but to spend 45 bucks for three months to try it, you know, I think it’s pretty reasonable.  And there’s studies on it for cancer, fibromyalgia, multiple sclerosis, inflammatory bowel disease. There are no studies to date on Lyme disease, but most of us in the Lyme world try it anyway, and some people respond really well.  The dosing on it, you can start anywhere from like a quarter of a milligram to one milligram at bedtime. Uh, one of the side effects that some people do get is either disrupted sleep or they get really wild, flunky, vivid dreams. And if that happens, we just say take it during the day, don’t take it at bedtime.  Usually that’s okay. Once in a while I’ll feel like, you know, even during the day my [01:09:00] sleep’s goofed up. Okay, we try it and it’s fine. So, I think it’s worth, you can work up to, you know, three to four and a half milligrams. We go up by one milligram generally every two weeks, and so we get to a target dose.  It can take up to three months to get the full effect of it. So once you get to what you think is a target dose, wait three months before really saying yay or nay, it helped or didn’t help.

PEMF, Pulse Electromagnetic Frequency. The idea is that there’s these devices that create a signal that’s the same frequency as our own human cells.  And the Germans have done a ton of research on PEMF. There’s over 1,500 studies, and basically it helps improve circulation, help with tissue repair, and really offsets a lot of the negative effect of the bad frequency of like 5G and Wi Fi and cell phones and all that kind of stuff. So improved circulation, decreased pain, reduced inflammation, faster recovery after injury and surgery, healing skin wounds.

And Acceleration of Nerve Regeneration. And usually it just involves, you know, [01:10:00] laying on a mat or putting the device close to your body. It runs anywhere from 10 minutes to sometimes an hour. Uh, but it’s very safe and can be very effective. There’s a doctor named William Pollack, P A W L U K. He’s one of the top, like, researchers on PEMF.  And if you just go to drpollack. com, he’s got a ton of research on PMF. He’s got devices he sells. But he’s vetted a lot of these devices. And they range anywhere from A few hundred bucks to several thousands of dollars, but again, it’s something people can do at home, they can do for themselves, they can do every day, and again, can be very effective.

Other detox therapies, I’m a huge fan of sauna, people can tolerate it, it’s a great way to mobilize mycotoxins, heavy metals, other toxic stuff. Uh, some people are very heat tolerant, you gotta be careful with the heat tolerant people. Uh, constitutional hydrotherapy, this is alternating hot and cold packs on the chest.

This is a little naturopathic therapy just to help improve blood flow throughout the body. There’s different companies that make drainage remedies. [01:11:00] These are usually combination herbal products for homeopathics. So we use a lot of Picana in our office. Uh, gentle exercise, colon hydrotherapy. Again, there’s another great way to help promote detoxification, which is different than just doing a whole enema.

Uh, the alternating, you know, filling of the intestines, draining for the intestine. It’s really designed to stimulate the vagus nerve. That’s what helps induce that parasympathetic state. So it is a good way to clean out the colon, but that’s really not the intent behind doing colon hydrotherapy. It really is the upstream effect of what it does to the liver, the gallbladder, and you’ll see at the end of a colon hydrotherapy session, everything starts to turn green while that bile’s starting to work its way.

So I’ve had some people that, you know, they’ve tried all these other things, and sometimes we’ll do these other strategies, and they respond really well. I think supporting the mitochondria for a lot of our Lyme patients that are tired all the time, all these nutrients that support the mitochondria, don’t be shy about using higher doses, CoQ10, Acetyl L Carnitine, Propoic Acid, B6 Magnesium, NADH, all [01:12:00] these are in some way, shape, or form related to mitochondrial function.

And I’ve got the doses written down here. Neuropathy can also be a big problem for a lot of Lyme patients. So there’s a lot of nutrients they can do to help support the nerves. Phosphatidylcholine, either orally or IV, glutathione, B12. I like B12 shots. Uh, they work better than oral or sublingual B12. We talked about PEMF, hyperbaric oxygen.  It’s not easy or accessible for people, but if they do have access, again, it can be really helpful. Improving oxygenation, supporting the mitochondria, and stimulating nerve growth. And IVIG, it’s not at the top of my list, but if people are having more Guillain Barre kind of symptoms, if you can get insurance to cover it, it’s horribly expensive, it’s hard to get insurance to cover it, but we’ve had some patients that have done really well with IVIG.

And Low Dose Immunotherapy, this was developed by Dr. Ty Vincent. He’s a medical doctor in Hawaii. The idea behind LDI is that we’re basically trying to use dead organism that’s been diluted out really homeopathically [01:13:00] as a way to turn off this autoimmune mechanism to the butt. So if your immune system’s treating Lyme as an allergen and not a pathogen, it’s engaging a completely different part of your immune system.

So, it’s literally that. It’s been irradiated, it takes the Borrelia organism, it’s dead, it can’t reproduce, it can’t cause infection. We dilute it out hundreds, millions of times, and then we mix it with an enzyme called beta glucuronidase. And the beta glucuronidase seems to activate whatever you mix it with.  And in very specific dilutions, it just seems to turn off that autoimmune reaction. And we’ve had some amazing cases of people that, again, tried herbs, tried antibiotics, tried all these other things, nothing really helped. And then we do this, and It’s a game changer. The challenge of this therapy is you gotta find the right dose, you gotta find the right antigen.  And sometimes we get bamboozled and we think it’s one thing and it’s really something else.

Very quickly, I had a young kid come in who overnight had typical PANS, OCD, anxiety, and I did his blood test, his streptiters were through the roof. I’m like, okay, this makes sense, it’s a strep infection. I did the [01:14:00] LDI for strep, did absolutely nothing.  Okay, so four years ago he had Lyme disease, but he was treated, and as far as I know he’s fine. That night, I gave it to him in the morning, that night, she calls me in a panic, says that he’s got a monster headache, so we talked about doing some natural things to control it, and the next morning all his symptoms were 100 percent gone.

So it was actually, I think what happened was he had the strep infection, which was the catalyst for the Lyme that was in the background that really had probably never been treated. So, ultimately, our treatment goals here, treat the organism if it’s acute, uh, treat the other immune distractors, other allergies that distract from the immune system, detoxify the body, fix the hormones, get proper sleep, reduce inflammation, get the nutritional status up, help their mitochondria, get the circulation going, and modulate the immune system.  And this is the little book I wrote and that’s all of my information. Thank you very much.

 


 

Dr. Weitz: Thank you for making it all the way through this episode of the Rational Wellness Podcast. For those of you who enjoy. Listening to the Rational Wellness Podcast, I would appreciate it if you could go to Apple Podcasts or Spotify and give us a five star ratings and review.  If you would like to work with me personally to help you improve your health, I do accept a limited number of new patients per month for a functional medicine consultation. Some of the areas I specialize in include helping patients with specific health issues, like gut problems, neurodegenerative conditions, autoimmune diseases, cardiometabolic conditions, or for an executive health screen and to help you promote longevity and take a deeper dive into some of those factors that can lead to chronic diseases along the way.  Please call my Santa Monica White Sports Chiropractic and Nutrition Office at 310 395 3111 [01:16:00] and we’ll set you up for a new consultation for functional medicine. And I look forward to speaking to everybody next week.

Dr. Jonny Bowden discusses The Great Cholesterol Myth with Dr. Ben Weitz.

[If you enjoy this podcast, please give us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts, so more people will find The Rational Wellness Podcast. Also check out the video version on my WeitzChiro YouTube page.]

 

Podcast Highlights

8:32  Dr. Bowden was working as a personal trainer at Equinox and he became a believer in the low fat diet.  He would order egg white omelets and he was convinced that if he ate any yellow of the egg, he would have a heart attack.  But he started seeing a lot of people coming to the gym who were following the low fat diet and were counting calories and they were doing hours of joyless aerobic exercise and they were not losing much weight.  Then some of his clients started following the Atkins’s low carb, high fat diet and some were losing a lot of bodyfat and their health was improving. Their blood glucose and triglycerides and their blood pressure were all dropping, all signs of improving metabolic health.

12:35  Dr. Bowden started to question the low fat diet, since clients following the high fat Atkins diet were losing weight and getting healthier.

 

 

 



Dr. Jonny Bowden has a PhD in holistic nutrition and he is an extremely prolific author, having written The Great Cholesterol Myth, The Metabolic Factor, The Most Effective natural Cures on Earth, The Most Effective Ways to Live Longer, Living Low Carb, Smart Fat, The 150 Healthiest Foods on Earth, and The 150 Most Effective Ways to Boost Your Energy, as well as 6 cookbooks.  Jonny continues to consult with clients and his website is JonnyBowden.com.

Dr. Ben Weitz is available for Functional Nutrition consultations specializing in Functional Gastrointestinal Disorders like IBS/SIBO and Reflux and also Cardiometabolic Risk Factors like elevated lipids, high blood sugar, and high blood pressure.  Dr. Weitz has also successfully helped many patients with managing their weight and improving their athletic performance, as well as sports chiropractic work by calling his Santa Monica office 310-395-3111.

 



Podcast Transcript

Dr. Weitz: Hey, this is Dr. Ben Weitz, host of the Rational Wellness Podcast. I talk to the leading health and nutrition experts and researchers in the field to bring you the latest in cutting edge health information. Subscribe to the Rational Wellness Podcast for weekly updates. And to learn more, check out my website, drweitz.com. Thanks for joining me. And let’s jump into the podcast. Hello, Rational Wellness Podcasters.

Today, we’ll be having a discussion on the Great Cholesterol Myth with Johnny Bowden, PhD. Johnny Bowden went to school, trained as a jazz musician. Eventually he became a personal trainer and eventually got a PhD in holistic nutrition.  He’s an extremely prolific author, having written The Great Cholesterol Myth, The Metabolic Factor, The Most Effective Natural Cures on Earth, The Most Effective Ways to [00:01:00] Live Longer, Living Low Carb, Smart Fat, The 150 Healthiest Foods on Earth, and the 150 Most Effective Ways to Boost Your Energy, as well as six different cookbooks.  That’s amazing, Johnny. How did you have time to do all that?

Dr. Bowden: Over 15 years. It wasn’t that hard. 20 years of writing.

Dr. Weitz:  That’s great. So thank you so much for joining us today.

Dr. Bowden:  Thank you. Thanks for having me.

Dr. Weitz:  So, uh, maybe tell us a little more about your background and how you became to become an expert in holistic nutrition.  

Dr. Bowden:  Well, I, first of all, we, we, I really hate the term holistic nutrition. It’s, uh, it was valuable back when I was getting a degree in it. It’s, it’s now turned into like the, when you think of holistic nutrition, you think of somebody on. Dennis Beach doing crystals. And it’s not that at all. I, what I would call it today is functional medicine nutrition, uh, integrative nutrition.  Nutrition is part [00:02:00] of an entire bunch of things that we use with clients to really make their lives better. It’s, it is not just looking at food diaries. It’s not just looking at nutrient amounts. It’s what is, what is this person in front of me? You know, they used to say. The difference between Eastern and Western medicine is that in Western medicine, the Western doctor says, Okay, what are the symptoms?  And in Eastern medicine, they say, Who is this person in front of me who has the symptoms? So, it’s that kind of orientation to nutrition.

Dr. Weitz:  That’s great, it was perfect because my podcast is really devoted to all things functional medicine.

Dr. Bowden:  Right, I sensed that, so I just wanted to bring it in alignment with what you guys know as functional medicine.  We used to call it Holistic medicine. It’s, it’s, it’s bad term. Um, I was a, as you mentioned, I was a professional musician. Uh, I grew up in the era of sex, drugs, and rock and roll, and I was addicted to everything in the, I [00:03:00] always tell my podcast, um, um, Host everything in the PDR, but audiences don’t know what the PDR but is.  It’s a book about this thick of over a thousand pages called the Physician’s Desk Reference, and it has every drug that ever came out. So I jokingly say I was addicted to everything in it but you know, I lived exactly what you would think of if you thought of the life of a, you know, partying, sex, drugs, and rock and roll musician in the 19, early 1970s.  That was me. And, um, I, I did a lot of traveling, and I, I always maintained, as unhealthy as I was, I always maintained an interest in health. It was like aspirational, you know, I’d go, I’d walk by the health food stores, we didn’t have a Whole Foods then, we didn’t have an internet then, this long, 70s, um, and there were these little stores, you know, that they called health food stores, and the people who patronized them, the people at large used to call, oh, those health nuts, they go to those stores, right?  So we were health nuts. Absolutely. I was, I [00:04:00] aspired to that, even, you know, during the heroin days and during the alcohol days. I always thought, you know, that, and when I, I began to get sober in the early 80s, I, I put all that behind me, uh, and, um, I was doing a lot of traveling, a lot of national tours or what we used to call bus and truck tours.  Those are Broadway shows that, you know, travel by bus and truck, they’re a little bit lower than the national ones. The national ones fly to big cities like Washington and Chicago, and the bus and trucks go to all the other cities, and I do a lot of those, and we’d be stuck like in a house for a week because we would set up and then we would do the show eight times a week at night and matinees, and the rest of the time we were free, and I started hanging out with the actors, and the actor’s job is to look great.

That is one of their many jobs, but that is a part of their job, so they all knew how to work out. Some of them carried weights with them, you know, on the bus. They really did. And here I am, I’m bored, and I feel like, okay, I’m finally, like, not taking drugs and not drinking anymore. Maybe I should, like, ask [00:05:00] one of them what the heck’s going on.  And I actually said to one of them, can you show me some of these exercises you do every day?  And that was, that was just like, uh, that, that just turned me on. When, when I started doing that, and seeing how I felt differently, and learning how I could change my own body and energy and everything else that goes with it.  It was, it was just a red letter day. It was like a revelation. And I, I was a decent musician. I was not a great musician. I could make a living at it. But this was something I really could be great at. And I started looking on the upper, I was a middle class Jewish kid from New York City. All we care about is academics and degrees, you know, that’s what our parents cared about.  So the first thing I thought about was like, I wonder if I can get a degree in this stuff, this, this weight stuff, you know, within a fairly short time, within a couple of years, I knew every [00:06:00] gym in all the cities that we went to, we’d check into Dallas, I would leave my bags, go to Doug’s Gym, this hole in the wall, and I knew where they all were, and I was really making a big change in my, in my lifestyle, and it was really working, and so I wondered to myself, I wonder if I can get some of my credentials in this, you know, that’ll, and so I did.  I found out that they had courses to certify personal trainers. So I took one and I got it. I got the certification and I got excited and I said, Oh, this one isn’t, I want another one. I want one that’s even more prestigious. And then I went to get a third one. And I wound up ultimately in that first year, maybe with six or seven, including the CSCS, Conditioning Strength and Specialists, the NASM, National Academy of Sports Medicine, the ACSM, the ACAP, they were, I got them all.

And I’d never worked with a, I’d never worked with a client, I just knew how to do it, and I knew what to do, and I’m a, really, I was always a good teacher and a communicator, so I’m waiting for a client to, to [00:07:00] try this on, and one day, I was home in New York City, and I was walking down Amsterdam Avenue, and I see this big sign, uh, New Gym opening, and it looks really special, it’s called Equinox, and I think, that looks really good, and they got a sign up there that says, Now Hiring, so I walk in.  And they’ve got the space there. It was their first gym in Manhattan. They had had one in Scarsdale, the family, then they opened this. First one in Manhattan, and of course everybody who’s listening to you knows what Equinox is, it’s one of the biggest, and most successful, and luxurious, and good, you know, national gyms in the, in the country, but at the time there was one of them, and um, I went in, and I, for the, the luck of the universe, or whatever, I clicked with those owners like that, I don’t know why, I was older than the average person coming in there to be a trainer in my 40s, most of them were 22 year old surfer boys and I clicked with Lavinia [00:08:00] Errico, she’s still around to this day, she’s a great motivational speaker, she was one of the brothers and sisters who owned Equinox and we just instantly got along and they hired me.  And I started my career in health and fitness on the floor at Equinox in Manhattan on the very first day they opened September. in 1991. And I stayed there seven years. I ultimately became the dean of the Equinox Fitness Training Institute, which is a model for how everybody trains trainers these days.  I mean, it was the best and it was the first and it was wonderful.

And during that time, Ben, I was a complete convert to the low fat orthodoxy of the time. I believed in calorie counting. I believed that if our heavy clients were not losing weight, it’s because they were cheating on, they, we never, ever, ever thought our advice was wrong.  We figured if they’re not getting the results, they’re cheating.  Um, and this was the zeitgeist at the time. I was one of the guys that would order an egg white omelet. The dumbest invention that ever came.  I’d order the egg white omelet. It would come out with a little bit of runny yellow.  I’d send it back because I just knew what was going to happen if I consumed any of that heated yellow fat.  I was going to get a heart attack because of all the cholesterol and I was going to die. So I was a true believer.  And until I started seeing clients come in where what I was seeing with my eyes was conflicting with what I had been taught. So all these people on low fat diets, all these people are counting calories, all these people are doing hours of joyless exercise on a stair master, just hating their existence doing it, and they’re not really losing weight.

Now I grant you that there are people out there who lost weight on the low fat [00:10:00] diet. To say otherwise is just ridiculous. But there were not as many as you might think, and it was not as successful as you might have thought. And in fact, people who really were able to keep weight off on a low fat diet do well and maintain it, were very, very, few. And right around this time, 1992, Atkins published this third edition of his book.  His first edition came out in 72. There was one in the middle, and then 92, the New New Diet Revolution, the new revised Atkins, and people were trying it. And they were trying it against our advice. We trainers, like, people would come in and say, You know, I’ve tried all this stuff, it’s just not working.  I got a friend who lost 40 pounds on Atkins.  I’m gonna try that Atkins diet. And we would go, No! You cannot do this! Yes, they lose a few pounds. They lose pounds on cocaine too. This is a dangerous diet. This guy should lose his license. He’s talking about bacon being, you know, forget it.  And guess what, Ben? They didn’t listen to us. So I, what would happen is I’d get these clients–I remember one in particular coming.  And to say transformed isn’t really, it wasn’t just that he lost so much weight.  His eyes were clearer, you know, you and I, we see, we work in fitness and health and we get really intuitive about knowing if somebody’s, I don’t believe in medical intuitives, but I do believe that, like, we have a lot of clinical experience, you can read if a person’s really healthy and fit.  There’s an energy, there’s something in their eyes, there’s something about how they carry themselves and you can kind of feel that or you kind of feel something’s off, they’re, they’re not doing well.  And I’m seeing this guy and he’s doing, and I’m, my intuition is saying, holy, you know what, this guy’s really transformed, big belly and now it’s not such a big belly, his eyes are clearer, he’s telling me, his doctor says his blood pressure is down and his [00:12:00] triglycerides have dropped, what is going on?  And we, I had what psychologists call cognitive dissonance, two thoughts that cannot both be true. And if you believe both, you have a psychological upset. And you have to resolve them somehow, and that’s what cognitive dissonance is. And, uh, here I am being taught by the American Dietetic Association that a high fat diet will kill you, that cholesterol, all the cholesterol in that food is gonna give you a heart attack, and if you go on something like Atkins, which is absolutely insane, then you will probably die.

And here I got this guy standing in front of me who is not dying at all, not even close. So something’s gotta be wrong. And I tend to believe my eyes, so when I see a very healthy person standing in front of me whose triglycerides have dropped and whose blood glucose is down and whose blood pressure is down and his waist is down, [00:13:00] I’m thinking what I was told might not be true.  So I began to question some of the orthodoxy. And an interesting thing, just from social and political kind of, for those who are interested in this, I didn’t have any credentials when I was teaching people at the Equinox Fitness Training Institute. I just, I had the certification as a trainer. I had a master’s in psychology.  I did get a master’s in psychology before any of this happened, but that’s not why they were letting me teach nutrition and anatomy and kinesiology and all the rest. But I was preaching the accepted narrative. I was preaching low fat diets, calorie counting, exercise,… the willpower.  Long as I bought the narrative, nobody questioned my credentials.  See if this brings it up and perhaps,

Dr. Weitz:  No, I mean, I did this same thing. In fact, I remember competing as a bodybuilder and getting my body fat down to 3 percent with a low fat diet and exercising twice a day. And just eating very Spartan, you know, Tuna fish, broccoli.

Dr. Bowden:  People did it. You know, I know I was, I was there, but I was going to say, perhaps you can think of a parallel in the past three years during the pandemic, so I was quoting the narrative and everybody loved me as a teacher.  And then I said, wait a minute, something that I asked a question, could we have possibly demonized saturated fat a little?  Maybe it’s not as bad as they told us. I’m seeing. Well, you want to talk about, we didn’t have cancel back then, but there might as well have been cancels. And this was like, who is this guy? A, he’s not an MD, B, he’s not even a nutritionist, he’s just a personal trainer, and what does he know that all these doctors are [00:15:00] saying the difference, and he’s questioning that?  I mean, you know, I was taught in, in psychology school, in graduate school, I had a year of statistics and research design, I’m not a great, you know, You know, researcher, but I know the basic thing is you ask questions. You try to disprove your own hypothesis. You look literally for what else could be going on.

You don’t just accept the first thing that comes to mind. You ask those questions as part of science. But when you ask questions, of a narrative that is very strictly enforced, you get canceled, or de monetized, or de platformed. And we saw that very, very clearly, and I’m not taking any sides. I’m saying, open your eyes and see what we did the last three years to anybody who had any question whatsoever about the policies we were following.

Okay, I’m not going to go there. But the point is, it happened to me. And they were like, well, we’re not letting him teach. He doesn’t even know what he’s talking about. So I went back to school and that’s when I went and got my PhD in nutrition. So now I had a [00:16:00] master’s in psychology. I knew my research and design.  I could read a study as well as anybody else in the world. And now I had a PhD in nutrition and I said, now I’m going to ask the questions and I’m going to tell you, you’re full of, you know, what, and I’ve been doing that for 20 years. So how did this book, The Great Cholesterol Myth come about? So here I am with the clients.

And the clients are going on Atkins, and they’re not dying, and they’re getting healthier, and they’re doing better. So, I ask myself, very logically, why have we been told to avoid saturated fat? Why, what was the big, if these people are eating it, and they’re eating animal products, And they’re doing really really well.  Why did they tell us that? And the answer was always the same. Because the saturated fat will raise your cholesterol, and your cholesterol will cause heart disease. What if that weren’t true? [00:17:00] Everything about the dietary recommendations, which you and I now know, work. Absolute bogus BS, 11 servings of grains a day, things that people would go, What?  They recommended, what? All of that was for one reason, because they didn’t want your cholesterol to go high. And they didn’t want your cholesterol to go high because they knew, quote unquote, that cholesterol caused heart attack. If this were something you could question, if it wasn’t true, what happens to your dietary guidelines?  What happens to them? They’re built on sand. They’re built on a fear of cholesterol. And what if cholesterol isn’t everything that they told you it was? Then what happens to those recommendations? I mean, we’ve been avoiding a perfectly good food, and we’ve been avoiding meat and things that we’ve eaten for, you know, a couple hundred thousand years.  We’re avoiding all of that because it’s going to raise your cholesterol? And we already knew [00:18:00] half of that story was bullshit, and I’ll tell you why. Because even at the beginning, everybody knew that dietary cholesterol had no effect on anything. If they were telling us, don’t even eat it, because it’ll raise your body cholesterol, and that just is not true, except for less than 1 percent of the population that has a condition called familial hypercholesterolemia.

It’s genetic, it’s very rare, and those are the only people who have to worry about eating cholesterol. Everybody else doesn’t. So, we knew that wasn’t true. And then I started thinking about whether the rest of it was, and that is how I got from a generalist to really taking on this particular issue, and then we wrote in 2012, the cardiologist Steven Sinatra and I wrote the great cholesterol myth.  And it kind of put us on the map. And then eight years later, we did the revised edition with all the new information we had gained since then. And, um, I’ve been talking about it very frequently. It’s not the only thing I talk about, but that’s how I got on the great cholesterol myth and [00:19:00] questioning conventional wisdom in general.

Dr. Weitz:  I saw where you made an appearance on the Dr. Oz show and, and your quote is trying to reduce the risk of heart disease by lowering your LDL cholesterol is like trying to reduce the calories on your whopper by taking off the lettuce. It was good. 

Dr. Bowden: I forgot about that. Thanks. That was very good. That was a good quote.  I’m proud of that one. So ask me, why does everybody think that? It’s this way. And I said, Dr. Oz, in the, I don’t know when, what century it was, but there was a time where the greatest minds and scientists of the country thought that the earth was flat. I mean, the fact that everybody thinks this does not make it true.

Dr. Weitz: Right. And by the way, they continue to think this. In fact, I wanted to point out that, um, uh, last year I heard [00:20:00] Dr. Peter Attia, who I know we both respect, say that Primary prevention for cardiovascular disease should involve treating patients starting in their 30s and we should make sure that their ApoB is below 30 or 40 by whatever means necessary, eating less saturated fat, taking statins, taking PCSK9 inhibitors. If we do that, we will eliminate heart disease.

Dr. Bowden: Let me just say that I have huge respect for Peter Attia. I do too. I have learned more from him than probably any other doctor, except maybe Howard Elkin. Um, I have, um, read his stuff. I learned a great deal about cholesterol from his nine part course on it, online.  Um, he is very, very strict about blood lipids. I would never, with my background [00:21:00] not being a fraction of his medical background, I’m not going to argue with his findings, but I think that he’s a little You know, he did, he does the same thing with his book on aging, which is I think the best book on anti aging I’ve ever read.  He looks at, you know, he’s a mathematician. He gets these Excel spreadsheets and he looks at, okay, I want to be a kick ass hundred year old. I’m going to lose this much muscle every. Decade. If I don’t do something about it, I’m going to lose this much balance, this much stability. So I have to, in my 30s, do this, and in my 40s, do this, all to counteract the effects of nature.  And then when I’m 100, I’m going to be a kick ass 100 year old. So he is very methodical. about the stuff he does and very, very precise and extreme and blood lipids. I’m not going to say he’s wrong. I’m going to say that I think that there is a bigger picture and a lot of what he says I totally agree with.  He thinks that the basic good and bad cholesterol test is nonsense and of course so do [00:22:00] I. He’s the one who said in the quote, I use it on podcast all the time, It’s such a great quote. Your total cholesterol has as much to do with your heart attack risk as your hair color. That’s Peter Attia. So he’s not a bad guy, okay?  

Dr. Weitz:  No, no, he’s brilliant, you know, and I have a huge amount of respect for him.

Dr. Bowden:   He’s pretty medicine heavy. And, and this, he’s pretty much like kind of, I don’t know why I keep coming up with COVID analogies, but like if, if your value was we are going to protect this world from this virus and the only way to do it is lock everybody down and vaccinate everybody, well, if that’s your goal, yes, that’s probably the best way, There’s a lot of collateral damage to that policy.  There are a lot of people who would disagree with that policy, and I think in the same way, yeah, you can get your blood lipids down low, but I’m interested in also talking to people about the stuff that has nothing to do with their blood lipids, like their relationships and their involvement with their community and their involvement [00:23:00] with their family. I’ll tell you something really quickly that I think your audience needs to hear, because you and I probably get clients, individual clients, from the same demographic, and I’ll bet if I asked you, are they confused about nutrition, you would be nodding your head.  You’re damn right they’re confused. Well, everybody’s confused about nutrition, and you know. Right. So what I like to tell those clients, is about, I’m going to tell you the story. Sardinian researchers have looked at what Peter Attia is doing and going, this is a noble goal. He wants to get people healthy at a hundred and not living in assisted living and doing really, you know, active things.

And there are centenarians in the world who do that. But instead of like all this stuff that We hear about what the biohackers, like the cold plungers and all, you know, the wind huff breath training and climbing up the mountains without a shirt and all that. I’m sure that’s all great, but it’s also very intimidating to the average person because most of us aren’t going to do that stuff.  So this research is really [00:24:00] interesting to all of you who do not want to follow that kind of rigorous, extreme way of living in order to be really healthy at 100. These researchers said, that’s a noble goal, but I want to reverse engineer it. Let’s go meet some kick ass hundred year olds and see what they’re already doing.  What are the people who are doing what we want to get to? What’s their secret? And they came away with three secrets. First of all, they went to Sardinia. Yeah, you’re talking about the blue zones. Yeah, so Sardinia is one of the five blue zones. And it happens to be the one that has the highest proportion of fully functioning, active hundred year old men.

That’s a place you want to study. So they spend some time in Sardinia and they come away and it’s tongue in cheek, but boy is there a truth in this. You want to know the three lessons? Sure. To live to be a hundred? Number one, live where there are a lot of stairs. Have you ever seen pictures of Sardinia?  You can’t walk out of your house [00:25:00] walking 10,000 steps in the grove. It’s all stairs and hills. Right. So the take home there is walk all day. Just walk, walk, walk, walk, walk. Number two. Many of these hundred year olds are shepherds. They spend all their day in the mountains with sheep. Sheep are the most docile, sweet, non aggressive animals in the world.

Lesson number two was, spend as much time as you can with sweet, docile animals. Well, think about it. What is, what information is your brain absorbing when you’re in that circumstances, as opposed to say a cop who goes to work and sees the worst of humanity and what people do to each other and the cruelty and the meanness.  And this is a person who is watching sheep in nature. What do you think their mind is like? What do you think their physiology is like? They’re in parasympathetic nervous system mode all day long. That’s where the [00:26:00] healing takes place. Bars Bathing All Day Long. Right? And number three, and number three was so far above the other two, that it was like in real estate they say there’s three most important things to know about real estate.  Location, location, location. This was the location, location, location for living to be a hundred. You ready? Yeah. Make your family and friends your number one priority. End of story.

So I mentioned this. Because we can go crazy about lowering blood lipids, and I, believe me, I, I worry about my own. I go to Dr. Elkin, we figure out how to bring the particle number down. It’s important, I’m not saying ignore it. You and I wouldn’t have careers if there was nothing to do about the metrics.  But I try to get people to look at this bigger picture. They come to me sometimes and they are so confused about their cholesterol, and their total cholesterol is high, and their doctor wants to put them on a stent, and they don’t want to do this. First of all, we already talked about total [00:27:00] cholesterol means nothing, ladies and gentlemen.

Zero. But that said, they’re worried about these granular particulars, and they are important. But what I always leave every client who sees me, with is the sense of what they’re already doing to make deposits in their health bank. They’re playing with their kids. They’re petting their dog. They’re making love.

They’re walking out in the sun. They’re kind of sunbathing from time to time, as you would say, forest bathing, and they are making major deposits, and I don’t know that those deposits are don’t wind up being more important than a particular lab value. And I get that Peter wants to bring them all down as low as possible.

I’m not a medical doctor. I don’t know how to do that. It worries me how much medicine is involved in doing that. I’m wondering if there aren’t other things we can do in addition that might be even more important, such as Loving each other, spending time around friends, and it appears from these [00:28:00] studies that’s the number one thing.  Nobody said in that study, here’s the three lessons, keep your cholesterol low. It wasn’t even mentioned. By the way, did you happen to see the paper in British Medical Journal a couple of months ago? Which one? It was, it’s called, Is LDL cholesterol associated with long term mortality among primary prevention adults?

A retrospective cohort study from a large health care system. What did they find? The conclusion of this study was that Those who had an LDL cholesterol under 79 had increased mortality. Oh, that’s old. I mean, I didn’t see that study, but I can tell you that from, that’s 20 years old. The lowest mortality was those with LDL between 100 and 189.  Those over 190 also had increased risk. Yeah, so let me give you a little context for [00:29:00] that, that has been shown since I was first a student in the late 90s. Um, we know that the higher, it’s not a curve that looks like this. The low cholesterol you’re doing great and the high cholesterol you’re doing bad.  It’s much more like a different shaped curve. Yeah, what we call a T shaped curve. You know what goes up in risk? Heart attacks. I’m sorry. Okay. Suicides and accidents. Why is that? Oh! Maybe because cholesterol is needed for the brain? Could that have something to do with it? So these doctors who are like the lower the better, the lower the better.

They’re screwing with your brain and they want to put 13 year olds on statins to get it even lower and the brain isn’t even developed until you’re 25? Are you kidding me? Not to mention you need cholesterol to make, uh, testosterone. I always tell that to men, they always, wait, wait, wait, I’m taking the, wait, wait, what did you say?

Yeah, your sex hormones come from that. And I had a wonderful doctor, I won’t quote him because [00:30:00] they always, when I quote them, if I don’t get them right, they get very upset, but this, this very smart doctor said, Bernie. I have never seen a case of ED that wasn’t also a case of ED. What did he mean? A rectal dysfunction and endothelial dysfunction, which is the heart of heart disease.  These are very related. Is it an accident that we see all these men coming into psychiatry’s office and psychologists and counselors office talking about impotence and they don’t have, they can’t get it up anymore and all of that, and half the male population is on statins? Really? No connection to that, huh?

Nobody wants to put that little thing together? By the way, I wanted to credit you. Your book, 12 years ago, talked about endothelial dysfunction. Yeah, we didn’t invent that. I mean, we just popularized it. No, I understand, but hardly anybody was talking about it. Now, everybody in cardiovascular medicine, or many people, are talking about the importance of endothelial dysfunction and that being a core factor [00:31:00] in cardiovascular disease.  Coronary artery disease. Absolutely. The wonderful, wonderful doctor friend of mine, Dr. Mark Houston. Uh, from Nashville, who’s also a master’s in nutrition.

Dr. Weitz: Had him on the podcast many times.

Dr. Bowden: Yeah. Oh, no kidding. So Mark, who I’ve known for a hundred years, and also is one of the few doctors in America who also has a master’s in nutrition, and he teaches doctors all over the place.  He taught me about endothelial dysfunction 20 years ago, so he’s been talking about that a long time. Another thing we both believe in that you mentioned a little bit is the importance of having an advanced lipid profile and not just having a standard lipid panel consisting of total cholesterol, estimated LDL, HDL, triglycerides.  That is just inadequate. It’s not adequate at all. It’s 1950s nutrition. It’s, it’s, [00:32:00] it’s working with a flip phone when you have the Galaxy 9 and the iPhone 15. It’s just, it’s just plain silly. We now know that there are subdivisions of HDL and LDL. I think there’s about 13 of them, there’s HDL2, 2A, there’s dysfunctional HDL, there’s LDL, oxidized LDL, there’s Lp, little a, there’s small LDL particles, big LDL particles, it’s, it, it, this good and bad is like giving a medical diagnosis based on if you’re short or tall, I mean it’s just such elementary nonsensical, you know, Yeah.

Dr. Weitz:  So what you’re saying for the listeners, maybe if you’re not quite following is the standard lipid profile that you’ll get with your annual physical. And in fact, it’s pretty much all that’s done by most doctors, including cardi, conventional cardiologists is just not adequate. There’s so much research showing the importance of not [00:33:00] LDL, but knowing LDL particle number, particle size, we know small dense LDL is much more atherogenic than large LDL.  Yes, they’re not all the same, I’m telling you. Yes, and there’s a whole series of other factors that you’ve talked about, which is that For the LDL to potentially create a problem, it’s, it’s got to be oxidized and inflamed markers. We need to look at oxidized LDL. We need to look at HSCRP, homocysteine.  There’s a bunch of stuff you really got to look at if you really want to assess your true cardiovascular risk.

Dr. Bowden:  I couldn’t agree with you more, you’re preaching to the choir. And another thing that you mentioned in that book that hardly anybody was talking about now, um, was you mentioned uric acid. Oh, I didn’t mention it.  The great David Perlmutter taught us about that. I just read [00:34:00] his book and said, hey guys, why are you not reading this and understanding that uric acid is a major metabolic marker. You know, I’m a popularizer, I don’t take any credit for these guys, intellects like David Perlmutter who do this research and understand the neurology of it and all.

You know, they’re my heroes, all I do is I am very good at explaining this science to average people. That’s my only, that’s my talent. Speaking and writing and talking to the people who might be at my family table. They’re smart people. They just don’t know this stuff and they get very confused by it.  Right. And my talent, such as it is, is to go to those conferences, learn what those people say, and then come back and say, Look, you know how this happens? And that’s basically uric acid for years. And most doctors, if you ask them today, they think it’s just a measure of gout. Something that we do when we treat gout, but it turns out to be a major metabolic marker that’s very intricately related to [00:35:00] fructose metabolism.

We now know fructose metabolism is It’s central for so many things. Fructose makes us fat, so there’s a connection there that nobody’s looking at. And the reason why fructose is so important is because one of the most common sugars added to processed foods, like sodas, is high fructose corn syrup. 100%. So, I, you probably also saw where recently the, um, uh, the folks who make the U.

  1. Dietary Guidelines. Yeah. The U. S. Dietary Guidelines Advisory Group came out with a report saying that ultra processed foods do not cause obesity. Hmm. Hmm. Hmm. Hmm. This is where, lady, I’ll let the audience in on a little, uh, this is where it becomes very difficult for people like Ben and me and people who are engaged in this kind of dialogue with patients and with the [00:36:00] public on YouTube and to not talk about politics.

It is very, very hard to understand why these insane recommendations keep coming out, like 11 grams, you know, 11 servings of grain. And then, oh yeah, this, uh, what was the last one? Oh, all through processed food? Nah, you can have, you know, it’s perfectly fine to have. And you, and American Diabetes Association, oh yeah, you can have chocolate cake, just make sure you take your insulin.

You don’t, you don’t understand. No one really understands how deeply. The pharmaceutical and the big food industries have their tentacles on, have their hands on the throats of legislatures, politicians, 75 percent of senators or people in Congress, that’s the House and the Senate, represent an area in a state in which Uh, Big Food, or Big Pharma, or Big Hospital is the number one employer.

Cable TV, I [00:37:00] think now, Big Pharma is responsible for, in primetime, 75 percent of the ads. Yeah, it’s amazing how many ads for drugs are on TV. You can’t imagine the vectors of influence and how this stuff happens backstage. On media, on reporting, on television, on newspapers. In government policy, you’ve got the, you’ve got the fox regulating the hen house.

It is like putting tobacco executives in charge of smoking public service messages. Yeah, we’re actually one in a few countries that actually allows One of two. Two in the world. drug companies to advertise drugs to patients. New Zealand and us. Yeah, that’s it. All the other companies, they, they can put ads in, uh, pharmaceutical, in, in the journals to inform doctors about it, but they don’t market directly to patients.

That [00:38:00] might be something to ask of our presidential candidates, which one is committed to getting that crap off the air. Might be a question that would be interesting to people. Yeah, absolutely, um, and what do you think about, um, this came up when we were talking about what topics we were going to talk about, all the people who are losing weight these days by taking, uh, Ozembic and these GLP 1 agonist, uh, medications.

Well, I’m actually talking about this tomorrow when I’m giving a lecture at the, uh, I’m on the faculty of the Functional Medicine Coaching Academy and I’m going to be talking about it. Oh, okay. Um, so Ozempic and, and the GLP 1, uh, agonists, the semi glutide, that class of drugs, is very problematic for us because, This is going to be a hard drug to take a hard line black or white position on.  The truth is, there are some [00:39:00] amazingly promising things about that drug. There are also some amazingly scary red flags about that drug, but it’s not an either or. That drug stops addictive behavior. You, rats love alcohol. If you give rats alcohol, they’re going to, they roll around in their little cages and, and the happiest can be when they’re drunk.

When you give rats. GLP 1 agonist, or ozempic, and the alcohol, stop drinking it, they’re not interested. It’s right there for them to take as much as they want, they don’t even really do it. These are important things, let’s not deny that. Now, the list of problems is considerable. And I think that there are some cases where you go, but wait, it increases the risk of thyroid cancer by 50%, but it does this, and it does this, and there’s a chance of this, and the metabolic reset, and the ozempic rate, And then you have [00:40:00] to balance that against the very real documented problems with being 200 pounds overweight or 100 pounds overweight.

You’re going to die early. You have a, if you have diabetes, which you have a hugely greater chance of getting if you’re obese, you’ve got a 70 percent greater chance of dying from some other disease. You have to weigh that against the Negatives. My issue with it is, for one thing, Beverly Hills housewives have taken it to lose 20 pounds, which is absolutely insane.  But if you’re talking about, you know, this is a way out for people who are morbidly obese, um, a case can be made. I, I get that. The problem, a couple of the problems that I see, apart from some of those scary side effects, is that I’ve seen a number of people who lost a bunch of weight and once they stopped taking it, they just gained weight.

Right back. Let’s say [00:41:00] this right now about that. That is exactly what happens. This is a drug you had, and this is one of the things people need to consider. You need to be on this for life. If you think you’re going to take it a couple of weeks and drop the weight and then go back, it ain’t going to happen.  So when you sign up for this, be aware that this is a lifetime commitment. Right. Now, another problem is, is that it’s documented that people tend to lose muscle when they lose weight on this drug. So on another And they’re actually trying, they’re actually right now testing out, um, uh, CIRMs or some other sort of drug that might promote an anabolic effect that you now stack with Ozembic.

Yeah, we have that already, by the way. Would you like to know what it’s called? It’s called weight training and protein. I mean, how much are we going to go down this, you know, one [00:42:00] author who studied the Ozembic said, it’s a false solution to a false problem. Ultra processed food has made us fatter than ever.

in a way that we have never been as, as Homo sapiens have ever been in history. Made by the food that we’re eating. And now this drug comes along, and those, those ultra processed foods do one thing, which is very clear and very documented in the research. They make you want to eat more of them. When that potato chip commercial came out years ago, Ben, Bet You Can’t Eat Just One, they weren’t, they weren’t kidding.

They design these foods to have just what they call the bliss point, the exact proportion of fat, salt, and, and carbohydrate and sugar, so that people can’t stop eating them. So they create this appetite, which can’t be satisfied because the foods don’t have any nutrition in them, so you just keep eating more, trying to get the protein that you need.

And then they solve this [00:43:00] problem by coming up with a drug that will make you feel full on that crap. Right. You, I think when people really understand this, if they understand it, that the people on Mozempik will come to people like us even more because they will see that metabolic health and healthy weight are not the same thing.  They’re not the same thing. Underneath the stuff that causes heart attacks and diabetes and Alzheimer’s and insulin resistance, all of that doesn’t have symptoms. You don’t see that happening. So if you get your weight by a drug to be perfect, you can keep eating the crap you’re eating. That’s going to be metabolic disaster for people.

Absolutely. So another problem, take the drug, come to us and let us help you navigate the food environment so that you don’t Collapse metabolically underneath that healthy weight. Yeah. Um, so another aspect of this drug is essentially my understanding is the way [00:44:00] it blunts your hunger is that your GI motility slows down.

So essentially the food stays in your stomach longer and your whole, um, movement of your GI tract is slowed. GI motility. Which is not great because, you know, we have a lot of patients and I work with a lot of patients with a whole series of GI issues like IBS and reflux and these things are directly related with altered motility of their GI tract and now we’re taking medications that are slowing the motility of the GI tract.

100 percent and I’ll, uh, I’ll top you one that’s even more alarming. I’m sure your listeners have heard you talk a lot about the microbiome. Yes. And you’re a functional medicine doctor, you know what the first saying in functional medicine is, first treat the gut. Yeah. I’m talking about the, what do you think these [00:45:00] drugs do to the microbiome?  I’m sure they have to. I mean, that’s in the, that’s in the very new exploratory research. They screw it up badly. And that is connected to everything from schizophrenia to depression to weight loss. Right. Your microbiome.

Dr. Weitz:  Yeah, I, I, I did hear somebody who was on Mark Hyman’s podcast. She uses, um, compounded versions of semi glutite and She claims that you can use a much lower dosage and in combination with a full functional medicine approach that incorporates weight training and exercise and etc, um, that perhaps these drugs can be used more safely.

Dr. Bowden:   That I, I think that we all have to get behind that because they’re [00:46:00] going to be used whether we like it or not. They are, they are the experts. that I’m reading now are predicting probably higher than 40 percent of Americans will be on some form of these drugs in 10 years. They won’t be injectable, they’ll be by pills, the price will have come down, insurance will cover them, and we’re looking at something as, as, as significant as Prozac or the pill.  And that’s going to change everything. And if people continue to think that weight and metabolic health are the same thing, we’re going to be a very sick nation, even worse than we are now. But if people use wisely, use that drug under supervision with, with coaching about how much, how to get the right, the right amount of protein, even though you’re not as hungry as you used to be and how to, you know, get the benefits of intermittent fasting, you cannot, this is not a free pass to eat Pringles.  And if you use it as that, yeah, you’ll stay skinny, but you won’t like the results in 20 [00:47:00] years, man. Trust me. Right. Yeah, you’ve got to have good metabolic health and simply losing weight by eating the wrong foods and not exercising is not the way to do it. Correct. So, just like with many drugs that are, can be beneficial, there’s a right way to use it.

Absolutely. You know, it’s very funny about what people will do to, to, to not have to change anything in their lives. Human growth hormone used to be a very popular thing that people would do. Um, and I don’t know if you know this, most people don’t, but, um, I was a consultant to Kent Asynogenics Medical Institute for a while, and they are, you know, the largest anti aging practice in the country, 18 places around the country.

And, um, one thing that we learned is that HGH doesn’t work for you very well if you’re on a high carb diet. In fact, if you take HGH and you eat the standard, you eat the way [00:48:00] we’re eating now with stuff like that, you’re more likely to develop diabetes. So when people go, wait, I can’t just take this and all of a sudden I’m going to have all these bad, well, no, if you, you, you can sabotage even that expensive drug if you continue to eat this crap.

Right. Right. You know, as an ex alcoholic, I know technically you’re not ever supposed to say that, but I say it anyway, I’m an ex alcoholic, I don’t identify as that, that’s not my, but I can tell you that it really requires a change in your headset. I, my wife drinks, we have alcohol in the house, I serve it to friends, I go to bars, I socialize where there’s alcohol.  It’s not an option for me. And at this point, it doesn’t even go like, wow, wouldn’t that be nice? No, it’s not even possible [00:49:00] for me. And I think that, hard as it may be, some people are going to have to do that at some point with the most egregious offenders in our diet. It’s hard to say don’t eat sugar, but man, to the extent that you could do that, your life will change.  Your health will change. Absolutely. We, it takes. It can’t be that you’re just like, I’m gonna take this pill, and I’m gonna, you know, I mean, there’s a pill like that for alcohol. It’s called Antabuse. It makes you sick if you take alcohol, but it doesn’t have a great track record. You gotta change your mindset.  And it, you know, as someone, I think that’s a pretty significant thing to go from like, I want that drug, I want that thing, to like, not for me, it’s not for me. Allowed, that’s a big change, but man, you can’t just, whether it’s human growth hormone or whether it’s semi glutide, the drug alone is maybe going to make something easier, but you’ve got to do the [00:50:00] work.  You’ve got to do some work. Right.

Dr. Weitz: Just out of curiosity, how has your thinking about cholesterol and heart disease changed since you first wrote this book?

Dr. Bowden: Well, when we first wrote this book, one of the chapters was called the Statin Scam. Okay. We changed it on the, the, the, uh, on the updated edition.  I actually would have to look to see, but it was more like the statin misunderstanding. Okay. We, we did not want to be in this polarized environment we all live in. We did not want to be the anti statin guys. Right. Steve Sinatra, my partner in the writing of this, the cardiologist, he’s no longer with us, but he would prescribe statins very infrequently, but in certain cases.  We didn’t want to have this religious position. Right. I’m not, again, it’s like [00:51:00] what Joe Rogan said about vaccines, I’m not anti vaccine, I’m anti propaganda. That’s what he said, I love that. Right. I’m not anti statin, I’m anti propaganda. I’m anti this brand extension of this drug that does do some good in a very small population of middle aged men with previous heart disease.

There was some use for it, but then they did the brand extension. Well, let’s see. Can we do it in flavors? Let’s see. Can we get the 70 year old women to take it? How about 13 year old boys? And that’s what’s crazy. And they prescribe it based on total cholesterol, which as we said and all agreed on, is as relevant as your hair color.  So that’s what we’re against. If someone like, um, you know Howard Elkin, correct? Yeah, of course. He’s a very close friend of mine. Mine too. If Howard Elkin looks at my charts, and does the smart vascular, and the Cleveland heart panel, and a [00:52:00] nuclear stress test, and a calcium scan, and he, with his functional medicine approach, and as a nutritionist, looks at it, and he goes, Maybe we should add 5mg of Crestor.  I say, give me the prescription. I’m not a fanatic. I want those prescriptions to come from doctors who know what the hell they’re doing. who are using the proper tests, who are looking at your particle number and your particle size, and looking at those risk factors, not your good and bad cholesterol.  Right. And if that holistic approach results in perhaps adding a small dose statin to the mix, I personally would take it. But not if it comes from Dr. Jones and Kaiser who says, Oh, 236, you’re going on the statin. No, I’m out the door. And unfortunately, that’s most of the people who come to me. That’s how they got their statin prescriptions.  Yeah, unfortunately, that’s the healthcare system. That’s the way it’s designed to work right now in America. It’s [00:53:00] not working, folks, just so you know. It’s not working to make people healthier. Uh, Robert Lustig, a person I’m sure you know who wrote the, he has that incredible YouTube video that has over 5 million views on, uh, on Sugar, The Bitter Truth, Lustig said the American medical system is like this.

Picture a hill, a mountain, right, with a top, and then a big cliff, right? And you’re up there at the cliff, and we got tons of ambulances waiting at the bottom of the cliff to take you to the hospital. That, is the American medical system. What we’re trying to do is put some freaking guardrails on the cliff.  I know, it’s unbelievable. I had a patient came to see me for his, his back pain. And we, I looked at his [00:54:00] questionnaire as part of the intake. And I said, I noticed that, um, you have, uh, elevated blood glucose. And he said, well, I’m pre diabetic. I said, Oh, okay. What did your doctor say? Oh, he said to wait till it gets worse. And then they’ll put me on medication.

You realize that that is exactly what we were told. That’s the clip you’re talking about. Exactly. It’s also exactly what we were told at the beginning of the COVID epidemic, before we had a vaccine, stay home until you’re sick enough to go to the hospital. We’ll put you on a ventilator.  That was the advice. Right? Let’s just, just say it. Yeah, all these chronic diseases, there’s a long curve. You know, nobody goes from having normal, healthy blood sugar, fasting glucose of 80, to suddenly having 140. It’s slowly going up over time, and we [00:55:00] got to start helping people to get healthier, to get their metabolic health better, to control these chronic conditions before they get to the top and fall off the cliff.

Dr. Weitz:  Exactly what the medical system is not set up to do. The medical system, Big Food and Big Pharma make their money and stay in business. by having good ambulances. Unfortunately, it’s going to bankrupt society because our health care system’s spending so much money, you know, little results. Exactly. With so little results.  So we’ve got to start doing prevention. We’ve got to start incorporating ways of getting people healthier before they get really sick. Couldn’t agree more, man. Okay, Johnny, uh, final thoughts?

Dr. Bowden:  No, I’d love to tell people how to reach me if they want to do, I’m doing private coaching. I do a different kind of private coaching than most people do.  I do one session. [00:56:00] So you don’t have to sign up with me for, you know, um, I do kind of sessions where we really talk about not just nutrition and cholesterol but the person’s whole life and we see if we can kind of do a course correction, correct some misinformation, find out what’s going on, maybe reassure them a little about some of the things that they think are so bad that they’re doing when in fact they’re often doing some very good things.  Um, so I love doing that. That’s on my website and of course I love if people would Reading, buy the book, the good, oh, isn’t it chilling? Well so much for that. The Great Cholesterol Myth. Thank you so much for having me on. That’s the old edition, but you get the new one. It’s got a lot more stuff on it. So what’s your website?  Johnnyboden. com and there is no H in Johnny, J O N N Y. B O W D E N.

Dr. Weitz: Excellent. Thank you so much, Johnny.

Dr. Bowden:  Thank you so much. It’s been a pleasure. Thank you, man.

 


 

Dr. Weitz:  Thank you for making it all the way through this episode of the Rational Wellness Podcast. For those of you who enjoy Listening to the Rational Wellness Podcast, I would appreciate it if you could go to Apple Podcasts or Spotify and give us a five star ratings and review.  If you would like to work with me personally to help you improve your health, I do accept a limited number of new patients per month for a functional medicine consultation. Some of the areas I specialize in include helping patients with specific health issues like gut problems. neurodegenerative conditions, autoimmune diseases, cardiometabolic conditions, or for an executive health screen and to help you promote longevity and take a deeper dive into some of those factors that can lead to chronic diseases along the way.  Please call my Santa Monica Weitz Sports Chiropractic and Nutrition Office at 310-395-3111.  And we’ll set you up for a new consultation for functional medicine.  And I look forward to speaking to everybody next week.

Dr. Kim Crawford discusses Inflammatory Bowel Disease with Dr. Ben Weitz.

[If you enjoy this podcast, please give us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts, so more people will find The Rational Wellness Podcast. Also check out the video version on my WeitzChiro YouTube page.]

 

Podcast Highlights

3:50  Bioidentical Hydrocortisone and Methylene Blue.  Gastroenterologists often treat patients with ulcerative colitis or Crohn’s disease with synthetic corticosteroids like prednisone or Medrol, but Dr. Crawford prefers to use bioidentical hydrocortisone that is made by a compounding pharmacy without unhealthy binders and fillers.  She may also use methylene blue for patients with inflammatory bowel disease who are having a flare up, which is an amazing anti-inflammatory and antioxidant product.  Dr. Crawford prefers an oral, liposomal formulation of methylene blue made by a compounding pharmacy at a dosage of 25 to 50 mg twice per day. 

8:17  Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD). Dr. Crawford noted that about half the patients that she sees with IBD have already been diagnosed.  Most have been treated by traditional gastroenterologists and are on a biologic drug or have taken several of them.

 

 



Dr. Kim Crawford is a nationally recognized, board certified Internal Medicine and anti-aging specialist who uses a Functional Medicine approach to help patients overcome various chronic disease, including Inflammatory Bowel Disease.  Dr. Crawford herself was exposed to high levels of environmental mycotoxins, which attacked her GI tract and this resulted in CIRS, leaky gut, and eventually Crohn’s disease, which for her was a totally life-altering autoimmune disease.  Her website is KimCrawfordMD.com.

Dr. Ben Weitz is available for Functional Nutrition consultations specializing in Functional Gastrointestinal Disorders like IBS/SIBO and Reflux and also Cardiometabolic Risk Factors like elevated lipids, high blood sugar, and high blood pressure.  Dr. Weitz has also successfully helped many patients with managing their weight and improving their athletic performance, as well as sports chiropractic work by calling his Santa Monica office 310-395-3111.

 



Podcast Transcript

Dr. Weitz: Hey, this is Dr. Ben Weitz, host of the Rational Wellness Podcast. I talk to the leading health and nutrition experts and researchers in the field to bring you the latest in cutting edge health information. Subscribe to the Rational Wellness Podcast for weekly updates. And to learn more, check out my website, drweitz.com. Thanks for joining me. and let’s jump into the podcast.

Hello, Rational Wellness Podcasters. Today, I’ll be speaking with Dr. Kim Crawford about inflammatory bowel disease from an integrative perspective. Inflammatory bowel disease, of which Crohn’s disease and ulcerative colitis are the most common conditions, is an autoimmune disease characterized by chronic inflammation of the gastrointestinal tract that leads to damage to the mucosal lining.  Crohn’s disease can affect any part of the GI tract, including the mouth, esophagus, stomach, and even the anus, and it most often affects the portion of the small intestine closest to the large intestine, and there tends to be patchy areas of damage, and the damage may reach through multiple layers of the intestinal wall.  Ulcerative colitis occurs usually only in the large intestine and the rectum. Damaged areas tend to be continuous and usually start in the rectum and spread into the colon and is usually only found in the innermost lining of the colon. Of course, Dr. Crawford, you can correct me if I’m misstating. 

Dr. Crawford: Good job, Dr. Ben.

Dr. Weitz: And then I wanted to read a couple of sentences from a blog post written by Dr. Crawford about the current allopathic conventional medical care [00:02:00] for inflammatory bowel disease. She writes in this blog post: “Crohn’s disease treatment starts off with brain and gut damaging corticosteroids.  Then we add in immunomodulators like Methotrexate and Mercaptopurine and eventually biological agents, which are TNF alpha inhibitors like Remicade and Humira and the story’s about the same for ulcerative colitis. All these drugs are super toxic, and none of them are curative, and their long term use not only causes severe side effects, but can lead to cancer.”  Dr. Kim Crawford is a nationally recognized board certified internal medicine and anti aging specialist who uses a functional medicine approach to help patients overcome various chronic diseases, including inflammatory bowel disease [00:03:00] like Crohn’s disease. Dr. Crawford herself was exposed to high levels of environmental mycotoxins from mold, which eventually attacked her GI tract and resulted in a chronic inflammatory condition, leaky gut, and eventually Crohn’s disease, which for her was a totally life altering autoimmune disease.  Dr. Crawford, thank you so much for joining us. Oh, I should say Dr. Kim.

Dr. Crawford: Okay. Thank you, Dr. Ben. And excuse me if you hear a dog barking in the background. I do collie rescue. I have four rescue collies here. Somebody might bark a little. It’s not a patient with a respiratory condition. I have four, four big collies here.  So anyway to your point about the treatment It’s not just, let’s say with ulcerative colitis and Crohn’s the allopathic medicine, the GI guys and girls start out with hydrocortisone, but [00:04:00] not bioidentical hydrocortisone, which is what I use. They start out with synthetics like prednisone or Medrol, and you’re not only just dealing with the synthetic hormone, you’re also dealing with capsules that may not be compliant with the dietary restrictions that I use for inflammatory bowel disease. And you’re dealing with fillers. These toxic capsules and fillers are in all pharmaceuticals. Some are actually not as bad as others. For instance, if you need a Tylenol, it’s better to take a Tylenol that is a name brand rather than a generic because it has safer for-your-gut fillers.  That’s just one little tidbit for your viewers there. But anyway, going back to how…

Dr. Weitz: So interesting. So you’ll use a bioidentical cortisol, cortisone, that’s different than Prednisone?  What’s the difference?

Dr. Crawford: Bioidentical hormones, okay? And I am board certified in functional medicine and one of the 12 modules is just hormones and it’s not, and if, I have a blog where I talk about all the hormones.  Everybody thinks about male hormones and female hormones, like testosterone, estrogen. Oh, and there’s other things, but we don’t know what they are. There’s about a hundred hormones we have to think about. One of them is our body, our adrenal glands make cortisol, or we can get bioidentical, meaning the body recognizes it as what you would be putting out, so the body doesn’t get upset.  We use bioidentical hydrocortisone in functional medicine. And when somebody flares they’re, I may use a little bit of bioidentical hydrocortisone. I may use methylene blue, which is an amazing anti-inflammatory, very powerful antioxidant product. Turns your pee blue, but that’s the only side effect.  And it’s also being studied, interestingly enough, for other conditions, neurodegenerative conditions. 

Dr. Weitz: So interesting, so you use methylene blue?

Dr. Crawford: Believe it or not, the dye, methylene blue.

Dr. Weitz: It’s been talked about on other functional medicine podcasts and I don’t know all that much about it.  What is the type of, is there a type of methylene blue or is there a way…is it a oral, is it an injectable? 

Dr. Crawford: The injectable is only necessary for people with a condition for which methylene blue was used decades ago. And so I use an oral form and I use a liposomal, so liposomal preparations get into the bloodstream faster.  Okay. So I’ll use, I use a liposomal preparation, but people who are there they go. Sorry. Thank you. People who are flaring really do respond to methylene blue and, it is over the counter, but I would just advise people not to, with inflammatory bowel disease, not to treat themselves.  But certainly if you want to, if you want to ask Chat GPT about methylene blue, Chat GPT, I’m sure will have a lot to say. Sorry.

Dr. Weitz: What’s the dosage of methylene blue that you typically use? 

Dr. Crawford: Anywhere between 25 and 50 milligrams twice daily when somebody’s flaring.  That’s the dose I’ll use. And again, I find that liposomal just tends to work better than regular.

Dr. Weitz: Is there a particular company that you like it from that makes a good product?

Dr. Crawford: I have a compounding pharmacy that I use, that compounds it for me.

Dr. Weitz: Oh, okay. Interesting. When you get a patient in your office, what’s the first thing that makes you suspect that they might, this might be somebody dealing with inflammatory bowel disease?

Dr. Crawford: Before I actually see somebody, I know what the diagnosis is [00:08:00] because my first visit with somebody is a very long visit. We go over many things, everything from exercise to sleep to stress habits. And what makes me suspect it quite frankly, most of the people that come to me have been treated by, allopathic doctors and are on a biologic and they have been switched, a biologic will tend to work for 18 to 24 months, then they’ll switch them to another, then they’ll switch them to another.  And they’ve been through this a few times and maybe they’ve had COVID one too many times and maybe they keep getting other infections.  They’re a bit immunosuppressed and they just, and they read that, gee, maybe I can get off of this stuff. And half the patients with IBD that come to me are already diagnosed.  And the other half I see a lot of patients with CIRS, Chronic Inflammatory Response Syndrome, or mold related illness what I had. And and when I had it, I was, nobody even knew what it was or knew how to treat it. So I had to figure [00:09:00] that out. I had to figure out when I developed Crohn’s, which I now could go back and block myself from getting, which is what I do if I see it brewing in a CIRS patient or a chronic Lyme patient.  I had to figure that all out too. So I really, a lot of times they’ll come to me and say, and they’re starting to get GI symptoms and I see that their CRP, Which is a lab that I’m, I know you’re familiar with, it’s a inflammatory marker and most people think it’s a coronary marker, but it’s really a better marker it’s the first thing you’ll see bump up in just about any autoimmune disease.

But somebody who’s trying, I say trying to develop, because it doesn’t just happen overnight, okay, trying to develop inflammatory bowel disease is going to have, maybe they’ll have a little belly pain, a little blood if it’s you see some diarrhea. It’s not, don’t get nervous. It’s not necessary IBD if you have diarrhea, people that are exposed to [00:10:00] mold or any other toxins by definition have leaky gut and you need to have leaky gut in order to develop inflammatory bowel disease.

So patients, you said, what makes me think they have it? They either come to me diagnosed or they come to me having had an exposure or something that people don’t realize. They come to me after a long period of stress, when they’re stressed, and their catecholamines are up, the neurotransmitters that make our heart go faster, the sympathetic side of our nervous system and their cortisol is up.  And cortisol actually, not only kills brain cells, it kills the lining of our gut. And so just a sustained high cortisol or a period, if somebody is going through a divorce or if somebody has a, loses a parent or any other, tragic thing that gets us all upset and stressed and raises our cortisol, makes us stressed, upsets our sleep.  That [00:11:00] is going to give somebody leaky gut.

Dr. Weitz: So as far as your workup for testing for a patient with inflammatory bowel disease, besides the CRP, I’m assuming you’re using like the high sensitivity CRP, what other labs do you run and do you recommend colonoscopy or other testing?

Dr. Crawford: I do complete labs on everybody, which everybody tells me is 20 tubes of blood.  Sorry, Barkadar. I hope you’re, I hope your viewers are dog lovers. I have two dogs myself, oh good job. Adopt, don’t shop. I check full labs because everybody with an inflammatory disorder, okay, is going to have other things that just the inflammation causes. For instance, if you’re inflamed, You’re going to be plaquing your arteries.  If [00:12:00] you’re inflamed, there’s going to be a diminution of output of the hormones that you need. If you’re inflamed, there’s going to be impaired enzymatic pathways. For instance, your SIRT1 pathway can be impaired, and that’s the pathway that controls glucose and cholesterol. I deal with the inflammation, just everybody gets a vagal nerve stimulation device because everybody’s in sympathetic, sympathetic side of the autonomic system is the, escape the wildebeest side.  And then the parasympathetic side is the rest and digest. And so I want people to get more into the parasympathetic side. Everybody comes to me, their cortisol’s are up, they’re in sympathetic overdrive. And that’s why one of the first things I do, I need to calm everything down I have them get a vagal nerve stimulation device.  I have them start managing their stress. Just about all of them are not [00:13:00] sleeping well.

Dr. Weitz: For listeners who don’t know what a vagal nerve stimulating device is. Can you explain that for a bit?

Dr. Crawford: I’m very, yeah, very sorry. I do have a blog on that. If people want to go to kimcrawfordmd. com, there’s a blog on that.  Basically it’s. A little handheld device and, oh, here’s an old one I have right here. And you just hold it against your neck, two minutes, twice a day. And it stimulates the vagus nerve, which is the longest nerve in the body. And it goes all through the nervous system. And if you’re feeling stressed and you put this little zapper on your neck, it will make it’ll increase your GABA, which is a neuro hormone that makes you feel calm. That’s the neuro hormone that goes up. If you take a Xanax or a Valium, which you shouldn’t take, you should use a vagal nerve stimulation device or use some liposomal GABA. Anyway, so that’s a vagal nerve stimulation device can help people fall asleep, can help [00:14:00] people get back to sleep and can reduce their stress levels.  And it’s been found in studies lately that people with inflammatory bowel disease tend to be higher stressed than the average bear. And and so everybody needs help with their stress and their sleep. Just losing one night of sleep will bump up everybody’s inflammatory markers.  Losing a week of sleep will make somebody, not a, not, a whole week of sleep, but let’s say somebody gets really bad sleep for a week for whatever reason. That’s enough to flare them. So it’s really important to manage stress, manage sleep. Everybody’s on the Uber rings, kick, it really is important.  Sleep is important. Stress management, diet. Exercise, all those basics have to be covered for everyone, but especially for the patient with inflammatory bowel. And let me go back to your last question about diagnoses. If someone is flaring, The traditional [00:15:00] literature, American Journal of Gastroenterology even, is saying don’t scope them.  Don’t get a colonoscopy if you’re flaring. And there is some GI docs that are still scoping people that are flaring, but you can actually perforate somebody who’s flaring. And it’s really, if you get a, what’s called a Fecal Calprotectin it’s a stool sample that’s very diagnostic. If somebody has an elevated CRP and sedimentation rate which are two inflammatory markers, and they have a high fecal calprotectin along with the symptoms of Crohn’s or UC, you can basically make the diagnosis without a colonoscopy.  You can also do. MRE imaging and imaging studies if you need to look at the small intestine, then you would need to do that with Crohn’s but just to make the diagnosis, just as I said before, you can make it without a colonoscopy with biopsies are needed for a definitive diagnosis [00:16:00] and to make sure you’re diagnosing Once in a while, you’ll get a crony that will bleed, and you need biopsies to make sure you’re diagnosing Crohn’s, not Ulcerative Colitis.  So that’s why you would need a colonoscopy with biopsies, it’s just for the definitive diagnosis. But for my purposes, if somebody’s really sick I don’t want to, obviously, first do no harm. I don’t want them to have anything done to them that’s going to make them worse, obviously. Yeah. ,

Dr. Weitz:  Have you used that Prometheus lab for inflammatory bowel disease?

Dr. Crawford: Prometheus Lab? I use LabCorp. They Okay. Thus far, LabCorp has given me what I need. Yeah.

Dr. Weitz: There’s some specialty lab thing for IBD.

Dr. Crawford: Yeah, there, you know what, there are so many companies that are opening up, they’re offering specialty labs or specialty, microbiome tests.  There’s one good one, and it’s the one I use. Which one do you like? It’s [00:17:00] actually, it’s, the company is, Enjoy, I N J O Y. And what’s cool about them is they give you a report that’s really actionable. Foods, probiotics, prebiotics, and they break down for you. What are the, what’s in your microbiome?  That’s bad for your inflammatory bowel disease. That’s bad for your metabolic state. They look at, how much you your microbiome produces three important free. Short chain fatty acids, say that three times. Short chain fatty acids. 

Dr. Weitz:  Butyrate, propionate, and acetate, right?

Dr. Crawford:  Good job.  Yeah. How many people know that? And it’s important to be producing enough of these things. And have enough good bacteria and not have bad bacteria. And, I, this company uses a, uses AI. It’s the only company I know of that does microbiome testing that’s using AI. And you get a subscription for, I think it’s 1.99 a month, and you can you put your symptoms [00:18:00] in and you get, and you can ask the chat bot questions. And there’s a little bathroom beacon. It’s quite interesting. And it’s a three sample test and it’s enjoy. You can find it in your app store and you can use my code DrKim10 and get it and get a 10 percent discount.

Dr. Weitz:  Interesting. Yeah. I’ve never used that.

Dr. Crawford:  Very important to get a good microbiome test. Yeah, even I, when this test finally got perfected and I did my test, even I found I had one, I had too much of a bacteria that was good to have if you had Crohn’s and the reason I had it was because I was eating, um, too much high fat dairy, which is not supposed to be AIP compliant, but as a re entry food, I was able to eat it, but anyway, I found only because of this [00:19:00] microbiome test, which is why I keep eating it. telling everyone, you really, you don’t know what’s in your gut unless it gets tested.  I tell everybody, you, you got to do at least one because if you’ve had any sort of disorder, what, whatsoever, it’s generally can be traced back to the microbiome and the data is evolving, but you’re reading studies, the same studies I’m seeing that, we’re, they’re linking it to obesity, metabolic health sorry, we have Arthur.

Dr. Weitz: It’s okay.

Dr. Crawford: Ob, sorry, obesity, me, meta metabolic issues. Inflammatory bowel. You know what let me ask my husband to let to Sadie quiet.

Dr. Weitz: Okay.

Dr. Crawford: You can, maybe you can cut that out.

Dr. Weitz: Yeah, I’ll cut that out.

Dr. Crawford: Sorry. I’m so sorry.

Dr. Weitz: What are the what are some of your favorite strategies for when you see a [00:20:00] patient and let’s say you see them and they’re having an acute flare?  What are some of the things that you like to use?

Dr. Crawford: In an acute flare, I, they go on a very strict AIP diet. Okay,

Dr. Weitz: what is AIP?

Dr. Crawford: Okay, Autoimmune Protocol, and people can find copies of that all over the internet.

Dr. Weitz: So this is an autoimmune paleo diet?

Dr. Crawford: It it is an autoimmune diet. It’s not a paleo diet because paleo diet.  But it’s similar and here’s why it’s similar. It’s similar because it’s no grains, no beans. The typical paleo, but paleo implies we want you to eat a lot of meat. And I don’t want anybody to eat quote a lot of meat. That’s just not good for you. But I would say to take out

Dr. Weitz: greens, beans, and then you also

Dr. Crawford: You take out initially you have to take out everything that’s paleo.  Okay, you look [00:21:00] at a paleo diet and in it’s alcohol, caffeine, and don’t hate me because I do allow you to re intro that back in. I am not coffee free anymore and I am not alcohol free anymore. So don’t worry, you won’t be either. But it’s paleo, which is No grains, no beans, no alcohol, no caffeine, no dairy.  And then also dairy and then no, no nightshade vegetables and nightshade spices and nightshades. You can Google what are nightshades, but it’s basically peppers and peppers, tomatoes, potatoes. Those are the big ones. And then you have to look at your spices. That was one of my problems is I like hot, spicy food.

And so my whole diet had to get much more bland than I wanted it to be. But I will say that we do what are called re intros when somebody says, Stable, and they’ve been in a nice remission, and one of the re intros is, this is going to [00:22:00] sound strange, but people can’t usually tolerate hot coffee, but they can tolerate iced coffee, and but and But some people can’t, and there were coffee alternatives, like there’s a company, Tachino, that makes coffee ish.

Dr. Weitz: Interesting,what’s the, why do you think that they can tolerate cold coffee versus hot coffee?

Dr. Crawford: That hasn’t been studied, and I just think, I just tried this on myself. And so it was an experiment because I just love coffee. I just love it. Okay. And I have some patients now sipping iced coffee.  And it hasn’t been studied. I don’t know, but. But, heat or hot food does cause peristalsis, whereas cold food causes less peristalsis, or, moving things along the segments in the small intestine and large intestine, so it might have something to do with the peristalsis.  I don’t really know. But but it’s not AIP compliant. So anyway, you asked about if somebody comes to me and they’re in a [00:23:00] flare, right? They’re immediate AIP. No, but even if people think they’re eating AIP, they’re usually not because for instance, Eggs are off it and they’re eating eggs, but you can have duck eggs and quail eggs on AIP.  So there’s that. Or they’re having some, they’re having some dairy and initially we have to cut out all dairy. 

Dr. Weitz: You take out nuts and seeds. Yeah,

Dr. Crawford: nuts and seeds, just like paleo. And those are a re intro that many people can re intro. So it’s not like you’re, you’re going to be without all these things forever, but just till you get out of your flare.  When somebody’s in a flare, they get the, all the peptides that I use, which are about five peptides. They get low dose naltrexone. They, now they get methylene blue. They get bio they probably get bioidentical hydrocortisone. And I also use if it just depends if I can’t get them out of the flare, which not good, hasn’t happened yet, but if I can’t get somebody out quickly after the [00:24:00] flare, I’ll have them come to the office and I’ll give them IV exosomes which are the little nanopods that they get out of the stem cells.  And then that will nuke the flare right there. Really? Interesting. Yeah.

Dr. Weitz: And It’s the first time I’ve heard using Exosomes for IBD.

Dr. Crawford: Oh yeah, it works wonders. Yeah. And it also and also if somebody wants to consolidate I use exosomes for many conditions, but for IBD and CIRS, they’re very useful.

Dr. Weitz: Interesting. Have you used ozone?

Dr. Crawford: Yes what people aren’t really fond of ozone even though it really, it does work. You have to have a sealed gut to be able to, to get Really the best effects. And so that means you already ha have to have had a couple of weeks of one of the peptides I use that seals the gut but oz ozone.  What people don’t [00:25:00] understand about ozone is you can go to the doctor’s office and get IV ozone for whatever that doctor charges. Per pop. Usually one 50 to two 50. Okay. Or you can use ho ozone and use intra rectal ozone, which actually works great when somebody is flaring.  You just have to use a real low dose. But int Rectal Ozone gives you 75% of the results that IV will, and it’s. for pennies on the dollar. And you can do it yourself. And so I personally have used intrarectal ozone. And I do have a few patients, but most patients are just ooeyed out at the whole prospect of sticking a tiny little catheter up their butt.  They just can’t take it. They can have diarrhea 25 times a night, but they won’t stick a little catheter up their butt. Go figure. But yeah ozone is helpful. And there are other modalities which are additive. There’s a lot of conversation about red light [00:26:00] therapy.  Red light therapy, if somebody’s flaring is helpful. And the easiest way to get red light therapy, easiest and quickest and cheapest, without having to go find a doctor, is join a Planet Fitness. Get a black card membership and that’s, I think it’s 25 bucks a month and that allows you to use their red light pod, which is a very good red light pod and you can go every day.  You could go twice a day. 

Dr. Weitz: And it’s just like a full body red light thing? 

Dr. Crawford: Yeah. Okay. And you just get in the pod and join a plan of fitness and use their red light pod. There you go.

Dr. Weitz: There you go.

Dr. Crawford: Yeah. And people ask about hyperbaric oxygen. That’s a little additive, but not a lot.  And people ask about cryotherapy. It’s a little additive, especially if there’s a lot of fatigue. That helps fatigue, not a lot. I, for fatigue, I’d rather just give them NAD trochees. NAD is the, there’s a lot of buzz about NAD and nicotinamide mononucleotide. And [00:27:00] that’s, Inflammatory bowel disease, just like all inflammatory diseases, is a mitochondria disease, a disease of the mitochondria, which are the cells of respiration. And there’s less ATP, adenine triphosphate production from your mitochondria. And so that’s why people with inflammatory disorders, including IBD, feel fatigued and you give them NAD and boom, that, that fixes the fatigue. So would you ever prescribe a biologic?  Oh, hell no. Are you kidding me? I write, I prescribe pharmaceuticals every once in a while if they’re needed. For instance, for hypertension, I use metformin for glucose control, not for anti aging because there’s really no subspecialty called anti aging and the data on continuous glucose monitoring and metformin use really isn’t there for age extension for life extension or [00:28:00] cellular life extension.  But I do use metformin if somebody’s blood sugar isn’t controllable with, for instance, berberine, etc. But would I, When I developed Crohn’s, I thought to myself, there is no way in the world I’m taking a biologic and and I thought I’m just gonna look around PubMed and try things and figure this out, which is what I did.

Dr. Weitz: Do you find that a percentage of your patients with IBD also have SIBO?

Dr. Crawford: You know what because they’re CIRS patients. Okay, just about everybody who’s living in a moldy house and the mold mycotoxin mix is always, it’s mold, mycotoxins, dust mites, actinomyces, the endotoxins, other bacteria, and they, a huge proportion of those patients get SIBO and SIFO.  Huge percentage. probably 80 percent. Of my just Crohn’s or just UC patients who are not [00:29:00] moldies I would say it’s less than 50 percent, but I do, I do check for that.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. So what do you do when they have mycotoxins, you test for mycotoxins and you put them on like a mycotoxin detox protocol?

Dr. Crawford: It’s a bit more complicated than that, but a lot of doctors test for mycotoxins in the pee and Which is silly, that’s not diagnostic. That tells us, that tells us you’re eating American food. American food is loaded with mycotoxins. From grains to beans to coffee to milk.  Mycotoxins are in every, are in everything. So if you’re peeing out mycotoxins, unless it’s a very unusual one, like for instance, gliotoxin, which is made by Stachybotrys, which is normally not found in the food supply. So if somebody’s got a lot of That one you can infer they’re getting it environmentally, but the way you test for Sears is you check the innate immune system.

You check [00:30:00] labs that conventional doctors don’t check, a TGF Beta 1, an MSH, an MMP9 things that other doctors probably haven’t even heard of. And then the first thing I do is, there’s two patients in mold. The house or, or the house in the house, who knows people have more than one house, they have a workplace.

So we’ve got those patients to deal with. And then we have the sick person who’s a patient, but you have to have all those environmental patients. clean enough to support the detoxing of the patient. And the first thing that has to happen that I see patients that come to me and other doctors haven’t fixed their guts, and if they’ve got a leaky gut, which by definition they have, they’re going to, and they’re given binders before they’re gut sealed.  then the binder binds in their GI tract and it goes right out the leaky gut, right into the bloodstream, and there’s leaky gut means you’ve got a leaky gut brain barrier, goes right into the brain, and so everybody who [00:31:00] comes to me who’s somebody’s put on, yes, who’s somebody’s put on detox agents, they’ll tell me, Oh, I 10 minutes after I take it, I feel terrible.  Yeah, because you’re binding the toxins, and then you’re releasing them into your bloodstream. That’s why you feel terrible. So anybody out there who’s taking binders, who hasn’t had their gut fixed, That’s why you feel lousy after you take the binders. So right. Yep.

Dr. Weitz: So you got to fix the gut first,

Dr. Crawford: fix the gut.  And then I do a lot of tissue repair with peptides and everybody’s hormones are messed up. Everybody’s inflamed. I do my thing for inflammation. Everybody’s having sleep issues because of a of a number of things that happen in Sears. Yeah. Gotta fix the sleep. As I mentioned before, lack of sleep is very inflammatory in and of itself.  But back to the topics you want to talk about, Ben.

Dr. Weitz: One of the things you mentioned on your website was that there are natural ways to inhibit TNF alpha besides taking [00:32:00] biologics. Maybe you can talk about some of the nutritional supplements that can be of some benefit here.

Dr. Crawford: These will tend to lower what I’m going to mention, but they don’t necessarily have a clinical impact.  So I would tell people, don’t think you can treat yourself with, quercetin and curcumin and resveratrol. Those are the big ones, the TNF modulators. Those are all very good supplements, but they’re not necessarily going to make a clinical difference. Okay. They might make a little, but curcumin, for instance, is not AIP compliant.  So when I have people that come to me taking a whole bunch of curcumin, a lot of times they’re just exacerbating their inflammatory bowel disease.

Dr. Weitz: Oh, interesting, huh?

Dr. Crawford: Yeah. Yeah.

Dr. Weitz: My experience has been the opposite on that one. I find curcumin very helpful for inflammation within the gut.

Dr. Crawford: Okay. Okay. [00:33:00] Inflammation in the gut is one thing, but if they have a diagnosis of inflammation related

Dr. Weitz: to an inflammatory bowel disease.  Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Okay.

Dr. Crawford: We’ve had you know what? So many of my patients have way more than just inflammatory bowel disease. And, have so many other things going on because they usually have chronic Lyme or Sears along with inflammatory bowel. And they, and sometimes, like half the time they’ll have, They’ll come to me with two or three autoimmune diseases.  There’s a lot more than just inflammatory bowel going on. Sure. 

Dr. Weitz: Patients who have one inflammatory bowel autoimmune disease are more prone to others.

Dr. Crawford: Absolutely. And once you get leaky gut, you are, you are genetically, there’s all, it’s who in your family had an autoimmune disease? If you get leaky gut.  You gotta be very careful.

Dr. Weitz: Does pretty much all your patients who come to see you for IBD end up on this [00:34:00] autoimmune diet? Or do you sometimes test for food sensitivities and and, customize it that way?

Dr. Crawford: You know what people with Sears develop food sensitivities and people with at a more rapid rate than people with just IBD, but people with IBD develop food sensitivities.  Now, there’s food sensitivities and food allergies. Sure. IgA mediated, IgG mediated, and IgE mediated. And the IgE mediated are like the peanut allergies. And that’s very rare. That’s, that’s a medical emergency. And so you’ve got to test if you believe there’s any IgE, throat closing, wheezing, hive, if there’s any of those reactions.

You check IgE levels to the foods you suspect and you get somebody an EpiPen, blah, blah, blah. If somebody just has food sensitivities, many times someone will come in to me with a [00:35:00] laundry list of food sensitivities. And rather than do, immunoglobulin testing to every single food, I give patients a choice, but they tend to know which foods are bothering them.

And the thing about food sensitivities in association with either Sears or Chronic Lyme or inflammatory bowel, etc, is they tend to reverse. And of course everybody needs to be on AIP. That’s like the The foundation of, that’s like step one of treating an autoimmune disease. And let me mention that there’s a Facebook group you can go on to, to find recipes, just look up autoimmune protocol.

It’s a really good Facebook group. I’m not trying to give Mark Zuckerberg more business here, but it’s a very good Facebook group and you can get recipes and Please cook something and send it to me. Cause I hate to cook. But anyway, yeah, I look at these recipes and I go, Oh, that looks great. Maybe I can find somebody to make that for me.

Dr. Weitz: I know. How [00:36:00] long do you keep your patients on the autoimmune diet or do they stay on nap for life?

Dr. Crawford: Until we can reset the genes with CRISPR. Autoimmune diseases go into remission, but you don’t cure them. What you can do with the exosomes, if somebody has got the finances and they want to do it, is you can calm it down because that, what’s in the exosomes mix that I get, and I, I can’t go into that because the FDA isn’t crazy about us using these things.  Isn’t great. The FDA just quite frankly, isn’t crazy about. functional doctors using things that are not pharmaceuticals. I’m just going to put that out there. I’m not a conspiracy theorist. I’m just saying pharmaceutical companies want you to buy pharmaceuticals. And there’s been a, like a, they’re going after certain things.  And now and now they’re looking at hemp products, which is where [00:37:00] we get CBD products, which are. which are also very useful for people with inflammatory bowel disease for pain, for sleep. There’s, really great sleep CBD products. They’re thinking

Dr. Weitz: about taking those off the market.

Dr. Crawford: They’re talking about that now, and they just took off some peptides. And they’re looking at exosomes. So I don’t like to really. Talk about it a lot, but I will say that that exosomes not only can get somebody out of a flare, but they can make them flare less.  Somebody with Crohn’s this hasn’t been studied. I’m just going to give you, I’m not big on doctors using anecdotal information, but I will tell you 15 years, which is how long I’ve been treating this I’ve just noticed that stress and lack of sleep is way, it flares my Crohn’s patients way quicker than it flares my UC patients.  It flares them too, so everybody, not to sound like a broken record, but everybody has got to do active stress management and [00:38:00] active sleep management. as well as dietary management and exercise management. I have one kid who’s a I’m just going to say that he’s a, he’s going to be a professional athlete.  And if he plays his sport too much, that can cause GI problems, because all the, The catecholamines, the, the adrenaline epinephrine that’s released when he is playing his sport. That, that’s hit in the gut. So everything really, about the lifestyle has to be managed.  And my favorite expression to use is don’t let this get your cortisol up. Whatever the news is, don’t let it get your cortisol up. ’cause that means you’re damaging your brain and you’re damaging your gut.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. Um, so let’s see what else you you talk about other things that can reduce TNF alpha and you mentioned ice baths, saunas, things like that.

Dr. Crawford: Yeah again, [00:39:00] not incredibly clinically relevant, ice baths and saunas are both a form of what we call hormesis, and we know that hormesis is really good For the human organism and hormesis is anything from timed eating to intermittent fasting to HIIT, high intestinal in high intensity interval training.  Sauna use ice plunges. All of that helps every inflammatory condition will raise your happy hormones, may extend cellular longevity, so all of those modalities are actually good to put in clinical practice for anybody. I would recommend it. say that, you don’t want to do all of them at once.  For instance cold plunges are quite good, but you don’t want to start doing HIIT, intermittent fasting, cold plunges saunas. You don’t want to start that all at once. If [00:40:00] you don’t know where to start, get a good functional doctor. And I think probably some coaches know how to talk you through these modalities too.

Dr. Weitz: You mentioned Methylene Blue. Can you explain what Methylene Blue is, and how that can be beneficial, and what dosages you use, etc.?

Dr. Crawford: Methylene Blue was discovered as a dye. And that sounds ooh, that’s disgusting. It was used

Dr. Weitz: to look at at Slides under a microscope, right?

Dr. Crawford: When I was in medical school we used to draw blood, put it under a microscope and, and look for certain bacteria with it.  So that was the use of the original use. It’s now been repurposed and it’s given as a medication. And functional doctors are using it for for different reasons. It’s being studied as a antibacterial and an anti malarial. There are definitely antiviral, antibacterial, antifungal properties to it.

It hasn’t been fully studied, [00:41:00] but but I will tell you on a personal level, I don’t take antibiotics. If I think that something is needed or I will take some Methylene Blue because antibiotics are really kind of death to the microbiome. If you need them, if it’s a life threatening thing, go ahead, but but if it’s not life threatening, don’t think that every time you get handed a prescription for antibiotics that you actually need it.  Really, think about it before you take antibiotics, proton pump inhibitors Motrin, Aleve any, all of that stuff is just really bad for your gut. 

Dr. Weitz: Methylene blue, is this, you use an oral formulation or an injectable and in what dosage and then how long a period of time do you use it for?  Is this something you do ongoing?

Dr. Crawford: If somebody’s flaring, this is one of my flare meds. Okay. If they also have a neurodegenerative condition as as is associated with Sears, which is what I see a lot of, I see a lot of people that have been diagnosed with [00:42:00] Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s, but they really have severe.  Sears. And and this is being studied. Methylene blue is being studied for neurodegenerative conditions and I’m following that data. And sometimes even before data is published and finalized, I’ll use something if it really looks promising and it looks good. I’ll use it for flares. And as a nice side effect, it’s going to help clean up, clear up their noggin and I’ll use between 25 and 50 milligrams twice a day.  I use liposomal preparations work far better than just the over the counter powdered stuff you can get. And if you’re getting stuff over the counter, be very careful because what’s in the capsules and What’s the capsules are made out of, okay, may be toxic and the fillers that are being used may be toxic.  And that, that really is the case for the bulk of the pharmaceuticals out there. So when I get things compounded, I make sure I get a clear dye free veggie cap. And I make sure [00:43:00] that the fillers that are used, those are the inactive ingredients. If you’re looking at the label, And I’ll make sure that the fillers are non toxic.  For instance this isn’t going to sound toxic.

Dr. Weitz: Methylene, Methylene Blue is over the counter or it’s prescription?

Dr. Crawford: I get it. I use prescription Methylene Blue. Because I like Liposomal. I’m just saying people can find it. Okay. Over the counter. I wouldn’t recommend using it. But, people are going to use what they’re going to use.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. But it is available over the counter. Okay.

Dr. Crawford: I’m pretty sure it is. Yeah.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. And so methylene blue has an anti inflammatory effect. Is that its main benefit or what?

Dr. Crawford: It’s a potent antioxidant and it’s a potent anti inflammatory. Yeah, those are the two properties. And you asked about IV use.  IV isn’t necessary. IV is only needed in certain blood disgraces that have nothing to do with what we’re talking about, but [00:44:00] for our purposes, it’s oral. Yes.

Dr. Weitz: All right. And then talk about low dose naltrexone, LDN.

Dr. Crawford: Yeah, low dose naltrexone. People know naltrexone as an, as a, Probably they’ve heard of it or a related drug.  Narcan can, as something that reverses opioid ingestion, excess ingestions. But low dose naltrexone, not the 50 milligrams that’s used to reverse, reverse problems, but very low dose, meaning I start somebody at 0.5 milligrams. Okay. Work, work my way up. That, causes the pituitary to release growth factors and pain stopping factors and endorphins and enkephalins, which are like your natural pain relievers.  And those, Mod, help modulate the inflammatory response. So [00:45:00] LDN, and people can Google, or ask, don’t ask chat, GPT. I don’t know what chat, GPT is going to tell you. But there are websites on what does LDN work for? Are you a candidate for LDN? And LDN, just like everything else, can be used. prepared in a good way that’s not going to harm your gut or a bad way that’s going to harm your gut.

So when people tell me, Oh, I got, they come to me and they tell me, Oh, I got this cheap LDN and it didn’t seem to work. And then they show me what they got. They got something with a toxic filler. Sometimes I’ll see like filler is brown, dried brown rice, which doesn’t sound toxic. But if you’ve got, if you’ve got inflammatory bowel disease and you take a capsule of dried brown rice, It could flare you right there, just that one capsule.

So LDN has to be prepared correctly. It has to be made not from the crushed tablets because the [00:46:00] tablets have bad fillers in them. So you have to get LDN that’s made from powder and they put it with clean fillers in a clean capsule and then you go up very slowly or it can mess up your sleep.  That’s why I go up slowly on the dosing.

Dr. Weitz: All right, good.

Dr. Crawford: Okay, and so that is another component for most people of their therapy.

Dr. Weitz: It sounds like there’s a lot of things that can be used. And do you often use a lot of these all at one time or you pick and choose?

Dr. Crawford: It’s very dependent on the patient.  An ulcerative colitis patient is generally easier for me to get under control than a Crohn’s patient. So maybe they won’t need all five peptides, but the Crohn’s patients, they all need all five peptides and they all need to more carefully manage their stress. And they all need to do the vagal nerve stimulation more than the UC patients.  It’s, but it’s, I individualize. When you see, [00:47:00] when you see a patient, you individualize their therapy and I individualize the therapies that the patients I see as well.

Dr. Weitz: All right, great. So I, I think that’s the questions I had prepared. Anything else you want to tell us about?

Dr. Crawford: No, I just let me see. When we talked about, I don’t want people to get, diseases. Okay, so let’s talk about. So we don’t

Dr. Weitz: just cure them from their autoimmune disease, we want to make them healthier.

Dr. Crawford: You know what? I don’t want them to get an autoimmune disease because I can’t cure that right now.  I can. Quasi reset the epigenome with the exosomes. We can wait for CRISPR, but I don’t want to wait till people get these diseases. I want them not to get it. So how do you not get inflammatory bowel disease? What are the things that cause leaky gut? The main things. Okay. They’re eating ultra processed foods, the standard American [00:48:00] diet, so the first thing is you got to eat a healthy diet.  Second thing, we talked about how high cortisol can damage your gut line and give you leaky gut. You want to manage your stress. Number three, you want to avoid toxins. You want to make sure your house is not moldy. 50 percent of the houses in the U. S. are moldy. 25 percent of the people in the U. S. have the genetic makeup to develop Sears.

So you do the math, that’s millions of people walking around with other diagnoses and they’re just not getting the help they need and they’re not getting the mold cleared up in their house. And this goes to everything from mold to the bad types of seaweed that wash up to heavy metals, everybody should know by now not to eat tuna fish every day.

Like somebody running for president, I won’t mention names. Yeah. Thanks. Okay. But toxins, stress, lack of [00:49:00] sleep eating a bad diet. Those are really the main, those are the main reasons people get leaky gut. If you just take a look at your lifestyle, and if you need help, get a lifestyle coach.

Or, somebody who can help you with the big things. What should you eat? How should you exercise? How do you sleep better? How do you manage your stress better? Those are all the things that can keep you healthy. Manage your environment, get a nice air purifier, make sure you don’t have mold.

Mold sniffing dogs, by the way, I’m obviously a dog fan, but mold sniffing dogs, find mold 95 to 99 percent of the time and human inspectors find the mold about half the time. Oh, really? Really. I’ve had so many patients where they have a, the human inspector comes in and here’s the whole inspection report and here’s the samples and this is the mold it shows and then I put them on treatment and then, and then three months later.

I think [00:50:00] they’re doing well, and then all of a sudden they flare. And what’s the problem? Get a mold dog. The mold dog comes in and goes woof in the bathroom, and it’s behind the, and there’s more mold behind the tiles in the bathroom. I’m mentioning all of this just because it all ties back to inflammatory bowel, because a lot of people who develop mold illness will, if it runs in their family, will develop an autoimmune illness.

Dr. Weitz: We didn’t touch really on the on the microbiome. And I know you like to do a microbiome analysis, you mentioned, and then work on improving the health of the gut. So we didn’t talk about

Dr. Crawford: that. I don’t think we

Dr. Weitz: really did. Yeah. We just mentioned that you like to use a a certain microbiome analysis, but let’s talk about that.  And you get this microbiome analysis, this stool test,

Dr. Crawford: which

Dr. Weitz: is using old genome sequencing. Is that what it’s using?

Dr. Crawford: Yeah. Okay. And it’s basically sequencing your entire Microbiome. Okay. But it’s categorizing [00:51:00] it very nicely. And you can see if you do it, if you do it, you’ll get a report and everything is categorized for, not only just do you have a normal amount of firmicutes to bacteroidetes ratio.  The two main kingdom types of command, all specter kingdom. Yeah. Kingdom, Order, Class, Phylum, Genus, Species, but, the two kingdoms, do you, and then do you have enough diversity? And so you want a diverse microbiome. And then are you making the short chain fatty acids?  And then it goes through the sections. Here are the bacteria that you have or you don’t have associated with. inflammatory bowel disease. Oh, and here’s what you can do about it. And here’s the ones associated with metabolic disorders. And here’s what you can do about it. So the whole report basically has you altering your diet, maybe adding certain prebiotics.

For instance I will look at somebody’s report and I will look at the suggested foods and I’ll come up with okay, [00:52:00] once a week, I want you to make up your. Prebiotic Smoothie, and then here’s the probiotic I want you to take because this is what’s, and then here are the foods I don’t want you to eat because you got too much of this.  And for instance, a typical prebiotic smoothie recipe would be and I try to make it easy for everybody, is you grab a bag of frozen organic spinach, and you grab three apples and then you grab a can of unsweetened pineapple. That’s like your basic, nothing fancy here and you mix it all up.  It tastes just fine. You put it, you get little glass bottles, you freeze them, and every day you take one out for the next day. And you, if you take that with your probiotic, you’ve got a prebiotic and a probiotic, and your probiotic is going to take hold quicker. We know, for instance, Ackermansia is a probiotic that is essential for maintenance of the [00:53:00] gut lining.  And it’s amazing. Some people have none when you do their microbiome analysis. And so obviously those people, you give them that, but so it’ll take hold better. I have them drink whatever their prebiotic profile is in their report. I’ll have them do a smoothie that will, that will cover it.  And help their acromantia, if that’s the probiotic, take hold quicker.

Dr. Weitz: What about some of the prebiotic products on the market?

Dr. Crawford: There is nothing, I have tried them. There’s nothing that I find palatable out there.

Dr. Weitz: Okay.

Dr. Crawford: So I just have found nothing palatable. There are oligosaccharide, fructosaccharide mixes that are used for infants.  And that’s actually palatable. But it’s got too much, I call it goulash, when they put extra stuff that they don’t need to put that there’s too much goulash in the the commercially available. That’s why I have everybody just make their own. No [00:54:00] preservatives, no, no chemicals, no junk.

Dr. Weitz: And then how do you decide which probiotics to use?

Dr. Crawford: I will look at their profile, right? I will see As an example this one company I use, Enjoy, and my code is drkim10 for a discount. Okay. They will tell you you may have heard the term psychobiotics. And if you haven’t, it’s a term you’ll be hearing because we know that depression, anxiety manic depressive disorder, schizophrenia.  All sorts of things that we call psychological disorders are really neurological disorders and they’re, and they are primarily based in the gut. All things really do start from the gut. And so the psychobiotics are the things that will increase your good hormones and the things that you want. And one of the things I mentioned was GABA, Amino Butyric Acid, which is the thing that makes us [00:55:00] relax.

And this report measures your GABA. Now, we know in the literature that there are certain strains of bacteria that will produce GABA. And so I will pick a probiotic for a person who’s anxious and can’t fall asleep at night, that person needs more GABA. And I’ll give them a prebiotic drink with a probiotic with strains in it that are known to increase GABA.  That’s just a one of the four examples. But there’s a whole bunch of things that I take into consideration. And the data is evolving. Every week, even in the mainstream literature, I see probably 10 articles. In my functional literature, I see probably 30 articles talking about the relationship between the microbiome and other parameters of health.

Dr. Weitz: One of the tricky things though is, you can do one of these as stool analysis and see, say the patient is low on a, lactobacillus rhamnosus or [00:56:00] something. And then, but unfortunately, most of the data doesn’t show that if you take a probiotic with lactobacillus rhamnosus, that it becomes a permanent resident.

Dr. Crawford: That’s why you take it with a prebiotic drink. And just about everybody has enough of that, of lactobacillus remnosus. The plantarum is available, and that helps bloating. There are You know, Adalentis is available. That helps GABA. And again we’re really just at the beginning of the probiotic, prebiotic, and functional foods.  And this is going to be a thing. Functional foods. We’re just starting to explore those avenues. And AI is really helping this company. I think AI used correctly. And if we teach the chatterers, if we teach them what they need to know, which [00:57:00] is don’t come kill us, please.  But if we control AI, then it’s a useful tool for us. And so this company is using AI to go through tens of thousands of articles and be able to give recommendations like right on the app. And I will check it out just to, if I read something in the literature, I’ll check it out just to see did they tell the app that yet?  And usually they have, so it’s pretty cool. Okay, cool. We’re just starting. The reason that, that there’s there’s no real guidance about this is because we’re just at the cusp, what’s available for probiotics. It’s just, it’s 1 percent of what we’re going to have in another 10 years.

Dr. Weitz: So mention a couple of your favorite probiotics. Do you like the spore based probiotics? Do you use the Acromantia? What kind of products do you like?

Dr. Crawford: If somebody doesn’t have enough diversity which is, a lot of people, like I use, for instance, if I [00:58:00] can mention a company, I use Designs for Health.  And if somebody wants a discount. designs for health account, they can go to kimcarfordmd. com and go to the page where there’s products and If you use Designs for Health link under my product list, that gives you something like a 15 20 percent discount on everything. And for Designs for Health, I like their, they have a line called ProBiomed.  And those they have a sporulating probiotic called Probiospore. So for diversity, you want a sporulating. You want a lot of bacillus bacillus subtilis. You want bacillus coagulans. And there are, I think there are two other companies that have good sporulating probiotics. Rebel Health Tribe had one or has one and then there’s another company so 

Dr. Weitz: Microbiome Labs has the Megaspore.

Dr. Crawford: The Megaspore probiotic that’s a good product. [00:59:00] Exactly. And so for diversity you, you always want to sporulating. I always check like somebody can have too much acromantia. So I would say you know check your microbiome before, ideally before you start any probiotic.  So check and see, do you need acromantia? And if you’re deficient, I would recommend acromantia. And then the other, I’ll use ProBiomed that, the ProBiomed 50 or 100 because those there are lactobacillus strains and bifidobacterium strains that will help with the serotonin and GABA and that will help with metabolic stuff and that will increase your metabolism.  amount. If you have a really low level of Firmicutes I really want that level up. And this is a little controversial because high Firmicutes are found in obese patients or people well over their ideal body range. But on the other hand, if you [01:00:00] look in the blue zones and you look at those microbiomes, The Blue Zone people who all, there’s people with

Dr. Weitz: the longest Dan Buettner.

Dr. Crawford: They’ve all got high firmicutes. And they’re all thin, they’re thin, they eat they don’t eat a lot of meat. That’s why when we talked about paleo, that’s why I say I’m not a fan of a lot of eating a lot of meat for multiple reasons, for from a health standpoint it’s not a good idea to, from an inflammation just an inflammatory, and we’ll just leave it at that standpoint, it’s not a good idea.

And here’s the other thing about when you’re eating, when you’re eating animal products, whether it’s dairy or meat chicken, beef, whatever. or whatever it is you’re eating what those animals were fed. So if they were fed grains, those grains, are there, are the grains GMO grains? Were they sprayed with pesticides?   Were they sitting in silos covered with mycotoxins and the animals have ingested [01:01:00] mycotoxins? I figured out how to treat CIRS looking at the veterinary literature because they were treating animals who were getting Mold Toxin Related Illness, so everything that the animal eats, you eat, which is why I always say you must get grass fed everything, chickens, free range chickens that walk around and eat grass and lay eggs and Become your meal if you want it to become your meal and beef, beef if it’s fed grains, you’re eating the same grains the beef is, you’re, you’re, if they’re injected with hormones and antibiotics, you’re eating that too that’s why organic, it is more expensive, but if you’re trying to be a healthy person and not develop inflammatory bowel disease, You’ll eat organic, and you’ll eat organic with not only your meat, but with your grains, with your fruits, with your vegetables and an easy rule of thumb about what to get organic is if you can peel it and eat the inside, [01:02:00] then it doesn’t have to be organic, but if you can’t peel it, like you’re eating an apple or you’re eating a strawberry, those have to be organic.  If you get a sweet potato and you take off the skin, that doesn’t have to be organic. That’s the rule.

Dr. Weitz: Sure, or you can go to I’m drawing a blank on the clean ten or the Yeah, the dirty dozen. Dirty dozen, yeah.

Dr. Crawford: I’m just saying if people don’t have access to that list and they’re at the grocery store and they’re looking, that’s a way to think about it.  Sure, absolutely.

Dr. Weitz: If you’re not going to eat the outside of it and it’s covered in a shell, you’re going to get less of the pesticides inside.

Dr. Crawford: like an avocado.

Dr. Weitz: Yeah, absolutely. Okay, great. A lot of great information. Thank you so much for sharing with us, Dr. Crawford. And how can viewers and listeners get in touch with you?  What’s your website, etc.?

Dr. Crawford: It’s Kim Crawford, like the wine 

Dr. Weitz:  Is your wine called Kim Crawford?

Dr. Crawford: There’s a guy in New Zealand that owns a vineyard, okay? And he makes a good Sauvignon Blanc. Oh, okay. And I get three, three texts a week with people sending me Kim Crawford wine and asking and saying, Is this yours?  I wish. So they can go to kimcrawfordmd. com. And I do one off consults. If you just want to want a 45 minute to 75 minute consult, I do those. And then I’m still, I do get a lot of applications on a daily basis, but I do. So I don’t take every new applicant as a new patient, but I do get you situated and I help you and I do answer every single person that, that gets in touch with me.

Dr. Weitz: That’s great. Thank you so much, Dr. Kim.

Dr. Crawford: Thank you, Dr. Ben. Lovely being with you.

Dr. Weitz: The same.

Dr. Crawford: Bye.

 


 

Dr. Weitz: Thank you for making it all the way through this episode of the Rational Wellness Podcast. For those of you who [01:04:00] enjoy. Listening to the Rational Wellness Podcast. I would appreciate it if you could go to Apple Podcasts or Spotify and give us a five star ratings and review.  If you would like to work with me personally to help you improve your health, I do accept a limited number of new patients per month for a functional medicine consultation. Some of the areas I specialize in include helping patients with specific health issues like gut problems. Neurodegenerative conditions, autoimmune diseases, cardiometabolic conditions, or for an executive health screen and to help you promote longevity and take a deeper dive into some of those factors that can lead to chronic diseases along the way.  Please call my Santa Monica Weitz Sports Chiropractic and Nutrition office at 310 395 3111. And we’ll set you up for a new consultation for functional medicine. And I look forward to speaking to everybody next week.

Jasen Powell, head athletic trainer for the LA Clippers, discusses Injury Prevention with Dr. Ben Weitz.

[If you enjoy this podcast, please give us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts, so more people will find The Rational Wellness Podcast. Also check out the video version on my WeitzChiro YouTube page.]

 

Podcast Highlights

2:33  Football vs Basketball.  When you work with football players, because it is a collision sport you are in more of a triage position, trying to get guys back on the field right away.  In football, you are dealing with a lot of acute injuries, whereas in basketball, you tend to deal with more chronic type injuries and you may have four games per week rather than one.  Return to play strategies are different for basketball players, game prep is different, and how you communicate with the players is different. 

4:02  How to assess athletes to screen for the risk of injuries?  Jasen and the Clipper staff put players through a movement analysis screen, including jumping off a force plate, which can tell you if there are imbalances in force output from one leg to the other.  Jasen analyzes how players move in the sagittal, frontal, and transverse planes of movement. He and his staff look at groin range of motion and strength, calf strength, quad strength and then he also looks at goniometric ranges of motion for the hips, angles, shoulders, and even the big toe.  Jasen points out that you can’t prevent injuries, but you he does injury risk management.  Then they work on improving range of motion with joints that are limited both with passive and assistive stretches and mobilization.  This is followed by lifting that incorporates range of motion work to build strength into those ranges.  Jasen also works with players to strengthen muscles that are weak and this is continually reevaluated and modified through the season and off season.

7:45  Movement analysis.  Jasen feels that assessing movement patterns may be the most important thing to focus on.  When you watch an athlete lunge into a particular plane, is it a full range and it is smooth and under control?  If the movement is limited, is the hip or the foot or ankle that is limiting you?  Are you having trouble pushing off the big toe?  Do you have a tight arch?  Have you had an ACL injury or surgery?  Are there spinal restrictions?  Do you have a congenital issue with your hip, such as a cam deformity or labral tear?  We also have to consider hydration and nutritional factors. 

10:32  Biomechanics.  When you observe an athlete going into a lunge position in the sagittal plane with the left leg, we want to see how his left foot strikes and how far can he lunge and does he have good control?  Are there restrictions in his right hip or is he having trouble pushing off his right big toe?  When lunging forwards, is there a valgus stress at the knee?  

 

 



Jasen Powell is the head athletic trainer of the Los Angeles Clippers and he has been since 1999. 

Dr. Ben Weitz is available for Functional Nutrition consultations specializing in Functional Gastrointestinal Disorders like IBS/SIBO and Reflux and also Cardiometabolic Risk Factors like elevated lipids, high blood sugar, and high blood pressure.  Dr. Weitz has also successfully helped many patients with managing their weight and improving their athletic performance, as well as sports chiropractic work by calling his Santa Monica office 310-395-3111.

 



 

Podcast Transcript

Dr. Weitz: Hey, this is Dr. Ben Weitz, host of the Rational Wellness Podcast. I talk to leading health and nutrition experts and researchers in the field to bring you the latest in cutting edge health information. Subscribe to the Rational Wellness Podcast for weekly updates. And to learn more, check out my website, drweitz.com. Thanks for joining me and let’s jump into the podcast. Hello, Rational Wellness Podcasters. Our topic for tonight is preventing athletic injuries with head athletic trainer of the LA Clippers, Jason Powell. Jason, thank you so much for joining us today. I’m very excited about this interview.

Jasen: Thank you, Ben.  Thanks for having me.

Dr. Weitz: Tell us a little bit about yourself and how you ended up becoming the head trainer for the LA Clippers. And my understanding is you’ve been a trainer for 25 years.

Jasen: Yeah. I just finished my 25th season here with the LA Clippers. My first season was 1999. Ironically, the first year that the franchise moved into Staples, which is now Crypto.com.  I actually started off as an intern with the L. A. Clippers. And then when I left as an intern, I went into a full time position with the San Francisco 49ers. Left that football experience and then came back. In ’99 as a head athletic trainer, and I’ve been here ever since and enjoyed it. The franchise has been good to me.  I think I’ve done a job that they’ve been, happy with and moving forward, as we continue to grow in the profession and as organization, it’s always forward thinking with the franchise and with our profession. That’s great.

Dr. Weitz: I also understand that you were a college basketball player.  Do you feel that helps you in your work as the Clippers trainer?

Jasen: Yeah. And it came full circle. I got into sports medicine and athletic training not to work in basketball. I got into it just for the love of sports medicine and just health care alone. It just so happened that I did play college basketball and I’m back into working with, basketball athletes, having worked football, worked numerous sports while I was in college doing my understudy. Yeah, I tell people it beats working, working in a sport that you play. And that you enjoy working with and just helping athletes. That’s just, I think that’s the nature of what I’m doing and what I enjoy to do.

Dr. Weitz: How different is it working with basketball players versus say football players?

Jasen: Big difference football, which I call a collision sport in basketball, which is a contact sport. And football is more of a triage. You’re trying to get guys back on the back on the field readily right away. Now it’s a 17 game season, so it’s still a lot of games, but you’re trying to get them ready by the week.  In basketball you may have four games a week, so it’s more like chess, whereas it’s more like checkers in football. Just the mentality of the player is a little bit different. How you [00:03:00] communicate and what you put together as far as a format and strategy of players for their return to play as, as well as for a game prep is a little bit different.  But I think football really prepares you for any sport that you work. I think the type of injuries and the kind of things that you see in football over a span of one week, you may not see for almost an entire season in basketball. You get more chronicity type things in basketball. In football, you, like I say, you see more traumatized kind of thing, more acute type injuries.  It’s a big difference, but it’s all encompassed of, at the end of the day, the common denominator is helping athletes no matter their football or basketball.

Dr. Weitz:  So let’s talk about a big part of your job is how to prevent and manage these injuries. How do you assess athletes to screen for the risk of injuries and what factors do you see as the most significant?

Jasen:  It’s pretty comprehensive and every organization is different. We’ll put a player through a [00:04:00] movement analysis screen process. We see how they move in all different planes of movement. The sagittal, frontal, transverse plane of movements. You look at how they jump. You take, force plate measurements.  Force plate is a testing tool that you symmetry or asymmetry. In a person’s limb output

Dr. Weitz:  So this is something when you jump on it, it detects how much pressure and how

Jasen: much pressure, how much load you have on one limb comparable to the other. And if there’s a difference between the two and how much load you have enforced that you’re generating through your actual, output.  And that’s part of our sports science department. They do a really good job, putting that kind of thing together. We have, we do growing tests growing tests, growing strength tests calf strength, growing bar calf strength bar. So we put leg extension bar for quad strength.  So we, we put a lot of different testing measurements together that can that can help us. comprehensively be able to tell us what [00:05:00] we need to do or what we need to get better at from a performance standpoint. We actually, we’ll do table measurements for, goniometric measurements for hip range of motion, ankle range of motion, shoulder range ankle range of motion, which is big big toe range of motion.  So I love it because you get to see, you can peel back the banana from where a player may be, To where you want them to go and what maybe has made them to be successful for where they are now, right? You put these these metrics together and figure out a plan, a workout plan a manual therapy plan for restricting things that they may have restrictive with their hips or their ankles.

And we have pretty much a routine and flow where they’ll go and do table work. Then they’ll go and do some active range of motion, movement, stretching then they’ll go and do a lifting based on what the assessment shows, which incorporates some corrective exercises. Then they go into more performance based strength exercises.  So everyone has their own plan on their own customized program based off their evaluation and their assessment. And then that’s how we put our day to day, our week to week plans for the players. And it, it’s modified throughout the course of the season and how we do things in the beginning of the season.  So there, there’s an off season evaluation assessment that we put them through in season. And then, of course, a new offseason based off what limitations they had or injuries they may have had during the season. So it’s pretty comprehensive. It’s real good. It’s the bulk and meat and potatoes, as I should say, of our assessment plan for what I call injury risk management.  Rather than injury prevention, because there’s risk of injury, but we want to try to manage you from those type of risk that you can receive, and I never get caught up in the term of injury prevention. You can’t prevent injury. There’s many force factors that come into no matter how hard train.  You have forces that come against you. So you just try to manage the risk of injury that you can probably endure.

Dr. Weitz: So of the various factors, what are some of the most important ones?  We have mechanics, we have range of motion, you mentioned, we have balanced strength, stability. What are some of the most important ones?  Give us some examples of some things that you see that are liable to create increased risk of injury and what can you do to correct those?

Jasen:  I’m not I’m not married to or biased to anyone being, more important than the other. I think they all, I think they all synchronize hand in hand, believe it or not.  However, if I had to choose what we like to, or what I like to look at the most is your movement pattern, right?  How you’re lunging into a movement, how you’re squatting into a movement, how you can functionally bend down, how you can functionally reach in different planes of movement.  Is it the hip that’s limiting you?  Is it your foot/ankle that’s limiting you?  Is it you can’t push off your big toe? And what is that reason? Why aren’t you able to do that? Is it previous history? Did you have plantar fasciitis? You have a tight arch? Did you have an ACL? Did you have some lumbar pain before?  Did you have some surgical intervention that remodeling created some restriction or some restrictive movement patterns. And, do you just have a congenital/hereditary type of lack of opportunity to move at the hip? Do you have cam deformity? Do you have some labral issues in your hips?  Do you where’s the restriction coming from and why are we having that? So I think movement analysis is a big part of it to me.  We can break down all the parameters. We go as in depth as far as nutrition what’s hydration those are two other factors that are big into how you perform and what can create or limit the risk of injury that you can have and all these components.

And when we talk about nutrition, I think that’s a huge part of it. I think nutrition is another what I call Plan B of injury management with [00:09:00] movement. I can go in depth, but this is a whole other podcast is the mental health component of it. How your brain functions, with sleep and how you recover in terms of you being able to move the right way.  The energy output that you have, which is out of nutrition, sleep, rest, recovery. So there’s so many components, but how you move is real important.

Dr. Weitz: Yeah. Why don’t we talk about that for a little bit? I was watching another podcast episode with some biomechanical guy and he was explaining how there’s a tendency for if athletes, when they’re running or lunging or cutting if their knee goes in a little bit.  In other words, if it adducts and they’re also in flexion that’s a common issue, that’s more likely to lead to an ACL thing. So getting athletes to make sure that their knees are tracking properly is,.. give us an example of a few types of things that you see.

Jasen: Simple movement pattern.  And you look at an athlete who, let’s say going to a lunge position into the sagittal plane–lunges forward. And you look at, okay, first, how was he foot striking with the left foot? Lunging forward, right? So how far can he lunge?  What’s his limitations?  What about that? If he’s lunging forward with his left, why isn’t he lunging as far or with much control?  Is it because, does he have restriction in his right hip–to not be able to lunge forward enough with his left foot strike with his ground reaction force?  So now with his right leg in the back stance phase, does he not have enough push off with his big toe? Can he not push off his big toe on his right foot in order to have a good forward lunge with his left leg?  Is it a restriction in the toe foot or is it a restriction in the ankle? Is it a restriction in the right [00:11:00] hip that is creating that lunge pattern on the left side to be restricted?  And not just restricted with the range, but restricted with the control, right?  With, what’s the controllability do you have in the hip?

Now, if you lunge forward with your left and have a valgus stress at the knee, now you’re looking at, okay, is that because he has a restriction in his left ankle?  Does he have a restriction and weakness in his left hip? And is it coming from his right side? lack of control because he doesn’t have control.  So those are the tricky things that you look at. You slow down the movement patterns, and peel back and see what it really is. Is it coming from the actual forward, left leg lunge movement, or is it coming from the opposite limb hip extension, restriction, or toe extension, or is it actually just weakness and just hip control?  Is the lumbar pelvic hip stability weak? And now he doesn’t have control on his movement pattern, or is it just [00:12:00] a restriction in range of motion, or is it restriction in strength, right?

Now you’re going to the frontal plane, and now you may have a different restriction, and you may move better in the frontal plane.  Now what muscle groups are you recruiting, allowing you to move better in that plane of motion? Contrary to how you’re moving in the sagittal, now you get into a more, idealistic movement pattern of the transverse plane and where you have been moving. Some players can move better transversely because they’re big compensators, right?  We all know that.  And we talk about that too. The compensation component of athletes who are really good at moving in the pattern, least resisted, right?  It’s really tricky how you look at movement. What you’re really looking for and how you study that and having more than just two eyes in the movement pattern is really good because now you can talk as a team and support each other on what you feel like you have to work on building, building up and getting stronger and whatever is limited, you [00:13:00] have to increase the range of motion, and I’m big on, it’s pretty To me, it’s simple.  What’s weak, you strengthen and what cannot move, you work on that range of motion.  And it could be more of a soft tissue restriction or it could be a joint issue that you have to work on increasing that joint kinematic movement pattern.

Dr. Weitz:  Good.  I imagine jumping and jumping mechanics must play a big role in basketball and the way players land.

Jasen: Yeah. Deceleration. You got to have your brakes have to be just as good as your gas pedal. I’m big on brakes. Posterior chain, hamstrings glutes, soleus muscles is big in the lower leg. All your scap/thoracic, that’s huge.  Lumbar spine. How you break, ie. how you decelerate, is important. It’s really huge so training eccentrically, but getting to the movement pattern that you can be able to even train with that kind of movement, right? So you, your muscles have to be strong enough to be able to be able to turn off the muscle pattern in an elongated positioning, eccentrically.  Training in the eccentric movements and training basketball movements.  Getting guys on vector machines, on pulleys using control Kaiser machines. Dumbbell just it’s just a movement pattern of having someone that can assist you in your mechanics in your movement, making sure that you’re not loading the joint as much as you are putting strength and and more emphasis on muscle.  Strength and muscle movement patterns, so you won’t, be contraindicated on your, on what you’re trying to train and what you’re trying to get better at, right? So training eccentrically we all know science has shown us like isometric training is huge. That’s big.  The soleus muscle is big for the ACL just as much as reducing calf strains.

Dr. Weitz:  Why is isometric training so important?

Jasen:  First of all, it’s tension. It’s load under tension, right? So without movement. So if you’re training isometrically, you’re not moving through the joint. You’re just putting that muscle under tension. And when you put the muscle under tension, you get tensile [00:15:00] forces.  that you normally get when you push off and when you have resistance, right? So that muscle fibers are in the sarcomeres and all the fiber intrinsics of a muscle really get recruited. They get recruited and get stronger. And this is all through testing and, and actually results that we see. We like to do a lot of isometric calf strengthening Quad, Iso training for tendon loading is big, for our basketball athletes and you do isometric tendon loading, for our guys, but putting tendons under stress with load without movement, where they’re just recruiting a lot of that load and tension, right?  Just, we used to be away from quad extensions, right? They used to be old school, now you’re back doing, isometric quad. Contraction, contract, hold, contract, hold, release type stuff.

Dr. Weitz: That’s interesting. Cause for a while it was all, no, you got to use closed chain exercises–we don’t use open chain.

Jasen: Right now you have, you do isometric, contract, hold contract, isometric holding, for quad tendon, patella [00:16:00] tendon loading, Achilles tendon, eccentrically, you can load them, in split stance. Isometric holds, as if they’re in a running stance, have your back laid, what maybe like Kaiser shoulder press squat machines with the tension and load coming all through through your body, making sure that tendon is getting that load that it’s going to endure when it actually plays again, against contact too, so it’s good, man. It’s fun. It’s fun to see results. It’s fun to have players who have had issues and who has issues and to take them through the entire season on a high hygiene program, isometric hygiene program and a performance based corrective exercise program. But you can’t just do corrective exercises, right?  Because, you, if you’re six seven, two hundred and thirty five pounds, you can’t just do bands.

Dr. Weitz:   Because No, of course not. You gotta maintain your strength and your speed and your power.

Jasen: Yeah. You load, you gotta load the tissue, right? Because you are gonna have resistive load against you.  You’re gonna have six nine, 270 pushing against you. So you have to be able to train that accordingly. And throughout the season, now you have to paradise it to where. You’re not doing it. You got to make sure you know when you’re doing it because you have to factor in travel. Do we have four games in seven days?  Is it on the East Coast, West Coast? Is it in a hot, dry climate? And your hydration with your tissue? Are we going to do it two times this week or are we going to do it three? Are we going to do less sets? But more times this week, that kind of thing. So that’s where it gets tricky.  That’s where it gets fun. And I think that’s where experience comes in. Also one thing you can’t teach or take away, which is huge for the respectability and the trust from the athlete to know what kind of program they may need or may want, now who’s professional, who’s not, is the results you get from the player who wants to put the time in for the program that you arrange for them.

Dr. Weitz: I’ve heard of some players that do their weight training after the game. Other players do it in the morning. What do you prefer or does it depend on the athlete?

Jasen: It depends on the athlete, but your metabolic rate is higher after after play. Your endorphins are going.  You want to still get that pump, as if you’re still playing with the resistance. Then you got, you have your other notion of, you want to recover and you want right after the game. So you get a better output after you recover and rest, the next day. And it’s like a mixed thing with guys.  Some say, let’s go knock this out now, and I think there’s, I’m torn in between. I haven’t seen any wrong between the two. I think our injury risk has not been this any different for one guy lifting more after game. opposed to the next day. Now, if you do have four games and in seven days, we do know how many games you play a week.

You guys want to lift after the game, not back to backs, of course, but they’re going to get the amount of lifting. For the season, now will you be able to lift more weight the next day? Probably so that’s where you have to talk with the athlete about what your your programming, which you need to get [00:19:00] done or what they haven’t done that you need to maybe have a little bit more recovery to do, but our strength coach, he does unbelievable job.  He’s really good at getting guys in the weight room, whether it’s the next day or after games. And that across the league, you see a lot of guys getting it in. Hey, let’s be honest. Some guys, they don’t want to come in the next day. So at least they get it in. Right.

Dr. Weitz: So now that it’s the offseason, what kinds of things are your players focusing on in terms of strength and rehab and stuff?

Jasen: You you do offseason evaluation and assessment like we talked about earlier comparable to what it was like in the beginning of the season and midseason, and that determines your programming. You do go over an evaluation over each player and you talk about what were your strengths this season?  Literally and figuratively. What were your strengths? What did you see that you liked in the weight room? What did you see you liked in the training room? What can you get better at? What do you need to get better at? What do the coaches see? What does our strength coaches see you need to improve? And we put [00:20:00] together what the coaches see they need you to get better at rather than lateral movement.

Power, more stronger. You need to get more, you get more, you need to get stronger upper body to get more depth and distance on your jump shot. We need you to be able to move laterally quicker defensively. So you put those things together to build, like I said earlier, a comprehensive program for what the offseason training will be to customize for what you need.  You sit down with guys within the first two weeks of the offseason to go over that plan, what coaches and medical staff may see. And then, of course, the player, what do you see? What do you need to get better at transparently? And then what do you, what do the team think you need to be better at?  So you put all that together. Then you have the program and how you go about doing it, where the player is going to be working out in season. I’m sorry, offseason at home. Or off season in the practice facility. And you we do a Monday through Thursday deal, with our guys, we give that Friday off and, give and take but we don’t jeopardize that Monday.  That’s why we give the Friday off. So Monday through [00:21:00] Thursday and then we retest and if a guy needs to gain weight, we see where he is, after, after, some time, maybe three, four weeks or whatever it may be. If a guy needs to lose weight, a guy, we’ll retest.

Probably before they get into live contact type of play in their offseason programming. But now we have guys who are younger contract players who will play in the summer league. So we do some we increase the workload, preparing them for the summer league and make sure their strength work is the is up along with their condition.  But that, don’t get me wrong, these guys, they do take their time off. They do rest. They have to season and then they ramp back up. Huh. But like I said, I strength of the good job working on getting them prepared for their summer league routine and or their entire offseason regimen. And let’s be honest, a lot of few guys have their own guys that they work with outside of team.  So keeping that relationship and rapport is really good. So both parties and both sides can be working hand in hand with each other.

Dr. Weitz: What kinds of [00:22:00] things do you track to see if players are over training, doing too much, versus not doing enough?

Jasen: Yeah, in house our sports science crew, they do a good job.  We use a Kinexon system. Okay. Those are small little chips that they embed in their shorts, in the back of their shorts, on the waistline. And that give us some good output. And I like to use, I like to use the red, yellow, green system, is a player exerting himself in the red where he’s working really hard, right?  Now, are they in a yellow, where they’re in a moderate state of exertion, right? Or if they’re, I won’t say the green, if they’re not, dogging it or pushing it or not really dogging or pushing it, but if the activity level that they’re working at isn’t that strenuous.  If a player has multiple days of being in the red, then we know now we have to up their recovery, right? Or we have to 

Dr. Weitz: And what determines that they’re in the red? How do you determine that?

Jasen: No, there’s a sensor that connects on the sensor. Oh, okay. Yeah, the sensor [00:23:00] that they wear.

Dr. Weitz: Oh, and is this looking at heart rate recovery?

Jasen: Yeah. Heart rate recovery and energy output, their output. So we would if a guy, so if a guy’s numbers, if they’re 500 or above multiple days, then we’re like, Hey, look, we got to think about what the recovery is, but it’s also subjective feedback as well from the player, like how you feel this week.  I see, you’ve been over the 500, over 500 in the red for the last three days as we go. I feel good. I feel good. Yeah. That may be their norm, or they, I feel a little tired. So then, we may work hand in hand with the strength coach. I’m sorry, with the play development coach and let them know, Hey, we need to have maybe like a lighter day to day, maybe go like a 20 minute, just, shooting a workout.  Or if it’s a guy, it feels like he can do more or he doesn’t feel too bad. Say, Hey, look. Play development coach is like, Hey, look, I want to implement some rim touch finishes in some defensive segments and his connexion numbers show that he hasn’t been exerted. He doesn’t [00:24:00] report any ailments or soreness and he feels like he can do it.  Then we may add that to his regimen, so it’s an, it’s a new school of adding a tool to help make sure a player is, stays adequately prepared to output when it’s time when you don’t have the connects on, you don’t have the measuring components available.

Dr. Weitz: So what sorts of things can you do to promote recovery?  I know there’s the Normatec compression sleeves.  There’s a number of other things that are available, including hyperbaric oxygen, cold plunges, and cryotherapy. What sorts of things do you feel like moves the needle as far as recovery? 

Jasen: I mean, you just said quite a few of them, right?  Like you said, Normatech, we, we do, of course, massage flushing. There’s, you have different, tart cherry juice. That’s a good recovery too. Magnesium is good for sleep. It was really good. Contrast. I’m not big to, cold tub.  Yeah, you can do that. But contrasting is really good [00:25:00] for recovery. Even before activity, I tell our guys, you do a hot, cold, hot, cold. And before activity, You want to finish in the warm when you do a contrast, right? And after activity, you go hot, cold, hot, cold, and finish in the cold, right? So you have them go like in a sauna and then into they can do sauna.  We have, we’ll have a hot jacuzzi and a cold plunge. And I’ll usually go three minutes, three minutes. And they may go three cycles and finish in the warm before they hop on the table or hop in the weight room, right? That’s before practice. And then after practice, they may do the same and then finish in the cold.  Or they may just go 10 to 12 minutes of cold afterwards. But I like to keep the muscle tissue elastic and keep blood circulating as well as while it’s recovering with cold as well. That’s why I like the two dynamics. Recovery types are big. I like this mission it’s a special mission.

Portable unit called Firefly that fits right around the fibular head and it’s electrical [00:26:00] stimulation that pumps and keeps blood circulation all the way through your lower leg to your entire body. Firefly is the name of the product. I really like that. It’s portable. No wireless you wear it on flights, you wear it after games it also helps with a lot of lower leg injuries.

Dr. Weitz:  And how does it works through electrical stimulation?

Jasen: Yeah, electrical stimulation and it’s it’s powered by just a simple button push on the actual device. It’s a long strip that you put right on your right behind your fibular head. Yeah, you may get like a little perineal nerve impulse contraction, it’s non fatiguing contraction.  And you really get that electrical stim, almost like a high volt pulse for recovery, keeping that blood circulated. Now, I’ve seen some good results even with injury and not just recovery. Recovery, you keep it on for four hours. And for injury, you you keep it on as well, and it helps plump out the fluid for for swelling as for the lactic acid as well, too.  So Firefly is big. We said Normatec Recovery Tights, Hot and Cold Plunge, Cryo Chambers. We [00:27:00] mentioned that, as also. I know some players use hyperbaric oxygen. Yeah, that’s I like to use that for injury. The big tanks are really good for injury. But the oxygen I think helps you for sleep.  I think it helps you wind down and get those red blood cells relaxed. And so you can sleep better. It’s not going to make you sleep, but it’s going to help you get into more of a relaxation frame of mind to be able to sleep. And sleep is a huge, that can be a whole nother podcast. Sleep is another thing that’s huge that goes under, underrated for your mental recovery and for your body recovery, because that’s when the body is actually doing all of its work for what you did,

Dr. Weitz: so for a heart training athlete, how much sleep do you recommend? And also do you track the quality of sleep, deep sleep and REM sleep?

Jasen: Yeah. It’s still the same. I think eight hours is still, you want to have no less than six. Some guys, if you get 10, that’s great, but how are you tracking that? We have a thing called the ora ring. Yeah. [00:28:00] Or ring. We’ve used and used for our players and that kind of can digitize and electronically let you know your deep sleep, your REM sleep.  Yeah. Restless sleep, and, it’s, it seemed to have worked out pretty good because how a player responds and says, without even looking at the numbers man, I slept pretty good and they may be at 89 or 90, the percentile of sleep or if a guy says he, he slept pretty crappy and he could be at 54 or 45 or, and, but what is the reason why you slept crappy and, and what’s the purpose and is it nutritionally, your body’s trying to digest processed foods more than just natural foods.  Is it that you aren’t recovering well because you’re exerting yourself too much and you’re not hydrated enough for your organs to relax and calm down and actually do its job? Sleep is huge. For your recovery and for your body to actually put to work all the things that you’ve done throughout the day, right?

Dr. Weitz:  So you just mentioned hydration. What are some of the general rules you like to use in terms of hydration for the [00:29:00] players? How much should they drink? When should they use a sports drink? What kind of sports drinks do you like?

Jasen: Everyone says hydrate, hydrate. What is hydration? Hydration is more than just water, right?  We know our body is 80%. Our muscle tissue is 80 percent water, but we also have to realize we need our magnesium, potassium and minerals in our body, right? So magnesium is huge, is a huge part. That’s hydration to me. Electrolytes, Magnesium is Hydration. I like there’s tons of products out there. I like, we use Drip Drop.  We use Liquid IV. Those are two products that we really, our guys really like. Um, um, Those, yeah, those are the two biggest ones that we use it’s, just simple salt alone is good for, good electrolyte for the muscle tissue and the bloodstream. Drip drop is one, like I said liquid IV is another one, but I think hydration encompasses the electrolytes of the magnesium and the [00:30:00] salt that the body needs and not just water.  And minimize the sugar, right? Not to knock difference, I’m not into the business of knocking different, products and all that, but really look at sugar count. They may have the electrolytes in them, but they also may have the sugar for the taste. So you have to think about, it’s not going to taste great.

If you’re going to get all the nutrients that you need for your electrolytes and replenish your fluids, right? So less is best when it comes to sugar and the magnesium is huge and, some of them have the zinc in it as well. Zinc is big. Drip Drop is a good one.  Like I said, Liquid IV is another good one. We use another company called Revitalite. Provided Light is another one which is pretty good. They’re made in 16 ounce 32 ounce ready to go bottles for our guys.

Dr. Weitz: Yeah. What about at halftime? What kinds of things do you like to use to refuel them?  Actually, let’s go into the whole nutrition thing for a little bit, and I realize we could spend hours on each one of [00:31:00] these topics, but in general, in terms of the nutritional what’s best for athletes to get maximum performance? Is there a type of nutritional program that you prefer in general?  Does each player have their own nutritional perspective? How important are some of the different factors like protein intake and carbohydrates for fueling, et cetera?

Jasen: I don’t claim to be a dietitian, nor do I act as if I’m one. We have that specialty and we have that skill set that helps us with our guys.  But just the concepts and the basic normality that you deal with is of course, fuel, right? Carbohydrates and protein. We protein is big for building bodily tissue. We know carbohydrate is big for energy. And, of course, you have, your less percent intake of good fats, right?  Okay. So we do we have, our chefs do a good job of of specializing the meal plans based on what’s needed for morning and after practice, after game [00:32:00] food energy intake, right? So we try to really, carbo load before activity as quiet as kept and as easy as it may sound small snacks before games or peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, right?

We do that, after games, we try to do some big protein, to rebuild bodily tissues. And, we have what about at half time? Oh, half time is we have guys do a lot of energy bars. Energy bars are big. Some guys may take some, scoops of peanut butter or something like that.  Fruit is a big thing, huge thing. I have certain guys who traditionally do. I remember Serge Ibaka was a big banana, apple, orange guy at halftime. Zubac has his things. Paul has his thing. We got some guys who, have their little routine, but the hydration is huge. And they all have their, They’re small, little superstitions of hy hydration or replenish things that they like to do.  Of course energy packets where they do the energy energy quick packs are big for replenishing and have time. And of course, how much you play determines how much you quit also, of course, yeah.

Dr. Weitz:  Do some of the guys get [00:33:00] IVs at halftime?

Jasen:  No, we don’t administer IVs.  It’s not even, not even legal to do in the NBA.

Dr. Weitz: Oh, okay.

Jasen:  You have to administer that in a sanitary, hospital.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. What part, how important is taping in preventing injuries and helping to manage injuries? And I know there’s different types of taping. There’s K tape, there’s, standard athletic tape.  Okay.

Jasen: Yeah taping, that’s a, a long time traditional thing for guys in all the sport. Like, I’ve been a wizardry, I’ve been a wizard and have had, great approaches with using tape for different injuries. That’s where you get unique and you get creative with that with hands, finger sprains shoulder injuries ankles, even knees, like you, you do different things based off knowing the anatomy, right?  Understanding how it’s a spiral and how you trying to move up a simple soft tissue away from the injured part or try to move some tissue off of a ligament Trying to [00:34:00] support a tendon that’s in its groove. So just knowing your anatomy of what you’re trying to support and what you’re trying to prophylactically help a player use.  Like I said, Kinesio tape is another one. It’s a brand product that is used vastly. Some believe in it, some don’t. It’s all about what the player likes. Or what you’re trying to promote to help them to see if they say, okay, let’s go with it. You see a lot shoulder stuff. You see a lot of kinesio with knee stuff or patellofemoral issues.

I like using mechanotaping also. You really get some force and tension on that McConnell tape, that brown, the brown tape with the with the cover roll to really get, move bony structures to move soft tissue. So just knowing your anatomy is huge for. using taping techniques, and I have a lot of, I have a lot of techniques that aren’t even in the books that I’ve used that have worked for guys, and it just sometimes some things just work and some things don’t work, guys, I don’t, so, you play with it a little bit, but [00:35:00] the main thing is the main thing with taping is what are you trying to support?  What are you trying to help? So that’s what you work on as a common denominator for the different taping techniques and a different style of tape that you use also.

Dr. Weitz: This is more of a general question, but from my perspective as an NBA fan, it seems like the league’s overall attitude towards injuries has changed over time.  For a number of years ago, it seemed like players were expected to play even if they were in pain, as long as there wasn’t a major injury. And then that sort of changed over time. And then we had a few years where it seemed like it was getting to be more common for players to take days off, and we heard about load management, I even heard about agents being involved in helping to direct medical care.  And then a few years ago, it seemed like the fans were [00:36:00] complaining that all these star players weren’t playing and the NBA ownership wasn’t happy. And it looks like the NBA has put a few rules in place to reduce load management, to encourage players to play more. And how has this impacted your job?

Jasen: It’s moved the needle to make players more accountable for choosing when and why they want to sit out or want to rest.

Dr. Weitz: Right.

Jasen: It’s just, I think it was more putting the the players on notice more so than trying to crack the whip. I think I think it’s important for the league to recognize, players are playing 82 games.   

Dr. Weitz: They’re not going to ever change that, they haven’t, and you lose too much money involved in all those games with all the TV contracts and everything.

Jasen: So how do we navigate through the space of making sure that players can still play? but also think about [00:37:00] why they don’t want to play or aren’t going to play.  And and I think that’s one of the main reasons why the league, integrated this. And I think it’s served, it’s, the numbers have probably served true for what they’re doing. And, I, it can get sticky when you talk about certain things and certain reasons.  You can’t never question a player why he doesn’t want to play. Sure. But you also can put him on notice on the rules that the league will get, come back to the team if we have a certain reason why you aren’t playing that’s not abiding by the rule, right? So how you place the information to the player understanding what a player really cannot play with and what he can play with.

Being respectful of them and their job and that it is their body. But I think the players and the players union and the league puts the players on notice enough to realize that they have to be more conscious about the decisions on when they want to play or when they can or cannot play and what they can play with, right?  [00:38:00] Having two star players sit out together. Is a issue for rest, right? But if they have injuries, you got to show proof that they have injuries. So the league they definitely hold teams accountable for making sure that these players have legitimate injuries that they’re sitting out for.  And you can’t rest two players, that have been, on an all NBA team, within the last couple of years. There’s parameters to it.

Dr. Weitz:  And it’s a fine line. If you have pain, is that an injury? Maybe it is. It, we generally think of pain as resulting from injury, but sometimes it’s a fine line.

Jasen: No, pain is a fine line. And who’s a better judge of that than the person who’s dealing with it? And that’s for knowing your athlete and respecting your athlete, but also having the athlete understand and respect the job you have to do and respect that you’re going to have the player’s best interest.  I’m in the business of making sure players know I have their best interest. more so than [00:39:00] forcing myself to do a job to make myself look good. I think that’s huge and trust, which is one of my four principles is big. And you can’t get that overnight. It’s just over time through exam, from example and experience to gain that.

Dr. Weitz: When it comes to the treatment of non surgical injuries, there’s been a plethora of new physical therapy modalities in the last number of years. We, there’s various types of lasers, there’s class three lasers, class four lasers. We’ve had electrical stimulation and ultrasound for years, we have shockwave, there’s a bunch of, there’s, seems like there’s always a new machine.  Are there any of these modalities that you find really move the needle in helping with recovery?

Jasen: I’m not, like I mentioned before, I’m not married to, I’m not married to neither one. As one is like ultimately the best thing out there, right? We use all of what you [00:40:00] just mentioned shockwave, laser.  Um, but don’t, we’re not a big electrical STEM team. Our sports medicine staff, we’re not big on electrical STEM. When we do, we like using the MarkPro. The MarkPro is a big one. Like I said, we use the Firefly for recovery. lower leg injuries. As, as far as modalities I do Shockwave the Zimmer Shockwave is pretty good.  The E Pulse is a pretty good one too. There’s different levels of it but whatever the, it depends on the indication too, right? Consistency of how you’re using it. That’s huge. I think these are the best things in the business. They can’t steer you wrong, but it’s also a feel and a player’s response to treatment.  And I think modalities are secondary and a support to manual therapy and

Dr. Weitz: For those who are listening rather than watching, you held up your hand. So you’re talking about using your hands to do soft tissue

Jasen: work [00:41:00] manipulation. Yeah, so joint mobilization acupressure active ART, Active Release Techniques that you do with your hand utilizing tools with that for deeper pressure or less less pressure.  And modalities complement that. Modalities complement manual therapy. So they all work together. And as I said, that’s the uniqueness of our job. There’s no one modality that’s better than the other. You try everything. I’ve tried a lot of things over the years and you couple that with the robust staff that we have and, the things that everyone does from, of course, like what you do, like chiropractic work manipulation you have we have our doctors who do biologic, injections, things of that nature, outside, that’s part of 

Dr. Weitz:  Are you guys using peptides a lot these days?

Jasen:  If it’s needed, if peptide injection is needed, but, different cocktails are designed by, our team doctor, Dr. Steve Yoon, who’s pretty good. He’s out there, pretty good. One of the best in the business. People go to use him from across the world, but, biologic injections are big based off your [00:42:00] pathology and your indications of what you may have going on.

Dr. Weitz:  With biologic, you’re generally referring to PRP?

Jasen: That’s a basic, yeah, PRP is a basic one. You have your hyaline hyaline injection, HA injections. You got it’s so many different kind. We got stem cells or exosomes. Yeah. Yeah, so you have different ones. It all depends on what you need, and the clinician who’s doing the injections will educate on what are good ones, they have umbilical cord ones that they use too.  It’s a lot of different ones based on your situation. PRP is the more, most traditional one. Now, how you spend that and how much of the white blood cells you use or what you inject it with the PRP is big too, tenex is another procedure, that you do also for, tending stuff.

It’s a lot. You can go on and on. I didn’t wanna sit here and be a chemist and mention all this kind of stuff and about what I know and what I don’t know. But it’s more so applicable based off your indication. [00:43:00] And then once these things are brought up by the expert, then you go over the return time the efficacy rate of it and the the benefit and the pros and cons and, and how does it impact your downtime, for your sport?

Dr. Weitz: It’s been great. A couple of easy questions to end. What do you like best about your job?

Jasen: Like I mentioned before, it beats working. I enjoy what I do. I enjoy interacting with the athletes. It’s been my, it’s been a gift of mine, having been an athlete and even, At my age now, understanding, the new athletes, my son plays basketball at a high level.  My daughter is in the sports as well. So I enjoy being around the athletes and having a staff that I can work with that understands athletes and want the best for the athletes. So I enjoy my workspace, my work environment, my colleagues and I enjoy working the sport and being around the guys.

It’s all every day. [00:44:00] Every day is a different day. But I find the communication is huge. With the athletes and staff, I find trying to find trust amongst everyone is huge. And you also try to have a balance amongst it all. And you also try to make sure you’re humble amongst it all. I just let, I just said my four principles in life in that, okay, what are they?  Yeah, balance, trust, communication, and humbleness. Those are my four principles. And being humble, like having done this for so long just as an athletic trainer I know it could come and go at any time. It could have come and gone. And I love what I do. Like I said, it beats working. So I love to continue to do it.  I don’t take it for granted. And I think I’ve been putting the space to help not just athletes, but to help people, being a caregiver is important to me. I’ve helped a lot of lives along the way. I’ve given a lot of advice along the way. I’ve made a lot of friendships along the way and I think that’s part of who I am and what I’m about and trying to [00:45:00] serve.  I’m a server, and that’s what God put us on this earth to do. And I just hope that I can continue to do it. And as long as whoever wants me to do it, that’s what I’m here for. So the best part is working with the athletes and just helping people. Whether it’s the general manager, whether it’s the equipment manager, the scout, whoever comes in, you just want to be able to help them.

Dr. Weitz:  That’s great. That’s a great way to end. So thank you so much, Jason. This was a great interview.

Jasen:  No problem, Ben. Thanks for having me.

 


 

Dr. Weitz:  Thank you for making it all the way through this episode of the Rational Wellness Podcast. for those of you who enjoy. Listening to the Rational Wellness Podcast, I would appreciate it if you could go to Apple Podcasts or Spotify and give us a five star ratings and review.  If you would like to work with me personally to help you improve your health, I do accept a limited number of new patients per month for a functional medicine consultation.  Some of the areas I specialize in include helping patients with specific health issues, like gut problems, neurodegenerative conditions, autoimmune diseases, cardiometabolic conditions, or for an executive health screen and to help you promote longevity and take a deeper dive into some of those factors that can lead to chronic diseases along the way.  Please call my Santa Monica Weitz Sports Chiropractic and Nutrition Office at 310 395 3111.  And we’ll set you up for a new consultation for functional medicine. And I look forward to speaking to everybody next week.

Dr. Sarah Ballantyne discusses Nutrient Density with Dr. Ben Weitz.

[If you enjoy this podcast, please give us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts, so more people will find The Rational Wellness Podcast. Also check out the video version on my WeitzChiro YouTube page.]

 

Podcast Highlights

1:40  Nutrivore marks a departure for Dr. Ballantyne from the Paleo diet that she previously endorsed as the Paleo Mom, to a more diverse nutritional approach focused on increasing the nutrient density of the diet.

4:45  Food myths.  Chapter 10 of Nutrivore busts many of the myths around food.  Dr. Ballantyne argues that animal foods are not bad for us and she discusses some of the myths related to food quality, olive oil, and organic foods. She argues against the idea that we should avoid eating legumes and grains because of them containing lectins, phytates, and oxalates, which is the argument in paleo circles why we should not eat whole grains or legumes.  Legumes are among the most nutrient dense foods, including being one of the best sources of folate, are mineral rich, and contain lots of fiber.

17:42  Nutrient density score.  Most peoples’ diets fall short of supplying us with the daily values of all the essential nutrients.  And the RDA should really be thought of as the minimum rather than as the optimal levels.  Dr. Ballantyne has developed this system that includes 33 nutrients in the calculation weighed equally, compared to the daily value, and considering the calric content of the food.

 

 



Dr. Sarah Ballantyne was previously known as the PaleoMom and is the best selling author of five books, including her new book, Nutrivore: The Radical New Science for Getting the Nutrients You Need from the Food You EatIn this book, Sarah creates educational resources to help people improve their day-to-day diet and lifestyle choices, empowered and informed by the most current evidence-based scientific research. With Nutrivore, Dr. Sarah has created a positive and inclusive approach to dietary guidance, based in science and devoid of dogma, using nutrient density and sufficiency as its basic principles: Nourishment, not judgment. Her new website is Nutrivore.com.

Dr. Ben Weitz is available for Functional Nutrition consultations specializing in Functional Gastrointestinal Disorders like IBS/SIBO and Reflux and also Cardiometabolic Risk Factors like elevated lipids, high blood sugar, and high blood pressure.  Dr. Weitz has also successfully helped many patients with managing their weight and improving their athletic performance, as well as sports chiropractic work by calling his Santa Monica office 310-395-3111.

 



 

Podcast Transcript

Dr. Weitz: Hi this is Dr. Ben Weitz, host of the Rational Wellness Podcast. I talk to leading health and nutrition experts and researchers in the field to bring you the latest in cutting edge health information. Subscribe to the Rational Wellness Podcast for weekly updates and to learn more, check out my website, drweitz.com. Thanks for joining me and let’s jump into the podcast. Hello, Rational Wellness Podcasters.

I’m excited today that we’ll be speaking with Dr. Sarah Ballantyne about her new best selling book, Nutrivore. Nutrivore’s subtitle is the radical new science for getting the nutrients you need from the food you eat.  In this book, Dr. Sarah creates educational resources to help people improve their day to day diet and lifestyle choices, empowered and informed by the most current evidence based scientific research. With [00:01:00] Nutrivore, Dr. Sarah has created a positive and inclusive approach to dietary guidance based in science.  And this is the Rational Wellness podcast, so we love science and devoid of dogma, using nutrient density and sufficiency as its basic principles. Nourishment, not judgment. While there’s a lot of great valuable information in this book, one thing that I found particularly helpful was the Valuable Vitamins Cheat Sheet, which we can refer to.  Dr. Ballantyne, thank you so much for joining us.

Dr. Ballantyne: Oh, thank you so much for having me.

Dr. Weitz: You say Nutrivore in your book is not a diet, however, you were previously known as the Paleo Mom, so in this book, your description of a healthy diet in this book sounds more like a Mediterranean diet, so, it sounds like you changed your [00:02:00] approach, did you have to file divorce papers from the paleo community?

Dr. Ballantyne: I’m, I’m pretty sure it’s still enough through legal action that I’m not allowed to say anything. No, in all seriousness, you know, I think, my transition from Paleo to Nutrivore has been a very iterative process. I can’t say that there was one moment where I went, Oh, I think I’m wrong about some things.  I think this entire community is wrong about some things. I think there is a more diverse diet that we can be embracing that actually will be more health promoting, but also, have better coverage in terms of supplying all of the nutrients that our bodies need. It really, the research started, I think it was 2014 or 2015, I started doing, researching for a book on the gut microbiome, that still has not been published, but it was that research of really trying to understand how different foods impact the composition of the bacterial community that lives in our guts. That was the beginning of me going, oh wait a minute, legumes are really phenomenally health promoting. They’re the most nutrient dense, starchy foods. They have vitamins and minerals that, make them very valuable. They’re really great sources of polyphenols, and I don’t think we think of legumes as, being particularly great sources of polyphenols.  And the more that I did this research, the more I really questioned a lot of the dietary dogma that I had bought into.  And as the research and reading the science really, like, opened up my eyes, I started to realize that I had some disordered eating patterns that I had learned through the Paleo community as well.  So I had this personal journey behind the scenes of addressing my own food fears and expanding my own diet as I was undergoing this professional journey right out in the open for everyone to see as I kept going, excuse me, I think, I think maybe we’re wrong about lentils. I think maybe we’re wrong about corn.  I think maybe we’re wrong about oats. And the, the more foods that I, that are not considered paleo, that I really started to, like, change my mind on, the more it became obvious that it was time for me to move on, and, and build something new, and that’s what Nutrivore is.  

Dr. Weitz: So, you have a chapter in, or a section in your book where you talk about the myth of plant toxins, and, you know, one of the big knocks against legumes and lentils, things like that, are that, and this is a argument that paleo advocates often utilize, that lectins, that these foods like legumes contain lectins and phytates and what are called anti-nutrients or plant toxins and these are one of the main reasons why we want to avoid grains and beans.

Dr. Ballantyne: Yeah, so I actually this is, there was a huge conversation behind the scenes with my editor and the team at Simon Schuster about this chapter. So chapter 10 is a myth busting chapter and it kind of has something for everybody in there because it also talks about, whether or not, right, the myths about animal foods being bad for us, which is not true.  There’s a lot of seafood myths that I bust, a lot of myths about food quality, talking about, you know, olive oil and, organic foods as well.  It was really important to me to include a section on plant toxins, because that was the world that I used to, to, those were the circles I used to be in. And I had sort of learned that way of thinking from very prominent scientists names that we’re all familiar with if, if we’ve heard about Lectins and Phytates and Oxalates.

Dr. Weitz:  We might call this the anti-Gundry section.

Dr. Ballantyne: That could be. And as you dig into the science, I mean there’s, there’s a couple of different layers here. So the first layer is that yes, like sometimes the isolated compound in a food, like in, in a lab, it, in, when scientists are validating these compounds, they’re looking at them for potential use in pharmaceutical industries, typically where these scientific studies come from.  And I used to do this type of research. So like, I’m very, very familiar with how these experiments are designed and the different types of techniques that are used. So you take this, this compound that’s isolated from something. And you, first of all, you put it on some cells, and you see like, what do those cells do?  Does it change the proteins those cells are making, right? Like, that’s a really interesting way to understand that compound. Does it have use in a pharmaceutical industry somehow? And then the next kind of step you do to understand what this compound does is you, use it in animal models. So for example, there are some specific, plant toxins [00:07:00] that in animal models of colitis, when you administer just that one compound, you get increased inflammation.  That sounds really scary. That is not, that scientific study is not there to tell us to not eat the whole food. It’s there to help understand whether or not there’s pharmaceutical applications for that one specific compound in the food. And so we need to be understanding those studies within that bigger picture of how does the whole food, because a food is thousands of different chemical compounds, you know, maybe dozens of different nutrients. How does the whole food affect our entire biology?  Because every food will have something that you could isolate and concentrate and put in some, you know, high doses in an animal and go, okay, here’s a negative impact to one biological system. That is actually where a lot of pharmaceutical discovery has, has come from. A lot of cancer drugs come from exactly that process, [00:08:00] but that doesn’t help us understand the whole food.

And so my, my realization of this sort of logical fallacy of like, just because a food has a compound in it that is harmful to one biological system or one specific circumstance, we can’t judge the whole food based on that compound. And that was one of my main, um you know, uncomfortable realizations that I had been thinking about nutritional sciences in this way that is incorrect. And that really drove me to go back to the research and go, okay, so now let’s actually look at studies showing, like looking at whole legumes and not just looking at phytohemagglutinin as a, as an isolated compound. Let’s see how, in animal models, in humans, in intervention studies, where you give a group of humans and you have them eat more legumes.  Let’s look at these studies. And what you see is. the fiber types, the polyphenols, the very high legumes are the the most nutrient dense starchy foods on [00:09:00] average. They’re very rich in vitamins including folate which is one of the most common nutrient shortfalls in the standard American diet. So legumes tend to be some of our best food sources of folate.  Very very mineral rich. You start to see that the that all of the benefit we’re getting from those nutrients, the way that that fiber impacts the gut microbiome, all of that constellation of beneficial effects that we’re getting from eating the whole food completely suppress any potential negative impact from that one compound that in isolation is not great for us.

We’re not eating that compound in isolation, we’re eating the whole legume. And so that is a major sort of difference in how I have changed my view of research. Another big thing that really shifted for me over the last seven or eight years is putting more value in meta analyses. Now, a scientist will always say, right, that the most rigorous scientific [00:10:00] evidence is meta analyses, systematic reviews, umbrella reviews, right?  Like these are the studies, that pool together data for many, many, many studies. So they have a bigger data set. So they have more statistical power, and they incorporate a step of evaluating studies for bias. And so they, they actually have a step for evaluating a study’s quality before they incorporate the data into their giant data set.  And then they typically include a, now let’s also look at all of these, animal model studies, cell culture studies that help explain why this is the average effect we’re seeing. And that is another change that I’ve really made over the last, you know, several years in how I am understanding food is instead of looking at that one study that used phytohemagglutinin in an animal model of colitis, right, and showed increased inflammation.  I’m looking at the systematic reviews that look at all of the different [00:11:00] intervention studies where they take a group of people and have them eat more legumes and then measure various health outcomes, look at it, reducing risk of cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, how it can cause weight loss in people with overweight or obesity how it can reduce risk of certain types of cancer, like looking at that big, big picture in these huge studies that are pooling together data from 20, 30, 300 different studies.  So they have really, really high statistical power. So it’s also a more rigorous approach, and one that really values scientific consensus. And so I included that in Chapter 10 because, I know my followers have kind of watched this whole journey, right? They’ve, they’ve seen all the little bits and pieces as I start to piece this together and really question a lot of the diet dogma that I held to be true.  But it’s also there for the, for the people who are not following that closely to help them understand my transition to a permissive dietary [00:12:00] structure where we can make room in a healthy diet for any food.

Dr. Weitz: That’s great. I generally agree with your overall dietary approach. However, when it comes to the research, it continues to be problematic.  And even if you’re looking at meta analyses, unfortunately, most of the dietary studies are not randomized controlled trials where they give people certain foods and they’re basically just asking people to fill out these food frequency questionnaires, which are so inaccurate. And that makes it difficult, I think, to talk about the real science when it comes to food.  You can’t just take a group of people and just give them, make sure they’re eating legumes, you know.

Dr. Ballantyne: So let’s drill down on that because I think, you know, your point of large perspective studies is really important. Like, I think that is a really important thing to sort of explain to your listeners here.  So perspective studies, or they can be retrospective too, [00:13:00] but these are the studies where we take, I don’t know, 20,000 people and we follow them for 10 years, right? Things like, these are things like, the NHANES study, Framingham, right? There’s these huge, huge cohort studies.

Dr. Weitz: Right, but none of these are control trials where you’re actually giving them food.  So you really have no idea what they’re eating. And then they’re filling out these food frequency questionnaires, sometimes asking them, what did you eat in the last month?  Sometimes in the last year?  And, you know, the recall is so sketchy.

Dr. Ballantyne: Absolutely. So different cohorts have different levels of, sort of trust in their diet recalls.  So for example, the NHANES cohort, their diet recalls are what did you eat over the last two days? And they take that as various snapshots over time. So that is considered a dataset that is much more reliable in terms of, like, actually reflecting what people eat, but also, Our memory is fallible.  We do not want to admit to eating certain things when we’re [00:14:00] being given a survey. And all of those studies are correlative, right? So they tell us that there may be an association, but we have no way of knowing from those types of studies if that association is causative. Did that group of people have lower cardiovascular disease risk because they eat fewer legumes or more legumes, or is it because of this constellation of factors, because that’s the other thing that we see in these types of studies is something called healthy user bias.

So this is where somebody who is eating more plant foods, less, I mean this is a big problem in all of the studies showing that red meat is problematic. It’s a big problem. It’s like a classic example of healthy user bias because red meat has been demonized for so long that people who don’t eat very much red meat tend to eat more fruits and vegetables, they tend to be more active, they tend to also have higher socioeconomic status, so they have social determinants of health working in their favor.  They tend to be female, who also we just get less cardiovascular disease.  And so it’s really hard when you have a lot of different things stacking in these correlative studies to be able to separate out, okay, but how much of this is that these people are eating more legumes? And how much of it is all of the other things that go along with that person who eats more legumes?

And that is, This is absolutely a challenge in nutritional sciences research, and one of the reasons why I never only rely on prospective studies in my interpretation of nutritional sciences. So fortunately for us, we are getting more randomized control. They’re not blind, because you can’t blind somebody from the diet they’re eating, typically.  There’s a few studies where they’ll be like, here’s a muffin and you don’t know if that’s the muffin that has the extra fiber in it or not, right? There are some studies that they can figure out blind, but overall diet studies, we can’t, but we are getting more studies where they take one group of people and say, keep doing what you’re doing, and they take another group of people and they have them work with a dietitian, they work with a, you know, work with a health coach, and they have a dietary structure for [00:16:00] them to follow.

And we’re getting more and more of those studies that we can then go, okay, so we have the intervention study that reinforces what we see in this big observational one that can’t establish causality. And then we can also look at The nutrient difference in, in what these people are eating and look at what we know about how those nutrients impact these biological systems and make a strong case for that being the causal mechanism here as well.  So it is very much about, yes, I absolutely agree that not putting too much weight into an observational study because it cannot establish causality. But taking that as our indication that here’s something to drill down further on understanding healthy user bias and, and how that impacts statistical analyses, but also then we can start layering on, other, other evidence.  And I think we do have a Fortunately, a growing body of intervention clinical trials, randomized but not blind, as well as animal [00:17:00] models that can help to drill down on the biochemical mechanisms behind the benefits.

Dr. Weitz: And let’s get back to the scientific information that you’re adding to our body of knowledge, which is the nutrient density of foods.  So tell us why higher nutrient density is so important and then how do we measure it?

Dr. Ballantyne: Yeah. So, I think that the background piece of information here is that most people’s diets fall short of actually supplying us with even the daily values of all of the essential nutrients, which, 

Dr. Weitz:  Which we know are very, very under, you know, very limited and most people would benefit from having more than the RDA.

Dr. Ballantyne: Absolutely correct. So, so we’re falling short of the RDA. Okay. And there’s some indication that the RDAs are still maybe not optimized, right? Like, they really need to be thought of as a minimum for most nutrients. I think they’re probably in the range for some. And [00:18:00] so there’s four essential nutrients for which 90 percent of Americans are not hitting the daily value, ever.  There’s ten essential nutrients for which half don’t of Americans are more or not hitting the daily value. But even when you, there’s a lot of different studies that will analyze diets that either look at meal plans from, you know, cookbooks or whatever, or they’ll look at people following that diet and look at what they’re actually eating.  And they’ll analyze the diets for nutrients and show that even people who are following diets anticipating that those are healthier ways to eat. Uh, each diet has a collection of nutrients that are a lot harder to get. And so there is a proportion of people who are not meeting the daily values of those nutrients.  And, I mean, government dietary guidelines aren’t off the hook here either. Even the dietary guidelines for Americans has a collection of about five nutrients that people aren’t getting enough of even if you follow the guidelines perfectly. So this is kind of a thing that is across dietary guidelines.

Dr. Weitz: Not to mention that there’s thousands of phytonutrients for which we have no guidelines at all and nobody has aren’t even calculated.

Dr. Ballantyne: Ew, I’m so glad you brought that up. I mean, we have, there’s like 10 ish thousand phytonutrients of which we really understand a few hundred. We know the more of them we consume, the healthier we are on average.  We know the biochemical mechanisms, there are very strong antioxidants, they tend to be anti inflammatory. Different phytonutrients localize in different areas of the body, they interact with different pathways, so they have a wide range of different benefits. So, we want. to be consuming a wide range of phytonutrients.  And there’s no daily value for phytonutrients. There’s probably enough data to actually establish one for polyphenols, but that hasn’t been done because we don’t get daily values for non essential nutrients. But I think you and I are on the same page that maybe phytonutrients could be labeled as essential just because they’re so important.

So we are, we’re in a situation where even people who are really intentional about their [00:20:00] food choices because We don’t learn this, right? We don’t learn in school, but also in dietary templates. When you are picking up a diet book at the store, you’re typically learning about what to not eat or how to measure the things that you eat.  You’re typically not learning about nutrients and what they do in the body and which foods contain what nutrients and how to choose foods from different groups so that you’re getting the full range of nutrients that your body needs. And that is what I am building with Nutrivore. And so that includes identifying nutrient dense foods and focusing on them because we’re trying to fill that gap.

So typically, our intake of these nutrients is high enough that we don’t have a disease of malnutrition, right? We don’t have scurvy. We’re getting enough vitamin C to not have scurvy, but we’re still falling short of hitting our daily value and vitamin C is definitely an example of a nutrient for which we Getting a lot higher than the daily value has been shown to have a lot of benefits for, for various situations.  [00:21:00] So, we’re in that weird ray of like, okay, it’s not so low that we’re like, I’m really, really sick, but not getting enough vitamin C is increasing risk of mental health challenges, increasing risk of cardiovascular disease. It’s having a negative impact on our health. So the best way to fill not just that vitamin C gap, but all of the different gaps that we have is identifying nutrient dense foods and being intentional about adding them to our diets.  So that is again, one of the tools that I am creating in my book, A Nutrivore.

Dr. Weitz: I’m curious as to how you come up with this, nutrient density score, for example, are all nutrients equal weighted? Are some more important than others, you know, how, how much is considered a good amount?

Dr. Ballantyne: Oh, I, that’s okay.  I’m going to nerd out about nutrient density calculation math with you. I think you, we’ve got [00:22:00] another three hours, I hope. So, I created something called the Nutrivore score, which is a measurement of nutrient density, which is scientifically defined. This is the consensus definition as total nutrients per calorie.  The definition of nutrient density, like it, Nutrient density calculations have an interesting history. So a nutrient dense food, that term was first coined in the 70s and it was defined as any food with a substantial amount of nutrients per serving. Substantial was not like specified any more than that.  You’re like, what does that mean? And so, I was someone who was alive in the 70s, 80s, and 90s. I remember labels and how that was like the beginning of like the health aura and the like healthification of labels but not the product, right? That led to a lot of challenges. And what ended up happening in the 70s, 80s and 90s was the demonization of foods as bad because they had high [00:23:00] fat content, like avocados, nuts and seeds, right?  These foods that we now recognize are really like important heart healthy fats. Those foods got demonized for having high fat content. But a sugary fruit punch could say a good source of vitamin C on the label if it had 10 percent of the daily value per glass. And so in the early 2000s, that definition was updated to significant amounts of nutrients per calorie.  Because we were in a situation, we’re still at a situation, where there’s no shortage of calories in the food supply, but there is a shortage of nutrients in the food supply. So we need to understand how to get more nutrients per calorie, not more servings of foods. And at the same time, scientists are working on different nutrient density scores.  So there’s a few dozen of them that have been created over time, none of which have been adopted by any institute or agency. My initial intention when I was first building the Nutrivore website and working on the the early foundational content.  In preparation for writing the book was I’m going to go through all this research and figure out which one’s the [00:24:00] closest to being ready for prime time, which one is almost there.  And I’m just going to use whichever is the best one in the science. I spent three months reading every single nutrient profiling paper out there. And I kept hitting, well, why are you guys doing that? I kept hitting these moments where I was like, That makes no sense. So, couple of the challenges, and you identified a few right in the question.  So, one of the biggest like, like pitfalls that I see happening in nutrient profiling right now is scientists are trying to figure out which nutrients to include in the calculation so that the score at the end aligns with the healthy eating index, which is a measurement of how well someone’s diet follows the USDA dietary guidelines for Americans.

Uh, it’s kind of like retrofitting the score for the guidelines that already exist. I think that’s the opposite of the right way to go about it. I think we should be figuring out how to understand the food and then seeing what that tells us about maybe some edits to the next day. The guidelines are [00:25:00] updated every five years.  It would not be a big deal to edit them again and go, hey, now we know these foods are more nutritionally important, right? That, that’s, there’s, that should be something that can happen. And then there’s this idea of like penalizing foods for containing things like added sugars or sodium or saturated fats or cholesterol.  And then there’s this idea of, like weighting certain nutrients. That’s all kind of happening right now in the scientific literature. So like the Food Compass is sort of well known because it keeps making the news for having such a high score for Lucky Charms cereal. It is not ready for primetime either, although I think it’s probably the most interesting out of the ones that are in development right now.

Dr. Weitz: We have to look at who’s funding all this food science.

Dr. Ballantyne: They’re weighting food attributes, they call them, in a way that is a very like plant based diet lean. And the fact of the matter is you don’t need to weigh certain nutrients more [00:26:00] heavily than others to get to the end of plants have lots of nutrients per calorie.  Like that’s, that’s an easy conclusion. All of these different scores come up with that result. That’s not something you need to put in the math, but that’s what a lot of the direct to consumer, right? That’s what Furman’s ANDI score does as well. It doesn’t include nutrients that are mostly found in animal foods but it includes a lot of nutrients that are only found in plant foods.  And you end up with a system that makes animal foods look terrible and plant foods look great. So with that being, my starting place, like that’s okay. This is, this is the field of science. What that, this is what I have to work with here. I, I, it was a really obvious like algorithmic choice for me.

So the Nutrivore score is algorithmically identical to something called the Nutri Rich Foods Index. So it’s simply a sum of amount of nutrient divided by daily value of nutrient, and then that sum is divided by the energy density of the food. There’s no weighting certain [00:27:00] nutrients more heavily than others.  I think you end up in a situation where you, you bias foods when you start doing that. And also, you could take the approach of, I’m going to weight the nutrients that people are more likely to be deficient in. more in this, like, I’m gonna, like, let’s say it’s like folate, vitamin E, vitamin A, vitamin D. I’m going to give those more weight.  Magnesium, vitamin D. Magnesium, vitamin C. But, you know what happens when you do that and you create an entire system on that, is you overcompensate, right? So people start choosing those foods because they have these higher scores and now they’re missing out on the nutrients that are not given as much weight in the calculation.

So that just felt like that the future proofing of the score is to not actually give these nutrients more weight, but to include as many different nutrients as I have enough data that makes sense to. So the Nutrivore score includes 33 nutrients in the calculation and weight them all equally and make sure that I have representation in these [00:28:00] nutrients of nutrients that are inherent to plant foods, that those are the only source, but also nutrients that are inherent to animal foods, that that’s the only source, so that we’re not automatically putting in a plant based diet bias into the score, and then do all of the math blind, and then just see what it tells me.

And so the NutriScore doesn’t, like, all the nutrients are weighted the same. There’s no, it’s really too complex of a system to be able to do corrections for competitive binding or nutrient synergy because it has to do with everything you eat at a meal and not just what’s in one food, like, as soon as you put salad dressing on your salad, you’re going to absorb more vitamin K and beta carotene, it’s way, it’s, it’s way too complex, and it doesn’t really tell us about the food.  So it’s just a very simple calculation. And it’s the context of like how much is nutrient is versus how much we need. It’s the daily value. Thank you. Yes, the daily values might be an underestimate, but in terms of the math, that doesn’t really matter, because what it is doing is it is basically saying, [00:29:00] this thing we need 100, 100 milligrams of so 200 milligrams in this food is amazing, right?

That’s so great. This thing we need 10 nanograms of, I don’t think there’s anything that’s measured in nanograms, 10 micrograms of, okay, so we’re gonna, we’re gonna, you know, basically it’s, it’s a way of correcting for how much we need. So it doesn’t really matter that they’re, they might be a little bit off.

It’s ballpark is, is good enough in that math. Uh, and then yeah. And then there’s no normalization. There’s no weighing for different food groups, which some of these scores do. They’ll just say, okay, we’ll give the top food in every, in every group. We’ll get a hundred. So then all of a sudden you’re making, you’re making like kale look the same as like whole wheat bread because they’re the tops in their groups, which is, I think also silly.  So it just keeps it very, very simple. It’s a straight up calculation. Yeah. The thing that’s special about it is how much data is in the calculation and that’s why it gives us such a complete picture of the nutrient density of foods.

Dr. Weitz: I make a prediction you’re probably not going to get a huge grant from [00:30:00] Kellogg’s for your program.

Dr. Ballantyne: No, but you know what, a grant would be a grant. Would it be a grant? As long, as long as I can maintain my independence. Yeah, no chance, chances, chances are good. Uh, the Kellogg’s cereal tends, tends not to, even fortified tends, tends not to have Amazing nutrients. 

Dr. Weitz: You know that whole fortification thing, it’s interesting.  There’s an example of where you’re weighting certain nutrients and how we think we’re making people healthier. Just take iodine as an example. So we had all these millions of people suffering from goiter because they had low iodine. And so we add iodine fortification by adding it to the salt and we have this huge decrease in the number of people with goiter.  And we have this huge increase in the number of people with autoimmune thyroid Hashimoto’s. So, you know, it’s being applauded for years now as this great example of how fortification is so beneficial, but [00:31:00] we just traded one disease for another.

Dr. Ballantyne: I mean, potentially, as somebody with Hashimoto’s thyroiditis very, very personal one there.

Dr. Weitz: You can put me in that camp too. 

Dr. Ballantyne: Yeah, I know. It’s like worst initiation ritual ever to get into that club, right? But, but yeah, I think, you know, that’s, so fortification is fascinating to me. Let’s go on this tangent. Because, because, you know, it really has very limited success stories. So even if you, even if you bought into that very simple narrative of we got a 74 percent reduction in, in goiter.  And even if you wanted to say Hashimoto’s thyroiditis is much more complex than iodine excess. And so let’s, let’s not count that as, as like coming off of the success story. I think there’s a lot of nuance here and probably Of course. 

Dr. Weitz: Yeah. I was oversimplifying for sure.

Dr. Ballantyne: And then we’ve got iron fortification, and that has caused, if I remember correctly, it’s like 30 or 40 percent reduction in iron deficiency anemia, [00:32:00] and then folic acid fortification has pretty, like, impressively reduced risk of neural tube defects.  Those are the three success stories of fortification, right? So we’ve got three success stories, we fortify with a lot more nutrients than just those three, right? Like pretty much all the B vitamins except B12 are in a fortification. Okay, well not B7 either. All of the, the, the B vitamins that we were known about in the 40s.  And then we’ve got vitamin D, but not, not in that many. That’s mostly in, dairy products that are geared at kids and not as much in dairy products that are geared as adults. I think it’s, it’s, It’s kind of surprising how little of an effect fortification has had on, well, no effect, on like the really big You know, health conditions that are a major burden on society that can completely take away your quality of life, that have really high morbidity and [00:33:00] mortality rates, right?  Like cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes and cancer. You can’t see a signal from fortification reflected in those health outcomes, nor can you from multivitamins. Which is fascinating to me, and it really to me reinforces the importance of getting at least most of our nutrients from whole foods.

Not that I’m anti supplement, there’s definitely a time and a place. Like, I take so much vitamin D to keep my levels normal, right? Like, I’m definitely not anti supplement, but I think that if you think of fortification as a supplement, right? It’s the same forms that are in a multivitamin, generally. It really, you see the value of a food first approach and then, you know, individualized supplementation as a second layer rather than supplementing the entire food supply.

Dr. Weitz: Right. So, since you’ve been calculating the nutrient density of so many foods, tell us about some of the biggest surprises that you’ve discovered, which [00:34:00] you talk about in your book.

Dr. Ballantyne: Yeah, there have been,

Dr. Weitz: by the way, warning, warning, … Sarah is about to bust some of the food myths and functional medicine practitioners are not going to be happy.

Dr. Ballantyne: Yes. Uh, thank you for the, like rolling out the, what is the opposite of the red carpet for the answer to this question. So I think the, there’ve been a lot of surprises now, my take a sort of high level view to this question before I share like the most nutrient dense food, which nobody would have ever guessed in a million years.  I think the best way to use the Nutrivore score is to identify simple swaps or additions in a meal that don’t take away from like your enjoyment of the meal, but will add a lot of nutrition to the meal. So like a really easy example would be like if you’re making a pasta dish, like swapping out regular pasta for whole grain pasta will add some nutrients, but then if you swap that out for like a lentil or chickpea based pasta, so you’re [00:35:00] gonna, you’re gonna double your nutrient density going from like plain whole wheat, you’re going to about quadruple it going up to like a lentil or chickpea based pasta.

And that’s all you did. But then maybe you also identified a simple addition and you added some sliced mushrooms to your sauce or some basil or some garlic. Probably added a lot of flavor to the sauce as well, but then you added a lot of nutrition and Your pasta dish is probably just as great. So, as a practical tool, I think that’s the best way to use the Nutri Force score.  My favorite, like, nerding out surprise moments, are the foods that have reputations for being nutritionally pointless, that get a redemption arc, that through the Nutri Force score calculation, my favorite example of this is iceberg lettuce, which has more nutrients per calorie than celery, or, which we put up on this pedestal.  or Cucumber or Artichoke. It actually has slightly more nutrients per calorie than Sockeye Salmon. 

Dr. Weitz: Does celery juice cure all ails?

Dr. Ballantyne: Waiting for the scientific study to show that one. So far, [00:36:00] so far so far lacking. Although celery does have some really interesting polyphenols, but you’re getting that from celery in any form, it doesn’t have to be juiced.  So that’s my favorite way to use the Nutri Score. Is to kind of say, like, look at the value of iceberg lettuce, look at the value of watermelon or potatoes. Like, foods that people kind of love to dunk on. But there’s also been a lot of, you know, Just like, who, okay, who could have known that the single most nutrient dense food was canned clam liquid?  Like, that is not something, if you had told me, like, here’s, here’s your data set of 8, 000 foods, guess, what, what are you gonna guess? And I would have guessed liver, maybe, Or maybe like a Leafy Green, like Watercress, and Watercress and Liver are both, like, way up there. But the single most nutrient dense food is canned clam liquid.  And here’s how the math works out. Like, here’s, here’s how that happens. I feel like that needs, because I do not want to start a drinking clam juice story. Trend That is not what we’re trying to do here. . I wanna say why we’re run clam

Dr. Weitz: juice in every [00:37:00] grocery store. .

Dr. Ballantyne: I mean, if you are going to incorporate, make sure to go up on totally paper

Dr. Weitz: and clam juice.

Dr. Ballantyne: Clam juice. Empty, empty shelves. Make sure to look for a low sodium option if this is something that you want to incorporate. You don’t have to, though. I think that’s the other liberating thing about the new, the 

Dr. Weitz: What the hell is clam juice anyway?

Dr. Ballantyne: So it is literally the liquid that, like, clams are cooked in.  So, so you can either get it from, like, it is the liquid when you drain a can of clams, or you can buy it separately because it’s used as an ingredient in linguine with clam sauce in clam chowder. It’s used as a cocktail ingredient. So it has some like traditional like food uses as well. But yeah, it is the liquid that clams are cooked in typically pressure cooked in.

Dr. Weitz: So there is some I think you should change the name to clam broth. It’ll sell like crazy.

Dr. Ballantyne: Yes. Clam juice does kind of sound like you squeezed the clams. That’s, I’m pretty sure there’s no squeezing [00:38:00] step. It’s just Heating them in liquid, then doing something really cool with the clams, and then selling the liquid because it has a lot of flavor.  Clam Bisque, I mean, I guess you could think of it as, yeah, but it’s unseasoned. So, there’s a lot of nutrients that are in the clams that ends up, you know, that are water soluble that end up in the liquid. So the reason why canned clam liquid or clam juice is the top most nutrient dense food, and this is true for all of the most nutrient dense foods, it’s very very low energy density.  So when you divide by a very small number, you get a much bigger number. So a food that has a very low energy density So canned clam liquid is five calories per cup. When you have something that’s that low energy density, it doesn’t have to have a ton of nutrition to have high nutrients per calorie.  So remember, nutrient density is nutrients per calorie, not per serving or per hundred grams. So, when you have something that’s super low energy density, doesn’t need to have a ton of nutrition. And canned clam liquid, [00:39:00] has some impressive nutrition. It has 500 percent of the daily value of vitamin B12 in a one cup serving, like, which is just huge.  And it also has some potassium, some other minerals, it’s, you know, it’s got some other B vitamins, it’s got some protein. So it has an impressive amount of nutrition. for that five calories. That’s how the math works out for it to be the top. But is it going to contribute the most, like, nutrients to your diet?

No, that’s going to be a food like the actual clams, right, or oysters, or liver, or those like really nutrient dense leafy greens like kale and watercress and rainbow chard. Those are all the foods that are going to contribute a lot more to your diet. like absolute nutrition, which is why I never recommend only using the NutriVerse score to choose our foods, that we, it’s fascinating, it tells us a lot about a food, but it’s not the only information that we want to be considering when we’re putting together our plates, because then we’re going to end up with a diet where we’re just eating, Clam juice and watercress all day and that’s not going to be [00:40:00] nutritionally beneficial.  But other foods that have that like really low energy density that end up with really high NutriVore scores are not as alarming as clam juice. Like coffee is way up there. You know, it’s, it’s one of the top most nutrient dense foods because it’s packed with polyphenols, actually has some B vitamins as well.  but also one or two calories per cup. A lot of leafy greens make the cut. Same, same thing, right? Not very high nutrient density, but for each calorie, tons of nutrition.

Dr. Weitz: Interesting. You also break the myth about healthy fats and you state in your book, that healthier fats include olive oil.  Avocado oil, which most functional medicine practitioners agree with, and soybean oil, canola oil, corn oil, and sunflower oil, which many in the functional medicine community do not agree with.

Dr. Ballantyne: Yeah, this was [00:41:00] one of I want you to just imagine me coming from a place where I was very anti vegetable oils in the past and really reading in the science and falling down this rabbit hole of scientific studies for a few weeks, because I had such a hard time wrapping my head around this.  So I, I want to, like, like, I want to preface my answer to this question by, yep, I, my inner child had a temper tantrum as I was reading these studies. I had a really hard time. Being open to this research. It was, it was really challenging, and, and it’s because We’ve got such a strong mechanism in place for understanding high omega 6 polyunsaturated fats in relation to omega 3 polyunsaturated fats and how those should be inflammatory, right?

We, we just have such a wealth of scientific evidence showing that, These fats in the cell membrane are used as substrate and what, which one you have will [00:42:00] determine which you know, paracrine and autocrine signaling molecules are made. We know that if omega 6 is there, we get inflammatory signals.

We know if omega 3 is there, we get either anti inflammatory or anti inflammatory. Only mildly inflammatory signals. Like, we have, we have it all mapped out. We know, we know all the biochemical mechanisms. And yet, when you give humans canola oil, or corn oil, or soybean oil, not only does it lower their cardiovascular disease risk factors, like, like, seeing lower serum cholesterol, is only exciting if you also see lower cardiovascular disease risk, which we do.

We see lower all cause mortality, a general indicator of health and longevity. And, what’s fascinating is studies that have actually compared canola oil head to head with olive oil intervention trials have shown They’re both equally as good for cardiovascular disease risk, and they work through different mechanisms, so actually, we would be, we would be best off if we were incorporating [00:43:00] both into our diets, which is mind blowing, because it tells us that there is some regulation of these paracrine and autocrine signaling molecules beyond substrate bioavailability.

but we don’t know what it is. And that is, fascinating. This is definitely a, science has really shifted in the last five years. We’ve got now a really good body of scientific evidence showing benefits to vegetable oils. I still put olive oil on a pedestal. I still think olive oil is, is the king of oils.

You just can’t, you just can’t, like the polyphenols, the triterpenes, it’s got so much good stuff in it. You, you really can’t, I don’t, I don’t think you can beat olive oil, but it shows that these more affordable. oil options are beneficial. Not as good as olive oil, but for somebody on a budget, you know, still beneficial.

And I think what’s, what’s so important in following that science is, again, right, the difference between how we understood it when it was in animal models, [00:44:00] and cell culture models, versus now how we understand it in humans, and the fact that it reveals an important something different in our biochemistry that we still need to understand, but we’ve got these intervention trials that make the result very, very clear.

Dr. Weitz: I just want to apologize to the listeners for this gardener who’s right outside my window who seems like he’s never gonna stop with his lawn blower or whatever it is. So I wanted to push back just a little bit because I do think that a percentage of these studies that have shown that there’s a decreased cardiovascular risk with soybean oil and some of these other polyunsaturated oils is because they’re comparing saturated fat with substituting a soybean oil or something like that and That’s not necessarily substituting an omega 6 versus omega 3 or, you [00:45:00] know, an overall different type of, you know, there aren’t too many studies that, you mentioned one, but there aren’t too many studies that are really comparing olive oil versus soybean oil.  uh, saturated fats versus polyunsaturated fats and the polyunsaturated fats having some benefit potentially.

Dr. Ballantyne: Yes, I, so I think that’s a great point. So I think, the, the broader point is when we switch to something, right, There’s two parts of the equation. There is whether or not the thing we’re now eating, what its health effects are, and what is the thing that we swapped it out for.  Right. So absolutely correct. The studies that show benefits to vegetable oils are the studies that show swapping out butter or margarine for vegetable oils. So swapping out a saturated fat, whether that’s a natural saturated fat or a man made saturated fat, which what fully hydrogenated vegetable oils and margarine are.

For an [00:46:00] unsaturated fat. I still think that’s very fascinating and I still think that it makes a strong case for benefits of vegetable oil, but there are now more, more studies that are comparing vegetables to olive oil. There’s one that I cite in the book that compared If I remember correctly, it compared, olive oil, corn oil, sunflower oil, and I think canola was in there, and it looked at all cause mortality, again, sort of a broad indicator of health and longevity.

And, I think, like, nobody is surprised, it showed olive oil, right, high oleic uh, acid, right, a omega 9, a monounsaturated fatty acid, extremely rigorously shown to reduce cardiovascular disease risk, right? So, it showed olive oil was, was, was the king, was definitely beneficial but then it showed still reductions in all cause mortality from other vegetable oils and increases in all cause mortality from margarine and butter.

So your [00:47:00] zero was not having these things, right? And I think, I think there is a good enough body of scientific literature, for example, showing in humans that we don’t see vegetable oil consumption increasing C reactive protein or TNF Tumor Necrosis Factor Alpha, or Interleukin 6, like these markers of inflammation.

I think there is enough information to say solidly, again, olive oil, avocado oil, I don’t think you could compete with them because those monounsaturated fats are so beneficial. But I think we can take a step back for sure from saying that vegetable oils are problematic. I don’t, science does not support saying that they’re increasing cardiovascular disease risk or that they’re inflammatory.

Dr. Weitz: Just to play devil’s advocate one more time, I hope you don’t mind, is, there was the Minnesota study, which was one of the few dietary studies where they actually had people staying at this mental institution and they were able to control everything they ate so they know accurately what they really ate.  And it turns out that when they [00:48:00] substituted, omega 6 oils for saturated fats, While there was a potential reduction in cardiovascular disease, all cause mortality actually increased in those eating the vegetable oils, and the conclusion seemed to be that there was an increase in cancer, which people attributed to some sort of increase in inflammation.

Dr. Ballantyne: I, I’d be very interested, I’m not super familiar with that study, so I, I don’t. 

Dr. Weitz: Remember the studies in the 60s, and the Minnesota was. Oh, the Minnesota starvation. Published, and they went. It was the Minnesota

Dr. Ballantyne: starvation experiment, was also part of it.

Dr. Weitz: I don’t know. This was like in a mental institution and they hadn’t published it.  And then just like in the last, I don’t know, 10, 15 years, they published it. And so.

Dr. Ballantyne: Yeah. I mean, I I don’t want to, to speculate on the quality of that study, having not, not read it. I, my, my, my little alarm bells go up as soon as you say the data was published 30 or 40 years later, because we don’t actually know what the methodology [00:49:00] was in that case.  The people who probably, We’re taking, right, taking notes on that data may no longer be with us. So I do have little like my little skeptic are dark up, but I don’t want to comment because I’m, I’m not familiar. That’s

Dr. Weitz: okay. Since, since you’re breaking myths, you also said something about olive oil, which I think people need to hear.  I talked to so many people who are like, I won’t cook with olive oil because it’s, it’s going to become rancid. It’s going to be damaged by the heat. Can you explain what the deal is and is it okay to fry my eggs in olive oil?

Dr. Ballantyne: It is absolutely fine to cook with olive oil. They’ve done studies where they sit, they heat olive oil for like 24 hours and measure how much of the fats get oxidized in that time and show olive oil is actually incredibly heat stable.  The higher the quality of olive oil, typically the better, even though it has a lower smoking point. So we do want to be aware of smoking points when we’re cooking with something like olive oil. So can

Dr. Weitz: you explain the difference between smoke point [00:50:00] and is it burning and heat stability? Okay.

Dr. Ballantyne: Yeah. So I’m going to try.  This, this is, I’m going to try. There, we’re getting into some really interesting physics phenomenon here. So, what is making a high quality olive oil have a lower smoke point, which is the temperature at which it will start to smoke is 

Dr. Weitz: And people automatically assume that means that the oil’s getting damaged.

Dr. Ballantyne: Yes, it kind of, so it is sort of. So it doesn’t necessarily mean oxidation of fat, so there’s other things in the olive oil that are starting to burn. So it is some, but it is other compounds, and these are compounds that are taken out in the refinement process in a regular olive oil. That’s why a refined olive oil has a longer shelf life and has a higher smoke point.  So it’s more like these other compounds are there that they can start to burn at a lower temperature and then that can trigger a bit of a downstream [00:51:00] chemical reaction for making some of the fats oxidize. So if you heat an oil to smoke, point. If it’s really smoking, like if I’m in my kitchen, if I overheated the pan, I didn’t realize it, if I’m putting the smoke, if I put the oil in and it smokes a little bit, I’m going to take the pan off the heat, I’m going to throw something in it, food, not water, don’t, don’t, not water, food in it to cool it down real fast, I’m not going to worry about it.  If I throw it in and it is like, smoke detector, like I need to throw on the fan over the range because it is smoking that much, I’m gonna toss that, I’m not gonna, like that is now going to have a lot of oxidized fat in it, and it can happen quite quickly.

Dr. Weitz: Right.

Dr. Ballantyne: So, that being said, If you’re staying below smoke point, which most cooking applications will be like, like olive oil hat, depending on the quality of olive oil, it’s going to have a smoke point in the like 360 to 410 range.

Yeah.

Dr. Weitz: I’ve seen 375, 350. [00:52:00] Yeah.

Dr. Ballantyne: Most like baking is getting to like a hundred and sixty like anything in the oven, right? That your actual functional temperature is not as high Like your surface temperature on the food is not as high as the oven temperature, right? That’s because that’s that’s how cooking works. 

Dr. Weitz: Wait, wait, wait, wait.  I don’t think most people understand that So, so if you bake vegetables in the oven and you put the temperature at 375, the food’s not at 375

Dr. Ballantyne: Not yet. Yeah, it takes, so the food, so think about the heat transfer. Okay. So your food starts off, let’s say at room temperature. Okay. So it’s, it’s, it’s starting off at, I don’t know, 70 degrees.

Dr. Weitz: Right.

Dr. Ballantyne: You rub some oil on it, some, some seasoning, you put that in the oven at 375. Let’s say the smoke point of your oil is 375, right? So you’re right at that that line. You are, until you’re at a point where the food is starting to burn, you are not at a point where that oil is going to be hitting the smoke point because the food [00:53:00] has, it’s like a heat sink, right?  So it’s absorbing the heat, from the rest of the oven, but the temperature of the food, where that oil is, isn’t coming up to the temperature of the oven yet, until, right, until you’re, it’s starting to burn, but in that like, nice phase of like, I’ve got a little browning, a little roasting, it’s very, very delicious, you haven’t hit the smoke point of the oil.

Okay. If you pull the pan out. Things are starting to burn. You pull the pan out and you can see smoke coming from the pan. You overdid it. So typically for me, if I’m roasting vegetables, I actually typically do them at 375, but I’m using an olive oil that’s going to have a smoke point more in the 400 to 410 range.

So like I never, I’m not risking it, by having the oven temperature higher than the smoke point. But like this is why you can bake with olive oil, right? Like baked goods, the internal temperature typically is getting up to 160 is typically where a baked muffin or, you know, a cake or something is, is done.

So most of the time, even on your pan, [00:54:00] The temperatures that you’re cooking with in your pan are probably more likely in the 300 range than in the 400 range. Again, unless you’re overheating the pan, which can happen. So these fats are absolutely fine to cook with. It is the vitamin E and the polyphenols are helping to prevent oxidation, but also just those monounsaturated fats are more heat stable than a lot of other, a lot of other oils.  So absolutely fine to cook with. But if, if you, if you whoopsie, and we all whoopsie, it’s fine. Like that is a normal I’m cooking at home experience, and you’re getting a lot of smoke, off of that oil, I, I would recommend tossing it and starting over.

Dr. Weitz: Okay, so you can cook with olive oil, you can bake with olive oil, but just keep the temperatures down below the smoke point.  So if your olive oil has a smoke point of 400 or 375, you know, then don’t roast at 450, roast at 350 or something like that. And with the pan, if you’re making eggs or something on a pan, just don’t [00:55:00] put it up to the highest heat and just watch to make sure that the oil’s not.

Dr. Ballantyne: Most pans don’t like that either, right?  Like most Most of your pans aren’t even as like, I mostly cook on stainless steel. My stainless steel pans don’t want to be cooked, like heated up on, on maximum heat either, like they’re going to warp. So it’s, it’s good for the oil and good for your cookware.

Dr. Weitz: So does higher nutrient density of your food correlate with better health outcomes and or longevity?

Dr. Ballantyne: Yes, so, what we know is that people who get more, have a more nutritious diet, who have fewer nutrient shortfalls, who are, like, eating more of these nutrient dense foods, eating, right, eating more vegetables, eating more fruit, eating more seafood, like these foods that are very nutrient dense, they have reduced risk of heart disease, all cause mortality, cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, cancer, Alzheimer’s disease, osteoporosis you know, like a list goes on and on and on. Do we have studies looking at people [00:56:00] following Nutrivor yet to be able to say that? Not yet. Not yet. But Nutrivor is very much built on the scientific consensus around the importance of nutrients and the overall eating patterns that are shown in a wealth of studies to support long term human health.

Dr. Weitz: You state in your book that being overweight is not necessarily associated with being unhealthy and that you can be overweight, or obese and still be metabolically healthy. Isn’t it the case that in the U. S. Very few people are actually metabolically healthy. In fact, one study published in 2018 found that only 12 percent of Americans were actually metabolically healthy.

Dr. Ballantyne: Uh, yes. So there’s a little bit of a difference in how, like, how metabolically healthy is defined. So the study that said that only 12 percent of people are metabolically healthy used a like more rigorous definition. There’s been other studies that, you know, basically it’s like how [00:57:00] many health markers have to be normal to be called metabolically healthy and how many are allowed to be abnormal, before we start calling you, metabolically abnormal.  Uh, so it’s like do you say zero markers, one marker, or two markers? And that’s, that’s kind of how it’s searched for hard to compared the actual stats in some of these studies because they’re using a slightly different definition. So, in one study that I quote in the book, it showed that basically about half of overweight people are metabolically healthy.

About a quarter of normal weight people are metabolically abnormal. We can’t directly compare that to the 12 percent study because they’re using a definite, a different definition. So, of like how many of these markers and which markers exactly we’re looking at. So it makes it a little bit tough, tough to, to do a direct comparison there.

I think the, rather than getting like into the weeds of the actual number because of that challenge with how it’s defined in different studies, I think the more important thing is to take that step back and say, look at this number of overweight and obese people. It’s about a third of [00:58:00] obese people, about half of overweight people who you know, have normal blood pressure, normal serum triglycerides, normal CRP, normal fasting insulin and glucose, normal A1c, like, they are the example of people who are not experiencing metabolic health detriment.

And when you, regardless of how you define, like, how rigorously you define metabolically normal versus abnormal, The, the, when you start to striate these populations based on other things other than BMI and you look at, for example, physical activity is, physical activity is the strongest indicator. So people who are physically active regardless of their weight have a vastly higher percent chance of being metabolically healthy and people who are inactive regardless of their weight have a vastly higher chance of having metabolic abnormalities.

Other factors that are influenced. are things like diet quality how much sleep we’re getting, right social determinants of, [00:59:00] of health. Uh, so that’s reflected in things like socioeconomic status and race and ethnicity. So it’s complex. And I think that because, because we have these large population studies showing, you know, 50 percent of overweight people are metabolically healthy.

Again, regardless of these differences and how different studies define it. The, I think the take home from there is these other things like physical activity, like diet quality are where the focus needs to be, right? We also see that most people regain weight when they lose it, right? That weight loss diets are not sustainable.

I’ve gone through this experience myself, having lost substantial amounts of weight three times in my life. Uh, hopefully third time’s the charm. We’ll see. It’s, it’s such a I think anybody who’s gone through it, so I can say from my own personal experience, the science backs this up, but this is my own experience.[01:00:00]

My health has not correlated very much, very well with my weight. So I have had very, very good health at moments in time where I have been heavier. And I have had very, very poor health at moments in time when I have been lighter and vice versa, right? Like, but the correlation is not really, you can’t really, you can’t really line it up.

But I can line up how my health has. related to my stress levels and I can line up how my health is related to my activity levels and my overall average diet quality. And so what I want to do with Mutivore is create that focus on the health habits that somebody who is obese, those are health habits that typically will lead to, to weight loss.

Maybe not for everyone. The great thing is it will lead to health independent of weight loss. So I’m trying to, create something that’s weight inclusive, that is certainly compatible with weight loss goals. You can definitely apply a NutriVer philosophy to [01:01:00] an energy deficit. Like that is absolutely something that you can do.

And actually I would recommend it because the less the gain, the harder it is to get all of the nutrients that we need. So the more that nutrient density focus is actually important. But I don’t want. The benefits of a healthy diet to feel unobtainable for somebody just because they haven’t had success on a weight loss plan in the past.  And by shifting that focus to the things that actually matter for long term health, independent of weight, that’s what I’m hoping to achieve is improving people’s health. And it’ll be, you know, individual whether or not that goes along with weight loss.

Dr. Weitz: Right, and you’re also trying to shift the focus away from all these restrictive diets and, you know, in the functional medicine world we constantly have discussions about, you know, which is the best diet, the vegan, the carnivore, you gotta avoid food BODMAPs, you gotta avoid lectins, Oxalates, Histamines, [01:02:00] on and on and on and people are constantly, oh I don’t know if I should eat that food because it might create oxalate and you know it it just gets kind of crazy end up with uh people on very very restrictive diets and that’s not healthy.

Dr. Ballantyne: I agree completely. And I think it’s not, I mean, there’s two challenges with restrictive diets. First is the fewer foods you eat, the harder it is to actually meet your nutritional needs from those foods. So that is kind of goes against the, the NutriVer philosophy. But the second one is we’ve got psychology research dating back to the nineties showing that restrictive diets lead to disordered eating patterns, emotional eating, weight regain cycles.

It’s, it’s when you define a diet based on the things you’re missing. and that you are depriving yourself of. It doesn’t set us up psychologically to sustain that diet. So on Nutrivore, we really talk about sustainable nutrition. So how do we increase diet quality, but without depriving us of our favorite foods?

Other than for medical reasons, that’s obviously a separate, that’s obviously a separate thing over [01:03:00] there. But how do we intentionally make room for what I call quality of life foods in order to sustain that overall higher quality diet? So that is a large part of the discussion in the first part of the book.

Dr. Weitz: Yeah, I feel like you’re in some ways carrying forward kind of the Part of the philosophy of Dr. Jeffrey Bland, who I used to, every year, go to his lecture he would give. I used to listen to his audiotapes, and when everybody was engaged in all these diet wars, and they still are, of course, he’s always talked about emphasizing the quality of the food and not just, you know, how much fat and how much carbs, and we’ve got to look at the quality, and, and that’s what this is sort of getting to.  Let me, let me ask you one more question and we’ll wrap. You mentioned 12 foundational food families in your book, which are the categories of foods with the most nutrient density. So I thought this would be a good way to kind of sum, sum up this discussion. [01:04:00]

Dr. Ballantyne: Yes, so the 12 foundational food families are all of the foods that have something unique to offer us nutritionally, that have a really like solid foundation of scientific studies showing us health benefits of the nutrients those foods contain.  It doesn’t mean we have to eat all of them. So, for example, one of them is seafood, and if you’re allergic to seafood, or you can’t access it because it’s not affordable to you, like, it’s, it is, none of those foods are a absolute 100 percent must, but they are the foods that help, expedite the goal of getting all of the nutrients our bodies need from the foods we eat, which is our bodies.  the goal of Nutrivore. So they are the foods that make achieving that the easiest. And when we prioritize, I, I lay out serving targets per day or per week, depending on what food we’re talking about of these 12 foundational food families in the book. That adds up to like a third to maybe half of our, of our food intake, depending on, on, on what you’re choosing.

It is a small portion of the overall diet, but when we do that, that gets us most of the way to [01:05:00] achieving our, our nutrition. goals, you know, our daily values of everything across the board. So they are very much about achieving that goal efficiently so that we have the most room for rounding out with whatever other foods we want.  So the 12 foundational food families are, I will just list them vegetables in general, root vegetables, leafy vegetables, cruciferous vegetables, mushrooms, alliums, that’s the onion family, fruit in general, berries and citrus fruit, seafood I already mentioned, legumes, and nuts and seeds.

Dr. Weitz: That’s great. This is just an aside.  I just recently became acquainted with one of the downsides of eating fruits, which is, for some reason, in the last couple of weeks, our house has become inundated with fruit flies.

Dr. Ballantyne: Oh, I have, I have two suggestions for you. Oh, really? Wow. Yes, let’s, great, perfect, perfect question to wrap up on. So, So I will say, you can buy these little, they’re like yellow look at like fruit fly traps or, gnat traps [01:06:00] on Amazon or wherever.  They’re these little pieces of yellow sticky, they’ve got some kind of coating on it that attracts insects. So in my house they’ll also, Find the occasional mosquito that makes its way in. I got rid of fungus gnats on one of my plants from them. And then I was like, what if I put this close to the bananas?  What will that do to the fruit flies? Oh look, it catches them. So that is the lowest, lowest effort one. But the free option is get a like old plastic, like a plastic water bottle, something like that. Stab some holes in the side so that there’s a way in, but the great thing about stabbing it, I use like a metal, like skewer for meat to stab, stab a ring of holes around the outside.

And then I stick, you can either use a string to like put a little bit of banana, it works really well. But a little bit of fruit either on a string that is like then tied with the cap. So it’s dangling down. or you can use like a bamboo skewer or something like that to put it in [01:07:00] so that you’ve got a little bit of fruit towards the top.

So the rotting fruit in there is going to be slightly higher than the holes. And then put like a half inch of water at the bottom with a drop of dish soap. So fruit flies are amazing at getting in. They’re not very good at getting out. They gorge themselves on the fruit and then they drop into the soapy water and drown.  And it is a fun project to do with kids. Definitely, highly recommend. Uh, careful with the stabbing things, because sometimes kids get a little excited by that. And it works, and it works, I definitely, it’s the, it works better than the sticky stuff. But then you do have that. And then when you’re ready, I just put, tape over the holes and throw the whole thing out.

Dr. Weitz: Oh, cool. That’s great. So tell our listeners how they can get a hold of the book and find out more about you, Ann. I’d

Dr. Ballantyne: love to. Thank you. Uh, so the book is called Nutrivore, The Radical New Science for Getting the Nutrients You Need from the Food You Eat. It’s available from just about any online bookseller and lots of local bookstores.  You can also request it at your local library if they don’t already have a copy. My website is neutrovore. com and that’s where like all of the really academic deep dive articles that are like the supporting evidence for everything in the book. Uh, that’s where all of those live and on social media, on TikTok, YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, threads, and Pinterest.  I’m at Dr. Sarah Ballantyne.

Dr. Weitz: That’s great. Thank you so much.

Dr. Ballantyne: Thank you.


Dr. Weitz: Thank you for making it all the way through this episode of the Rational Wellness Podcast. For those of you who enjoy. Listening to the Rational Wellness Podcast, I would appreciate it if you could go to Apple Podcasts or Spotify and give us a 5 star ratings and review.  If you would like to work with me personally to help you improve your health, I do accept a limited number of new patients per month for a functional medicine consultation. Some of the areas I specialize in include helping patients with specific health issues like gut problems. [01:09:00] neurodegenerative conditions, autoimmune diseases, cardiometabolic conditions, or for an executive health screen, and to help you promote longevity.  and take a deeper dive into some of those factors that can lead to chronic diseases along the way. Please call my Santa Monica White Sports Chiropractic and Nutrition office at 310 395 3111 and we’ll set you up for a new consultation for functional medicine. And I look forward to speaking to everybody next week.

Dr. Dipti Sagar discusses The Management of Constipation at the Functional Medicine Discussion Group meeting on May 23, 2024 with moderator Dr. Ben Weitz.  

[If you enjoy this podcast, please give us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts, so more people will find The Rational Wellness Podcast. Also check out the video version on my WeitzChiro YouTube page.] 

 

Podcast Highlights

8:20  “No organ in the body is so misunderstood, so slandered, and maltreated as the colon.”  “Besides death, constipation is the big fear in hospitals.”  The goal of the presentation is to understand the pathophysiology of constipation, including the diagnosis, the presentation and pattern recognition, management, and the association with the gut microbiome, as well as other illnesses.Constipation occurs in 10 to 20% of the population and about 700,000 individuals present in the ER for constipation every year in the United States.  And 10 billion is spent annually on laxatives.

10:42  Slow transit constipation vs obstructive defecation.  You want to ask your patients two questions related to constipation:  1. How frequently do you have a bowel movement, and 2. Do you have difficulty with evacuation?  If you only have a bowel movement every two or three days or even longer, then this indicates slow transit constipation. If you have difficulty with evacuation, then you have to start thinking about obstructive defecation, the most common form is pelvic dyssynergia. 

12:05  Secondary causes. There are a number of secondary causes of constipation, including diabetes and hypothyroidism, medications including opioids, NSAIDs, anti-cholinergics, calcium channel blockers and diuretics, and iron supplemention. Other secondary causes of constipation include neurological disorders, including Parkinson’s disease, Multiple Sclerosis, and dementia, and myopathic diseases that include scleroderma and amyloidosis, and structural disorders, including colon cancer and strictures.

 



Dr. Dipti Sagar is an Integrative Gastroenterologist and she is presently sharing an office with Dr. Sam Rahbar at LA Integrative GI and Nutrition in Los Angeles, California  (310) 289-8000.  You can find more information at the LAIntegrativeGI.com website.

Dr. Ben Weitz is available for Functional Nutrition consultations specializing in Functional Gastrointestinal Disorders like IBS/SIBO and Reflux and also Cardiometabolic Risk Factors like elevated lipids, high blood sugar, and high blood pressure.  Dr. Weitz has also successfully helped many patients with managing their weight and improving their athletic performance, as well as sports chiropractic work by calling his Santa Monica office 310-395-3111.

 



 

Podcast Transcript

Dr. Weitz:  Hey, this is Dr. Ben Weitz, host of the Rational Wellness Podcast. I talk to the leading health and nutrition experts and researchers in the field to bring you the latest in cutting edge health information. Subscribe to the Rational Wellness Podcast for weekly updates and to learn more, check out my website, drweitz.com. Thanks for joining me and let’s jump into the podcast. Hello everybody I’m Dr. Ben Weitz. Thank you for joining our functional medicine discussion group meeting.  I very much apologize for no food tonight. Unfortunately, Chop’s Eatery, who we ordered the food from, decided to go out of business yesterday.  So, sometimes stuff happens. I hope you’ll consider attending some of our future meetings. Next month we have Dr. Darren Ingalls, who’s going to be speaking about Lyme disease, and that’s going to be June 27th. July 25th, Alan Barrie on Hypothalamus, Pituitary, Adrenal Access. We don’t have a speaker yet for August.  September, we have Dr. Pimentel. I encourage everyone to participate and ask questions, and if you’re not aware, we have a closed Facebook page, the Functional Medicine Discussion Group of Santa Monica, so you can join there and we can continue the discussion. I post a lot of research studies there and have discussions about functional medicine.

I’ll be recording this event, and I’ll be posting it as part of my Rational Wellness Podcast, and you can find that on Apple Podcast, Spotify, YouTube. If you listen to the Rational Wellness Podcast, please go to Apple or Spotify, give me a five star rating, set a review, and our sponsor for this evening is Integrative Therapeutics.  I’m going to ask Steve right here to comment. Tell us about a few integrated products. Thank you, Steve. 


Steve : Thank you. Hello. Thanks for coming. Glad to be here.  I, the topic is constipation, right? Yes. That’s not a huge thing for us. We had a great product called laxative formula.  Unfortunately, we discontinued it. We do have a really nice formula called Motility Activator that, works as a, almost like an adaptogen for the gut. And so whether you tend towards loose stools or constipation, it actually helps with both. It’s a high potency ginger and artichoke extracts.  It’s a great formula. We sell a lot of it. That’s it right now. So maybe Dr. Rahbar will, I’ll listen and learn something tonight. We’ll come up with something new. Also in the back we have some of the, we have a couple new ones. There’s a vitamin D with K. This new, we kind of got into this late, , which is how we kind of roll, but this is a good thing because we’ve, we waited until sort of the, the science was clear on which [00:03:00] nutrients and how much to use.  So it’s a really, really good formula. That’s, it’s a 5, 000 IUs of vitamin D, 180 micrograms of K2, and it’s about half the price of K Force. So if you use K Force, it’s the same formula at about 25 bucks. We also have a brand new Mag threonate that I don’t even have, it’s that new, it came on our website today.  That one is also gonna be similar, it’s a high potency Mag threonate with a low cost. And then we have samples of Cortisol Manager, which you guys all know about and also the new curcumin, which is called Curalieve.  So get those.

Dr. Weitz: And then of course, one of the main causes of constipation is, is Methane SIBO and you guys have the elemental diet. 

Steve : Yeah. So we talked a little bit about the elemental diet. It’s, this is not the place, there’s too much to go into with the elemental diet, but it’s the only Real one out there right now. I guess Mark Pimentel’s come out with one that’s close, [00:04:00] but it’s super high in carbs So if you’re interested somebody already did tonight talk to talk to me about the elemental diet We also have last one.  We have a product called Blue Heron And I’ll just it’s it’s a oldie but a goodie. And the reason it’s called Blue Heron is because Blue Herons poop a lot. So If you happen to want to try that one, it’s something we can talk about too So there you go. Thanks for coming.


 

Dr. Weitz: Thanks, Steve. And so our speaker for tonight is Dr. Dipti Sagar, and she’s a integrative gastroenterologist who works with Dr. Sam Rhabar. And so why don’t you go ahead and introduce yourself, Dipti, and get started. Thank you. 

Dr. Sagar: Can you guys hear me okay? Yeah. Okay, so a very good evening to everyone. This is such an honor presenting here this evening, not only because I get to meet like minded physicians like you all, but because of how profoundly this has affected my life as a physician.  I first got introduced to holistic integrative medicine, then after several years of practice as a gastroenterologist, As a medical director in a big county hospital, doing thousands of endoscopies and coloscopies, and giving PPI to my patients like candies, I realized that a lot of my patients were not getting better.  So that made me look into what we are missing in traditional medicine. So I started to dig deeper and wanted to see some non traditional ways of treating my patients. And then I had my own journey. where I started having GI issues. Yes, a gastroenterologist with heartburn. And very quickly I realized that I could not take those medications that I was prescribing to my patients.  And that really put me [00:06:00] into this path to explore non traditional ways of healing. And I started this two year fellowship with Academy of Integrative, , , , Academy of Holistic and Integrative Medicine, where I really learned a lot, but unfortunately I could not bring those concepts into my previous practice.

But that said, I do believe that when you have an intention, the universe makes it happen for you. Just like we didn’t have a laptop today, but someone just walked in with a laptop. So when you have the intention, it happens. And I guess that’s how Dr. Rebar and me found each other and we started this collaboration together to do our practices together because of similar mindset.  And I’m really so very grateful for that collaboration because it has infused love, passion and life in medicine for me. And I really call this my rebirth as a physician. And to my surprise, my patients were very accepting of this kind of a model where I’m combining traditional medicine with holistic and complementary medicine because I thought I’m going to get so much pushback from my patients.  But instead they looked at me and said, what took you so long? This is what we have been waiting for all along. So really it changed my relationship with my patients as well. So without further ado, because I know I have to condense my 15 to 20 years of experience treating constipation into just 60 minutes, and now I actually have only 55 minutes, so let’s begin.

Dr. Weitz: Well, we have till 8:00 pm.

Dr. Sagar: All right, so I’m going back. Let’s see. There we go. So my collaborators for this presentation is Dr. Rahbar and Dr. Erdman.  So, as a gastroenterologist, I can very well relate to the first statement, which is that no organ in the body is so misunderstood, so slandered, and maltreated as the colon. And as physicians and providers, some of you probably working in a hospital setting, could relate to the second statement, that besides death, constipation is the big fear in hospitals.  So what is the goal of today’s presentation? We are going to understand the pathophysiology of constipation. We are going to learn about diagnosis, management, presentation and pattern recognition, association with gut microbiome, as well as other illnesses.  And we are going to understand the principles of management.  Let’s talk a little bit about the disease burden.  So, it affects about 10-20 percent of the population, and to be honest, it’s very underdiagnosed because a lot of the patients, they don’t even come to physicians for this, and they just think that this is normal, or they just have to live with it.  So this is just reported 10-20%.  It does affect the quality of life [00:09:00] in a similar way to congestive heart failure or rheumatoid arthritis. About 700,000 individuals present in the ER for constipation every year in the United States. And can you imagine, like, 10 billion is spent annually on laxatives?

Okay. So, when a patient walks into your office, and probably your 10th or 15th or 20th patient of the day, and they say, Doc, I’m constipated. That’s when all hell loose break, loose break, right? And you’re like, I’m ready to quit medicine, right?  But to be honest, it doesn’t have to be that way. And today I’m going to equip you with tools that you can use so that you know exactly what questions to ask this patient, what tests to order, and how to manage them, so that it doesn’t have to be that difficult. So when you walk out of this room today, you’ll be more confident in taking care of these kind of patients, okay? [00:10:00] So as we discussed, consultation is common, but it is challenging, and we have to have a systemic approach in evaluating these patients, so that we can treat them effectively.  However, I wish it was this easy. It’s not. So, what are the few questions that you’re going to ask the patient?  I’m going to give you two questions, which is going to kind of open your mindset as to where, which direction you would be going. The first question is, is it infrequent passage of stool?  That means they are not moving their bowel every day, or they are taking two, three days to move their bowels.  If that’s happening, if the patient said yes, then you have to stop thinking about slow transit constipation. That means the transit of the colon is not as well. 

The second question is, do you have difficulty with evacuation? Because if this is the problem, that they are not able to evacuate, then the problem is not because of the [00:11:00] transit, but you have to start thinking about obstructive defecation.  And one of the most common ones is pelvic dyssynergia. I’m going to go into details of all of this, but this, these two questions will kind of help you understand which direction you have to go. Also remember that constipation can be a distractor. That means there could be a lot of underlying chronic systemic conditions, the presenting symptom of which is constipation.

So you have to explore that. Just don’t think it’s constipation and just laxatives. We have to do more tests. We have to dig deeper into the root cause of that constipation. So this is a simple list, but it’s not complete as you can see, there’s a variety of conditions that can cause constipation. It could be hormonal imbalance like diabetes, hypothyroidism.  It could be problems with the uterine. Honestly, this meditation list is pretty short. It’s not a complete list, but these are the [00:12:00] common medications that can give constipation. So you have to ask the patient, did you change your medication recently? Is there something new that was added? And even old medications can take like a year or so, like calcium cannel blockers do have constipation, so we have to take that history.

Neurological disorders like Parkinson’s disease, spinal cord disorder, myopathic disorders, and of course we have to think about structural disorders like colon cancer, rectocephaly, things like that.  So what’s the next question?  Is this chronic constipation?  Is it because, you know, you were admitted to the hospital, had a surgery or a c section and you got morphine, maybe that’s why you’re constipated, then that’s not chronic, right?  That’s related to the opioid execute. So how would you know if it’s a chronic constipation? Well, if the constipation is present for at least three months for a duration of six months, that’s how we define chronic. And if it’s chronic, then you have to ask this question. Is it Functional Constipation or is it IBS [00:13:00] Constipation?

I actually got this slide from Gastro of 2020 and it summarizes very nicely what’s the difference between Functional Constipation and IBS Constipation. So with Functional Constipation, about 25 percent or more of the times they will complain of straining, lumpy stool, sensation of incomplete evacuation.  Very important, use of fingers to dis-impact yourself. This is extremely important and especially, I see this a lot of time in women and I’m passionate about it because middle aged women, they will come to you saying that they have been constipated all their life. And it started at the age of 18 and they have never had a regular bowel movement.  The very next question that I always ask them, do you ever use your finger to dis-impact yourself? And if the answer is yes, you already know that you’re dealing with an obstructive defecation, most likely pelvic dyssynergia. Okay, so that’s one point. And then in those cases, you [00:14:00] will never have loose stool.  They will always complain of hard, lumpy stool. As compared to IBS constipation, where it will always be associated with some kind of abdominal pain which is relieved with defecation.  The stools would be either infrequent or inconsistent and about less than 25 percent of the time they will say that they have a loose stool.  So loose stool is present in IBS but not in the functional constipation.

So, the chronic constipation could be either normal transit, slow transit, , dyssynergic defecation, or it could be a combination of the two. It could be slow transit with dyssynergic defecation. So a little bit about the slow transit, it is also called a lazy bowel syndrome, and as we said, there is decreased motility of the colon.  The etiology is really very poorly understood, but there could be a lot of things at play, like lack of fiber, it could be autonomic neurology, the interstitial cells of Cajal are actually the colonic pacemakers, and [00:15:00] sometimes abnormalities of those can decrease the motility. And we cannot undermine the role of, neuroendocrine, systems like pancreatic polypeptides, serotonin, because those also play a role in the colon’s motility.  This is different from obstructive dedication, as I said, and with dysnergia, especially in women, there is a problem with the pelvic floor which cannot relax, or it could be a spasm of the anal sphincter. Decreased rectal sensation, where even though stool is present in the rectum, they don’t feel the urge because the sensation is less.

So that can also happen. And then weakness in the pelvic floor, if they have multiple vaginal delivery, during this difficult childhood, they could have things like rectocele, internal collapse. And when you have, these things, they can either cause a physical blockage to evacuation, or sometimes they form these pockets, and that traps the vagal contents, causing obstruction.

So, how do you [00:16:00] identify patients with primary functional chronic constipation? So again, as we said, thorough history taking, asking them everything, when it started, frequency, medication. The visceral stool chart, honestly, we should all have this in our office, a big one on the wall. If you don’t have it, please carry it in the size of a pocket.

A picture. The reason is that I feel like whether you’re having soft or hard stool is a very relative term, which is soft or, , you know, formed for one person can be like a loose stool for another. So this picture kind of generalizes it so that it’s very uniform for everyone. And if your patient says that the stool looks like type 1 or type 2, you have to start thinking about slow transit constipation because why?

It takes, that means the stool is passing through the colon. For a long time. And what is the role of colon to absorb water from the stool, right? So if it stays in the colon for a longer time, your stool is going to get harder and harder And that’s why they have type 1 and 2, [00:17:00] then you have to think about slow transit.

This, the third thing that you have to think is I cannot actually, tell you how important a pelvic floor and anorectal exam is that you need to do on all your patients with chronic constipation. And I’m going to tell you six points that you need to look when you’re doing that rectal exam that’s going to give you so much clues as to what’s happening with the patient.

And then, ultimately you have to do the anorectomy for these patients to differentiate slow transit from pelvic dyssynergia, and we’re going to talk about that as well. So digital rectal examination. So the first thing, the very first thing is inspection. So even before you put the finger into the rectum, you have to separate, the cheeks with both your hands and look around.

What are we looking at? We are looking at external hemorrhoids. Is there a bulge? We are looking for internal hemorrhoids, which are prolapsed. We are looking for any irregularities because [00:18:00] then you have to start thinking about rectocele. You have to look at the vaginal area. Is there a vaginal prolapse?

You have to look at? If there is a scar, are we dealing with the anal fissure? Are the holes around? Are we looking at fistula? Right? So inspection is very important. We look at those things. The second thing is sensation. So we are going to do the endocritoneus reflex. So usually I use a Q tip. So one end has a cotton and the other end is like wooden and we are going to check that sensation in all the four quadrants at 9 o’clock, 12 o’clock, 3 o’clock, and 6 o’clock positions.

And if there is a contraction of when you do the, the reflex there, it’s normal. However, if you don’t see any contraction of the skin, then you use the wooden side. And if you see contraction now, then it is, abnormal or impaired. And the absent is when you, even with the wooden side, you cannot see any, , contraction.

Next is palpation. So when you insert the finger, you have to see the consistency of the stool. Is it a hard stool? Is the patient [00:19:00] impacted? If yes, then yeah, you’re thinking about obstructive defecation. Is there a liquid stool? Or is it no stool? So patient is constipated, but there is no stool. So yeah, this is slow transit constipation then, because the stool hasn’t come to the rectum yet.

So that gives you some clue, and if you have done enough rectal exams, you would know what a normal resting sphincter tone is, right? So that is something that we need to feel at rest, and after that, you tell the patient to squeeze very hard for 30 seconds, because you’re checking if they have enough strength, if there is enough squeeze there.

If not, you have to start thinking about problems with the sacral nerve and, , probably get an MRI. The next, we are going to ask the patient to push down, , thinking that your, finger is actually a stool and they have to evacuate it. Before the patient starts doing that, you have to put the other hand onto the patient’s belly, okay?

And then you ask them to push down. When the patient is contracting the lower abdominal muscles, [00:20:00] the sphincter in your finger should feel relaxed, right? However, if there is opposite, that means the sphincter is tightening and the abdominal muscle is relaxing, it’s a problem. If both of them is relaxing, that’s a problem.

If both of them is contracting, that is also a problem. So if you see any of this, you already is thinking in terms of pelvic dyssynergia and the next step would be to, do an anorectomy. So when you do the push down, you have to see what’s the push and pull. You have to see if the sphincter is relaxing or not, and you also see if there is a perianal descent or not.

So balloon expulsion test is a useful test to test that. I recommend doing it in the office. We do it combined with anorectal immunometry, where you insert a balloon with a catheter and fill the balloon with 50 ml of water. The patient is supposed to, expel it within 60 seconds. If they are not able to do it or take longer, then again you have to start thinking about therapeutic disinertia.

We always combine this. with anorectal [00:21:00] myelometry in our office setting. I’m not going to talk about that because Dr. Edmund is going to go into the details of how we do that after my talk, so you’ll get some overview there. Let’s get to the cheese effect, the treatment. Alright. Okay. So if you have diagnosed a patient with pelvic dyssynergia, , we recommend doing a pelvic floor physical therapy.

There are several exercises that we can recommend to the patient to strengthen their pelvic floor. And I know I said women, but men can also have pelvic floor abnormalities and dyssynergia. So there are crucial exercises for men as well that we recommend to our patients. This was a good study, which was published in the Clinical Gastroenterology in 2023, an office based point of care test that predicts treatment outcomes with community based pelvic floor physical therapy in patients with chronic constipation.

It’s very interesting that we used this [00:22:00] special balloon, and it’s a foam based balloon. As you can see, when it’s deflated, it looks like that, and then you inflate it with water. The benefit of this is that the consistency feels like that of stew. So it doesn’t feel like water or air for the patient, so it’s more natural for them because it has a consistency of stew.

I always believe in going back to the basics before we start, you know, the big guns. So lifestyle, we always start with this, right? Are we drinking enough water? 60 to 80 ounces of water or fluid every day. Are you getting enough exercise? You know, because if you are moving, your colon is moving. Are you having enough fiber in your diet?

Start small. I start with one fruit every day. So I tell the patient maybe have one apple, plum, apricot, any fruit which is like high fiber with the skin for breakfast every day. Start there and see how you do. Because sometimes that’s enough, you know. [00:23:00] And then this is, , something which I always encourage my patient that a lifestyle change, which is free of cost.

And trust me, your patients will be, their ears will be all open. They wanna know what that is. You ask them to drink a big glass of warm water every morning, okay? So there is no, you don’t have to buy anything. It’s free of cost, but it’s so helpful for patients with constipation. What it does is, because the water is warm, it’s going to cause basal dilatation, so it’s increasing the blood circulation to your gut, right?

And secondly, because it’s warm, it’s also stimulating peristalsis. So extremely helpful if the patient is kind of dealing with a slow transit kind of situation. , fiber, I’m especially a big fan of bulk forming fiber, but remember not all fiber is the same. There could be soluble fibers and insoluble fiber.

Psyllium is my favorite. It is also a prebiotic because it’s broken down by gut microbiomes into postbiotic metabolites like starchy fatty acids, [00:24:00] which in turn is helpful for gut, brain, gut, lung, and gut liver access. So extremely helpful, the patients have to drink enough water with the fiber for them to work.

And remember that fiber can sometimes cause gas and flatulence, so not every fiber is good for everyone. So your patients have to try different ones to see which one works best for them. So outlet obstruction, again, we talked about high fiber will work for those patients as well. , because sometimes the sensation in the rectum, as I said, is decreased.

So your job is to bulk up the stool so that the rectum is stretching more than usual. So that they have the sensation that now they have to go. So that’s why even fiber works in outlet obstruction. Sometimes we do warm water rectal irrigation. Biofeedback, very helpful in patients with NSMIS and reduced rectal sensation.

This is something we offer in our office setting as well. , Botox injection into the pubertalis, psycho, psychological counseling, pelvic floor [00:25:00] rehabilitation as I said. Surgery is the last resort, but you have to remember that about 50 percent of your patients will have recurrence of symptoms in six, in four years.

And therefore, again, going back to the basics and doing the basic stuff is more important.

I usually get asked, like, when I’m going to order the MRI. Honestly, whenever you feel that there is an organic abnormality, like you’re thinking about a rectocele, or a prolapse, or intersusception, that’s when you get an MRI. A few words about the laxatives. Osmotic laxatives really works well. Magnesium is one of my favorites.

And the docoset is actually a lubricating laxative, but only use that for a short term. I do not like to put the patient’s long term on that. And laxatives like Senna and Dopset, , they can cause a lot of cramping. So I usually don’t recommend that. And you can use the rectum forms too, if that’s what is preferred.

A few words about magnesium, because I love magnesium, but you have to remember that not all [00:26:00] magnesium salts are the same. So if the patient is having a constipation problem, We prefer to give Magnesium Citrate or Oxide, but some of my patients, for example, my all time favorite is Magnesium Glycinate. And especially in middle aged women, in perimenopausal women, somebody who’s like 50 years old, having constipation, but at the same time they’re having perimenopausal symptoms like hot flushes, anxiety, not able to sleep at night, I always combine magnesium glycinate.

Because it has a very calming effect on the nerves, especially in that patient population. So if you combine Magnesium Citrate with Magnesium Glycinate, in those patient population, you will see significant improvement, not only in terms of constipation, but also relaxing the pelvic floor, because it has a calming effect, the glycinate.

So just a few words about, the medication. So we have Elitesia, Lenz’s, TruLenz, and Multigridly. , I’m just going to say that all of this [00:27:00] works by increasing the colonic transit. So honestly, if you are having a patient with slow transit constipation, you can consider them, definitely. They are peptides.

But remember, we always need to have a discussion with the patient and not everyone is ready to try medications. If by your physical examination and your test you have established that this patient has pelvic dyssynergia or obstructive defecation, you do not want to use this because there is no problem with the colonic transit in those patients, right?

So be very careful because if there is an obstruction and you use this, it can be very uncomfortable for the patients. Again we are not without side effects. Sorry the slide is not very clear, but this is the um. Published in 2007, the side effects of amethysia, like abdominal pain, cramps, diarrhea, flash lens, , lenses, and the true lens, same kind of a side effect.

This is the new kid on the block, IBS Ryla. , it is minimally absorbed, and it’s a small molecule inhibitor of sodium hydrogen [00:28:00] exchanger isoform 3. It is recently FDA approved for iiv constipation. You give 50 milligram twice a day with meals and again, it has side effects, diarrhea, ulence, and oph pharyngitis.

So this is another option that we can use. So as a holistic gastroenterologist, I always try to think out of the box what is it else that I can give offered to my patient because not medication has less side effects and more effective. I’m going to share some of my tools with you. And this is one of my favorites, it’s Triphala.  If any one of you are familiar with Ayurvedic medicine, you would know that this is a very potent herb, which is used in Ayurvedic medicine. It’s a combination of three herbs, Hari Taki, Devi Taki, and Amla. And it’s used in Ayurvedic traditional, medicine for years for treating constipation and inflammation.  I’m very fascinated with Ayurvedic medicine, so if you know about [00:29:00] it, in Ayurvedic medicine, you classify individuals based on their doshas. And the doshas is kind of their personality or how the body works, and there are three types of doshas.

As you can see, Triphala kind of works in all the three doshas. In fact, in India, Triphala is not only used for constipation, it’s also used for weight management. So people use Triphala to lose weight, effectively without any side effects. So I offer this to my patients, usually it’s taken half to one teaspoon, you have to drink it with warm water.

Especially if you are treating constipation at night time, it’s great. , it also comes in pill form. I do like powder form. But if you’re doing the pill, it’s like 750 mg or something like that. But it has no side effects. Very potent. The other one is, use of MCT oil. So, MCT oil [00:30:00] is the same as coconut oil, but it has the medium gene fatty acids, which is more potent because it has 90 plus, as compared to coconut oil.

And how it works, it works by loosening the stool and lubricating the lining of the colon so that it’s easier for them to pass the stool. Vibrating Capsule, this is another service that we offer in our office as well. This was a study that was published by Rao 2023, and it showed that Vibrating Capsule was superior to Placebo Capsule.  It improved constipation symptoms and quality of life, and it was very safe and well tolerated. The patients inject one capsule, for five days in a week. And this study was for eight weeks, and it showed that they, improved bowel movements to one to two bowel movements every week. So the most common side effect of the vibrating capsule was the sensation of [00:31:00] vibration, which 11 percent of the patients felt, but none of them quit the study because of that sensation, so it wasn’t that bad.  So, However, you have to keep in mind that there are some contraindications. For example, you cannot give this, give this in pregnant patients, if the patient is needing a lot of MRI studies, what we recommend is that patients should be able to evacuate all the capsules before they go for the MRI.

And for the same reason, because of obstruction or a diverticulum, you don’t want the capsule to get stuck. So they, you have to rule that out before you give it to the patient. And, , remember that the capsule has to reach the colon. to start vibrating for it to be effective. So if your patient has gastroparesis, that will not be a great candidate because it will not be like, the capsule might start vibrating even before they go to the colon.

So you don’t want to, you want to exclude those patients. And then those are nerve stimulators, pacemaker, and defibrillators. We don’t want to give them those. So the, this is a study showing the benefit [00:32:00] of Nalgimidine, which is a re opioid antagonist in patients with cancer, so more like more opioid or morphine induced constipation have shown benefit with that one.

I’m a strong believer of the brain gut connection, the vagus nerve. So it starts origins, it has an origin in the brain and it goes all the way into your colon. The rectum, however, is innervated by the sacral plexus. However, I do believe that there could be sometimes a miscommunication between the vagus they are not communicating very well, and that can cause constipation.

And as you can see, the vagus nerve can aid in digestion, it can increase gastric juice, it can promote gut motility. So yes, if you stimulate the vagus nerve, your patients with autonomic neuropathy or decreased parasympathetic tone could actually have improvement in constipation. So, this is a stimulator that we also offer in our office, very easy to use, there are several locations.

There is another study which is showing the benefit of [00:33:00] transcutaneous auricular vagal nerve stimulation on abdominal pain and constipation in patients with IBS constipation. So, you can use the vagus nerve stimulation either in the neck or, the yellow circle around the, , in the ear, you can use there to stimulate the vagus nerve.

But do you really need a device to stimulate the vagus nerve? Not really. You can tell your patients to do these things that will stimulate vagus nerve activation like meditation, exercise, singing, massage, cold plunges in Lake Tahoe, splashes of cold water, breath work, yoga, intermittent fasting, and just hugging each other more often is going to stimulate your vagus nerve.

So we have been proving the wrong way in America all along, right? So, the right way to poop is by squatting, because when you’re sitting, the puborectalis muscle has an acute angle, as you can see here. So it’s really difficult for the [00:34:00] stool to go all the way when you have that acute angle. And that angle really becomes straight when you’re squatting.

So I really, for all my patients with constipation, I tell them that they should be squatting, because squatting is the only natural edification process. And we should really be doing this. Sometimes there is a deficiency of bile in your gut and that can cause constipation. And there comes the role of a bile acid transporter inhibitor when I feel like this is the cause because this medication can decrease bile acid absorption and increase the colonic bile acid.

And that in turn is going to accelerate the colonic transit. So this was a study that was published in Practical Gastroenterology by Virginia Schur, , about almost a decade back. And she talked about the Bell’s palsy of the gut. So when you have Lyme disease, you [00:35:00] have Bell’s palsy, which is the paralysis of the seventh cranial nerve, and you have this drooping of the face.

And the similar kind of presentation can happen in the gut, where the nerve endings get paralyzed, and doesn’t move as well. So, in all clinicians with constipation, please ask them about, you know, the history of Lyme disease, like, did they have a history of tick bite, did they go hiking, camping, and had any target lesions?  Because, yeah, the constipation, in Lyme disease is a real deal. There are other studies here which are showing kind of a similar presentation of Lyme disease as constipation.

Dr. Weitz: Could I ask a quick question? Yeah. With respect to bile.

Dr. Sagar: Yeah.

Dr. Weitz: What about the use of herbal bitters to stimulate bile production or using ox bile as a supplement?

Dr. Sagar: Absolutely. Yes, you can definitely use bitters and we use that in our clinic setting too. You can use that to stimulate the production of bile. Absolutely. So use that. But that’s another option that I showed you. [00:36:00] Does that answer your question?

Dr. Weitz: Yes.

Dr. Sagar: Very good. So, not only constipation, but as you can see, Lyme disease can affect other, can cause other GI symptoms like bloating, abdominal pain, irritable bowel movements.  So obviously, keep that in mind, you know, just like whenever a patient with multiple GI issues comes to your clinic, start thinking about Lyme disease as well. Leg poisoning is another one, , it can cause constipation, so any patient with constipation I always check their venous leg levels, to see if, leg toxicity is the cause.  Autonomic neuropathy, again can cause constipation, and the treatment is really sacral neuromodulation, so in patients with Parkinson’s disease and Alzheimer’s disease we have to think of that. And then the gut microbiome. This is really important because they are the keystone species in the ecosystem.  And, these are the organisms that really help define an entire [00:37:00] ecosystem. And not only the gut, but several organs in your body have microbiomes. including your hair, nostrils, skin, vagina, oral cavity, esophagus, the composition of the bacteria is very different. For example, in your skin there is more actinobacter as compared to your colon which has more bacteroids and fumigators.

So it’s very different. It’s like really a whole ecosystem there. However, the gut microbiome is affected by a variety of things. It can be affected with your diet. We recommend a high fiber fermented diet if you want to improve your gut microbiome. It’s also related to physical activity. Use of antibiotics is going to affect it.

Hormones, for example, if a woman is on oral contraceptive pills, it’s going to affect their gut microbiome and cause constipation. Stress, because when you’re stressed out, the gut releases CRF. which increases the cortisol level and down regulates your immunity, and thus making you more prone to, stent infections.

Early [00:38:00] life trauma, if you have pets, the use of prebiotics, heavy metals, and, , you know, the pesticides, like glyphosate, all of this can affect your gut microbiome. This is a very small list of what a disruption of gut microbiome can do to you. I don’t have, this is beyond the scope to kind of list everything, but this is just a small list.

And really, when you have a disrupted gut microbiome, which is producing a lot of methane, there is an immune dysregulation that happens and immune suppression associated with vector like Borrelia, Balesia, and Boltonia can happen. For example, if you have, a methane producing bacteria, retinobradylbacter smelii, that is really linked to constipation, and that methanogen can also be seen in colon cancer, in colonic polyposis, in ulcerative colitis, and in diverticulitis.

Dr. Weitz: Can I, can I ask another question? Yeah. Methanobrevibacter Smithii, so [00:39:00] that shows up on a stool. We, we do a lot of GI map stool tests.

Dr. Sagar: Mm

Dr. Weitz: hmm. And methanobremy factor shows up.

Dr. Sagar: Yeah.

Dr. Weitz: Ideally, it should be below detectable levels, but very frequently, it’ll be above that. It may not necessarily be in the red.  Is that something that we should be concerned about?

Dr. Sagar: Very good question. So we never look at one thing only, right? Of course. So it’s always a whole clinical picture. Whenever we have a patient like that, you have to see what are the symptoms. Are they constipated? Are they bloated? Do they have a rash? Do they have food allergy? I would probably do a SIBO test.  I’ll probably look at the gut microbiome. I’ll look if they have leaky gut syndrome. So a combination of all of that. And based on what you found, we are going to treat that. We never usually give antibiotics targeted to just that bacterial, but yeah, if you have a clinical picture of SIBO or SIFO or leaky gut, then we do address that.

Dr. Weitz: Right, because there’s a bit of a [00:40:00] controversy now about methane SIBO or EMO because now it’s recognized that it can exist not just in the small intestine, but in the colon as well.

Dr. Sagar: Yeah, it can. 

Dr. Weitz: And the question is, you know, is seeing methanobrevibacter smithii on a stool test, can that be used to diagnose methane SIBO?

Dr. Sagar: I would say it would support the diagnosis, but you have to obviously combine that with the breath test and the clinical picture. But for example, , a load of, like when I’m talking about bloating and constipation, so everything is assigned and then you have to combine those, , the points that you’ve collected to make your clinical judgment.

Speaker 8: Right.

Dr. Sagar: So if you see something like that, definitely that’s going to alert your mind to see if this is like, aha, Methane, SIBO, and you’re probably going, it’s going to prompt you to do further testing, like a breath test, for sure.

Dr. Weitz: Okay. When you do the breath test. Do you recommend three hours or two [00:41:00] hours?  We do it for three hours. For three hours, okay. It’s alright, it’s two hours. Two hours. Two hours. Yeah. Because there’s this whole issue, how do you diagnose, , methanoprebi bacter overgrowth, EMO, in the colon? So we would either need a stool test or we would need a three hour breath test.

Dr. Rhabar: I don’t have a microphone, but I speak loudly.  I mean, as you put everything together, it has never been a necessity to check the colon. I mean, I’ve talked to other GI doctors. I don’t find it very helpful to go to three hours just to look for excess methane. There would be some other indicators that methane could be a problem. The other thing I think it is probably going to touch base, is that methane will be back to its beauty age.  Methane will be a killer. You know, microbe. Okay. And, , you have to remove the oxygen from the gut environment. And generally when you see this all way, look for a fungal marker. You’re going need to sit on organic acid. You’re [00:42:00] gonna see it on the same GI map you’re gonna see on stool culture. You’re gonna see fungal antibodies, is all the clinical picture basically speaks of that scenario.  And just as another commented, I practically would never treat a SIBO with methane directly. Targeted towards the SIBO, we generally target the fungi first before you attack the methane, okay. Because the potential for giving antibiotics and switching the microbiome to a more fungal predominant is very high.  And if physicians follow the patient, they’re going to see that the effect of the benefit from the SIBO treatment is generally temporary. It’s going to come up with some other recurrence if the fungus is not addressed.

Dr. Weitz: , Sunomidressum can currently address the fungus first with something like Nystatin or

Speaker 11: would

Dr. Weitz: it?

Dr. Rhabar: Well, I mean, there are many ways to address that and it probably is another hour or two to have a discussion. Yeah. , but the short [00:43:00] version is that we treat the fungi first with Diatin, the antifungals that would be appropriate for that patient. Biofree musters. And then if we plan to treat the SIBO, then I usually keep the patient on an antifungal concurrently.  Otherwise, in my experience, you’re going to get a microbiome switch. You’re going to you’re going to have fungi have more accuracy because of their behavior. And you know, even though some of this is not completely U. S. literature, but there’s information out there from the Europeans that we have

Dr. Weitz: to

Speaker 11: get through.

Dr. Weitz: What’s your favorite biofilm busting strategy?

Speaker 11: How about we let you finish up the presentation? 

Dr. Sagar: I have a tweet for you at the end.

Speaker 11: Okay.

Dr. Sagar: Because you asked me that question.

Speaker 11: Thank you.

Dr. Sagar: Alright, so let’s get back here. So we have, we always have those patients who are constipated and they’re also bloated, right?  So that’s like a perfect combination. [00:44:00] But remember that not all bloaters are the same. And how do we differentiate that? So you could have some patient who would have constipation and bloating, but they will also see that I always have rumbling, like my stomach makes so much of noises that my partner who is sitting across the table can hear that, right?  And then when you put the stethoscope into the belly of that patient, you’re going to hear a lot of noises. As compared to silent bloaters, where they would see that they are pretty big, like bloated, But they don’t hear anything, like there is no rumbling, and when you put your stethoscope into the belly of those patients, it’s pretty silent.

So that tells you that probably the colon is not moving as well as it should. So it is probably a slow transit. Again, there could be an upstream problem, because the classic definition of SIBO is abdominal pain, bloating, constipation, and diarrhea. So, [00:45:00] if you have a patient who is constipated and bloating, I do recommend doing the SIBO testing.  And, again, a huge list of things that, , would indicate a SIBO breast test, including constipation. And I wanted to bring your attention to this, the yeast, , function, because when you have a fungal overgrowth of the yeast, um and Overgrowth, that can drive a Th17 response, which can sometimes protect from pathogens, but when you have a disregulated Th17 response, it can cause inflammation, it can cause leaky gut, it can upregulate the immune system, and cause autoimmune conditions and, , constipation as well.

So, we are going to have, a case presentation, just to kind of keep up our interest. So I have a very lovely 40 year old female who presented with multiple GI symptoms. She had indigestion, constipation, dyspepsia, flashlights, malaise, fatigue, [00:46:00] distention, so she was bloated, she had nausea. When we did the breast test, she had a methane sequoia test, which was abnormal, and then when we did the food allergy testing, she was allergic, she was allergic to multiple food items.

We did the Heidenberg gastric pH testing which showed some bile reflux and pyrolytic insubstituency. This stool test showed some Klebsiella, so she has a dysploric, , gut microbiome, and there was some candida in the stool as well. We did the urine mycotoxin screen and she was, , highly abnormal. The gluotoxin levels were 18 times that of the normal.

The live screen was positive as well. This is her endoscopy picture and this is the stomach. Usually, the stomach should not have this yellow stuff. So this is bile. When you see that, it means that there is a bile reflux and bile really has no business in the stomach. It is supposed to be going into the small [00:47:00] bowel and downstream from there.

So this patient, just to make you understand, the bile is produced over here. So, for the bile to go back into the stomach, it has to pass the pylorus, and usually that’s not the normal route. The bile should be produced and go down over here. So whenever you have a case like this, where a patient has bile reflux and constipation, the upper GI and the lower GI, you really have to target the middle man here, which is the small bowel.

So, this patient was treated for SIBO, for fungal overgrowth, and she was also treated for SIBO. With that treatment, her constipation significantly improved. And there was a special thing that we used on her, which did not only address the C4, the bacterial fungal overgrowth, but also the constipation. So to answer your question, we used Diamethaceous Earth in her case.

So Diamethaceous Earth, not only helps with the C4 treatment [00:48:00] because it’s a biofilm buster, but also with constipation. So what is Diamethaceous Earth? Well, we all love the ocean in Southern California, right? So when you go to the ocean and you look at the bottom of the ocean, there are these dye atoms and there are these crustacean organisms which were made into food grade and used as a biofilm.

So it kind of detoxifies the colon and cleanses it. So, the biofilm is disrupted and also it helps patients with constipation. So this really helped our patient therapy. So take home message is always do a thorough rectal exam in all your patients with chronic constipation. We have to stop thinking about pelvic dyssynergia because it is very common and underdiagnosed.

We have to consider balloon expulsion test with anorectal manometry in all our patients. It’s going to help you differentiate slow transit from obstructive defecation. Constipation is a very common problem and sometimes you, it’s a distractor, that [00:49:00] means there is something else going on with the patient and they present as constipation.

So we have to wear our detective hats and get to the root cause of what’s causing the constipation. And SIBO whenever you have a patient with abdominal pain, bloating, constipation, diarrhea, food allergies. Methane SIBO is associated with agonist constipation. And if you have a negative febrile test in patient with bloating, bile reflux, and IBS constipation, it may indicate the presence of a fungal overgrowth and febrile.  Thank you so much for your attention. And with that I’ll come to the end of my presentation. I’ll be happy to take any questions, but I know that Michael has prepared some slides for anorectal manometry too. So in the interest of time, I’ll have him come over and do his presentation.

Michael: Thank you for being patient.  And I’m Michael [00:50:00] Erdman. I work with Dr. Sagar and Dr. Rahbar and I’m going to give a very brief talk on anal rectal manometry because that’s what I do in the office. And it’s very interesting when you have certain cases of chronic constipation, it’s a very useful tool. So the purpose of my little brief talk is to, make you very aware of why you should refer some of your patients for this test.  that’s the button there. So brief objectives, basically just to, you know, get that message across the importance of ARN. And pretty much what Dr. Sehgal was saying, you know, one in three patients with the first line treatments for chronic constipation failed treatment. They’re the ones that you start thinking about, you know, The indication of, you know, wanting to assess their pelvic floor and to get them a anal retinometry so that you can see if they have a functional defecatory issue.

And why? And it’s basically because laxatives and fiber [00:51:00] therapies are not as effective as biofeedback and pelvic floor physical therapy. John’s already gone over this, so I’ll skip past it. and also the buzzwords in a clinic, the digital facilitation of defecation. These things you always think, anal rectal manometry, pelvic floor, physical therapy, and biofeedback.

The detailed rectal examination can actually pick up about 70 percent of cases of dyssynergia. And that’s what an ARM machine looks like. And these are the types of tests that you, , the ways that you can analyze a patient’s, , issues. So the first thing you look at with ARM is the anal sphincter pressure.

And then after that, their ability to squeeze and how effective the sphincter is at doing that. , the next thing would be looking at the myenteric plexus, and the recto anal inhibitory [00:52:00] reflex, which is abnormal in patients with Hirschsprangs, for example. The sensory motor response with hyposensitive patients that have a distended rectum.

Rectal compliance, which is, , something that you see, , that’s all about the pliability of the rectum, and whether, , , for example, elderly patients have a stiffer colon, and, , patients with Hirschsprung’s, for example, would have a more distended rectum. And then there’s the defecation tests, which is all about disinertion defecation, which is the really interesting bit.

So this is pretty much what you’re dealing with with ARN. You’re looking at a lot of, a lot of graphs. And there are four balloons attached to this catheter and they’re positioned posterior, anterior, left and right of the internal anal sphincter. And they’re color coded and then the colored heads come up on a graph.

So. When you ask a patient to squeeze, you’ll see the activity of [00:53:00] that and you’ll see the anal sphincter response. So a squeeze initially is a biphasic wave pattern. There’s initially a big spike, and then there should be this prolonged duration when you ask someone to try and squeeze for 20 seconds. If they have problems with incontinence, they’re not able to do that.

This is actually a reasonable squeeze pressure. It’s not too bad. This is a much better squeeze pressure. It’s not entirely symmetrical, but they can sustain it for 20 seconds, so that’s totally normal. So these are the kind of things I want you to see with what the, what the testing is for your patients.

Someone who has a low squeeze, , that’s a very poor effort of a squeeze, can be poor compliance. Then you start thinking neurological problems, damage to the sphincters. If it is poor compliance, they do well with biofeedback, which is something that we offer in the office. Whenever you look at someone’s ability to squeeze, you look at the cough reflex as well because [00:54:00] you see them together.

So a cough reflex, when someone, when you ask someone to cough, the abdominal pressure rises and then the anal sphincter muscle contracts. So it’s intact, with patients that have upper motor neuron lesions, and then it’s not if it’s a chordaequine lesion. So when you look at someone who has a poor squeeze and a normal cough reflex.

you think it could be poor compliance, or it could be a central motor pathway issue. And then the other way around, it would be, if it’s a poor squeeze and there’s no cough reflex, then you think an issue, for example, with the sacral reflex. This is a very high squeeze. Now, you see this in male patients that have chronic pelvic pain.

When they have a high squeeze, they usually have a very tight anus. I said that on camera. And, , you see that and typically they also have type 1 dyssynergic defecation, which is something that I’ll [00:55:00] show you. Rectal sensation is another part of the test. This is your ability to see how your patient has, what they can feel, as you inflate this balloon inside them and the balloon gets bigger and bigger.

And you say, let me know when you first feel it. Let me know when it gives you a desire to have a bowel movement. Let me know when you can’t take it anymore and you need to run to the bathroom and let me know if you have any pain. If they have pain, you stop. This is an example of someone who’s actually hypersensitive because they had a desire to go, and then with a very similar pressure, they had urgency.

You use this test to look for hyposensitivity and hypersensitivity. Hyposensitivity, they would not be able to recognize two of these sensory tests. For example, if they can’t feel anything in the beginning, you see that with diabetes. If they don’t feel a desire for, or urgency, for example, that’s with [00:56:00] constipation.

So I’ll skip this bit. , the sensory motor response. That’s when you inflate the balloon. Someone should have a urgent desire to go to the bathroom. If they don’t, that’s a sign of hyposensitivity. And then the myenteric plexus, which is that the neurons and ganglia in between the longitudinal muscles and the circular smooth muscles that work with peristalsis.

There’s a lovely test with the A RM, which is the recal anal inhibitory reflex. When you inflate the balloon, what you should see is a relaxation of the internal aim sphincter, and this is how it looks. So you have a nice increase in the rectal balloon. You know, it’s been pumped up here. and then you see a decrease of all the anal sphincter muscles.

This is a very good example of an intact rectal anal inhibitory reflux. And that’s how it also shows itself with ARN. It’s the same way. You can see all the internal anal sphincter muscles [00:57:00] relaxing at that point there. Compliance. This is all about, like I was saying, the kind of ability for the, , , rectal space to.

accommodates the increase of the stool in that zone and it changes as we get older and also with scarring to the rectum and it’s, , there’s actually a higher compliance with megarectum and faecal impaction. And then this is what dyssynergia looks like, which is really what our talk is all about, in regards to ARN, so What should normally happen is you ask someone to push when they try and poop, they push, and then the anal sphincter muscles relax.

So this would be a normal looking defecation on ARN, and this is how it would look on, on the report. Dyssynergic defecation, there’s four types. The [00:58:00] first, this is type one. It’s where you ask a patient to push and they can push really well. that the anal sphincter tightens up, right? So the pressure rises instead of falls and that’s, that’s very abnormal.

Type 2 at the top would be they don’t have a very good push and the anal sphincter muscle tightens up inappropriately. Type 3, They have a very good push and the sphincter doesn’t really tighten up. It doesn’t really do anything at all. And then type four, nothing’s working. You know, they can’t push and they can’t relax the anal sphincter.

So this is a case that I had where a patient came in with a hugely abnormal squeeze pressure reaching, you know, 300, , points on the squeeze, which is super high, like really damage your finger on a retinal [00:59:00] examination. And he was very proud of that. And then, , you know, when you, when, when he did his dis inertia defecation test and I asked him to try and replicate having the bowel movement, the balloon inflates.

And as it, as he’s pushing, you see the anal sphincter muscles are rising as well. So this is type one. Dyssynergic defecation. So if I go back to where we were, that’s what we’re looking at here, right? So you had a type 1 dyssynergic defecation with the balloon inflated and not inflated. So he was, he came back and had biofeedback with us.

Biofeedback is very similar to ARN. They look, they can look on a screen so they can see they’ve got a catheter in the bottom and they can push and when they push they can see the rectal pressure rise. and they can also play around with their pelvic floor and try and work out how to make the anal sphincter relax.

The first time he [01:00:00] came in was on the left, and you can see this was after multiple rounds, he couldn’t quite get it. On the third session, he came in with a higher anal sphincter pressure than he did on the first, the first attendance, but he had a perfect correction of his dyssynergia. Which is amazing, you know, and these, these are patients who have huge problems pooping for a very long time, right?

So, moments like this are great, and that’s the benefit of anal retinometry, that’s the benefit of biofeedback. Typically, they do much better when they have pelvic floor physical therapy at the same time. And so, then the balloon expulsion test we’ve already gone over, and I’ve already mentioned this, And Dr.

Sehgal already mentioned this article, but what was interesting, in addition to what’s already been said, is it also mentions the importance of paying attention to squeeze pressure, squeeze duration, [01:01:00] especially with an abnormal balloon expulsion test. It indicates a very good response to pelvic floor physical therapy and biofeedback.

The problem with the reports is it’s very, it can give you a mental block trying to figure out what’s going on. So Dr. Rabar and I, a couple of years ago, had had enough, and we came up with our own version, which, so now whenever people come to see us for ARN, we send them home with a lovely report. It goes to the practitioner.

Any questions you can get in touch with us. And it’s very informative so much so that the company, , Purchase the report from us as well. So now everyone has access to it, but it’s another way, a very informative way of understanding the outcome of your patients that you refer. So just to clarify once more, chronic constipation cases that fail that trial, [01:02:00] you think ARM, balloon expulsion testing, because it’s thought that there’s 50 percent of these cases out there that are actually functional, , dyssynergic problems, and only 2 percent are tested with anal retinometry.  The most important thing is getting these patients the treatment that they actually need. Biofeedback, pelvic floor physical therapy, that’s what it’s all about. As rapidly as possible. And treatment, you can actually help dyssynergia cases up to 90 percent of the time. So, it’s very valuable. And that’s actually the end of my talk on Anal Rectal Manometry, and I just came up with that.

 


 

Dr. Weitz: Thanks for making it all the way through this episode of the Rational Wellness Podcast. For those of you who enjoy, Listening to the Rational Wellness Podcast, I would appreciate it if you could go to Apple Podcasts or Spotify and give us a five star ratings and review. If you would like to work with me personally to help you improve your health, I do accept a limited number of new patients per month for a functional medicine consultation.  Some of the areas I specialize in include helping patients with specific health issues, like gut problems, neurodegenerative conditions, autoimmune diseases, cardiometabolic conditions, or for an executive health screen and to help you promote longevity and take a deeper dive into some of those factors that can lead to chronic diseases along the way.  Please call my Santa Monica Weitz Sports Chiropractic and Nutrition office at 310 395 3111 and we’ll set you up for a new consultation for functional medicine and I look forward to speaking to everybody next week.